Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#47751
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages
Happy page 1911 everyone! Posted Image

Posted Image

#47752
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests
Something else I found out as of a couple months ago:

TSA_383 wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Also, in the Final Hours app, the chapter they talk about the ending is called "The Perfect Illusion". Can't be just a coincidence.



This.
I first saw that a couple of months ago, and I still regard it as evidence for our case here.
I'd be curious to know how much the guy who wrote the final hours app knows...



Wait, they actually referred to The Ending as "The Perfect Illusion"?

WHY THE HELL WASN'T I TOLD?

We might as well call it here. IT is confirmed.

It's from the previous thread.

#47753
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

magnetite wrote...

Something else I found out as of a couple months ago:

TSA_383 wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Also, in the Final Hours app, the chapter they talk about the ending is called "The Perfect Illusion". Can't be just a coincidence.



This.
I first saw that a couple of months ago, and I still regard it as evidence for our case here.
I'd be curious to know how much the guy who wrote the final hours app knows...



Wait, they actually referred to The Ending as "The Perfect Illusion"?

WHY THE HELL WASN'T I TOLD?

We might as well call it here. IT is confirmed.

It's from the previous thread.


They were a lot less subtle at first. For the first month or so after launch they were dropping hints everywhere, then abruptly stopped. It's like they wanted IT to get itself going, then removed the training wheels when we had Posted Image

#47754
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

magnetite wrote...

Something else I found out as of a couple months ago:

TSA_383 wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Also, in the Final Hours app, the chapter they talk about the ending is called "The Perfect Illusion". Can't be just a coincidence.



This.
I first saw that a couple of months ago, and I still regard it as evidence for our case here.
I'd be curious to know how much the guy who wrote the final hours app knows...



Wait, they actually referred to The Ending as "The Perfect Illusion"?

WHY THE HELL WASN'T I TOLD?

We might as well call it here. IT is confirmed.

It's from the previous thread.


"The Perfect Illusion"  eh? Well that pretty much goes against any litteral interpretation of the ending since under a litteral interpretation there is nothing Illusinary over the ending.

#47755
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests
Gotta say though, it's the most mind blowing ending twist I've ever seen in all my years of gaming. It'll go down as the greatest video game ending ever created, at least for me.

#47756
MWMike2011

MWMike2011
  • Members
  • 486 messages

magnetite wrote...

MWMike2011 wrote...
I agree. I wasn't pissed off by the ending, just disappointed. It didn't make a whole lot of sense, but after hanging around the forums and watching Acavayos' video, it started falling together. I still want the devs to release the DLC to confirm it, though...


I wouldn't get our hopes up. If they don't release a confirmation DLC, that doesn't make it not true and that we're all just supposed to believe the ending from a literal sense. I mean Shepard is showing every single symptom not to mention all the evidence that we found. Thing is by relying on the devs to tell us what is true, and what isn't, that's indoctrination.

You might want to watch this video. It's very interesting. Doesn't relate to Mass Effect, but it does have to do with indoctrination in general.


No, if they don't release confirmation DLC, it doesn't necessarily make it not true. The fact that they have let this entire thread go on for a combined 6000+ pages proves that there is at least a very real possibility that it holds merit. That said, though, I would at least like to see it validated. If it isn't and they continue making incredible DLC like they have been doing, I will most likely get ME4 when it is released. To me, it is real. Shepard was in the ending stages of being indoctrinated. When my John Shepard shot the **** out of that terminal and put an end to the Reapers, he walk up, dusted himself off, shot a husk square in the forehead, and gave Harbinger the finger right as Normandy shot the killshot to end him. The combined, assembled fleet beats the bejesus out of the fleet.

I have to believe, though, that they are really planning something to show your assets in use. I mean, come on. They SURELY weren't going to make you go through 40+ hours, not to mention all that multiplayer, just for it to mean nothing. I flat out refuse to believe that. And, sense they did design this game with the mass market in mind, I whole heartedly believe that they are planning on showing the true ending in a paid DLC.

#47757
MWMike2011

MWMike2011
  • Members
  • 486 messages

magnetite wrote...

