paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Unfortunately, in a total and ultimate war, it does.Rosewind wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
that still doesn't give him the right to choose for everyone.
It's Right thereRosewind wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
that still doesn't give him the right to choose for everyone.
Steelcan wrote...
Although the problem arises, what if it is a change for the better? Control makes the reapers docile. But do they have the same rights as an organic?
Modifié par MaximizedAction, 02 janvier 2013 - 08:22 .
paxxton wrote...
Control is not.lex0r11 wrote...
paxxton wrote...
[...]
Those are actually wise words they say. But what if someone agrees to be changed, accepts it, like Shepard in the ending? Then it becomes voluntary and legitimate.
It's beside the point. It's galactic, genetic rape.
It's a stereotype that actually only applies to the beach/lake- or riversides or other places, where people sunbathe.Skillz1986 wrote...
Where exactly does this "europeans rune around naked" stereotypecome from? Hell i've been living in three different european countries for the past twenty six years. And i certainly did not see a lot of boobs (except thos of ocasional girlfriends). We don't have spring break!
Sure, but in the literal ending the Catalyst is trustworthy.lex0r11 wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Control is not.lex0r11 wrote...
paxxton wrote...
[...]
Those are actually wise words they say. But what if someone agrees to be changed, accepts it, like Shepard in the ending? Then it becomes voluntary and legitimate.
It's beside the point. It's galactic, genetic rape.
Control is the voluntary sacrifice of ones life to maybe change the leadership of a synthetic collective on the ambiguous promise of some god AI that waged war against all of you for 3 games.
Not even talking about the chance that it might just incorporate into one of the new reapers. trololololo, Shepard. Gotcha!
Yeah.
paxxton wrote...
Unfortunately, in a total and ultimate war, it does.Rosewind wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
that still doesn't give him the right to choose for everyone.
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Not when the option to destroy them is staring you in the face when you have been trying for years to destroy them. He is not just compromising with the Reapers, he is achieving what they have been striving for.paxxton wrote...
Unfortunately, in a total and ultimate war, it does.Rosewind wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
that still doesn't give him the right to choose for everyone.
byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Nope. Destroy is the only one that includes dead Reapers. Any ending without dead Reapers is not a good ending in any sense.
Maybe they got it right.401 Kill wrote...
Not when the option to destroy them is staring you in the face when you have been trying for years to destroy them. He is not just compromising with the Reapers, he is achieving what they have been striving for.paxxton wrote...
Unfortunately, in a total and ultimate war, it does.Rosewind wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I was talking about Control.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
I think i missed the part in which the rest of the galaxy also agreed...
Synthesis could also be justified by saying that Shepard was granted the power because he out of everyone made it to the end.
that still doesn't give him the right to choose for everyone.
byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Nope. Destroy is the only one that includes dead Reapers. Any ending without dead Reapers is not a good ending in any sense.
I dare to disagree.byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Nope. Destroy is the only one that includes dead Reapers. Any ending without dead Reapers is not a good ending in any sense.
paxxton wrote...
I dare to disagree.byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Nope. Destroy is the only one that includes dead Reapers. Any ending without dead Reapers is not a good ending in any sense.
Right, because geth are metal junk.Skillz1986 wrote...
@paxx
No it does not. He still has his orders to follow. The order being "do whatever it takes to stop the reapers". From a literal point of view, the easiest option to stop them would be destroy. Everything eose involves uncertainties and risks, not to mention very questionable moral issues. Sacrifices (geth) in war are expected and widely accepted afterwards (big picture and all that). Robbing everyone of their very essence (humanity/turianity..whatever) is not.
Why do you want them dead if you can make them honestly friendly?byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
I dare to disagree.byne wrote...
paxxton wrote...
Well, from a literal standpoint, Control is clearly the best ending.
Nope. Destroy is the only one that includes dead Reapers. Any ending without dead Reapers is not a good ending in any sense.
Well then you'd be wrong.
Its not difficult for me tbh. I kill the geth and EDI without a second thought. Enslaving the reapers isn't much better.MaximizedAction wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
Although the problem arises, what if it is a change for the better? Control makes the reapers docile. But do they have the same rights as an organic?
A great BSG-y question actually if you take the ending literal. But then Control isn't very democratic either because Reapers are supposed to be an assembly of many minds, too.
Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut
