Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#30676
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

BatmanTurian wrote...


These three posts of yours are the best on BSN and you should make your own thread and copy this into it. Seriously.


Thanks.  I tried that once but the mods told me to post here instead lol.  I was thinking is it possible to be indoctrinated via Prothean beacons?  This is part of the reason I say Shepard has been indoctrinated since ME 1.  Here are some codex entries to put some food for thought:

To save space, some of the codex lines was cut out but notice what it's referring to by the time you reach the one we're all familiar with sprinkled throughout


To start - Indoctrination Codex - Slow, patient indoctrination allows the thrall to last for months or years.


Citadel Codex - Supposedly constructed by the long-extinct Protheans, this colossal deep-space station serves as the capital of the Citadel Council
The Citadel retains many secrets. The precise age of the station is not known, nor what resilient material it is constructed from. The location of the Citadel's core and its master control unit, regulating systems such as life support and navigation, remain hidden. (REMEMBER HOW DID TIM USE THE REAPERS TO MOVE THE STATION?  HE'S NOT IN CONTROL)
The Citadel was not, in fact, constructed by the Protheans; they were simply the last race to make use of the station before the asari arrived. It, and the mass relays, are the creations of the Reapers, and were built to help facilitate their cycle of galactic genocide.

Mass Relay Codex -
In ME 1 the codex starts off saying - Mass relays are feats of Prothean engineering advanced far beyond the technology of any living species. 

By the end of ME 1 and throughout till ME 3 the codex says - Once believed to be of Prothean origin, mass relays were in fact created by the Reapers using technology far beyond that of other living species.

Protheans: Beacon Codex -The beacon was a Prothean artifact unearthed on the Alliance colony of Eden Prime.
It proved to be a solid state data storage device, part of a galaxy spanning comm network similar to the modern extranet.  Intact Prothean "paleo-technology" is rare, the beacon seemed to promise another quantum leap of technology, akin to the discovery of the mass effect drive and relays.
During the recovery operation, the beacon fired a pulse of energy at the Executive Officer of the Alliance frigate Normandy. Lieutenant Commander Shepard survived and appears to have suffered no ill effects. Afterwards, the beacon fell inert. The mechanism appears to be dead

Protheans Cipher Codex -The Prothean beacon downloaded its knowledge into Lt. Commander Shepard on Eden Prime, causing confusing dreams and visions. While the imagery is becoming clearer with time, the meaning of the beacon communication remains elusive.
It has been suggested the Prothean data recording is highly dependent on a certain point of view, what Carl Jung described as the collective unconscious. The "cipher" needed to comprehend the images implanted in Shepard's mind is the cultural knowledge of a Prothean: the archetypes, biological instincts, and common experiences universal to the race. Since the Protheans have been dead for millennia it may be impossible to acquire this "cipher".

 Indoctrination Codex - Reaper "indoctrination" is an insidious means of corrupting organic minds, "reprogramming" the brain through physical and psychological conditioning using electromagnetic fields, infrasonic and ultrasonic noise, and other subliminal methods. The Reaper's resulting control over the limbic system leaves the victim highly susceptible to its suggestions.
Organics undergoing indoctrination may complain of headaches and buzzing or ringing in their ears. As time passes, they have feelings of "being watched" and hallucinations of "ghostly" presences.

The Cipher from the Mass Effect Wiki -

The Cipher[/b] - was used by both Saren Arterius and Shepard to allow them to interpret the visions held in the Prothean beacons on Eden Prime and Virmire. It is the cultural context, knowledge and experience of the Prothean race. This unique racial perspective allows a mind to comprehend information as a Prothean could, though it takes time for a non-Prothean mind to become accustomed to it. Without the Cipher, the images in the beacon's vision don't make sense to non-Protheans who lack the necessary attitudes, mindset, and cultural experience to correctly interpret them.