Gotta say though, it's the most mind blowing ending twist I've ever seen in all my years of gaming. It'll go down as the greatest video game ending ever created, at least for me.


Agreed. From the company that brought you YOU ARE REVAN!, comes the BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE! :o

#47758
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

MWMike2011 wrote...

magnetite wrote...

Gotta say though, it's the most mind blowing ending twist I've ever seen in all my years of gaming. It'll go down as the greatest video game ending ever created, at least for me.


Agreed. From the company that brought you YOU ARE REVAN!, comes the BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE! :o


Someone who knows the list of all the twists and deceptions BioWare has done over the years should post it again. I believe, without IT, Mass Effect would be the only series without one.


magnetite wrote...

Gotta say though, it's the most mind blowing ending twist I've ever seen in all my years of gaming. It'll go down as the greatest video game ending ever created, at least for me.


Agreed! Though, all my years only go back to 2007 Posted Image

Modifié par BleedingUranium, 18 novembre 2012 - 08:53 .


#47759
MWMike2011

MWMike2011
  • Members
  • 486 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...



Someone who knows the list of all the twists and deceptions BioWare has done over the years should post it again. I believe, without IT, Mass Effect would be the only series without one.


Did Dragon Age: Origins have one? I can't remember, been far too long since I played through the whole thing. And never played Baldur's Gate...

#47760
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

"The Perfect Illusion"  eh? Well that pretty much goes against any litteral interpretation of the ending since under a litteral interpretation there is nothing Illusinary over the ending.


Aside from TIM confrontation change (boss battle that turned into what we have today), and the changes to the Starbinger scene (it was a Q & A session, rather than what it was originally where you didn't ask him about the Reapers or Leviathan with that DLC. Perhaps similar to the EC), they don't mention anything else in that chapter. Maybe polishing the game and fixing bugs, but that doesn't hint at an illusion of any sort.

I'd suggest reading through the whole thing. It's only around $3 or so. Lots of cool information.

#47761
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests

BleedingUranium wrote...

Agreed! Though, all my years only go back to 2007 Posted Image


Endings are quite complex today. Back when I was growing up this was considered a traditional ending. Very simple by today's standards.

Ack, double post. Sorry.

Modifié par magnetite, 18 novembre 2012 - 09:01 .


#47762
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
I'm willing to predict that BioWare will release a dlc on 4/11. Here's why:

Shepard was born 4/11
Shepard enlisted 4/11

Wouldn't it be interesting if they released a Shepard dlc on that day?

#47763
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

MWMike2011 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...



Someone who knows the list of all the twists and deceptions BioWare has done over the years should post it again. I believe, without IT, Mass Effect would be the only series without one.


Did Dragon Age: Origins have one? I can't remember, been far too long since I played through the whole thing. And never played Baldur's Gate...


Ill have a go at this as I have played or know of quite a few Bioware games. Oh and obviusly heavy spoilers here, proceed at own risk.

Baldurs Gate 1: Sarevok is your half-brother and you are both Bhaalspawn.

Neverwinter Nights: No idea, I must admit.

Jade Empire: Throughout the game you repeadedly hear from other characters you fight how your style seems to have a flaw, though they are unable to exploit it as they cant quite find it. They dismiss it as a clever trick in your style drawing in the opponent to strike where no flaw exists...that is until your mentor reveals his true colors as the true villian of the game and using his knowledge of your style and its flaw easily kills you.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: Revan, nuff said.

Dragon Age: Origin: Perhaps not a twist per see, but Teyrn Loghains betrayal at the start of the game actually took me by suprise. A better example might be the reveal that a Grey Warden must die to kill the Archdemon.

Mass Effect 1: Sovereign is not a ship, it is a Reaper.

Mass Effect 2: Reapers are made from somekind of DNA paste made from breaking down Organics and the Collectors were Protheans.

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 18 novembre 2012 - 09:17 .


#47764
MWMike2011

MWMike2011
  • Members
  • 486 messages

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

MWMike2011 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...



