Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#19576
pseudonymic

pseudonymic
  • Members
  • 370 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

On Chronus Station there were video logs regarding Shepard's reconstruction, EDI's construction, and EVA's constructions. I still don't know where you're finding this video log of TIM imlanting himself with reaper tech.

I think others will remember the video, sorry if you don't. We do not see the actual "transplant", it's just a few moments before, when TIM is preparing for a risky medical business...



 

:ph34r:

#19577
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages
A thought!

If there is some connection between cerberus and salarians. (say Dalatress for example) -
it suddenly makes some sense.
Dalatress new Shepard was going to take the femakes - cerberus aatacks the facility.
Dalatress asks Shepard to sabotage the cure.
Cerberus troops try to blow up the bomb and destroy Tuchanka - that prevents geno****e cured (what dalatress wants)
Salarian councilor tips you of that it is Udina behind the coup...

It is interesting, that when cerberus is not pushing it's own agenda - it is the agenda of Delatress.
It is the Salarians who have control over Ilos, btw. - A thing that would certainly interest illusive man,

Modifié par demersel, 06 septembre 2012 - 05:50 .


#19578
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

TIM is a gambler, no doubt about that! But he gambled too high this time, and just like you wrote, he faced the consequences. We can see from the video archive in Sanctuary that the lady about to mod TIM doesn't seem too sure if it's a good idea. But time is running, and TIM is greedy enough to do it.


What ever TIM is he IS NOT a Gambler. He always makes sure there is a back up plan. 

#19579
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

pseudonymic wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

On Chronus Station there were video logs regarding Shepard's reconstruction, EDI's construction, and EVA's constructions. I still don't know where you're finding this video log of TIM imlanting himself with reaper tech.

I think others will remember the video, sorry if you don't. We do not see the actual "transplant", it's just a few moments before, when TIM is preparing for a risky medical business...



 

:ph34r:

Thanks, Ninja!  :lol:

 I also found a reference for it :

http://masseffect.wi...ki/Illusive_Man

It's at the beginning of par. 4 of the "Mass Effect 3" section :

"Video logs found on the station show that the Illusive Man allowed himself to be implanted with Reaper-derived nanotechnology"

#19580
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

On Chronus Station there were video logs regarding Shepard's reconstruction, EDI's construction, and EVA's constructions. I still don't know where you're finding this video log of TIM imlanting himself with reaper tech.


There is such log. 

you have to really search to find it. 
It also contains the record of tim implanting Kai Leng. 

#19581
GethPrimeMKII

GethPrimeMKII
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages

pseudonymic wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

On Chronus Station there were video logs regarding Shepard's reconstruction, EDI's construction, and EVA's constructions. I still don't know where you're finding this video log of TIM imlanting himself with reaper tech.

I think others will remember the video, sorry if you don't. We do not see the actual "transplant", it's just a few moments before, when TIM is preparing for a risky medical business...



 

:ph34r:


Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.

#19582
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages
What do you guys think about possibility that Cerberus is allied with the Salarians?

#19583
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

demersel wrote...

A thought!

If there is some connection between cerberus and salarians. (say Dalatress for example) -
it suddenly makes some sense.
Dalatress new Shepard was going to take the femakes - cerberus aatacks the facility.
Dalatress asks Shepard to sabotage the cure.
Cerberus troops try to blow up the bomb and destroy Tuchanka - that prevents geno****e cured (what dalatress wants)
Salarian councilor tips you of that it is Udina behind the coup...

It is interesting, that when cerberus is not pushing it's own agenda - it is the agenda of Delatress.
It is the Salarians who have control over Ilos, btw. - A thing that would certainly interest illusive man,

The two (Salarians and Cerberus) obviously share a taste for "backstabbing", granted. And that's an interesting connection you are making, I never really went back on the reasons behind Cerberus' attack on the Salarian lab.

#19584
pseudonymic

pseudonymic
  • Members
  • 370 messages

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.


but we have to keep in mind that shepard = project lazarus, and it was never disclosed what exactly was done to him/her. so that's a connection that could explain it?

#19585
Home run MF

Home run MF
  • Members
  • 805 messages

demersel wrote...

A thought!

