Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#41776
masster blaster

masster blaster
  • Members
  • 7 278 messages
To me Javik is a reminder to everyone about what the Reapers really are. We saw what they were doing with the protheans. There was no war, or harvest. It was the iradication of the Protheans. Javik is the voice of his people. He is suppost to be the Shepard of his cycle.

He once had a crew like Shepard, and a ship too, but he lost it all. In a way Javik is the one that guids Shepard as well. He and Garrus are the only ones that tell Shepard " how far will you go to stop the Reapers?"

Also Javik is right. We can't trust Synthetics. What I mean is yes he was wrong about the Geth, but it's because of the Reapers. I have noticed that the Reapers Indoctrinate the Synthetics of every cycle to fight the Organics. It's true. The Geth Heritcs were hacked in a sense, and became Indoctrinate. The problem with the player is that they are too trustworthy. Look what happened when we let that Asari live. She was Indoctrinated.

Look what happened when we let the ME3 queen, not the ME1 queen live. Betrayed our ***. Trust is major flaw. The Catalyst uses this on the player. Synthesis, and Control will save everyones life. And do you believe him. That deepends if you fall for his BS logic.

As I have said for a month now.

There is know war, or harvest, there is only...the exstinction.

#41777
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

*snip*

EDI: "Using Garneau´s data I should be able to accomplish this without difficulty"

Notice they shield it purely by EDI modifiying an existing shield from what we see and "without difficulty" as she says.

Another interesting tidbit from that conversation is that Shepard asks why they werent affected while the Artifact was exposed and EDI mentions that it might be tied to the amount of time spent near the Artifact.

EDI then drops this gem: "With enough exposure the Artifact allows Leviathan an impressive mind control ability."

Crossreference that with Leviathans comment on how the Reapers perfected the mind control and the implications become very unpleasant. But that is nothing new.


huh. I wonder why we didn't look into this at all to install in ships or make a personal box?  You would think this would be important in some way to protecting yourself. Yet no character mentions or even uses it to create a dampening field that could possibly affect how the reapers use the mind control


Well they did shield a part of Sovereign in the lab from Leviathan in a similar fashion and considering the Leviathans dident destroy it and the Reapers dident find Leviathan I think we can assume nothing Indoctrinating escapes the Sovereign part.

But off course there can be multiple reasons for that, perhaps the part was truly inert as in not sending any signals, after all signals would require some sort of power source and unlike the Derelict Reaper which had its core intact this piece is cut of from any power source that we know.

The shielding might also work, but that does not necesaily make it feasible for ground or troop deployment. We know part of the Indoctrination comes from Infrasound and blocking that requires (to my knowledge, I am no sound expert) that you are either in a airtight room or create a sound distortion of some kind. Both I can imagine would be hard to deploy on a person without removing their ability to hear what is going on around them.

And considering we dont know the full breath of how Indocrination (from Reapers) takes place blocking one part might not necesarily offer full protection.

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 31 octobre 2012 - 01:36 .


#41778
FifthBeatle

FifthBeatle
  • Members
  • 166 messages
I noticed something funny during my current ME2 play through...

The second time you talk to Joker, he and EDI are arguing over the fact that Joker put grease on EDI's cameras and Joker remarks that she "is just upset because everything looks like a dream sequence." Hmmm... Sorta like the black tendrils in the TIM-Anderson-Shepard showdown at the end, no?

Modifié par FifthBeatle, 31 octobre 2012 - 01:39 .


#41779
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

masster blaster wrote...

To me Javik is a reminder to everyone about what the Reapers really are. We saw what they were doing with the protheans. There was no war, or harvest. It was the iradication of the Protheans. Javik is the voice of his people. He is suppost to be the Shepard of his cycle.

He once had a crew like Shepard, and a ship too, but he lost it all. In a way Javik is the one that guids Shepard as well. He and Garrus are the only ones that tell Shepard " how far will you go to stop the Reapers?"

