Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#43701
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages
Because he has a gambling problem...

#43702
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...
So anyway, back on track... that line from Padok Wiks mentioned earlier? "Somewhere, deep in the fabric of reality, our actions are recorded and remembered. Yours will be remembered for eternity." That one. It's from the end of the Tuchanka mission where Shepard is given the choice on whether to let Wiks cure the genophage. Seems an odd line, doesn't it? Now consider this... whether you cured the genophage is what determines whether Starbinger is an ass to you at the end or if he's all polite.

Is this true?


Near as I can tell.  I found the plot flag that determines whether the brat needs a nap or not, and it always set between the last opportunity to save before curing the genophage, and the first opportunity to save afterwards.

I always thought that it had to do with EMS.

Now how can we apply this? I think it gives credit to the end being made up by Shepards memories. Sorry, but that is the best I can do right now. How about you? I will try and think this over.


I highly doubt EMS.  My EMS is ridiculous from MP anyway.  I'd say you're right, it's more of a "Shepard's subconscious is punishing him for being a douche" thing.

So you're saying you have a full ems where star child says "Why are you here?"

#43703
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

demersel wrote...

paxxton wrote...

I don't take my scientific knowledge from movies.


Yes. For you it is Initially X-box Exclusive Games only. Right. 

LOL.

#43704
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

magnetite wrote...

Just wrapped up my 35 hour playthrough of Mass Effect 3. I basically talked to every single person on the Citadel and the Normandy after each mission I did. There's no doubt, IT is definitely what the ending is or what was intended by Bioware. It's not meant to be anything else (no space magic or otherwise involved here). Naysayers can't hide from the truth.


Yeah I only have:
-Sanctuary
-Leviathan
-1-2 more N7 missions
-Cronos Station
-London
-Citadel/Crucible

left in my completionist Insanity playthrough and I'm right with you. It's damn clear that the ending IS a mind-f*** and we're MEANT to understand that the Mass Effect story isn't done yet, even if the story focus (aka Shepard's Story) is done with ME3.

#43705
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

demersel wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...


Maybe because he can afford to lose that bet, and the gesture looks grand and makes a great publicity story? 


Google "scientific wager" sometime.  Enjoy the education.

#43706
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

paxxton wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...

He apparently lost it.

Did you get something I missed?

#43707
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

plfranke wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...
So anyway, back on track... that line from Padok Wiks mentioned earlier? "Somewhere, deep in the fabric of reality, our actions are recorded and remembered. Yours will be remembered for eternity." That one. It's from the end of the Tuchanka mission where Shepard is given the choice on whether to let Wiks cure the genophage. Seems an odd line, doesn't it? Now consider this... whether you cured the genophage is what determines whether Starbinger is an ass to you at the end or if he's all polite.

Is this true?


Near as I can tell.  I found the plot flag that determines whether the brat needs a nap or not, and it always set between the last opportunity to save before curing the genophage, and the first opportunity to save afterwards.

I always thought that it had to do with EMS.

Now how can we apply this? I think it gives credit to the end being made up by Shepards memories. Sorry, but that is the best I can do right now. How about you? I will try and think this over.


I highly doubt EMS.  My EMS is ridiculous from MP anyway.  I'd say you're right, it's more of a "Shepard's subconscious is punishing him for being a douche" thing.

So you're saying you have a full ems where star child says "Why are you here?"


I didn't take it all the way to the end of the game each time just to test.  God, that would take forever.  I used Gibbed's datamined documents to look up the plot id that causes that branch in his dialogue.  Then I tested a bunch of saves and tried new stuff to see when that plot id was altered.

#43708
ZerebusPrime

ZerebusPrime
  • Members
  • 1 631 messages

401 Kill wrote...

@ZerebusPrime- The parallel between the kid and the cut dialogue between Anderson and Shepard is interesting. Wasn't it stated in the comics that Anderson did have a kid? If so, this gives it even more credit to the conversation being in Shepards mind. It's how he "idolizes" Anderson to be.


