Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#16701
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

jgibson14352 wrote...

if the created always rebel against their creators shouldnt the reapers have rebelled against the AI?


this is probably nothing but still

Short answer? Yes.

Top again! Maybe I'll let someone else have a turn soon Posted Image

Modifié par BansheeOwnage, 31 août 2012 - 07:30 .


#16702
legaldinho

legaldinho
  • Members
  • 359 messages

Rifneno wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.


Citadel lawyer: Look kid, if you take this plea bargin it'll save you a lot of jail time.
Starbinger: You can't save me...
Citadel laywer: Stop saying that!  It doesn't make any sense!


Citadel lawyer: Listen, I'm trying my best to help you but if you don't let me, the case will go to the feds.
Starbinger: Good. We welcome their involvement.
Citadel laywer: ...

#16703
SauliusL

SauliusL
  • Members
  • 162 messages
Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.

Modifié par SauliusL, 31 août 2012 - 07:33 .


#16704
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

Rifneno wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.


Citadel lawyer: Look kid, if you take this plea bargin it'll save you a lot of jail time.
Starbinger: You can't save me...
Citadel laywer: Stop saying that!  It doesn't make any sense!


QFT.  I know the kid's parents have probably been killed right before his eyes, and the world is going to hell in a handbasket as well, but even taking both of those into account, Shepard is a SOLDIER.  The kid must know that.  It's kind of hard to mistake Shepard for anything else.  You'd think that he'd be smart enough to go with him.  But no, "You can't help me," And he disappears without a sound.  Something that's kind of drawn attention to, when you think about it, by the scene on Mars where Liara and the Cerberus Troopers are in the vents and are making enough noise that the Reapers probably could have heard them from dark space!

#16705
legaldinho

legaldinho
  • Members
  • 359 messages

RavenEyry wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.

Glad everyone knows then, I missed the discussion and was ignored the last two times I mentioned it.


The bit about darker hair is just me. I'm not sure there was a discussion; I remember someone posting about there being a kid with the back to the camera and reining in his/her own speculation about that. No real discussion.

You can't expect everything to get picked up. That's a highly solipsistic approach.

NOW WHAT ABOUT THE RED POPPIES YO

#16706
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

legaldinho wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.


Citadel lawyer: Look kid, if you take this plea bargin it'll save you a lot of jail time.
Starbinger: You can't save me...
Citadel laywer: Stop saying that!  It doesn't make any sense!


Citadel lawyer: Listen, I'm trying my best to help you but if you don't let me, the case will go to the feds.
Starbinger: Good. We welcome their involvement.
Citadel laywer: ...




The people will always rebel against their laws. We created crime so that never happens. That's the solution.

#16707
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

legaldinho wrote...

Rifneno wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.


Citadel lawyer: Look kid, if you take this plea bargin it'll save you a lot of jail time.
Starbinger: You can't save me...
Citadel laywer: Stop saying that!  It doesn't make any sense!


Citadel lawyer: Listen, I'm trying my best to help you but if you don't let me, the case will go to the feds.
Starbinger: Good. We welcome their involvement.
Citadel laywer: ...


Jury Foreman: On the charge of murder in the first degree, we the jury find the defendant guilty.
Starbinger: SO BE IT.

#16708
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

SauliusL wrote...

Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.


I should point out that they DID put a rewritten/extended version of An End Once and For All in the EC.  It's a lot more... optimistic, maybe?  Here's the link to the song: 

Modifié par Dwailing, 31 août 2012 - 07:37 .


#16709
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.

Glad everyone knows then, I missed the discussion and was ignored the last two times I mentioned it.


The bit about darker hair is just me. I'm not sure there was a discussion; I remember someone posting about there being a kid with the back to the camera and reining in his/her own speculation about that. No real discussion.

You can't expect everything to get picked up. That's a highly solipsistic approach.

NOW WHAT ABOUT THE RED POPPIES YO


WHAT'S ALL THIS TALK ABOUT RED POPPIES?!  Seriously, I think I missed something.  Will someone please fill me in?

#16710
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

TSA_383 wrote...

Well holy ****.
Leviathan... EVERYTHING in the dlc was about indoctrination...

