Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#54926
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

byne wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Ditto. If you want to headcanon that Shepard is dreaming for 15 hours, be my guest, but it did most certainly did not happen in-game.


I'm currently playing ME1.

Just activated the Beacon on Eden Prime and woke up.

Shepard: How long was I out?
Chakwas: About 15 hours.

If it didnt happen in your game you didnt play ME1.


Read what I said earlier. Shepard might have been out for 15 hours after he got the vision from the beacon burned in his brain, which happend while he was still very much awake.

Shepard did not dream for 15 hours. Or maybe he did, but the vision was clearly only a couple of seconds and he saw it when he was awake.


The ending may have only been a couple seconds too.

Krimzie wrote...

I'm glad you clearly concede that visions, no matter the cause, are part of the narrative -- because that's fact. 


Yes, visions  are part of the main plot. Dreams or 'All Just A Dream' plot-devices however are not.


Dreams, visions, hallucinations, alternate reality. To deny that these are all related is once again not understanding theme.

Modifié par BleedingUranium, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:08 .


#54927
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

Krimzie wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Krimzie wrote...

I'm glad you clearly concede that visions, no matter the cause, are part of the narrative -- because that's fact. 


Yes, visions  are part of the main plot. Dreams or 'All Just A Dream' plot-devices however are not.


Dr. Chakwas: But I detected some unusual brain activity. Abnormal beta waves. I also noticed an increase in your rapid eye movement, signs typically associated with intense dreaming. 

And it's not a prompted response -- it's one everyone gets.


"This one is too sure of itself to fact check."

#54928
Lokanaiya

Lokanaiya
  • Members
  • 685 messages

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Krimzie wrote...

I'm glad you clearly concede that visions, no matter the cause, are part of the narrative -- because that's fact. 


Yes, visions  are part of the main plot. Dreams or 'All Just A Dream' plot-devices however are not.


Go check my post 2 pages ago regarding that.

Modifié par Lokanaiya, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:11 .


#54929
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

DaveTheRave05 wrote...

Ok, guys(..)


You rock :)

That's interesting about your mother too. Sadly, my boyfriend:
-couldn't realize that Kenson was indoctrinated
-chose to keep the collector base
-thought Udina was trustworthy until the Citadel coup (he just finished this level)
-thought the Collectors were not related to the Prothians at all and barely related to the Reapers (wtflol)

I think it's actually how his mind works in many cases, so I don't fault him, but it's astonishing sometimes.
He's so attentive to the details of a scene (visually, auditorially) that he DOES catch things I miss, but narratively, he's constantly just 'in the moment' and seemingly unable to look at the bigger picture.

(I guess I should note that in my first playthrough of Mass Effect games, I can go blindly Paragon as well, and make some of the same 'mistakes' he did, but that he doesn't even remotely question what he sees, continues to blow me away haha)

#54930
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

byne wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Agreed. That's why Inception and Zelda Links Awakening are good stories.

However, dreams and hallicunations have never been part of the major plot in Mass Effect, except for maby those 3 dreams about the kid. But there is a clear distinction between those dreams and what we experience during the ending.


I defy anyone to tell me he's not trolling after saying Link's Awakening was a good story.


Links Awakening had a good story, much better than Mass Effect 3. It was a good game.

I defy anyone to tell me this guy is not trying to flamebait me after saying absolute horsecrap nonsense about an excellent game.


Wasnt Link's Awakening all a dream?

Didnt you say earlier that being a dream makes a story suck?

Werent you going to bed?


It wasn't JUST all a dream.  It was a Zelda game that didn't include so much as a mention of Zelda and was entirely the dream of a a god-whale called the Wind Fish.  This asinine creature:

Posted Image

He slept in a giant egg, and his dreams of an island were made reality.  Why?  Because **** you, he's the god-whale, that's why.  Since Link shipwrecked on the dream island, he wasn't allowed to leave while the Wind Fish slept.  Why?  Again, **** you, that's why.  So Link pretty much genocides the island so he can leave.  But whatever, ethics are for douchebags anyway.  Much like a coherent storyline.

And I'm flame-baiting by saying that story sucks?  Really?

#54931
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages
Lost at the bottom of last page:

-Eden Prime Beacon
-Watching it again with Liara
-And again with Shiala
-Virmire Beacon
-Indoctrination codex
-Overlord alternate reality overlay
-Derelict Reaper crew having hallucinations
-Arrival team having nightmares and hearing voices
-Shepard's nightmares with the kid
-ME3 Eden Prime visions
-Geth Consensus
-Constant overuse of the word "nightmare" in ME3
-Entire end sequence of Leviathan (nearly identical to ME3 end)

#54932
Andromidius

Andromidius
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages
Burr. I should stop watching Mass Effect videos on Youtube at 3am when its freezing cold. Gives me the willies.

#54933
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

DaveTheRave05 wrote...

Ok, guys(..)