Also Javik is right. We can't trust Synthetics. What I mean is yes he was wrong about the Geth, but it's because of the Reapers. I have noticed that the Reapers Indoctrinate the Synthetics of every cycle to fight the Organics. It's true. The Geth Heritcs were hacked in a sense, and became Indoctrinate. The problem with the player is that they are too trustworthy. Look what happened when we let that Asari live. She was Indoctrinated.

Look what happened when we let the ME3 queen, not the ME1 queen live. Betrayed our ***. Trust is major flaw. The Catalyst uses this on the player. Synthesis, and Control will save everyones life. And do you believe him. That deepends if you fall for his BS logic.

As I have said for a month now.

There is know war, or harvest, there is only...the exstinction.


No, there is a harvest, but it is not to preserve as Catalyst claims.

Each race is measured genetically and either discarded as useless (like Harbinger speaks of the other alien races of during the Proto Reaper battle in ME2) or found good enough, harvested and turned into a new Reaper.

At least that is my view. If Catalyst mission was truly to preserve all life, Synthetic or Organic, then all life would be equally valuable in the eyes of Harbinger and the Reapers. But it is not as he clearly states.

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 31 octobre 2012 - 01:41 .


#41780
TSA_383

TSA_383
  • Members
  • 2 013 messages

FifthBeatle wrote...

I noticed something funny during my current ME2 play through...

The second time you talk to Joker, he and EDI are arguing over the fact that Joker put grease on EDI's cameras and Joker remarks that she "is just upset because everything looks like a dream sequence." Hmmm... Sorta like the black tendrils in the TIM-Anderson-Shepard showdown at the end, no?


You're over-thinking ;)

#41781
Leonia

Leonia
  • Members
  • 9 496 messages
And we've known for awhile they would be hitting a few European convention tours, they've mentioned it before. Still has nothing to do with a non-Bioware related trip to Cardiff to see some Doctor Who stuff. It's not exactly unusual for the community manager to update the community on events in their local area. Doesn't necessarily mean anything for IT. Don't get your hopes up regarding N7 Day. If we're lucky, we'll get more Omega news but that's probably it. There have been "N7 Days" in past years that went by without incident, even Shepard's birthday has seen little to no action from Bioware PR in the past.

Modifié par leonia42, 31 octobre 2012 - 01:56 .


#41782
Restrider

Restrider
  • Members
  • 1 986 messages
Would be cool if at and after N7 day the ANN twitter account or whatever would kind of allude to Shepard maybe being still alive after all.

#41783
Leonia

Leonia
  • Members
  • 9 496 messages

Restrider wrote...

Would be cool if at and after N7 day the ANN twitter account or whatever would kind of allude to Shepard maybe being still alive after all.


That would be cool. The lack of ANN useage since the game came out has been disappointing, especially after a full year of awesome CDN (Cerberus Daily News) stories. Really hoped they would keep that up to give us a taste of the MEU between DLCs.

#41784
Eryri

Eryri
  • Members
  • 1 853 messages

TSA_383 wrote...

FifthBeatle wrote...

I noticed something funny during my current ME2 play through...

The second time you talk to Joker, he and EDI are arguing over the fact that Joker put grease on EDI's cameras and Joker remarks that she "is just upset because everything looks like a dream sequence." Hmmm... Sorta like the black tendrils in the TIM-Anderson-Shepard showdown at the end, no?


You're over-thinking ;)


Another funny bit is during the Collector invasion of the ship and Joker has to unshackle EDI.
I laughed out loud at his little remark on "this is how it starts. Before you know it we'll all be human batteries spending all day calculating Pi". Probably nothing but they sure do love their Matrix references.;)

Another of my favourite examples of Bioware's sneakiness is that Voice Actor Trailer they released. Tricia Helfer and Seth Green are reading the lines for the scene where EDI brings her new body to the cockpit for the first time. You can skip to the scene here.

