masster blaster wrote...
Meg here is why.
Mordins
Legions, and
Thanes death mean nothing.
Oh lookk at Synthesis it cures the Geno if you didn't cure it, but oh wait that's right Mordin died trying to do the right thing. Pointless didn't have to die.
Oh Legion wanted his people to become true AI's, oh look Synthesis gives them this, and more. His death pointless.
Oh Thane fighting Kai Leng to stop Cerberus. Oh wait in Control they were right after all, why couldn't I join Cerberus during ME3's beginning. Death pointless. Hell alot of deaths are pointless in ME3, and ME1/ME2. I could same more about Destroy, and refuse, but that's if you take things literaly, yet IT I hope is true.
Which is exactly why it's no simple Reaper off switch. This is exactly why it's no ABC ending.
I actually haven't had a save where I not cured the Genophage and picked Synthesis so I can't much comment, but as Mordin said "someone else might have gotten it wrong"? If you've got a non cured genophage synthesis ending where Krogans show up then maybe Mordin died in vain, but it's still you choice, and it's the consequence of multiple choices. It's not that they don't matter. Compare it to an ending where Shepard shot Mordin and tell me it's the same as Mordin dying while curing the Genophage. It might be the same result to some degree, but it's vastly different in what implications it brings.
The same is true for Legion.
Thane on the other hand stopped Kai Leng from killing the Council, or at least the Salarian Councilor, which might not matter to you, and isn't shown later, but it still matters. It's basically a small scale "save the DA" choice in ME1.