Someone who knows the list of all the twists and deceptions BioWare has done over the years should post it again. I believe, without IT, Mass Effect would be the only series without one.


Did Dragon Age: Origins have one? I can't remember, been far too long since I played through the whole thing. And never played Baldur's Gate...


Ill have a go at this as I have played or know of quite a few Bioware games. Oh and obviusly heavy spoilers here, proceed at own risk.

Baldurs Gate 1: Sarevok is your half-brother and you are both Bhaalspawn.

Neverwinter Nights: No idea, I must admit.

Jade Empire: Throughout the game you repeadedly hear from other characters you fight how your style seems to have a flaw, though they are unable to exploit it as they cant quite find it. They dismiss it as a clever trick in your style drawing in the opponent to strike where no flaw exists...that is until your mentor reveals his true colors as the true villian of the series and using his knowledge of your style and its flaw easily kills you.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: Revan, nuff said.

Dragon Age: Origin: Perhaps not a twist per see, but Teyrn Loghains betrayal at the start of the game actually took me by suprise. A better example might be the reveal that a Grey Warden must die to kill the Archdemon.

Mass Effect 1: Sovereign is not a ship, it is a Reaper.

Mass Effect 2: Reapers are made from somekind of DNA paste made from breaking down Organics and the Collectors were Protheans.


Neverwinter Nights: Aribeth was working for Morag the whole time. Not to mention her boyfriend and his boss started the plague in act I. :blink:

#47765
MWMike2011

MWMike2011
  • Members
  • 486 messages
The fact that Bioware was the developer on that is a surprise to me. I now understand why I love that game, too. Lol

#47766
Gwyphon

Gwyphon
  • Members
  • 810 messages
We just have to stay at this page for 4 and a half hours and we'll be at page 1911 on the 19th of November!

#47767
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages
I believe in an expansion for NWN the final boss fight was in an illusion, and if you chose wrong the credits rolled, but if you saw through the illusion you broke free and actaully fought him.

Someone should know it better than I, but I think that's the most important one.

#47768
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

magnetite wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

Agreed! Though, all my years only go back to 2007 Posted Image


Endings are quite complex today. Back when I was growing up this was considered a traditional ending. Very simple by today's standards.

Ack, double post. Sorry.


Hahaha Posted Image

I'm off to bed now, see you all tomorrow! Posted Image

#47769
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

cavs25 wrote...

I love this theory but I have some questions for you guys: (They probably have been answered before)
These are things that bother me when I think about IT.
1. Why does Harbinger give you a choice to break free from indoctrination?
Why doesn't he just put you on an endless loop?
Is it Shepard's will creating the option in his mind?

2. Why doesn't Shepard wake up immediately after breaking indoctrination? (Choosing destroy)

3.Completely random: Whats up with leviathans obvious eye shifting when is asked about the crucible? He knows something he isn't sharing, but what?
Does he know is a trap?
But if he did why wouldn't he tell Shepard
No reason why the leviathans would want the reapers to succeed with the harvest..


I know the guys here alreay covered it, but still, I'll pitch in.

1. The thing about indoctrination most people actually forget is that it doesn't really make you do anything. Like Leviathan's entrallment or the spores of the thorian. It just makes you suggestions, and suddenly you come to interesting conclusions - those you wouldn't even think about before. 
The reason why there is a choice to break free from indoctrination is because, belive it or not - IT IS ACTUALLY YOUR MIND. I mean it is yours - you own it - you can do anything you like! And every action you take - it is the action you choose to take. You point a gun, you pull the trigger. You choose to shot your friend and allie in the back. It is not like someone made you shoot mordin. Or Ashley, Or Wrex.  It just for some reason may seem like a think to do at the moment, and not always it will be because of the reapers. It is deffinitly Shepard;s will that is creating this option. Stephen King wrote a novel - Dreamcather - and there one character get's trapped inside a tiny room inside his own brain, while his body and the rest of his brain is highjacked by an alien. Spoilers ahead. You know how he beat him, and got that alien purged out of his brain? He just realized that he's in the small tiny room, and the alien is in control of the rest of his brain because he's scared - and the room his in can be as big as he want's it to be. And in fact it is not he, who is locked out of the rest of his brain, but really the alien, and the allien is in control only because he' himself is scared and just want to hide in a small tiny safe room. Then he makes this room bigger, and it get's reversed - the room is everything his brain is, and everything outside the door becomes just a tiny broom closet - it represents the small damaged part of his brain affected by the alien infection. 