I've still not replayed London after doing it yet, as I played through leviathan immediately after cerberus took the citadel. Surely there's scope for this DLC to affect London in a big way... Surely?

Good to see you TSA. Sorry to say it doesn't do much at all for the endings. So little in fact that I'm convinced (again) it couldn't have happened in real life. And how did you go to the citadel after it disappears?Posted Image


the brain is not one cohesive thing. it is made of multiple vastly different parts. awareness and cognition is in the cortex while the body can be controlled through other parts.....edit:damn total quote fail...

Modifié par spotlessvoid, 31 août 2012 - 07:40 .


#16711
MaximizedAction

MaximizedAction
  • Members
  • 3 293 messages

SauliusL wrote...

Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.


I absolutely agree with every syllable of this post.

But what do you think about the high EMS EC version of this track? Pre-EC it was only what is now used as the low-EMS version (the one with the waking from nightmare/cliffhanger ending).

#16712
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

SauliusL wrote...

Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.

Music is an extremely important part of anything, especially when it comes to mood, as I'm sure you know. I'm hoping to make a video showing this. Here's another thing to think about. In the endrun in ME2, The End Run looped. It made it feel much more epic and gave you a feeling of victory. Now think about London. There is only one track that plays at all in London (unless you count the cutscene where the destroyer dies). It's the extraction music that plays in Vancouver while waiting for the Normandy. But in 90% of London there is literally no music. No one does that without meaning something else. To add to that, "The night is always darkest just before the dawn."
London is that dark. Literally! London can't be the end! If they wanted it to feel like you won, they could have easily done so!

#16713
legaldinho

legaldinho
  • Members
  • 359 messages

Dwailing wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

legaldinho wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

There's a child on the board of murders although I can't tell if it's Creepy McBlownup.

I'm gonna keep reposting this til someone replies.


It's been mentioned before. The child has got his back to the camera, so hard to tell. Also seems to be darker haired than bieber, but hey.

Glad everyone knows then, I missed the discussion and was ignored the last two times I mentioned it.


The bit about darker hair is just me. I'm not sure there was a discussion; I remember someone posting about there being a kid with the back to the camera and reining in his/her own speculation about that. No real discussion.

You can't expect everything to get picked up. That's a highly solipsistic approach.

NOW WHAT ABOUT THE RED POPPIES YO


WHAT'S ALL THIS TALK ABOUT RED POPPIES?!  Seriously, I think I missed something.  Will someone please fill me in?


I was making a bit of a joke- you know, solipsism, "let's talk about my thing". Anyway.

I can't find the post- it was long ago- but I do have a post which is an amalgalm of three posts i made.

How about those poppies?

http://i.imgur.com/XkLje.jpg

legaldinho wrote...

Time to prompt my betters to do some speculating/ investigating/ picturing/ youtubing.

Subject: The red poppy that features in Leviathan.

Motive:
This poppy is everywhere on the citadel. I think it appears elsewhere
too, i think. It features everywhere in Dr Bryson's lab's balcony.

Support:
It looks a bit like the scarren flower in Farscape. We know how far the
sci fi influence net is cast in Mass Effect's case.

Relevance of
Leviathan: When chasing Garneaux, you enter the research lab or
something. This is where you pick up lots of conversations/ datapads.
One of these datapads is next to a bunch of these red flowers. It says
something like "though common, this strand is extremely dangerous". With
the recap of indoctrination-creatures including the thorian and its
"spores", as well as emphasis on the organic nature of the Leviathan's
indoctrination means, I say this warrans some monocle popping
speculation.

Found a vid that does some semi-thorough investigating.



At 07:12.

Datapad says:

"NOTE TO STAFF:
This new crossbreed appears harmless and would be inconspicuous in an
office environment. However, it is exceedingly dangerous. Use extreme
caution when working with all third-generation plants."

This
guy's shep is jittery as ****, but anyway, you can see the plant is in
Dr Bryson's office, inside at 00.16 and outside at 4:14



The flowers are in udina's office, and elsewhere on the embassies ward.


I just find it a bit weird. Are they potential substitutes for the spheres, which are too obvious? Dunno.

#16714
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

legaldinho wrote...
*snip*


If we take that the decision chamber is not real, then it is not about defience or giving in. 

It is about Shepard's desire -  what he want's to do. 

The Harbinger tries to make shepard truly want something. 

Refuse is not defience - refuse is "Id' rather die then play along" (Shepard himself says almost exactly this)

Harbinger in fact, wants to trick shepard into accepting death. 

In the middle of the gave there is a scene where you talk with Anderson - 
He says something about morale of his troops, that they directly face the reapers and know about them first hand. 

There are two options of response

One - that is on top, like the paragon option would be is written - "we have not forgotten you, help will come" 
But instead of this Shaperd actually says something like - "if a have to die to see it through - i gladly will"

Anderson goes wideeyed - and says... "Whao... Hold your horses, you already died once, and we have a war to win." And acts very concerned.


The other option - the bottom one (supposedly renegade)  goes "then they are motivated" 
Shepard says - "then they know better than anyone what we fight for" Anderson says " Agreed" and it is just a normal conversation. 

Remeber that conversation in Serenity between Mal and the Operative
- Do you truly believe that what you're doing is right and must be done?
- I do.
- Are you ready to die for this belief? 
- I am.
- So be i... (Mal shoots the operative, and forces him to take cover)
- Of corse that's not exactly plan A!

Being ready to die for the cause, does not actally mean any kind of jesus christ-like sacrifice - 
It is not I will sacrifice mysefl, and the whole galaxy will live thank's just to that fact - war doesn't work this way. 

#16715
SauliusL

SauliusL
  • Members
  • 162 messages

Dwailing wrote...

SauliusL wrote...

Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.


I should point out that they DID put a rewritten/extended version of An End Once and For All in the EC.  It's a lot more... optimistic, maybe?  Here's the link to the song: 

Yeah, you are completely right. They changed that completely. Interesting :)

#16716
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Dwailing wrote...

I should point out that they DID put a rewritten/extended version of An End Once and For All in the EC.  It's a lot more... optimistic, maybe?  Here's the link to the song: 

True, but it still sounds very cut off. Cliffhanger. It's still the melodification (I made that word up) of "We're not done here yet".

#16717
RavenEyry

RavenEyry
  • Members
  • 4 394 messages
About the music, I always like to remind everyone that (pre-EC) the very cliffhanger-y music also goes strait into the credits theme of 'Das Malefitz'. The whole soundtrack for the original end always made me think of curly writing saying 'The end...?'

#16718
spotlessvoid

spotlessvoid
  • Members
  • 3 497 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

I should point out that they DID put a rewritten/extended version of An End Once and For All in the EC.  It's a lot more... optimistic, maybe?  Here's the link to the song: 

True, but it still sounds very cut off. Cliffhanger. It's still the melodification (I made that word up) of "We're not done here yet".


is that a real word?
it came out of my mouth didn't it :D

#16719
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Gwyphon wrote...
Also is it just me or does this and this kind of seem a little similar. Crazy Leviathan's wanting control... ^_^

Repost because links. Posted Image

#16720
RavenEyry

RavenEyry
  • Members
  • 4 394 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...
If they wanted it to feel like you won, they could have easily done so!

I recall that a lot of lists of problems made after the initial release was 'Not feeling like you won'. Even Lance Henricksen commented on it! Making the player feel victorious is so easy to do. Look at ME1 and 2 for easy examples.

#16721
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Dwailing wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

As far as I can tell leviathans don't indoctrinate, they just control. There isn't the degredation either I believe. However, it's not much of a leap to assume indoctrination is a descendant of whatever levis do.


It would make sense for indoctrination to be a refinement of what the Leviathans do.  I think Levvy specifically mentions that the Reapers refined their method of control into indoctrination.  Which makes me wonder about just what Harby is capable of.  If he's the first Reaper, then that means that he probably has Levvy's original control powers at his disposal in addition to regular indoctrination.  Implications... unpleasant (Or very pleasant, depending on how you look at it. ;)).

Edit: Oh!  I just realized!  That explains the whole "Assuming direct control" thing that he does all the time!  He's employing traditional Leviathan control!

