Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#69601
GethPrimeMKII

GethPrimeMKII
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages

Andromidius wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

Just like in ME1&2, where you could choose the order of missions.... ahhhhhhhh good times, good olde times^_^


Yep, to some degree.  You can certainly 'fail' some missions in ME2 as well - getting Tali exiled, killing Zaeed, recruiting Morinth...

And heck, you could screw up ME3 in ME2 with a single choice - whether or not to save the Genophage cure data!


Theres plenty you can F up in 3. Hell, theres enough F-ing up you can do in all three games.

#69602
Fur28

Fur28
  • Members
  • 729 messages

Big_Boss9 wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

could you give an example because that has never ocurred to me

One example is that you will lose the ability to do Rannoch: Admiral Koris and Rannoch: Geth Fighter Base if you do Priority: Rannoch first.

Edit: :ph34r:'d


i would never do Rannoch before the other 2 missions, since the Admiral tell me they wouldn´t be fully prepared, but well it´s an option to do that so it´s okay
whats :ph34r:´d?

#69603
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Andromidius wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

Just like in ME1&2, where you could choose the order of missions.... ahhhhhhhh good times, good olde times^_^


Yep, to some degree.  You can certainly 'fail' some missions in ME2 as well - getting Tali exiled, killing Zaeed, recruiting Morinth...

And heck, you could screw up ME3 in ME2 with a single choice - whether or not to save the Genophage cure data!


Theres plenty you can F up in 3. Hell, theres enough F-ing up you can do in all three games.

Whoa! Last time I destroyed the data and let Maelon go. This time it turns out I will have to check out other options.

Modifié par paxxton, 19 décembre 2012 - 02:59 .


#69604
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Hey, I'm sure you guys have talked about it, but have you ever considered the Catalyst's true motivations behind the Reapers?

A bit of an odd question. In IT there is most likely no Catalyst and only Harbinger. In literal, what he says is truthful even if it makes no sense.

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Modifié par LDS Darth Revan, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:02 .


#69605
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Fur28 wrote...

@Jade, its kinda hard to find a way to connect both Puzzle and IT, since the former is in Literal and IT is in IT, the only way, i can think of, would be if the DLC war assets are seen fighting or use by post-indoctrination Shepard, maybe using some of the intel gained in MP storyline

Not necessarily. PT can be either literal or non-literal. At its most basic level, it simply states that the ending will be expanded upon through DLC. As well, war assets could play an enormous role in an IT reveal.

#69606
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Hey, I'm sure you guys have talked about it, but have you ever considered the Catalyst's true motivations behind the Reapers?

A bit of an odd question. In IT there is most likely no Catalyst and only Harbinger. In literal, what he says is truthful even if it makes no sense.

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Huh. Cool, I like it. It's a flawed goal, but it has to be.

#69607
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.

Modifié par LDS Darth Revan, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:07 .


#69608
Krimzie

Krimzie
  • Members
  • 443 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Huh. Cool, I like it. It's a flawed goal, but it has to be.


I also like this theory, Revan! Since it's a flawed goal, it explains why the presented "solutions" are flawed, as well. It also gives a good reason for why the Catalyst makes the huge blanket claim that "synthetics seek perfection through understanding" of organics. Do they? Or does he? Because EDI seemed to want to do more than just understand... she wanted to feel, to decide, to evolve. (And not to get ADD with the topic here, but synthesis doesn't promise that kind of thing for synthetics; only understanding.)

#69609
Fur28

Fur28
  • Members
  • 729 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

@Jade, its kinda hard to find a way to connect both Puzzle and IT, since the former is in Literal and IT is in IT, the only way, i can think of, would be if the DLC war assets are seen fighting or use by post-indoctrination Shepard, maybe using some of the intel gained in MP storyline

Not necessarily. PT can be either literal or non-literal. At its most basic level, it simply states that the ending will be expanded upon through DLC. As well, war assets could play an enormous role in an IT reveal.


only the remainig DLC will tell, if it is a CItadel centered DLC, i think it would help Puzzle Theory a lot with the keepers, who knows how much with IT

#69610
Fur28

Fur28
  • Members
  • 729 messages

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.


with what little i understood, i still dont understand how he :ph34r:´d me but whatever i still dont get it

#69611
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Krimzie wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Huh. Cool, I like it. It's a flawed goal, but it has to be.


