Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#39776
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages

dreamgazer wrote...

I'm curious: what do the IT "interpretation-only" and "BioWare indoctrinated the audience" folks think about where ME4 is going to go, if it turns into a sequel? Or, are you assuming that the series is effectively over, leaving on a hostile debate among the fans?

ME4 won't be a sequel...

Modifié par Bill Casey, 26 octobre 2012 - 02:48 .


#39777
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

BleedingUranium wrote...

MegumiAzusa wrote...

I don't get why people over and over try to reinterpret the word Crucible. It's in the story the Alliance named the project like that because for them it's the trial if they can build it. Many cycles didn't even manage to do that. Story wise the Crucible was named by the Alliance, not like the Catalyst which "name" was passed down.
Reinterpreting the name is as if you would say "Spectres are named that way because they are actually specters of the Reapers" it just doesn't make any sense.


You're being too Watsonian. Sure that is all true, but you also have to look at everything from a Doyleist perspective. Why did the writers name it the Crucible?


Yep. It's layered onto the story.

But by the way, the Alliance had the Mars stuff for some time. :whistle:

#39778
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages
Shepard needs to willingly align himself with the Reapers before being able to be ascended as the new Reapers avatar. Synthesis is walking into the beam, aligned with the Reapers. Literally. Just a thought.

#39779
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

dreamgazer wrote...

I'm curious: what do the IT "interpretation-only" and "BioWare indoctrinated the audience" folks think about where ME4 is going to go, if it turns into a sequel? Or, are you assuming that the series is effectively over, leaving on a hostile debate among the fans?


I don't think its over, personally. Three major possibilites:

1) DLC finishes the fight on Earth, and ME4 is a true war against the Reapers (not just the Reaper invasion) and discovering larger ideas of Mass Effect beyond the galaxy.
One sub-idea of this is that Shepard is in the game, but he may or may not be the protagonist, and he will NOT be military anymore, and he will NOT be known as Shepard anymore.
(Ew, I just got flashes of the 'Mass Shift leak :sick:)

2) DLC finishes the fight in Earth, and ME4 is a whole new story that doesn't require choices from ME1-3 to transfer over, or at least won't push you to do it.

3)DLC only finishes the 'puzzle pieces' and ME4 continues the main story.

In most of my predictions, the Reapers are not done yet and we'll have to wait for DLC/an expansion/ME4 for a full conclusion.

My preferred outcome is #1, that we get massive DLC to finish the story for those who choose to buy that DLC, and ME4 takes things in a different direction from the 'war/invasion' feel. The hint that its not a war, but a harvest, and the theories here that the Alliance may be compromised, contribute to my feelings on this.

#39780
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

1. cdn2.sbnation.com/entry_photo_images/4974393/mass_effect_3_leviathan_large_verge_medium_landscape.jpg

2. Wow... you really missed it?

"Meet me at the bar" -Garrus

"So this is it no? One more push, one last fight" -James
"Not necessarily our last" -Shepard

"Depends on whether you've got the Crucible good to go" -Shepard
"Oh its ready. No idea what it'll do exactly, but its gonna be big"
"Good luck Shepard. If you live through it, drinks are on me." -Kasumi

"If we both come back from this at all, everything... will be different."
"Sure everything will change, but on our terms. We've been running until now Miranda."
"It has to stop." -Shepard
"I understand." -Miranda
"This isn't goodbye. You have to believe we're not done yet." -Shepard
"Listening to you, I can believe it." -Miranda

"I'm ready" -Ashley
"Now lets get it done, and go home." -Shepard
(this one I admit might be too speculative)


1. Okay? What's that got to do with it?
2. I'm talking about Rio in specific.

I'm....concerned about Liara. Even just the fact that she keeps showing up right after each of the crazy-death dreams worries me.

Sigh... Just like it was said earlier... I can't help but think that at least half of ME3 was a giant mislead, and Shepard went right into danger in the worst way :(. And not just him, but the galaxy.