That actually goes a bit deeper than I thought. BleedinUranium and I were discussing that, and it went like this:
Banshee: "Sovereign assumed control of Saren."
Blur: "Actually he didn't. He only took control of his mech half after he died."
Banshee: I guess that's true. He didn't ever take control of him, just his mechanical parts after he died. So Harbinger remains the only reaper to ASSUME CONTROL of things."

Harbinger's role would be perfect if he was the kid in disguise.

#16722
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

SauliusL wrote...

Don't know if this was talked about, but some more speculation to IT.

I was just now listening to Mass effect soundtrack. The last song called "An End Once and For All".



The one we get after finishing the game. Since I am a professional musician, I tried to look at the piece as if I was a composer and some interesting thought got me - even an untrained ear hears that the beggining is really calm and smooth, as if everything is over, the battle is won etc. But what got my attention is the very end, where harmony and volume rises as if realizing something horrible. Let's say, if I was the composer for this soundtrack, and someone from bioware would ask me: "please write very soothing and nice melodie for the end, but before it finishes make it sound like waking from a horrible nightmare, realising something terrible" - I would compose exactly the same.

Somehow it fits perfectly for me to the IT theory, as there would be no other reason to make such a soundtrack, especially when we have "good" endings, where Shepard has stopped the Reaper threat and become a legend.

Music is an extremely important part of anything, especially when it comes to mood, as I'm sure you know. I'm hoping to make a video showing this. Here's another thing to think about. In the endrun in ME2, The End Run looped. It made it feel much more epic and gave you a feeling of victory. Now think about London. There is only one track that plays at all in London (unless you count the cutscene where the destroyer dies). It's the extraction music that plays in Vancouver while waiting for the Normandy. But in 90% of London there is literally no music. No one does that without meaning something else. To add to that, "The night is always darkest just before the dawn."
London is that dark. Literally! London can't be the end! If they wanted it to feel like you won, they could have easily done so!


#1 thing that influences people during things like movies and games...the music. The fact there is no music to London it makes it dull. They wanted the end to seem depressing and dark without outwardly appearing as so. So without adding depressing music that would be a hint they got as close to it as they could which was to not add any at all. If they intended to make the London kickass, they should of added kickass music. Seeing as they didn't....I'll tend to agree with Banshee on this one. 

#16723
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

RavenEyry wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...
If they wanted it to feel like you won, they could have easily done so!

I recall that a lot of lists of problems made after the initial release was 'Not feeling like you won'. Even Lance Henricksen commented on it! Making the player feel victorious is so easy to do. Look at ME1 and 2 for easy examples.

Pretty much. I need to get around to recording the end run so I can show everyone what I mean exactly. Anyway, I need to go eat. See you soonish. Posted Image

#16724
RavenEyry

RavenEyry
  • Members
  • 4 394 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

That actually goes a bit deeper than I thought. BleedinUranium and I were discussing that, and it went like this:
Banshee: "Sovereign assumed control of Saren."
Blur: "Actually he didn't. He only took control of his mech half after he died."
Banshee: I guess that's true. He didn't ever take control of him, just his mechanical parts after he died. So Harbinger remains the only reaper to ASSUME CONTROL of things."

Harbinger's role would be perfect if he was the kid in disguise.

Collectors are just prothean husks so Harby is probably doing the same thing.

#16725
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages
 After seeing the Leviathan DLC I decided to take the endings into perspective with the info I now know. (If taken literally)

Control - Rendered totally useless now. All it would do is render the Reapers vulnerable to Leviathan control. With no Reapers seeking annihilation, and organics are constricted to what they are allowed to do, the Leviathans would be able to slowly spread influence and eventually would do as they promised...take over the Reapers. So control would be just giving the Leviathans tools to fully conquer the galaxy again with no hope for organic freedom.

Synthesis - Point is mute. Organics lose. Reapers win by default. Shepard accomplishes what the Reapers were seeking to do the entire series.

Destroy - Without influence from anything organics are free to choose their future. It would delay the Leviathan rise and give organics a chance to possibly stop them. Total potential for future games w/ new antagonist.