I also like this theory, Revan! Since it's a flawed goal, it explains why the presented "solutions" are flawed, as well. It also gives a good reason for why the Catalyst makes the huge blanket claim that "synthetics seek perfection through understanding" of organics. Do they? Or does he? Because EDI seemed to want to do more than just understand... she wanted to feel, to decide, to evolve. (And not to get ADD with the topic here, but synthesis doesn't promise that kind of thing for synthetics; only understanding.)



An interesting point as well, considering most of the evidence he has for anything is of his own creation. I.E. saying synthetics will always try to wipe out organics because he and his reapers do that. Or because they hack other synthetics like the Geth and Zha'til to do it. Posted Image

#69612
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Fur28 wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.


with what little i understood, i still dont understand how he :ph34r:´d me but whatever i still dont get it

He was ninja'd, not you. Someone said what he was going to first.

#69613
Fur28

Fur28
  • Members
  • 729 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.


with what little i understood, i still dont understand how he :ph34r:´d me but whatever i still dont get it

He was ninja'd, not you. Someone said what he was going to first.


ok got it, confused the pronoums on what LDS said, thanks

#69614
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Krimzie wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Huh. Cool, I like it. It's a flawed goal, but it has to be.


I also like this theory, Revan! Since it's a flawed goal, it explains why the presented "solutions" are flawed, as well. It also gives a good reason for why the Catalyst makes the huge blanket claim that "synthetics seek perfection through understanding" of organics. Do they? Or does he? Because EDI seemed to want to do more than just understand... she wanted to feel, to decide, to evolve. (And not to get ADD with the topic here, but synthesis doesn't promise that kind of thing for synthetics; only understanding.)

http://ts4.mm.bing.net/th?id=H.5046441320908127&pid=15.1

I'm glad you guys like it so much, and I thought of that as well KrimziePosted Image

#69615
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Krimzie wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

     Well, it's just I've been thinking about it lately, so I thought I'd add my perspective. We know that the Leviathans created the Intelligence, who Catalyst claims he is, to study life in order to solve the problem between organics and synthetics and prevent them from conflicting. We also know that this Intelligence is responsible for the creation of the Reapers, and claims that he is the collective wisdom of them. My theory is: Perhaps he is creating the Reapers in order to add to his own intelligence by adding the perspectives of all the harvested races in order to solve the problem he was created to solve. The intelligence realized that he couldn't discover it on his own because he was seperate from them, which EDI when also trying to learn states can lead to missing crucial context. Thus the Intelligence decided that in order to obtain said context, he must assimilate the knowledge from all the races and turn them intodata, which he does by harvesting them into Reapers,until he understands it. He could still be doing that to this day, and will continue to do so until he discovers the answer to the problem he was created to solve. 

Huh. Cool, I like it. It's a flawed goal, but it has to be.


I also like this theory, Revan! Since it's a flawed goal, it explains why the presented "solutions" are flawed, as well. It also gives a good reason for why the Catalyst makes the huge blanket claim that "synthetics seek perfection through understanding" of organics. Do they? Or does he? Because EDI seemed to want to do more than just understand... she wanted to feel, to decide, to evolve. (And not to get ADD with the topic here, but synthesis doesn't promise that kind of thing for synthetics; only understanding.)



An interesting point as well, considering most of the evidence he has for anything is of his own creation. I.E. saying synthetics will always try to wipe out organics because he and his reapers do that. Or because they hack other synthetics like the Geth and Zha'til to do it. Posted Image

That's the reason why I've never felt the Catalyst was lying to us, or at least fully, during that scene. According to his logic, those chices aren't flawed and tries to convince you they aren't either, and for mqany people he succeeds. 

Modifié par LDS Darth Revan, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:25 .


#69616
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Fur28 wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.


with what little i understood, i still dont understand how he :ph34r:´d me but whatever i still dont get it

He was ninja'd, not you. Someone said what he was going to first.


ok got it, confused the pronoums on what LDS said, thanks

Didn't mean to confuse. When I said you, I was doing so in the same way a dictionary would, not you specifically. Sorry about that.

#69617
Fur28

Fur28
  • Members
  • 729 messages

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Fur28 wrote...

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Fur28 wrote...
whats :ph34r:´d?

