Heretic_Hanar wrote...
Closure: Shepard and LI reunite in high ems
I find that entirely unneccesary. This is Mass Effect, not a dating sim or a Disney movie, even though ME3 did start to look like one. When a story ends there will always be some things left open to the imagination of the player. The EC gave us closure for all the major plot points from the entire trilogy. Mandatory stuff such as the romance subplot is left open to the imagination of the player. I'm fine with that.
Yeah. No. You see, I'm not asking for a happily ever after or kids or weddings ,or whatever else a Disney movie ending entails since you and so many others insist on using that, I'm simply asking for a slide or something where Shepard and LI are shown reuniting. Hell, they could have shown Shepard reuniting with the crew instead and then I would have agreed on there being closure. But as it stands? Tasteful and nice, but not closure.
Heretic_Hanar wrote...
Normandy takes off,
So? This is simply to show that the Normandy crew is not trapped on the jungle planet, something a lot of fans feared after seeing the original ending. The Normandy taking off shows that the lives of your former squad members continues, even after everything what happenes. They're is hope and a future for them. That's good closure to me.
This wasn't something I was expecting you to scrutinize, but okay nice interpretation. There are other issue I have with this that don't exactly relate to closure so I won't address that here.
Heretic_Hanar wrote...
Shepard breath scene before credits
This is the only part where I agree that this is a cliffhanger. The scene doesn't give closure, although it can. What i does though, is give the player a sense of hope that their Shepard might still be alive and kicking. It takes away some of the uncertainty of the Destroy ending. The other endings don't have this breathing scene because we know for certain that in those endings Shepard dies or becomes something else entirely.
So Bioware decided that High EMS destroy, requiring more than Synthesis, with the shepard breath scene should be the only ending where Shepard's fate is uncertain. Huh.
I also wouldn't say we know anything is for certain in the endings, but I'm sure you expect that and know why I would say that. You'd also know why I believe the breath scene is placed where it is and why it's left open ended for the moment, so yeah.
Good talk though.