I'd bet that the dialog was removed because it would have been a solid giveaway that what we were seeing at the end of the game wasn't lining up with established facts.

#43709
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Rifneno wrote...

demersel wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...


Maybe because he can afford to lose that bet, and the gesture looks grand and makes a great publicity story? 


Google "scientific wager" sometime.  Enjoy the education.


Google "Porn". Enjoy the sensation. . 

#43710
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

demersel wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

demersel wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...


Maybe because he can afford to lose that bet, and the gesture looks grand and makes a great publicity story? 


Google "scientific wager" sometime.  Enjoy the education.


Google "Porn". Enjoy the sensation. . 


Good idea!  Be back in 20 guys.

#43711
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

ZerebusPrime wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

@ZerebusPrime- The parallel between the kid and the cut dialogue between Anderson and Shepard is interesting. Wasn't it stated in the comics that Anderson did have a kid? If so, this gives it even more credit to the conversation being in Shepards mind. It's how he "idolizes" Anderson to be.


I'd bet that the dialog was removed because it would have been a solid giveaway that what we were seeing at the end of the game wasn't lining up with established facts.

Or maybe if Anderson revealed to Shepard that he was in fact his father, this would have hinted too much towards another franchise?...  :lol:

#43712
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...

He apparently lost it.

Did you get something I missed?

The last time I checked CERN announced that they'd found a particle with properties (energy state?) similar to the Higgs boson. IIRC Hawking himself acknowledged he lost 100 bucks.

#43713
Home run MF

Home run MF
  • Members
  • 805 messages

ZerebusPrime wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

@ZerebusPrime- The parallel between the kid and the cut dialogue between Anderson and Shepard is interesting. Wasn't it stated in the comics that Anderson did have a kid? If so, this gives it even more credit to the conversation being in Shepards mind. It's how he "idolizes" Anderson to be.


I'd bet that the dialog was removed because it would have been a solid giveaway that what we were seeing at the end of the game wasn't lining up with established facts.


Nowhere in the comics or the books it's established Anderson has kids. In fact it's the contrary, when Anderson fills for divorce his lawyer tells him it would have been a nightmare if he had kids.

#43714
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

SwobyJ wrote...



. It's damn clear that the ending IS a mind-f*** and we're MEANT to understand that the Mass Effect story isn't done yet, even if the story focus (aka Shepard's Story) is done with ME3.

I cringe whenever I read things like this. We still have no idea what is happening to Shepard after Destroy. I'm all fine and dandy with Shepards story being completed, but it is currently not completed. I am fine if Shepards story arc is completed, but we are not there yet. I weep at ME4 not having Shepard without finishing his story. That will be a disappointment that I will not be able to overcome.

#43715
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

paxxton wrote...
The last time I checked CERN announced that they'd found a particle with properties (energy state?) similar to the Higgs boson. IIRC Hawking himself acknowledged he lost 100 bucks.

I got this on Wiki :

"So far the observations are consistent with the observed particle being the Standard Model Higgs boson. The particle decays into at least some of the predicted channels. Moreover, the production rates and branching ratios for the observed channels match the predictions by the Standard Model within the experimental uncertainties.However, the experimental uncertainties currently still leave room for alternative explanations. It is therefore too early to conclude that the found particle is indeed the Standard Model Higgs.

Further confirmation will require more precise data on some of the characteristic of the new particle, including its other decay channels and various quantum numbers such as its parity. To allow for further data gathering, the current LHC proton-proton collision run has been extended by seven weeks, delaying the planned long shutdown for upgrades in 2013. It is hoped that this extra data will allow a more conclusive statement on the nature of the new particle in December."

Maybe I'm not reading well, but I think they reasonably hold their enthusiasm, at least it looks like it. Where did you read something more affirmative of the discovery?

Modifié par Iconoclaste, 05 novembre 2012 - 03:27 .