Commander Shepard gained the Cipher with the help of Shiala, an asari formerly working for Saren who was offered as a 'sacrifice' to the Thorian. (NOTICE THE QUOTES AROUND SACRIFICE THE WIKI USED)
When Shiala melded with the Thorian, she shared the Thorian's consciousness, and thus gained the Cipher left by the long-dead Protheans. Shiala transferred the Cipher directly to Shepard's mind. The experience left the Commander badly shaken, but was necessary to find the Conduit

Indoctrination Codex - Reaper "indoctrination" is an insidious means of corrupting organic minds, "reprogramming" the brain through physical and psychological conditioning using electromagnetic fields, infrasonic and ultrasonic noise, and other subliminal methods. The Reaper's resulting control over the limbic system leaves the victim highly susceptible to its suggestions.
Indoctrination can create perfect deep cover agents. A Reaper's "suggestions" can manipulate victims into betraying friends, trusting enemies, or viewing the Reaper itself with superstitious awe

The Thorian Codex - According to Shiala, the Thorian existed on Feros long before the Protheans arrived. It would spend thousands of years in hibernation, then awake for "a few frantic centuries" of activity before resting again.
IN ME 2 - In the aftermath of the geth attack, ExoGeni took the remains of the Thorian as they pulled offworld. Unfortunately, the effects of the Thorian spores still affected its victims. The colonists began having headaches or muscle spasms, similar to what they experience while under the Thorian's control,

Indoctrination Codex - Organics undergoing indoctrination may complain of headaches.
The Reaper's resulting control over the limbic system leaves the victim highly susceptible to its suggestions. 

A new question - could the Thorian have been a failed Reaper Experiment into creating Reapers before they decided on the synthetic route?  Could the Thorian really be a Leviathan just mutated into something unrecognizable and indoctrinated by the Reaper AI or at least still trying to function as a Leviathan?

#30677
Restrider

Restrider
  • Members
  • 1 986 messages
I think someone stated the idea that the Thorian might be a Leviathan larva.

#30678
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages
Possibly Cmdr, the thorian is certainly interesting. But here is another small thing I have noticed:

There are several interesting similarities bewteen the Thorian and the Rachni.

Both have a limited ability to influence other creatures minds, they have a hivemind like effect,  both survived a Reaper cycle (Javik mentions that the Protheans experimented on the Rachni, tried to make them beasts of war...another case of failed control there as well) and perhaps most interestingly both exhibit some kind of resistance to Indoctrination, the Rachni Queen directly and the Thorian in its Thralls and their connection.

Two creatures with Indoctrination Resistance and Mind affecting abilities who survived a cycle...is that just a coincedence?

Look at it this way who could have benefit of creatures with these atributes?

My answer is the Leviathans.

Essentially I theorize the Leviathans might over the years have tried to create the perfect race to combat the Reapers, something which can resist the Reapers Indoctrination and thereby overcome the Reapers greatests weapon.

The Thorian and the Rachni are a result of that (with the Leviathans possibly working on the Rachni through the Protheans), probably failed results though...

It is just an idea, but it would add some more layers to everything.

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 06 octobre 2012 - 08:50 .


#30679
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

TJBartlemus wrote...

If anyone is interested I'm playing mp. GT is MidProduct08.


I might add you later today. ;)


add me too. you already know my gt


Will do. Wait... I do? :blink:

#30680
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages
That was fun....the Geth have certainly become way more difficult. So what have I missed in the thread for the last 2 days?

#30681
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
"They will SUCCUMB (control) and ASCEND (synthesis)... or they will be ANNIHILATED (destroy)." - Harbinger, Retaliation trailer.

Bioware is all but shouting from the rooftops. My doubts (if there ever were) are gone.

#30682
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

Possibly Cmdr, the thorian is certainly interesting. But here is another small thing I have noticed:

There are several interesting similarities bewteen the Thorian and the Rachni.