2. Who  says that the breath scene is not a part of thedream where you go for 1 second "Hey, it seems i'm dreaming and actually am asleep"? Besides we don't know what the actual trigger is for start of hallucination - Before EC we assumed that it was harbingers beam that knocks you out. Not with the EC it is defiinatly at some point earlier - i would go with the mako transport falling on shepard during the beam run - You can see this exact moment in the very end of ME3 special edition trailer for WiiU. Or it could be when the transport with all your crew crashes suddenly right before the beam run. 

3. Leviathans are not our friends or allies - they are playing their own game.  
But the suddenly decide to come out of fighting, and fight the reaper openly after a brief conversation with one man... One very specific man... and it was the conversation where they contacted his mind directly... Let's just entertain one idea - Shepard is getting slowly indoctrinated during the course of all three games due to exposure to reapr tech. This process is especially strong and evident in ME3. Reapers certainly did something to Shepard in Arrival. And we don't know what it was. In ME3 you suddenly don't have to fight for loyalties of people - everyone will most likely do what you tell them....
So Shepard's mind is tainted with indoctrination. Leviathan's touch that mind with their own. Suddenly they decide to fight openly. They got indoctrinated from touching Shepard's mind directly, if only a small bit. 
Shepard is like patient zero - running around the galaxy, and spreading the desease - then everyone decides that it is a great idea to get into one big fleet and go exaclty where the reapers what you to go - Earth. 

#47770
Eryri

Eryri
  • Members
  • 1 853 messages

MWMike2011 wrote...

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

MWMike2011 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...



Someone who knows the list of all the twists and deceptions BioWare has done over the years should post it again. I believe, without IT, Mass Effect would be the only series without one.


Did Dragon Age: Origins have one? I can't remember, been far too long since I played through the whole thing. And never played Baldur's Gate...


Ill have a go at this as I have played or know of quite a few Bioware games. Oh and obviusly heavy spoilers here, proceed at own risk.

Baldurs Gate 1: Sarevok is your half-brother and you are both Bhaalspawn.

Neverwinter Nights: No idea, I must admit.

Jade Empire: Throughout the game you repeadedly hear from other characters you fight how your style seems to have a flaw, though they are unable to exploit it as they cant quite find it. They dismiss it as a clever trick in your style drawing in the opponent to strike where no flaw exists...that is until your mentor reveals his true colors as the true villian of the series and using his knowledge of your style and its flaw easily kills you.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: Revan, nuff said.

Dragon Age: Origin: Perhaps not a twist per see, but Teyrn Loghains betrayal at the start of the game actually took me by suprise. A better example might be the reveal that a Grey Warden must die to kill the Archdemon.

Mass Effect 1: Sovereign is not a ship, it is a Reaper.

Mass Effect 2: Reapers are made from somekind of DNA paste made from breaking down Organics and the Collectors were Protheans.


Neverwinter Nights: Aribeth was working for Morag the whole time. Not to mention her boyfriend and his boss started the plague in act I. :blink:


I've written spoilers in grey text below. Highlight to show it


To continue the twist theme - in Baldur's  Gate 2, Irenicus doesn't reveal that he is trying to steal your soul until half way through the game, and one of your party members has been working for him the whole time.

During the expansion Throne of Bhaal - a benevolent priest who offers help at the beginning of the story, turns out to be the big bad.

Bioware has serious form with this sort of thing.

EDIT: God, formatting colours is temperamental on this site!

Modifié par Eryri, 18 novembre 2012 - 10:25 .


#47771
JMDekker2

JMDekker2
  • Members
  • 124 messages

Gwyphon wrote...

We just have to stay at this page for 4 and a half hours and we'll be at page 1911 on the 19th of November!


