Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#26676
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

Bill Casey wrote...

Eternal. Infinite. Immortal.
The poster I was used these words,
but only now do I truly understand them.
And only now do I comprehend the full potential of this thread.
To ensure all ITers have a voice.
I will protect and sustain the theory.
I will be a guardian for IT.

Posted Image


We can always count on you for really great points like this Posted Image

#26677
Davik Kang

Davik Kang
  • Members
  • 1 547 messages

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

ivenoidea wrote...

Today i realized that people calling the Catalyst/Starchild a "Deus Ex Machina" are completely right.

Today this phrase means "sudden illogical solution to a problem", but translated properly from latin it means "God made from a machine."

Think about that for a moment.


Actually no, it literally means "God out of / from the machine", (not "made from") and even more accurately "God out of / from the crane".

In ancient Greek comedies and tragedies, whenever divine intervention was needed in the drama, they used a crane to lower a god onto the stage, as if he came floating down from Olympus itself.

I see your point, but it actually means that the god is coming from the machine, not made of it. ;)

That is why it can also be used to mean a 'fake god'.


Yep Doomsday's got it about Deus Ex Machina.  It was something that happened in Greek plays to tie all the endings together, where a previously unseen character or other plot device appears, to intervene and resolve the otherwise unresolvable issues.
 
Just wanted to chime in and say that the StarChild is not a DEM, because 

- he can't influence the decisions to be taken - Shepard ultimately makes the decision to use the catalyst (or not).  The StarChild is unable to make this choice or do anything.  He just explains, somewhat, the choices that Shepard has; and

- he is not a new element.  Though in the form of a ghost child, he is previously unseen, he represents the collective intelligence of the Reapers, and we already knew about the Reapers - they are nothing new.  It's just that this is the closest Shepard's come to being able to communicate with them.

The Crucible isn't a DEM either.  It was mentioned throughout the ME3 plot, and we already knew that it would "...do... something..." to end the Reaper threat.  We never knew exactly what it would do.

#26678
ElSuperGecko

ElSuperGecko
  • Members
  • 2 317 messages
I'm fairly sure that Ivenoidea knew about the role of a Deux Ex Machina, and was just comparing the Catalyst to the literal translation.

"God out of / from the machine" sums up the Catalyst quite effectively, in my opinion.

#26679
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

Davik Kang wrote...

- he is not a new element.  Though in the form of a ghost child, he is previously unseen, he represents the collective intelligence of the Reapers, and we already knew about the Reapers - they are nothing new.  It's just that this is the closest Shepard's come to being able to communicate with them.


I have to disagree. Before Leviathan was released, this Reaper AI came out of nowhere. The only foreshadowing for it was on Thessia, when the cycles are explained by Vendetta. But there is no mention of an AI whatsoever.

In fact, before the EC, in the original ending, the kid never even says he is an AI, there's no talk about how the Reapers were created. That was all new in the EC.

People literally thought he was some kind of god.

Hence the nickname 'godchild' that some still use.

#26680
Humakt83

Humakt83
  • Members
  • 1 893 messages

ElSuperGecko wrote...

I'm fairly sure that Ivenoidea knew about the role of a Deus Ex Machina, and was just comparing the Catalyst to the literal translation.

"God out of / from the machine" sums up the Catalyst quite effectively, in my opinion.


Yes, he even walks directly towards Shepard from the machine. Making Catalyst Deus Ex and Machina is Crucible.

Shepard ascends to heavens (the miraculous elevator) and is on his knees until spoken to him by a radiant figure.

#26681
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
'Viewing the Reaper with superstitious awe.'

#26682
Humakt83

Humakt83
  • Members
  • 1 893 messages
However, Diabolus ex Machina is even more fitting to Catalyst.

#26683
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

Davik Kang wrote...

- he is not a new element.  Though in the form of a ghost child, he is previously unseen, he represents the collective intelligence of the Reapers, and we already knew about the Reapers - they are nothing new.  It's just that this is the closest Shepard's come to being able to communicate with them.


I have to disagree. Before Leviathan was released, this Reaper AI came out of nowhere. The only foreshadowing for it was on Thessia, when the cycles are explained by Vendetta. But there is no mention of an AI whatsoever.

In fact, before the EC, in the original ending, the kid never even says he is an AI, there's no talk about how the Reapers were created. That was all new in the EC.

People literally thought he was some kind of god.

Hence the nickname 'godchild' that some still use.