You rock :)

That's interesting about your mother too. Sadly, my boyfriend:
-couldn't realize that Kenson was indoctrinated
-chose to keep the collector base
-thought Udina was trustworthy until the Citadel coup (he just finished this level)
-thought the Collectors were not related to the Prothians at all and barely related to the Reapers (wtflol)

I think it's actually how his mind works in many cases, so I don't fault him, but it's astonishing sometimes.
He's so attentive to the details of a scene (visually, auditorially) that he DOES catch things I miss, but narratively, he's constantly just 'in the moment' and seemingly unable to look at the bigger picture.

(I guess I should note that in my first playthrough of Mass Effect games, I can go blindly Paragon as well, and make some of the same 'mistakes' he did, but that he doesn't even remotely question what he sees, continues to blow me away haha)


I did something similar with my dad. I'm fairly sure he'd pick up on IT if he played, though he simply doesn't have the time. I'm not going to spoil it just in case though. What I did was have him listen to the three tracks from the three ending monologues (and the Refuse replacement for "And End, Once And For All", becuase there's no monologue part) without any context, and tell me what words he thought of while listening to them. Here's the result:



SYNTHESIS
What comes next?
Storytelling
Progress
Convergence
Coming together with a plan
Exploring
Looking
Analyzing
Awe
Approaching a terminus
Coming to an end

CONTROL
Apprehension
Concern
Uncertainty
Anticipation
Fear
Unknown
Tension

REFUSE
Aftermath
Loss
Reflection
Death
Realization
What now?
Remembering
Determination

DESTROY
Hope
New beginning
Looking ahead
Colleagues
Starting anew

Modifié par BleedingUranium, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:28 .


#54934
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

BleedingUranium wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

401 Kill wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

hehe

General Petrovsky: You might as well give up

Aria: I'm not going down like this

starts to destroy force field

"How did you know you could do that Aria?"

"I didn't."




*Shepard jumps through and is now alone...*  We all know what happens when Shepard is alone


He always has to make big, important moral decisions (in a vaccum) Posted Image


So this was an IT DLC then, right?

Hehe.

#54935
Krimzie

Krimzie
  • Members
  • 443 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...

I did something similar with my dad. I'm fairly sure he'd pick up on IT if he played, though he simply doesn't have the time. I'm not going to spoil it just in case though. What I did was have him listen to the three tracks from the three ending monologues (and the Refuse replacement for "And End, Once And For All", becuase there's no monologue part) without any context, and tell me what words he thought of while listening to them. Here's the result:



SYNTHESIS
What comes next?
Storytelling
Progress
Convergence
Coming together with a plan
Exploring
Looking
Analyzing
Awe
Approaching a terminus
Coming to an end

CONTROL
Apprehension
Concern
Uncertainty
Anticipation
Fear
Unknown
Tension

REFUSE
Aftermath
Loss
Reflection
Death
Realization
What now?
Remembering
Determination

DESTROY
Hope
New beginning
Looking ahead
Colleagues
Starting anew


Awesome. This is very cool. I feel exactly the same way about the compositions, and I have to wonder if Sam Hulick has a preferred ending or if he was given notes on how the scenes should sound.

#54936
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Krimzie wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Krimzie wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...
It's generally agreed upon that "It Was Al Just a Dream" is hack writing and a horrible plot-device, just like a Deus Ex Machina is generally considered to be hack writing and a horrible plot-device.


I keep reading this all over these forums and it really grinds my gears, because this "Writing 101" rule is not without exception -- and the exception is that if dreams and hallucinations are part of the major plot, it's not a cop out... it's part of the plot.


Agreed. That's why Inception and Zelda Links Awakening are good stories.

However, dreams and hallicunations have never been part of the major plot in Mass Effect, except for maby those 3 dreams about the kid. But there is a clear distinction between those dreams and what we experience during the ending.


Dude... did we play the same game series? I'm pretty sure the first major event of the original Mass Effect is Shepard knocked unconcious because of a beacon, and spends 15 hours having nightmares and visions.

Mass Effect wouldn't even have a story without dreams. It's the very first thing that happens. It's what Shepard spends the whole game trying to convince the Council -- the Reapers are coming. How does he know? Because he had a 15 hour vision dream.


EDIT TO ADD: In fact, Shepard always falling unconcious or drugged or sleeping and we are always getting Shepard's visions and dreams and hallucinations. It's really prevalent. Someone should make a compilation vid of all the times Shep's groggily waking up, or passing out, or having visions. Because it's always.


Just stop bothering. Really.

If he doesn't get that dreams and hallucinations have been a big part of Mass Effect ever since Eden Prime, I don't think anything matters.

#54937
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

byne wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Ditto. If you want to headcanon that Shepard is dreaming for 15 hours, be my guest, but it did most certainly did not happen in-game.


I'm currently playing ME1.

Just activated the Beacon on Eden Prime and woke up.

Shepard: How long was I out?
Chakwas: About 15 hours.