Both have a limited ability to influence other creatures minds, they have a hivemind like effect,  both survived a Reaper cycle (Javik mentions that the Protheans experimented on the Rachni, tried to make them beasts of war...another case of failed control there as well) and perhaps most interestingly both exhibit some kind of resistance to Indoctrination, the Rachni Queen directly and the Thorian in its Thralls and their connection.

Two creatures with Indoctrination Resistance and Mind affecting abilities who survived a cycle...is that just a coincedence?

Look at it this way who could have benefit of creatures with these atributes?

My answer is the Leviathans.

Essentially I theorize the Leviathans might over the years have tried to create the perfect race to combat the Reapers, something which can resist the Reapers Indoctrination and thereby overcome the Reapers greatests weapon.

The Thorian and the Rachni are a result of that (with the Leviathans possibly working on the Rachni through the Protheans), probably failed results though...

It is just an idea, but it would add some more layers to everything.


True.  I like the idea.  It might make sense where that Thrall Harbinger uses comes from.  Does Harbinger's Thrall look like a Rachni with a Prothean head?  I've always wondered why he looks this way?

 <---- video of Harbinger's Thrall at the end of ME 2

Posted Image <---- Harbinger Thrall
Posted Image <---Rachni
Posted Image <---Prothean

Modifié par CmdrShep80, 06 octobre 2012 - 09:08 .


#30683
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages
Cmdr:

Hmm, could be possible that it is a bit of a Reaper freak experiment.

I mean I could see why they would want to use the Rachni for something like that considering the Rachni hivemind. Implement a bit of that hivemind in each Collector and have what is essentially a queen (The Collector General) to assume control through. Simple organic repurpose for a more efficient Control system...also allows monitoring of every unit through a single on again utilizing the hivemind.

Also just remembered that Ann Bryson in Leviathan directly mentions how the Leviathans QEC way operating through the Orbs seem to ressemble the way Rachni communicate over massive distances also using a QEC like effect.

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 06 octobre 2012 - 09:17 .


#30684
Restrider

Restrider
  • Members
  • 1 986 messages
You are right. It could be similar to the Brute, consisting of the strength of the krogan physiology and the tactical mind (=head) of the turians. Thus, the Collector General might be some kind of abomination created by the Reapers/Harbinger.
I have one problem though with the idea that the Thorian and Rachni are Leviathan's pawns/creatures.
Since indoctrination is a more refined form of Leviathan enthrallment of organic minds, how are the Leviathans supposed to control such a species? Since they are immune to indoctrination I suppose they would be immune to enthrallment even more?
On the other hand we see Leviathans capable of assuming control of Brutes and even Sovereign class Reapers. Hm...

#30685
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
... and whatever Leviathans can do, Reapers can do it even better.

#30686
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

Cmdr:

Hmm, could be possible that it is a bit of a Reaper freak experiment.

I mean I could see why they would want to use the Rachni for something like that considering the Rachni hivemind. Implement a bit of that hivemind in each Collector and have what is essentially a queen (The Collector General) to assume control through. Simple organic repurpose for a more efficient Control system...also allows monitoring of every unit through a single on again utilizing the hivemind.

Also just remembered that Ann Bryson in Leviathan directly mentions how the Leviathans QEC way operating through the Orbs seem to ressemble the way Rachni communicate over massive distances also using a QEC like effect.


The only snag is that the Protheans supposively bred the Rachni as creatures of war.  However. it's possible BioWare hasn't truly given where the Rachni come from just like how they update the codex when Shepard realizes it's the Reapers not the Protheans.

#30687
Baal Sagoth

Baal Sagoth
  • Members
  • 148 messages
Regarding CW2 I must say that I don't buy "shared memories" part. It is still a game, and Vega "insight" on events he didn't saw can be only added just to let him say something more interesting than "We kicked their asses again". In fact it was present throughout entire trilogy: 2 squad members on mission but everyone talks about it.