That was my initial reaction.  "WTF, is the kid supposed to be God?"  Why?  Because God's the only one who could make synthesis happen.  Rewriting the way life works everywhere, changing the fabric of reality, is the province of the divine, not the technological.

#26684
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages
Don't know what possessed me to do it...but I just was looking at one of the "Look I have the magic bullet to kill IT" threads...and the only conclusion that I was able to come to -

that Bill Casey rocks!

Edit: Here's the thread: http://social.biowar.../index/14284005.  And it looks like some other IT'ers are doing some might butt kicking as well!

Modifié par D.Sharrah, 28 septembre 2012 - 11:38 .


#26685
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

Rifneno wrote...

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

Davik Kang wrote...

- he is not a new element.  Though in the form of a ghost child, he is previously unseen, he represents the collective intelligence of the Reapers, and we already knew about the Reapers - they are nothing new.  It's just that this is the closest Shepard's come to being able to communicate with them.


I have to disagree. Before Leviathan was released, this Reaper AI came out of nowhere. The only foreshadowing for it was on Thessia, when the cycles are explained by Vendetta. But there is no mention of an AI whatsoever.

In fact, before the EC, in the original ending, the kid never even says he is an AI, there's no talk about how the Reapers were created. That was all new in the EC.

People literally thought he was some kind of god.

Hence the nickname 'godchild' that some still use.


That was my initial reaction.  "WTF, is the kid supposed to be God?"  Why?  Because God's the only one who could make synthesis happen.  Rewriting the way life works everywhere, changing the fabric of reality, is the province of the divine, not the technological.


Oh yes, that went through my mind as well.

And then I realized he was spouting bull**** and went to shoot the tube.

#26686
lex0r11

lex0r11
  • Members
  • 2 190 messages

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

'Viewing the Reaper with superstitious awe.'



Posted Image

#26687
ElSuperGecko

ElSuperGecko
  • Members
  • 2 317 messages

D.Sharrah wrote...
Don't know what possessed me to do it...but I just was looking at one of the "Look I have the magic bullet to kill IT" threads...


Those threads can be mightily diverting at times.  On one hand you've got the IT theory - over 5,000 pages of (mostly) pleasant and intriguing discussion into the meanings behind the Mass Effect endings, the feedback we've had from Bioware staff, and the scattered hints, clues and references contained throughout the Mass Effect series, complete with videos, commentaries, extensive research into the game's lore, background, source material and game files, as well as offshoots such as IT Con, Waking Nightmare and Puzzle Theory...

...and on the other hand, you've got someone saying "Hai guize, look what I just thought up!  Eye Tee = Finished!"

#26688
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
I forgot who originally posted this, but I love it.

Posted Image

#26689
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

I forgot who originally posted this, but I love it.

Posted Image


I also like the sequel about Leviathan.

Posted Image

#26690
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages
Those ant-IT threads are awesome fun!

#26691
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
@Rifneno: lmfao

spotlessvoid wrote...

Those ant-IT threads are awesome fun!


IKR? :o

#26692
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Rankincountry wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Genetic Destiny wrote...

So, how has Leviathan contributed to IT? I think it strenghthens the thought of Harbinger being the Catalyst. He is the oldest reaper after all.

On a side note, I'm kinda hesitant to trust the Leviathans. They're too powerful, and I'm positive they still have the arrogance you'd expect from a reaper.

The sequence where Leviathan talks with Shepard inside his mind is eerily similar to the desicion room (Shepard on his knees, only happened in arrival and in the desicion chamber). 


Add in the resemblance of the device in London that is producing the conduit beam to Object Rho in Arrival - the parallels between all three scenes has to be a clue.

Don't forget that 1 datapad pretty much explained that the beam indoctrinates people...


+1 point to the WNT!!! :lol:

#26693
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages
Harbinger:" Struggle if you wish you mind will be MINE."

In Control Shepard is struggling to hold on to the rods, and if you think for a moment Shepard's thoughts, memories will be transported into a new frame work to Control the Reapers. Harbinger has Shepard's mind at the end because Shepard gave Harbinger Shepard's memories and personality's to make Shepard a Reaper, not the one that Controls the Reapers, but a Reaper in general.

Also hey everyone.

Modifié par masster blaster, 28 septembre 2012 - 11:54 .


#26694
Genetic Destiny

Genetic Destiny
  • Members
  • 290 messages

TJBartlemus wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Rankincountry wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Genetic Destiny wrote...