In Australia at least...though that's really all that matters :D

#47772
Gwyphon

Gwyphon
  • Members
  • 810 messages

JMDekker2 wrote...

Gwyphon wrote...

We just have to stay at this page for 4 and a half hours and we'll be at page 1911 on the 19th of November!


In Australia at least...though that's really all that matters :D

Damn straight! Hey you're from Brisvegas too! How about that weather? :lol:

Why can't the next 9 days go faster... :blink:

#47773
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

BatmanTurian wrote...

Love how they're b*tching about indoctrination being in the canon now. " Oh noes, all the bad guys are indoctrinated! This is just bad writing! There should be bad guys that aren't indoctrinated!" convienently forgetting Aria and the gangs.
They don't like it in the canon because it's inconvienent to their headcanon.

What a joke this forum is.


HAHAHAHAHA

Oh WOW.

Ok, the thread is bookmarked for later.

Astounding.

#47774
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

starlitegirlx wrote...

masster blaster wrote...

snip...

Bioware you clever devils, if you think about it, if Harbinger used his real voice, something in Shepard's mind will tell him/her that something isn't right. Now Bioware knew that the fans/ us would check to see if Bioware masked the guy that plays Harbinger. Which then they did male, female Shepard voice actors, and combined them with the child's voice to create a real voice.


Shepard's own voice gives him/her the options disguised at the brat. The reapers use you against yourself. Your fears become their tools. When you think about it, control and synthesis ARE shepard's fears in a way because shepard fought against krogan and geth that were under saren and sovereign's control so there is that element of synthesis (meddling with genetics) and then fought Saren who was synthesis and became soveriegn for the boss battle. More synthesis. Worst fear. Then all the heretics under control were control.

There are many aspects to control and synthesis and why they became options. They all stem from shepard's fears, desires, and needs. That is what indoctrination preys upon. And all of these things have been shown in battle or said by characters or witnessed in one way or another by shepard. The collectors are probably very much tied into shepard's fears and synthesis. Remember, that was quite the reveal in ME2. It's all connected seamlessly and it really boils down to the ruthless calculus of war. Probably the most relevant conversations were those with Garrus, which makes sense since odds are Garrus will be your teammate (pretty hard to kill him in ME2 as I understand) and was there from minute one before you are even a spectre. They also seem to parallel each other characterwise. Garrus is an outsider renegade in ME2 when he comes on board and that is where Shepard is at as well. In ME1 they are struggling to get saren and both have a strong sense of needing to stop him moreso than any other character. Then in ME3 they are both focused on saving their worlds while also saving the galaxy. The ruthless calculus of war is the greatest struggle for most players, I think.


Good way of putting it.

Even hardcore Destroyers have a difficult time seeing that in a 'general Shepard view', both Synthesis (as in, full co-operation and a proper merging of synthetics and organics) is an idea in Shepard's mind, and so is Control (he fights the idea of it, but in the script you'll notice Shepard continuously questions whether Control is possible or not - like he wonders whether the option exists, and should he ever take it).

Destroy is the big choice, sure, but Control and Synthesis represent some of the hopes and fears that Shepard, and the playerbase have had before. We've seen this on the forum itself, over the years of BSN.

#47775
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

BleedingUranium wrote...

starlitegirlx wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

starlitegirlx wrote...

We really shouldn't engage the trolls. It's like trying to reason with indoctrinated people. If they come to our way of logic they'll just have to kill themselves like Saren and Tim.


Nah, we don't really try to reason with them, most won't get it. But it's a good way to practice summing up what IT's all about Posted Image

Also, I played the end again yesterday, and London has more post-end clues than IT clues!


Post please! pretty, pretty please! I need some more interesting things to ponder.


The entire point of the FOB seems to be to tell the player that it's not really the end of the story. It's filled with:

-Not our last fight
-Shepard promises everyone he'll make it back
-Drinks later/bar in Rio

There's soooo much.


Even ITers deny this part.

The whole script for London keeps saying "This is the dark part, wait for the light part. Shepard is coming back. We're all coming back. Dont' let the Reapers make you believe otherwise."