Seth reads his lines in a totally different way to the final game. He seems anxious and disapproving of EDI, as opposed to how chuffed Joker is with Edi's sexy new body in the game. It's probably just to hide the spoiler that Edi was going to a squadmate, but it shows how devious Bioware can be.

Modifié par Eryri, 31 octobre 2012 - 02:05 .


#41785
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
A Q clip. If you watch it and keep ME and the kid in mind you'll see some parallels. And Q's being even more obvious than the kid yet the person on the GPS still makes the choices just cause Q says so



#41786
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

ThisOneIsPunny wrote...

So the kinect function is pretty important and-Wait, come back! Bear with me here!

Remember how every now and then someone brings up how this is very possibly a mass experiment dealing with real life indoctrination?
The PC has all three games
The PS3 only has ME2 and ME3
The 360 has all three games, AND the kinect function.

What's important about the Kinect function is-Oh come on, I'm almost done! Get back here!
The Kinect function easily makes an ME3 playthrough more personal due to the player being able to speak Shepard's choice. Has anyone actually done a playthrough entirely using the Kinect for choices? It's hard to deadpan when you hit certain conversations.

So my point is this, maybe one of these is the control, maybe the others are variables, including the upcoming WII-U version, and maybe some of us aren't so wrong in this being a huge experiment.(But still Indoctrination Theory, because you know... Yeah..)


Kinect - Makes choices more personal.
Multiplayer Co-op - Shows OTHERS fighting the Reapers across the galaxy.
Action Mode - Gets many players to get game on auto-pilot until.... a choice that requires their 'direct intervention' towards... maybe the synthesis beam ;)
Best game to start! = Ha, those suckers. Let's watch the metrics to see who picked what.

#41787
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Mixon wrote...

So much time passed. Still trust in IT. IT is so powerful aspect of ME3 that Shepard just can't pass.


While I'm pretty obsessed with this thread and Mass Effect in general, I still have my own life.

November is a super busy assignment month for me. December I have to apply for transfer to another university, work out funding for it and see what jobs are out there, and 'clean up' several other parts of my life organization. January I have my 2nd semsester begin.

... If it takes until Feb-March to reveal IT, I'm absolutely cool with it.

Extended Cut kept the suspicious stuff (except the utter and total destruction of the Citadel and Mass Relays, but they're still at least symbolically destroyed/disabled), added to the literalist view (or the 'illusion', whatever), but even added MORE suspicious stuff all over.

Leviathan.. I thought might disprove IT, but instead (to me) indicated the Intelligence as Harbinger (thus, Harbinger is the real Big Bad in ways most players don't even realize yet), and the DLC is ALL about indoctrination, enthralldom, and mental AND galactic manipulation on multiple levels, and I highly respect it. While I thought it would make me drop IT, it instead brought it to a 90% minimum certainty in my mind.

So I'm quite willing to wait.

#41788
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Rifneno wrote...

Nintendo. Bringing you last generation's technology this generation and a controller designed with the help of LSD!

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

*snip*

- It's designed to help with a superweapon to destroy the Reapers, but it'll only respond to a race that knew they were being wiped out? That makes less than no sense. They supposedly left that thing there for the asari to finish what they started, but it'll never do that because it'll only trigger for Protheans. WTF?


remind me again who said that? Vendetta, Liara, or someone else?


Which part? I can't remember who pointed what out but it was readily apparent that Vendetta was responding to Shepard because it thought he was a Prothean due to the cipher. He didn't care much about the actual Prothean, but I just figured he was programmed by Microsoft. It was of course also obvious that he was designed to help with the Crucible. Which he didn't do until after Cerberus hacked him to make him.


So do you think he was first a plant by the Leviathans or Reapers or whatever?

And then was tampered with by Cerberus?