Time for dawn to shine onto London... but we'll have to wait longer for that.


Liara has some role yet to fulfill. She's wearing iridium plot armor with a Shadow Broker insignia in a series that lets us have our murderous way with most everyone. But I doubt they'll flat out have her revealed to be indoctrinated. She's just too much of a beloved character for her dying or turning to be inevitable.

We never did find our why London. Anderson went on about how there's a disturbing concentration on London from the Reapers and we never get an explanation. They said at the end "at least we know why they're at London now" but we really don't. The final battle happens there because they're there, not the other way around. On the other hand, I can't think of any reason why either. Or any city for that matter. What, are the Reapers just pissed they can't ride that mega Ferris Wheel? ... Actually, I'm surprised it's still around in Mass Effect's time.

Bill Casey wrote...

leonia42 wrote...

Right, to deceive the player. Because the Crucible is a trap.


No, that's stupid...


My thoughts exactly on your "we don't need additional content because it's IMPLIED" thing.

#39781
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

Bill Casey wrote...

HE WAS ALREADY GOING TO DO IT.
THERE'S NO POINT.


I think you're placing too much emphasis on the use of the Crucible as the setting for the indoc attempt. The Crucible is an unknown to Shepard, so the AI/Harbinger is able to pretend it does anything, and comes up with what we have in the decision chamber.

You seem to think it's all about making Shepard not use the Crucible, but you don't have to indoctrinate someone to do that. If all they wanted was to stop Shepard from activating the Crucible, they should have done any of the following:

-Turn off the beam (if it really is a transport beam)
-Send more than Harbinger to defend it (maybe even some ground troops?)
-Actually kill Shepard
-Not leave before making sure he's dead
-etc

This is also not considering that anyone else could have activated the Crucible if it is actually legit, so why bother with just Shepard?

And then this also brings up all the problems with the Crucible being legit, which have been pointed out over the last page or two.

Modifié par BleedingUranium, 26 octobre 2012 - 02:59 .


#39782
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

So, if the beam run isn't real how do we get to the citadel?

Bill?

#39783
MegumiAzusa

MegumiAzusa
  • Members
  • 4 238 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...

MegumiAzusa wrote...

I don't get why people over and over try to reinterpret the word Crucible. It's in the story the Alliance named the project like that because for them it's the trial if they can build it. Many cycles didn't even manage to do that. Story wise the Crucible was named by the Alliance, not like the Catalyst which "name" was passed down.
Reinterpreting the name is as if you would say "Spectres are named that way because they are actually specters of the Reapers" it just doesn't make any sense.


You're being too Watsonian. Sure that is all true, but you also have to look at everything from a Doyleist perspective. Why did the writers name it the Crucible?

Because it's the question how well you can build and protect it with the resources you gathered.

#39784
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

Shepard needs to willingly align himself with the Reapers before being able to be ascended as the new Reapers avatar. Synthesis is walking into the beam, aligned with the Reapers. Literally. Just a thought.



I've actually thought about that...
With control as grabbing the structure while believing, and destroy as shooting the structure...

And sitting with Anderson as sitting with that dead guy by the circular thing...


And that's... fair enough...
I don't think that's happening at all, though...

Modifié par Bill Casey, 26 octobre 2012 - 02:56 .


#39785
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

spotlessvoid wrote...

Shepard needs to willingly align himself with the Reapers before being able to be ascended as the new Reapers avatar. Synthesis is walking into the beam, aligned with the Reapers. Literally. Just a thought.


Basically this.

I'm not sure what Control might bring though. It's...curious. It's the one that shows up in lowEMS if you saved the Collector Base...

#39786
MegumiAzusa

MegumiAzusa
  • Members
  • 4 238 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

But by the way, the Alliance had the Mars stuff for some time. :whistle:

Humans are idiots.

#39787
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages
The Crucible should do something like this http://social.biowar.../index/13721326

#39788
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

So, if the beam run isn't real how do we get to the citadel?

Bill?

Use the beam?