But if BW original plan was to indoctrinate player, then fact that almost all detailed info about indoctrination is revealed by optional dialogue, logs etc. or completly outside game (books, comics) seems legit. In that situation only most devoted fans who not only look for every piece of lore but also keep that lore in mind could connect the dots. It's kind like reward to most passionate fans: for your time and passion you will have greater chance to resist. If IT is something that BW guys could pull off...

On the side note: CW2 series got me thinking about IT in regard whole ME trilogy. Just some fun observation:

Mass Effect 2
  • Destroy Collector Base - Paragon ending - red/orange explosion - Star in TIM's office color code BLUE
  • Keep/Control Collector Base - Renegade ending - blue/greenish explosion - Star in TIM's office color code RED
Mass Effect 3
  • Destroy - Choice color code RED - red explosion - presented as Renegade option, yet using Anderson (Paragon inclined)
  • Control - Choice color code BLUE - blue explosion - presented as Paragon option, yet using TIM (Renegade inclined)


#30688
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

Restrider wrote...

You are right. It could be similar to the Brute, consisting of the strength of the krogan physiology and the tactical mind (=head) of the turians. Thus, the Collector General might be some kind of abomination created by the Reapers/Harbinger.
I have one problem though with the idea that the Thorian and Rachni are Leviathan's pawns/creatures.
Since indoctrination is a more refined form of Leviathan enthrallment of organic minds, how are the Leviathans supposed to control such a species? Since they are immune to indoctrination I suppose they would be immune to enthrallment even more?
On the other hand we see Leviathans capable of assuming control of Brutes and even Sovereign class Reapers. Hm...


Who like you say are also supposed to be immune to indoctrination because they already are.  Not only that don't forget the Rachni Queen who's also supposed to be immune to indoctrination, making Rachni warriors for the Reapers until she's freed.  The Reapers might have a technology that disrupts and redirects indoctrination for thier use?

#30689
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

Cmdr:

Hmm, could be possible that it is a bit of a Reaper freak experiment.

I mean I could see why they would want to use the Rachni for something like that considering the Rachni hivemind. Implement a bit of that hivemind in each Collector and have what is essentially a queen (The Collector General) to assume control through. Simple organic repurpose for a more efficient Control system...also allows monitoring of every unit through a single on again utilizing the hivemind.

Also just remembered that Ann Bryson in Leviathan directly mentions how the Leviathans QEC way operating through the Orbs seem to ressemble the way Rachni communicate over massive distances also using a QEC like effect.


The only snag is that the Protheans supposively bred the Rachni as creatures of war.  However. it's possible BioWare hasn't truly given where the Rachni come from just like how they update the codex when Shepard realizes it's the Reapers not the Protheans.


Yeah the mention of the Rachni beeing bred for war is the first mention of Rachni (as in when they were present) we have. They might go even further back than that and we have no way of knowing from which world they originated.

#30690
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Restrider wrote...

You are right. It could be similar to the Brute, consisting of the strength of the krogan physiology and the tactical mind (=head) of the turians. Thus, the Collector General might be some kind of abomination created by the Reapers/Harbinger.
I have one problem though with the idea that the Thorian and Rachni are Leviathan's pawns/creatures.
Since indoctrination is a more refined form of Leviathan enthrallment of organic minds, how are the Leviathans supposed to control such a species? Since they are immune to indoctrination I suppose they would be immune to enthrallment even more?
On the other hand we see Leviathans capable of assuming control of Brutes and even Sovereign class Reapers. Hm...


Who like you say are also supposed to be immune to indoctrination because they already are.  Not only that don't forget the Rachni Queen who's also supposed to be immune to indoctrination, making Rachni warriors for the Reapers until she's freed.  The Reapers might have a technology that disrupts and redirects indoctrination for thier use?


The Rachni Queen in ME3 seems forcefully restrained so it is possible, even likely, the Reapers did not have her Indoctrinated.

Still though Indoctrination resistance should not be confused with beeing immune. The Queen and the Asari at Zhu´s Hope both say they hear the Reapers voices but that they are able to block out. We also know that Indoctrination was the the cause of the Rachni Wars.