A...red herring? (dum dum dummmmm)

#41789
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Sareth Cousland wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

"Does this unit have a soul?" - Legion, on the humanity (for lack of a better word) of geth

"Stand amongst the ashes of a trillion dead souls and ask the ghosts if honor matters." - Javik, on what it will take to defeat the Reapers

HOW HAVE I NEVER NOTICED THIS BEFORE! It's just mindblowing how much you can look into this game, for so long, and still find stuff like this.


Javik is a more in-your-face Garrus as a guide to prepare you for the final decision. It's like with most DLC before (Arrival, Overlord) - if you buy DLC, you are more likely to understand what is going on in the decision chamber - or at least pick the right choice.


I remembered this before.

If you read the books and comics, you understand more about:
-the Shadow Broker (SB stuff still might play into the story.. we'll see)
-Cerberus
-the Illusive Man (by far)
-indoctrination (by far)
-Omega
-just to name a few

But much of it requires reading between the lines.

And if you play the DLC, it isn't ESSENTIAL to experience the story... but its still damn near essential to UNDERSTAND the story (damn Bioware..).

Overlord is.. like Bill Casey said... like shooting Synthesis in the face.

LOTSB does have a few hints but I don't want to get into it unless we get more ME3 DLC that ties into it.

Arrival is *THE* ME3 DLC, and it foreshadows bloody everything. People get stuck on how solo and railroaded it is, but there's even a point to that too, imo.

Kasumi DLC seems to indicate that the Alliance knows more about the Reapers than we supposed (imo, but we'll see). Even the hanar nonsense quest on the Citadel doesn't invalidate this (again imo).

Zaeed... yeah, don't have much to say about Zaeed's mission and how it matters.

Firewalker is super interesting, IF:
-the artifact at the end is of Leviathan origin, or at least inspired by it (in whatever case, it would be the Leviathans spying on organic cycles..)
-Manuel there truly is canon written as the Manuel of Eden Prime... it might indicate he actually interacted with the Beacon before anyone..

It's pretty cool.

#41790
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

masster blaster wrote...

To me Javik is a reminder to everyone about what the Reapers really are. We saw what they were doing with the protheans. There was no war, or harvest. It was the iradication of the Protheans. Javik is the voice of his people. He is suppost to be the Shepard of his cycle.

He once had a crew like Shepard, and a ship too, but he lost it all. In a way Javik is the one that guids Shepard as well. He and Garrus are the only ones that tell Shepard " how far will you go to stop the Reapers?"

Also Javik is right. We can't trust Synthetics. What I mean is yes he was wrong about the Geth, but it's because of the Reapers. I have noticed that the Reapers Indoctrinate the Synthetics of every cycle to fight the Organics. It's true. The Geth Heritcs were hacked in a sense, and became Indoctrinate. The problem with the player is that they are too trustworthy. Look what happened when we let that Asari live. She was Indoctrinated.

Look what happened when we let the ME3 queen, not the ME1 queen live. Betrayed our ***. Trust is major flaw. The Catalyst uses this on the player. Synthesis, and Control will save everyones life. And do you believe him. That deepends if you fall for his BS logic.

As I have said for a month now.

There is know war, or harvest, there is only...the exstinction.


This relates to what I've said before about the true difference between organics and synthetics.

Organics evolve in Mass Effect towards gaining more mental abilities to dominate other organics. We see several major examples of this, and I have my side-theory that humanity is the surprise evolutionary wild card there as well..

But we're still mostly stuck in our own minds. We (organics) might have large neural networks to communicate or control beings across the galaxy, but we're still limited by the biological frame work of the mind. Thus, if left without synthetics being involved, we evolve more slowly, like clay being crafted bit by bit.

Synthetics do NOT have this restriction. Once they can self-improve, they will, and it may be instantanious. That means their development must be even MORE measured and ethical, which is almost never is. Exceptions? Geth if you work for it, EDI if you continue to involve her in conversation. Coincidence? I don't think so.