#39789
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages
@Rif

The whole talk about London, to me, is clear forshadowing that the beam is a trap.

-Cerberus (Reapers by proxy) tries to take the Citadel
-Right after, the Reapers start something big in London
-Later, the Reapers take the Citadel, and connect it to the beam structure in London

The Reapers were planning this all along.

#39790
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages

Bill Casey wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

So, if the beam run isn't real how do we get to the citadel?

Bill?

Use the beam?


Why wouldn't the Reapers just turn it off?

#39791
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

spotlessvoid wrote...

Bill Casey wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

So, if the beam run isn't real how do we get to the citadel?

Bill?

Use the beam?


Why wouldn't the Reapers just turn it off?


I made a post about this partway up the page ^

#39792
PsiMatrix

PsiMatrix
  • Members
  • 513 messages

401 Kill wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Cool! what is the inverted color of the blue explosion and green one?


Synthesis and Control are both red actually. Inverted, they look like oily shadows. 

That's... Interesting. That coupled with the "sour yellow" colered desicion chamber, makes the inverted sequence seem an awfully like what the Rachni queen was describing as her indoctrination experience. What was it the Rachni queen experienced during her ME3 experience? Her children going crazy because they didn't hear the queens song?

In the first one they went insane because they didn't hear anything from the Queen. In 3 they were simply harvested and cannibalised for artillery units.


Just finished another playthrough of ME1. Convinced Saren to shoot himself and then as his body is control assumed by Sovereign; a familair black aura appears around everyone

Also: Sovereign turns a different colour when he's hooked up to the Citadel tower:
Posted Image
Yep, he's blue.:D

#39793
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages
The Crucible could just Rickroll every frequency in the Milky Way. Doesn't matter what it does if it doesn't do what Shepard thinks it does -- destroy the Reapers. They're not indoctrinating Shepard because they want to keep him away from the Crucible, they're indoctrinating him because they want his awesomeness to make some awesome Soylent Green for another Reaper. The Crucible can be BS in lots of ways and they'd still want to indoctrinate Shepard. There's tons of theories on what it really does. For instance that it's the new "Reaper womb" since Shepard blew up the last one, or that it's a device to send them back to dark space when this is all finished.

#39794
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

PsiMatrix wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Cool! what is the inverted color of the blue explosion and green one?


Synthesis and Control are both red actually. Inverted, they look like oily shadows. 

That's... Interesting. That coupled with the "sour yellow" colered desicion chamber, makes the inverted sequence seem an awfully like what the Rachni queen was describing as her indoctrination experience. What was it the Rachni queen experienced during her ME3 experience? Her children going crazy because they didn't hear the queens song?

In the first one they went insane because they didn't hear anything from the Queen. In 3 they were simply harvested and cannibalised for artillery units.


Just finished another playthrough of ME1. Convinced Saren to shoot himself and then as his body is control assumed by Sovereign; a familair black aura appears around everyone

Also: Sovereign turns a different colour when he's hooked up to the Citadel tower:
Posted Image
Yep, he's blue.:D


He picked control.  And what happened to him?  Lulz.

#39795
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
@Rif (as I don't want quote pyramid :P)

1. Shepard is standing likely on London. In the *daytime*. With Reapers not standing, but seemingly on a directed path downwards. With the ground looking like the Shepard_Lives video. To me at least, this indicates *something* happens which we haven't seen in-game yet, that severely messes with the Reapers.

Doesn't mean an instant 'on/off' switch, but I think it could mean we really screw with them enough to make this 'harvest'... a real war. Hey, I know, speculation, but the tone and details of that and other pics by Bioware tell a very different picture than what we see in-game, even in the Destroy ending itself.

2. Bar in Rio... meet me at the bar... drinks are on me. ????
You think Bioware would make *several* references to Rio? That would be far too blunt.
But my point was that Bioware seems to be strongly hinting that the story is NOT done yet, and we have yet one more location...one more story... to make.
Doesn't need to be a ME4, but in fact a conclusion DLC. Bioware can disclaim this stuff all they want, but we know their record.