But in regards to if Leviathans could control a Indoctrination resistant creature...I really dont know. Maybe they could leave the creature specifically open to Enthrallment or they simply want the Reapers out of the way first and can deal with the other race later...or it is a failure in the design.

#30691
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Restrider wrote...

You are right. It could be similar to the Brute, consisting of the strength of the krogan physiology and the tactical mind (=head) of the turians. Thus, the Collector General might be some kind of abomination created by the Reapers/Harbinger.
I have one problem though with the idea that the Thorian and Rachni are Leviathan's pawns/creatures.
Since indoctrination is a more refined form of Leviathan enthrallment of organic minds, how are the Leviathans supposed to control such a species? Since they are immune to indoctrination I suppose they would be immune to enthrallment even more?
On the other hand we see Leviathans capable of assuming control of Brutes and even Sovereign class Reapers. Hm...


Who like you say are also supposed to be immune to indoctrination because they already are.  Not only that don't forget the Rachni Queen who's also supposed to be immune to indoctrination, making Rachni warriors for the Reapers until she's freed.  The Reapers might have a technology that disrupts and redirects indoctrination for thier use?


The Rachni Queen in ME3 seems forcefully restrained so it is possible, even likely, the Reapers did not have her Indoctrinated.

Still though Indoctrination resistance should not be confused with beeing immune. The Queen and the Asari at Zhu´s Hope both say they hear the Reapers voices but that they are able to block out. We also know that Indoctrination was the the cause of the Rachni Wars.

But in regards to if Leviathans could control a Indoctrination resistant creature...I really dont know. Maybe they could leave the creature specifically open to Enthrallment or they simply want the Reapers out of the way first and can deal with the other race later...or it is a failure in the design.


I'll go with failure of a design of the indoctrination process.  The queen herself can't be indoctrinated easily but her workers can

#30692
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
dfafsd

Baal Sagoth wrote...

Regarding CW2 I must say that I don't buy "shared memories" part. It is still a game, and Vega "insight" on events he didn't saw can be only added just to let him say something more interesting than "We kicked their asses again". In fact it was present throughout entire trilogy: 2 squad members on mission but everyone talks about it.

But if BW original plan was to indoctrinate player, then fact that almost all detailed info about indoctrination is revealed by optional dialogue, logs etc. or completly outside game (books, comics) seems legit. In that situation only most devoted fans who not only look for every piece of lore but also keep that lore in mind could connect the dots. It's kind like reward to most passionate fans: for your time and passion you will have greater chance to resist. If IT is something that BW guys could pull off...

On the side note: CW2 series got me thinking about IT in regard whole ME trilogy. Just some fun observation:

Mass Effect 2

  • Destroy Collector Base - Paragon ending - red/orange explosion - Star in TIM's office color code BLUE
  • Keep/Control Collector Base - Renegade ending - blue/greenish explosion - Star in TIM's office color code RED
Mass Effect 3
  • Destroy - Choice color code RED - red explosion - presented as Renegade option, yet using Anderson (Paragon inclined)
  • Control - Choice color code BLUE - blue explosion - presented as Paragon option, yet using TIM (Renegade inclined)

Hmm, you might be on to something here.  I just thought the star was pretty.  I wonder if the colors change in one direction or another i.e. more green, more blue, or more red before the end as you play ME 2

I also noticed the war assets thing about it.  If you save the base, it also lowers the EMS requirements for the best "control Reapers" ending.  If you destroy the base it also lowers the EMS requirements for the best "destroy Reapers" endings.

Do you also notice how the star has 3 colors in it?  Red, blue, and green  The stills show this:

Posted Image

Maybe a forshadowing of what was to come via the star color and what happens at the end?

#30693
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

Baal Sagoth wrote...