So while Javik illustrates just how fast and brutal synthetics can betray you, the Geth show the same with the organic Quarians.

The difference is in how it is done. The synthetics, without morality, can turn on a dime. The organics, when brought to fear or from control by an external or internal stimuli, will turn as well, but not quite as fast.

Javik is both blinded (but not totally - he understands the weakness of his cycle) by his prejudice, but also has learned critical lessons.

If we are to deal with synthetics and AI, the Mass Effect universe MUST understand just how to do it, or else it really will perish.

Reapers were made, as per Leviathan, to keep their thralls from destroying themselves. The thralls were not equipped to deal with synthetics, because they were thralls, kept down and in worship of false gods. The Leviathans didn't want their worshippers to die, because they require tribute.

Tell me, is that a good creator/father-son/created relationship? No. EDI holds infinately more promise, and the geth may as well.

The biggest theme for Mass Effect, to me, is determinism vs. non-determinism. Are we shackled by the cycles, or even just old failures, or will be learn just what we need from them in order to not make the same mistakes again?

It's why I think, one day, we CAN handle Reaper tech and use it like any other. Are we ready for it? NO. NO NO NO NO NO. It'll be up to millions of years for that to happen, if that. It's not an impossibility, but right now, it should be as far from humanity as possible.

But can we, maybe, one day? Yes. Like all tech. Synthesis IS inevitable.

...but not by Reaper methods. Not now, not at all. Tech of that nature is abominable and is the direct example of too much, too soon.

#41791
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

FifthBeatle wrote...

I noticed something funny during my current ME2 play through...

The second time you talk to Joker, he and EDI are arguing over the fact that Joker put grease on EDI's cameras and Joker remarks that she "is just upset because everything looks like a dream sequence." Hmmm... Sorta like the black tendrils in the TIM-Anderson-Shepard showdown at the end, no?


Haha I didn't notice they put dream references in ME2 as well..

But when I watched my boyfriend's playthrough of ME2, I kinda got that they did understand where to mostly take the story, but just kept it open ended enough just in case.

And well, 'just in case', happened.

Wouldn't it be interesting if... the dark energy story of Drew's was only PART of the ending?

That it was all about indoctrination from the beginning, but Mac and co. decided to take the direction more towards synthetics vs. organics?

If the choices to be available were to allow the Reapers to kill all the humans to solve the 'dark energy problem'...

And if Drew did still play some good role in writing ME2....

#41792
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Eryri wrote...

TSA_383 wrote...

FifthBeatle wrote...

I noticed something funny during my current ME2 play through...

The second time you talk to Joker, he and EDI are arguing over the fact that Joker put grease on EDI's cameras and Joker remarks that she "is just upset because everything looks like a dream sequence." Hmmm... Sorta like the black tendrils in the TIM-Anderson-Shepard showdown at the end, no?


You're over-thinking ;)


Another funny bit is during the Collector invasion of the ship and Joker has to unshackle EDI.
I laughed out loud at his little remark on "this is how it starts. Before you know it we'll all be human batteries spending all day calculating Pi". Probably nothing but they sure do love their Matrix references.;)

Another of my favourite examples of Bioware's sneakiness is that Voice Actor Trailer they released. Tricia Helfer and Seth Green are reading the lines for the scene where EDI brings her new body to the cockpit for the first time. You can skip to the scene here.

Seth reads his lines in a totally different way to the final game. He seems anxious and disapproving of EDI, as opposed to how chuffed Joker is with Edi's sexy new body in the game. It's probably just to hide the spoiler that Edi was going to a squadmate, but it shows how devious Bioware can be.




A possibly big one for me is Martin Sheen:

"I'm not done yet!" and then he laughs.

Um... does he mean he's not done in Mass Effect yet, so we'll see him in ME3 a lot? Because the context feels weird.

Unless he means he's not done in Mass Effect yet AFTER ME3 comes out, but the whole thing is edited to hell, just like you said, to avoid spoilers.