3. Sadly... if the ending itself is what I think it is, Liara isn't safe from Bioware's writing. Doesn't mean she'll die in an indoctrinated mess though, don't get me wrong. I think Shepard's allies are Shepard's allies!
...I just also think that the Council standoff with the VS is a taste of what is possible. Just possible.

4. Bioware isn't just dropping Mass Effect, and imo they won't be wasting time on a side-story or RTS or recreation of the First Contact War. I strongly feel that the story will continue, even if Shepard's story (or at least story focus) will end.

#39796
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Bill Casey wrote...

spotlessvoid wrote...

Shepard needs to willingly align himself with the Reapers before being able to be ascended as the new Reapers avatar. Synthesis is walking into the beam, aligned with the Reapers. Literally. Just a thought.



I've actually thought about that...
With control as grabbing the structure while believing, and destroy as shooting the structure...

And sitting with Anderson as sitting with that dead guy by the circular thing...


And that's... fair enough...
I don't think that's happening at all, though...


I think the beam is just a massive fly trap. It doesn't transport anything, and Anderson is, sadly, compromised (so we get our properly sad goodbye with him through the 'dream'). The beam indoctrinates all who come near it.

Now why the Citadel is attached to it? .... we will more likely see with DLC.

Damn you EA!! *shakes fist*

#39797
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

MegumiAzusa wrote...

SwobyJ wrote...

But by the way, the Alliance had the Mars stuff for some time. :whistle:

Humans are idiots.


Nope.

Humans are guided by larger forces, at least when they're not aware of them. At least in the Mass Effect Universe.

#39798
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...

@Rif

The whole talk about London, to me, is clear forshadowing that the beam is a trap.

-Cerberus (Reapers by proxy) tries to take the Citadel
-Right after, the Reapers start something big in London
-Later, the Reapers take the Citadel, and connect it to the beam structure in London

The Reapers were planning this all along.

Reapers would've taken the Citadel regardless of Shep, they need it to build the new Human Reaper.

#39799
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages
Yeah, it's not like a giant space battery, if that's all it is, wouldn't be useful to the Reapers. Thanks for building it suckas!


Re the Beam still being on:
They want it on. We know what that implies.

They can't turn it off. Yeah....

Harbinger "How do I turn this off!"
Reaper 1 "press menu, select, then hit-"
Harbinger "how the hell-what's the sleep timer?
Reaper 2 "Hit exit, then menu, select-no, not stb, select. No-"
Harbinger"****! Shepards here!"

Modifié par spotlessvoid, 26 octobre 2012 - 03:14 .


#39800
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

BleedingUranium wrote...

@Rif

The whole talk about London, to me, is clear forshadowing that the beam is a trap.

-Cerberus (Reapers by proxy) tries to take the Citadel
-Right after, the Reapers start something big in London
-Later, the Reapers take the Citadel, and connect it to the beam structure in London

The Reapers were planning this all along.


I actually think the real TIM is out doing things quite against the Reapers.

And he tried to take the Citadel for his own purposes, via Omega+Klenndagon Weapon tech.

("It is revealed by the Illusive Man that an Alliance
Survey Team discovered that the Great Rift Valley was caused by a
strike from a mass accelerator round. The original target of that round
was the Derelict Reaper,
which was hit and disabled 37 million years ago. No trace remains of
the race that fired the round. However, he also indicates that both the
weapon and the target have been located, mentioning in passing that the
weapon was defunct.
")


I think both Destroy and Control are possible, but not in the way the Catalyst-BS-Dream shows. You can't trust a Reaper to offer Control.

Destroy - it's a super weapon, aplified by the Citadel (so this much the Catalyst is being kinda truthful on)
Control - it's capable of hacking Reapers, or of some such nature (Omega DLC can't come soon enough)
Synthesis - it makes the new Reaper personality. Sorry Shepard, you fell for it

But, again, you can't take control when you're already being controlled. Shepard is NOT fit.