#43716
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

401 Kill wrote...

I cringe whenever I read things like this. We still have no idea what is happening to Shepard after Destroy. I'm all fine and dandy with Shepards story being completed, but it is currently not completed. I am fine if Shepards story arc is completed, but we are not there yet. I weep at ME4 not having Shepard without finishing his story. That will be a disappointment that I will not be able to overcome.


Relax - ME3 is not done until the DLC cycle is done. 

#43717
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

Home run MF wrote...

ZerebusPrime wrote...

401 Kill wrote...
@ZerebusPrime- The parallel between the kid and the cut dialogue between Anderson and Shepard is interesting. Wasn't it stated in the comics that Anderson did have a kid? If so, this gives it even more credit to the conversation being in Shepards mind. It's how he "idolizes" Anderson to be.


I'd bet that the dialog was removed because it would have been a solid giveaway that what we were seeing at the end of the game wasn't lining up with established facts.


Nowhere in the comics or the books it's established Anderson has kids. In fact it's the contrary, when Anderson fills for divorce his lawyer tells him it would have been a nightmare if he had kids.

Ah, thank you for clearing this up! He techniquenly had a family though.

#43718
Bill Casey

Bill Casey
  • Members
  • 7 609 messages

Rifneno wrote...

demersel wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...
But I wonder why Stephen Hawkings bet 100$ with fellow scientists that they will not find the Higgs boson...


Maybe because he can afford to lose that bet, and the gesture looks grand and makes a great publicity story? 


Google "scientific wager" sometime.  Enjoy the education.


Google Hawkings track record on such bets...

Modifié par Bill Casey, 05 novembre 2012 - 03:28 .


#43719
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

demersel wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

I cringe whenever I read things like this. We still have no idea what is happening to Shepard after Destroy. I'm all fine and dandy with Shepards story being completed, but it is currently not completed. I am fine if Shepards story arc is completed, but we are not there yet. I weep at ME4 not having Shepard without finishing his story. That will be a disappointment that I will not be able to overcome.


Relax - ME3 is not done until the DLC cycle is done. 

I can only hope so :unsure:.

#43720
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests

SwobyJ wrote...

left in my completionist Insanity playthrough and I'm right with you. It's damn clear that the ending IS a mind-f*** and we're MEANT to understand that the Mass Effect story isn't done yet, even if the story focus (aka Shepard's Story) is done with ME3.


I forgot about the Leviathan DLC, but that was released after the main game. Haven't done that yet, but the scene with Hadley is basically a carbon copy of what happens with Shepard, Anderson, and TIM.  The scene

Modifié par magnetite, 05 novembre 2012 - 03:33 .


#43721
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

paxxton wrote...
The last time I checked CERN announced that they'd found a particle with properties (energy state?) similar to the Higgs boson. IIRC Hawking himself acknowledged he lost 100 bucks.

I got this on Wiki :

"So far the observations are consistent with the observed particle being the Standard Model Higgs boson. The particle decays into at least some of the predicted channels. Moreover, the production rates and branching ratios for the observed channels match the predictions by the Standard Model within the experimental uncertainties.However, the experimental uncertainties currently still leave room for alternative explanations. It is therefore too early to conclude that the found particle is indeed the Standard Model Higgs.

Further confirmation will require more precise data on some of the characteristic of the new particle, including its other decay channels and various quantum numbers such as its parity. To allow for further data gathering, the current LHC proton-proton collision run has been extended by seven weeks, delaying the planned long shutdown for upgrades in 2013. It is hoped that this extra data will allow a more conclusive statement on the nature of the new particle in December."

Maybe I'm not reading well, but I think they reasonably hold their enthusiasm, at least it looks like it. Where did you read something more affirmative of the discovery?

Well, it was in their initial announcement on YT. But I know that there were some doubts afterwards and hence the extended experimentation period. The more data they gather, the narrower the window for the particle to be confirmed or denied as the Higgs boson will become.

Modifié par paxxton, 05 novembre 2012 - 03:36 .