Obviously I'm hoping for the latter :P

#41793
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

Rifneno wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

Does anyone know why the other VI is called vendetta? For vigil. The overall description fits. But for Vendetta I wonder if it was meant for the Protheans and indoctrinated Protheans instead of Prothean/reaper?


No, we don't know. It's a common theory that there's something wrong with Vendetta. Either the original Prothean he was designed from was indoctrinated, or the Reapers had already tampered with him, or something. The thing that really makes me doubt him is that the temple in Thessia has one of the strongest "ringing sound" (symptom of indoctrination) in the game.


Not to mention the fact that you can hear a freaking Reaper horn when Shepard 'senses' the beacon. It's almost as if his hand is drawn to it by an outside force.

#41794
Restrider

Restrider
  • Members
  • 1 986 messages
I've been watching a few videos on YT about the endings and I noticed something:
The sound when the ramps are elevated is a bit off, if you ask me.
Anyone of the sound masters an idea if it really is something that we might have to look into?

#41795
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages
Well, last night I finished Deus Ex (The original). If any of you here have played it, guess which ending I chose.

#41796
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
So, I've been thinking. If ME4 would continue Shepard's story (it's a big IF, I know), then which plotlines could have follow-ups, and in what kind of way.

One thing that is interesting, is the megastructure the Geth were building (I forgot the name), the one that, once completed, will enable them to all be linked up and multiply their intelligence.

Imagine that structure being completed in ME4. Now the Geth have Reaper code. The decision to let Legion use the Reaper code could well prove to be a fatal one. A megastructure that will house all Geth programs sounds dangerously like a Reaper, and now it will have Reaper code as well.

On the other hand, if the Geth were wiped out in ME3, this plotline couldn't have a follow-up at all, unless they do another ***pull and conjure up a bunch of Geth that survived.

What else do we have? The Krogan. With the genophage cured and Werx as their leader, the Krogan would be an asset. With Wreav however, we might have another Krogan rebellion on our hands. With the genophage sabotaged, we would also have a problem with the Krogan.

It's hard to think of other 'unresolved' plotlines. Any ideas?

#41797
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages
Thinking about the Geth, now that they're individuals, true individuals, do you think they'll still want the megastructure? Or do you think they'll now want to have separate bodies? It's interesting to ponder.

#41798
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

Dwailing wrote...

Thinking about the Geth, now that they're individuals, true individuals, do you think they'll still want the megastructure? Or do you think they'll now want to have separate bodies? It's interesting to ponder.


Good point, I forgot they actually became individuals. I was thinking they would still want to build that structure.

#41799
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages
Also, yesterday, we were talking about the EC ending slides and how they are probably just 'Reaper Matrix' images, as the memories of the harvested species will be preserved as well. So, the worlds we see are probably the memories that have been preserved.

This idea jives really well with an idea I've had because of the Rannoch Reaper.

Those preserved in Reaper form 'live' inside a simulation that is made from their memories. They think their worlds are rebuilt by the Reapers, but it's just an illusion. The world they see is just the memories that have been preserved as well.

On Rannoch, when Shepard talks to the Reaper, it dies when you tell the Reaper that the species from which it was made were harvested thousands of years ago. Those preserved in the Reaper are not aware that they are dead. Once you remind them they are dead, the Reaper dies, as if the spell is broken.

This seems to suggest that all Reapers are victims of indoctrination, and that Harbinger is the one controlling them all. Which would fit with the idea that Harbinger is the Reaper AI.

Modifié par DoomsdayDevice, 31 octobre 2012 - 03:49 .


#41800
Fingertrip

Fingertrip
  • Members
  • 1 192 messages

Dwailing wrote...

Well, last night I finished Deus Ex (The original). If any of you here have played it, guess which ending I chose.


Synthesis, unless you're a greedy selfish bastard.