So, how has Leviathan contributed to IT? I think it strenghthens the thought of Harbinger being the Catalyst. He is the oldest reaper after all.

On a side note, I'm kinda hesitant to trust the Leviathans. They're too powerful, and I'm positive they still have the arrogance you'd expect from a reaper.

The sequence where Leviathan talks with Shepard inside his mind is eerily similar to the desicion room (Shepard on his knees, only happened in arrival and in the desicion chamber). 


Add in the resemblance of the device in London that is producing the conduit beam to Object Rho in Arrival - the parallels between all three scenes has to be a clue.

Don't forget that 1 datapad pretty much explained that the beam indoctrinates people...


+1 point to the WNT!!! :lol:


One thing I found pretty funny about the DLC (other than that husk) was when Ann Bryson said that she hasn't spent enough time around the artifact to be indoctrinated. Com-e-dy...Posted Image

And the Leviathan conversation did remind me of the Catalyst conversation a bit. Also, regarding what masster blaster said above, Control has yet another sense of irony.

Modifié par Genetic Destiny, 29 septembre 2012 - 12:01 .


#26695
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

masster blaster wrote...

Harbinger:" Struggle if you wish you mind will be MINE."

In Control Shepard is struggling to hold on to the rods, and if you think for a moment Shepard's thoughts, memories will be transported into a new frame work to Control the Reapers. Harbinger has Shepard's mind at the end because Shepard gave Harbinger Shepard's memories and personality's to make Shepard a Reaper, not the one that Controls the Reapers, but a Reaper in general.

Also hey everyone.


Hey MB! :D

And yes, you literally surrender your mind to the Reapers in control.

#26696
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages

D.Sharrah wrote...

Don't know what possessed me to do it...but I just was looking at one of the "Look I have the magic bullet to kill IT" threads...and the only conclusion that I was able to come to -

that Bill Casey rocks!

Edit: Here's the thread: http://social.biowar.../index/14284005.  And it looks like some other IT'ers are doing some might butt kicking as well!


Ya Bill rocks, and we ahve already said that the Prothean VI's can only detect FULLY Inodctrinated people, not the onces going through Indoctrination. Other wise the protheans could have won the war, as so many other cycles.

Also what ever happened to Freddy, Rosewind, and Either?

Modifié par masster blaster, 29 septembre 2012 - 12:03 .


#26697
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages

masster blaster wrote...

Harbinger:" Struggle if you wish you mind will be MINE."

In Control Shepard is struggling to hold on to the rods, and if you think for a moment Shepard's thoughts, memories will be transported into a new frame work to Control the Reapers. Harbinger has Shepard's mind at the end because Shepard gave Harbinger Shepard's memories and personality's to make Shepard a Reaper, not the one that Controls the Reapers, but a Reaper in general.

Also hey everyone.


Brilliant...

#26698
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages

Bill Casey wrote...

masster blaster wrote...

Harbinger:" Struggle if you wish you mind will be MINE."

In Control Shepard is struggling to hold on to the rods, and if you think for a moment Shepard's thoughts, memories will be transported into a new frame work to Control the Reapers. Harbinger has Shepard's mind at the end because Shepard gave Harbinger Shepard's memories and personality's to make Shepard a Reaper, not the one that Controls the Reapers, but a Reaper in general.

Also hey everyone.


Brilliant...


Thanks Bill, and DD.

#26699
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages

xBl4ck0p5x wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

The point bares repeating thats why! Why would Biowarw make a high resolution slideshow for everyone who didnt get the endings? No way they did all that work just to appease the people who weren't paying attention. It took them months to make it! They had to put aside making DLC to get those slides made

Ah. In that case, I agree. It seems like a BS story move to put all that effort into the endings, then say "LOL, here's the real ending." IT is the worst thing that could happen to the endings, IMO.




From another thread. He totally missed it. Love it

#26700
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

xBl4ck0p5x wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

The point bares repeating thats why! Why would Biowarw make a high resolution slideshow for everyone who didnt get the endings? No way they did all that work just to appease the people who weren't paying attention. It took them months to make it! They had to put aside making DLC to get those slides made

Ah. In that case, I agree. It seems like a BS story move to put all that effort into the endings, then say "LOL, here's the real ending." IT is the worst thing that could happen to the endings, IMO.




From another thread. He totally missed it. Love it


IT is not  an ending it's an expanision, and that's it. The ending will take place after Shepard wakes up, so there.