#43722
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

plfranke wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

Rifneno wrote...
So anyway, back on track... that line from Padok Wiks mentioned earlier? "Somewhere, deep in the fabric of reality, our actions are recorded and remembered. Yours will be remembered for eternity." That one. It's from the end of the Tuchanka mission where Shepard is given the choice on whether to let Wiks cure the genophage. Seems an odd line, doesn't it? Now consider this... whether you cured the genophage is what determines whether Starbinger is an ass to you at the end or if he's all polite.

Is this true?


Near as I can tell.  I found the plot flag that determines whether the brat needs a nap or not, and it always set between the last opportunity to save before curing the genophage, and the first opportunity to save afterwards.

I always thought that it had to do with EMS.

Now how can we apply this? I think it gives credit to the end being made up by Shepards memories. Sorry, but that is the best I can do right now. How about you? I will try and think this over.


I highly doubt EMS.  My EMS is ridiculous from MP anyway.  I'd say you're right, it's more of a "Shepard's subconscious is punishing him for being a douche" thing.

So you're saying you have a full ems where star child says "Why are you here?"


I never heard "why are you here?"

Is this in place of 'wake up'?  I do think it connects to shepards subconscious as do the voices in the nightmares which are indoctrination and we've read what they say. Lots of things to feel guilt over or generally unpleasant things. Like things that could haunt you. I would think that it's all connects. How the brat treats you would be symbolic as well since it's not real. It's a representation or projection of yourself on some level. I've come to think it represents the aspects of what shepard had to do to get the allied forces. Normandy is destroy which represents humans, synthesis is krogan/salarians and probably the turians too since they were involved, and the Quarians/geth are control. These are the key races that play a part in retaking earth depending on how things worked out. So I think the hallucination is a mirror of that and the conflict because no matter what YOU chose, there was always the other option. You could always let the krogan not have the cure. You could always destroy the geth or the quarians. You always had those choices and they were difficult ones no matter what YOU think as a player because the geth were the ones you were fighting all through ME1 and the krogan curing the genophage could lead to krogan rebellions again which would put the galaxy at risk but most especially the salarians and turians. Also, you have ALL of these races represented on your ship during ME3. Mordin, Legion, Tali, Garrus, Wrex - all of whom you have been close to during one of the games though least close to Legion until ME3 where he helps you a lot and you mourn his loss. The choices might simply represent all the conflicts playing out in shepard's psyche since essentially shepard was playing God through the game. Deciding the fate of each species depending on the choices made.

Modifié par starlitegirlx, 05 novembre 2012 - 03:54 .


#43723
Andromidius

Andromidius
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages
Best motivator to get someone to do something is to tell them its impossible.

Hense Hawking tells other scientists they won't find it, and bets money on it. So they set out to prove they can. Its a very smart move by him, even if he doubted it existed to begin with. Being right is secondary to scientific discovery.

And yeah, the Quantum Entanglement thing. I guess its like pulling a taut string - even if its moving extremely slowly it still acts on all points (nearly) instantly. Thus if you create a device with hundreds of such 'strings' that reads different movements as code you have instantaneous communication with any point in the galaxy.

And I suppose its possible to even have multi-way communication if there is a relay system connecting them all that can then copy the message to its destination. Sort of like a spider web in design. You're always in contact with the relay hub, not the person you're communicating to.

#43724
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

401 Kill wrote...

SwobyJ wrote...



. It's damn clear that the ending IS a mind-f*** and we're MEANT to understand that the Mass Effect story isn't done yet, even if the story focus (aka Shepard's Story) is done with ME3.

I cringe whenever I read things like this. We still have no idea what is happening to Shepard after Destroy. I'm all fine and dandy with Shepards story being completed, but it is currently not completed. I am fine if Shepards story arc is completed, but we are not there yet. I weep at ME4 not having Shepard without finishing his story. That will be a disappointment that I will not be able to overcome.


Look, when I said "It's clear", I mean "It's clear to me".

Especially with my thoughts of there being an expansion, instead of just DLC/ME4.

#43725
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages
Huh, so the genophage choice affects Star-Brat's dialogue? That's... very interesting. Someone should do a playthrough where they don't cure the genophage.