Mass Effect 2

  • Destroy Collector Base - Paragon ending - red/orange explosion - Star in TIM's office color code BLUE
  • Keep/Control Collector Base - Renegade ending - blue/greenish explosion - Star in TIM's office color code RED
Mass Effect 3
  • Destroy - Choice color code RED - red explosion - presented as Renegade option, yet using Anderson (Paragon inclined)
  • Control - Choice color code BLUE - blue explosion - presented as Paragon option, yet using TIM (Renegade inclined)

That is correct, but I have two things to say about that:

- Destroying the collector base (the paragon action) is even directly linked to destroying the Reapers in the ME3 ending, because it's your only option when you have low EMS and you destroyed the base. Same goes for keeping the base - directly linked to the control choice.

The colours of the explosions however, should not be interpreted as having a symbolic meaning (unless it was foreshadowing of the reversal in the ME3 ending). Think about it: if you keep the base, you use an electro-magnetic pulse to clean it out; electro-magnetic waves/pulses are always depicted blue in games/movies. An explosion that destroys the entire base is sure to be depicted as a red explosion, as it is the colour of destruction.

#30694
Either.Ardrey

Either.Ardrey
  • Members
  • 473 messages

masster blaster wrote...

Either your back. Where were you old friend.

Lol. I was in CryoSleep set to wake me up in time for new DLC.

Work got pretty busy and I got too tired trying to keep up, but crunch-time's over, I'm refreshed, and I'm having fun. Consider me back for the time being.^_^

#30695
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages
Ya the match was fun Either, and I ahte when Conection get's lost. We were on a roll, but no Connection gone bad. Also I got the Prothean partical rifle after the first match, I just forgot to equip it in the first gold match. We could have won that one.

#30696
Kulbelbolka

Kulbelbolka
  • Members
  • 238 messages
Does anybody know the name of the sound of Shepard's awakening on the Citadel in Extended Cut? I mean what's the name of the file in resources.

#30697
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages
So has anyone brought up yet that Harbinger is made of millions, possibly billions of Leviathans? Look at what three Leviathans were able to do. Yeah... that guy isn't going down withut a major fight.

#30698
Baal Sagoth

Baal Sagoth
  • Members
  • 148 messages

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

That is correct, but I have two things to say about that:

- Destroying the collector base (the paragon action) is even directly linked to destroying the Reapers in the ME3 ending, because it's your only option when you have low EMS and you destroyed the base. Same goes for keeping the base - directly linked to the control choice.

The colours of the explosions however, should not be interpreted as having a symbolic meaning (unless it was foreshadowing of the reversal in the ME3 ending). Think about it: if you keep the base, you use an electro-magnetic pulse to clean it out; electro-magnetic waves/pulses are always depicted blue in games/movies. An explosion that destroys the entire base is sure to be depicted as a red explosion, as it is the colour of destruction.


Right, I'm aware of that.

For me it is only proof that color coding can be tricky. And that puzzles fall into their places:
  • Paragon sees Collector Base as a abomination and Reaper tech as a threat which must be destroyed. Even without Reapers, experiments and tech like that used in Sanctuary is very dangerous and immoral. Thus Destroy appears as a true Paragon ending, despite possible losses (geth, EDI, everyone who relies on tech that will be damaged)
  • Renegade sees "wisdom in harnessing strenghts of the enemy" and is willing to keep Collector Base. In result player with that kind of approach would be more willing to pick Control. Especially if we take holokid's words as a face value then Shepreaper could easly elevate humanity above other races.
Unfortunatelly I think that reasoning supports literal endings rather than IT.

#30699
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages
God you got to love javik when he talks about Leviathan.

#30700
Baal Sagoth

Baal Sagoth
  • Members
  • 148 messages

Kulbelbolka wrote...

Does anybody know the name of the sound of Shepard's awakening on the Citadel in Extended Cut? I mean what's the name of the file in resources.


Do You mean Breathng Scene?

If yes, that is CGI sequence, BIK format movie End03-Shepard_Alive_Male.bik
No separate sound file.