Posted Image'd is when someone put what you were going to put up while you were doing it. The other person was like a ninja and snuck in the answer before you. At least that's what I think it means.


with what little i understood, i still dont understand how he :ph34r:´d me but whatever i still dont get it

He was ninja'd, not you. Someone said what he was going to first.


ok got it, confused the pronoums on what LDS said, thanks

Didn't mean to confuse. When I said you, I was doing so in the same way a dictionary would, not you specifically. Sorry about that.


by confuse i meant misread.... should have said misread from the beginning

#69618
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

jojon2se wrote...

DoomsdayDevice wrote...

I like how, in Omega, Nyreen dies a pointless death by being selfless to the point of stupidity.

Aria however, won't go down without a fight, and as a result, everyone lives to fight another day.

There's more to Omega than meets the eye at first glance. SO much ending foreshadowing there, it's awesome.


Sallying recklessly forth, in blind, single-minded, bezerker rage and literally leaping right into a trap, that the more levelheaded Shepard has to pull her out of - yep, yep... What were you arguing for again?

Please forgive the snark - I had hoped I was above dishing out as well as I take, but I guess not.

I do agree that Nyreen's sacrifice, the way it is presented, is extremely forced and could do with having had better everything; motivational weight, situational opportunity and so on.

I guess both Aria and Nyreen let acting go before thinking...


Oh, you're absolutely right, I didn't mean to imply that renegade > paragon. I'm just seeing some connections to the ending.

If anything, Omega makes it perfectly clear how Aria is just as predictable as Nyreen, and that both can be trapped.

It's all very situation dependent. In the reactor scene, the paragon choice was to (be prepared to) sacrifice the few to save the many, while in the ending the option that sacrifices the few to save the many is seen as the renegade choice.

#69619
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages
Heya Doomsday :)

#69620
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages
So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

Modifié par Dwailing, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:40 .


#69621
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Dwailing wrote...

So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

But they were reprogrammed by Sovereign, so you're undoing a rewrite by rewriting them to the way they were before Sovereign's rewrite rewroter them. basically, you're setting them free from Reaper control.

#69622
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Dwailing wrote...

So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

I see it more as unindoctrination. Imagine a group of turians or asari that had been indoctrinated, but you could somehow restore them to their original state. Remove the virus that made them flawed in the first place.

Edit: Posted Image I also like to do it to help the geth, because they are cool, and to show Legion that I am willing to help his people.

Modifié par BansheeOwnage, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:46 .


#69623
GethPrimeMKII

GethPrimeMKII
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

But they were reprogrammed by Sovereign, so you're undoing a rewrite by rewriting them to the way they were before Sovereign's rewrite rewroter them. basically, you're setting them free from Reaper control.


But its explained in 3 that rewriting the Heretics ends up biting you in the ass. The former heretics gave the reapers greater influence over the consensus, making the desicion to ally with the reapers for protection easier. 

#69624
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

I see it more as unindoctrination. Imagine a group of turians or asari that had been indoctrinated, but you could somehow restore them to their original state. Remove the virus that made them flawed in the first place.

Edit: Posted Image I also like to do it to help the geth, because they are cool, and to show Legion that I am willing to help him.


I don't know.  Do they ever actually SAY that Sovvy messed with their code?  Because based on what Legion said, it sounded more like the Heretics had an inherent flaw in their programming that caused them to support the Reapers rather than any interference on the Reapers' part.  And in ME3, you hear that the Heretics, despite being reprogrammed, still supported allying with the Reapers.  

Edit: Top with intreguing debate.

Modifié par Dwailing, 19 décembre 2012 - 03:48 .


#69625
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

LDS Darth Revan wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

So, I'm currently in the middle of a playthrough of ME2, and I've concluded something. Even though I know I'm primarily a Paragon, I'm going to destroy the geth heretics. Why? Because if this experience has taught me anything, it's that death is better than having your head screwed with. At least in the ME universe. And besides, when you listen to what ParagonShep says, it sounds like, at least at first, he supports destroying the geth heretics.  It seems like a bit of a last minute reversal of opinion at the end of the mission to reprogram them.

But they were reprogrammed by Sovereign, so you're undoing a rewrite by rewriting them to the way they were before Sovereign's rewrite rewroter them. basically, you're setting them free from Reaper control.


You may be setting them free from Reaper Control but they chose to follow Sovereign themselves, plus your also brainwashing them into rejoining the Geth