If it didnt happen in your game you didnt play ME1.


lolololol

I love it.

#54938
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...


I did something similar with my dad. I'm fairly sure he'd pick up on IT if he played, though he simply doesn't have the time. I'm not going to spoil it just in case though. What I did was have him listen to the three tracks from the three ending monologues (and the Refuse replacement for "And End, Once And For All", becuase there's no monologue part) without any context, and tell me what words he thought of while listening to them. Here's the result:



SYNTHESIS
What comes next?
Storytelling
Progress
Convergence
Coming together with a plan
Exploring
Looking
Analyzing
Awe
Approaching a terminus
Coming to an end


Synthesis being about storytelling made me laugh way harder than it should have.

#54939
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

byne wrote...

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

Ditto. If you want to headcanon that Shepard is dreaming for 15 hours, be my guest, but it did most certainly did not happen in-game.


I'm currently playing ME1.

Just activated the Beacon on Eden Prime and woke up.

Shepard: How long was I out?
Chakwas: About 15 hours.

If it didnt happen in your game you didnt play ME1.


and did you hear whispers?

#54940
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!

EDIT - This should take at best a day and at worse a week

Modifié par CmdrShep80, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:41 .


#54941
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


I think waiting for the lock is stressing me out. I had a dream last night that it got locked while I was asleep and Hanar of all people made the new one.

#54942
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
So...what's the easiest way to do this:

Operation DETONATOR (Nov 30th – Dec 2nd)

Event Description: Recent setbacks have prompted changes in unit composition. Turian cabal theory is now dominant training paradigm. N7 units will now be deployed with pairs or higher percentages of biotics wherever available to maximize effectiveness.

Individual Goal: Earn 20,000 Biotic Explosion points on any map at any difficulty. You will need to kill the enemy with the explosion for the points to count. Points are cumulative across matches. Extraction not required.

Reward: Commendation Pack

#54943
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


We must not draw attention to ourselves in order to surpass the marks set by the previous threads! 

#54944
CmdrShep80

CmdrShep80
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

byne wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


I think waiting for the lock is stressing me out. I had a dream last night that it got locked while I was asleep and Hanar of all people made the new one.


"Listen to yourself!  You're...indoctrinated!"

"Wake up!"

#54945
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
I remember you posting that before Bleeding.

It just reinforces my thoughts that Synthesis is seen as the best ending by Bioware just because of a possibly AMAZING storytelling possibilities it offers.

Control is bad guy (sorry Paragon Controllers) and Destroy is good guy (yay like ME1-ME2 anyway), but Synthesis is something new for Bioware (they've done the 'bad guy' thing before with KOTOR) and I'm interested that if IT is right, then we have some awesome stories to experience.

#54946
Andromidius

Andromidius
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages

byne wrote...
Synthesis being about storytelling made me laugh way harder than it should have.


You've got to admit, its a pretty good fairy tale concept.

In a horrifying way.

#54947
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

CmdrShep80 wrote...

byne wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


I think waiting for the lock is stressing me out. I had a dream last night that it got locked while I was asleep and Hanar of all people made the new one.


"Listen to yourself!  You're...indoctrinated!"

"Wake up!"


IT Mark IV

Hanar: "IT is stupid. You are stupid. Bad writing. Let's discuss IT!"

#54948
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

byne wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


I think waiting for the lock is stressing me out. I had a dream last night that it got locked while I was asleep and Hanar of all people made the new one.

My god... The Reapers are affecting you more than we could have possibly imagined:blink::blink:

#54949
Andromidius

Andromidius
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages

CmdrShep80 wrote...

So...what's the easiest way to do this:

Operation DETONATOR (Nov 30th – Dec 2nd)

Event Description: Recent setbacks have prompted changes in unit composition. Turian cabal theory is now dominant training paradigm. N7 units will now be deployed with pairs or higher percentages of biotics wherever available to maximize effectiveness.

Individual Goal: Earn 20,000 Biotic Explosion points on any map at any difficulty. You will need to kill the enemy with the explosion for the points to count. Points are cumulative across matches. Extraction not required.

Reward: Commendation Pack


Volus Adept, Bronze solo Cerberus.

Spam Biotic Orbs and Stasis = Biotic Explosions galore.

Modifié par Andromidius, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:48 .


#54950
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

byne wrote...

CmdrShep80 wrote...

oh and we're 24 pages away from passing Mark 2 and 70 pages from passing mark 1 YAY!


I think waiting for the lock is stressing me out. I had a dream last night that it got locked while I was asleep and Hanar of all people made the new one.


Hahahahaha oh god Posted ImagePosted Image


CmdrShep80 wrote...

So...what's the easiest way to do this:

Operation DETONATOR (Nov 30th – Dec 2nd)


Anything that can do lots of explosions, my favourite for this is the default Asari Adept (Liara)

Modifié par BleedingUranium, 30 novembre 2012 - 03:47 .