If there is some connection between cerberus and salarians. (say Dalatress for example) -
it suddenly makes some sense.
Dalatress new Shepard was going to take the femakes - cerberus aatacks the facility.
Dalatress asks Shepard to sabotage the cure.
Cerberus troops try to blow up the bomb and destroy Tuchanka - that prevents geno****e cured (what dalatress wants)
Salarian councilor tips you of that it is Udina behind the coup...

It is interesting, that when cerberus is not pushing it's own agenda - it is the agenda of Delatress.
It is the Salarians who have control over Ilos, btw. - A thing that would certainly interest illusive man,


"Females kept secret. Possibly a mole in STG. Could be indoctrinated."-Mordin

Has anyone tought that TIM could be already under Reaper control and he doesn't know it? Saren had doubts after Virmire and Sovereign implanted him. 

#19586
SubAstris

SubAstris
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

pseudonymic wrote...

SubAstris wrote...

pseudonymic wrote...

so, i watched clevernoob's post-ec documentary again yesterday and the discussion about the citadel beam stuck to my head. generally, do you guys agree with what he says, that the beam cannot possibly exist since we've only seen it in mass relay form before, thus being a part of shepard's indoctrination?


The beam from the Citadel, I assume? If so, it doesn't seem to follow


yep. the idea of it being something created in shepard's mind, as opposed to it being an actual beam, since all of the instances in where a beam was present it had to do with a mass relay - and even the conduit on ilos was presented in a mini-mass relay form as well. in other words, anything that "transported" someone, which would indicate this is something that may occur in shepard's mind. i'm not sure whether or not i agree with that being a valid IT sign, simply because of how it was present before shepard being knocked out.


And that means IT? A little tenuous methinks...

#19587
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.

Too late in game, and it's a good element of surprise. Usually the Codex updates after something new arises, not before, except for "historical data". Not everything needs to be spoon-fed to players, and I think it's not too far-fetched to have some credit.

#19588
Arashi08

Arashi08
  • Members
  • 612 messages
So...why is this Glyph thing still going on? Do people still think that Glyph will turn out to be an indoctrination ball? while it isn't as ridiculous as the idea of Hackett being indoctrinated, I still don't think it has any real merit to be considered actual evidence.

Based on what we know about BioWare's DLC, especially with mass effect. even if IT is going to be implemented, it will likely be revealed by something new in upcoming DLC. that'd usually hoe BioWare does these things. I still remember in LOTSB threads pre-DLC how some people seriously speculated the Conrad Verner was the SB. But if BioWare had gone with anything other than a different species the DLC wouldn't have been as good.

Also what would be the point? Glyph has a role to play in the game, sending you messages, reminding you of upgrades, etc. even if Glyph was some reaper trap then it would makes sense that you would have to defeat him at some point yes? considering how many people acknowledge his presence it seems like more of a hassle to code in him suddenly not being there at certain places, they'd have to change dialogue in people like Dr. Chakwas and I think Traynor who acknowledges Glyph around the middle of the game as well as Glyph's interactions with Liara. you might as well ask why isn't Traynor a double agent, or maybe Cortez. Traynor seems to always know where Cerberus is and even when Reapers show up sometimes. And Cortez always manages to get away from his pursuers, (except for that one time where he could DIE.) one would say that because they are LI's but people are also eager to accuse Liara of being indoctrinaed even though she's an LI...

And people STILL think Shepard was implanted with Reaper tech? Seriously? Grayson was the first one implanted with Reaper tech AFTER the events of ME2. and yes they did have cybernetic prosthetics before they found Reaper tech, it was one of the reasons why the Parlamentary Subcommittee for Transhuman Studies existed. I can't see TIM risking Shepard's identity with tech that could possibly indoctrinate her when he wanted to keep who she was intact.

im not angry or anything, so don't accuse me of yelling or whatever, I just think we should be looking forward rather than back. I mean we already know that there are clues that lead us ot believe that indoctrination maybe occuring, but to me, it seems like if IT is real, future DLC will contribute to it far more than looking at every character who acts unusual.

#19589
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

pseudonymic wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.


but we have to keep in mind that shepard = project lazarus, and it was never disclosed what exactly was done to him/her. so that's a connection that could explain it?

This would account very well for the first sentence TIM addresses to Shepard on the Citadel, something along the lines of  "I told you, control is the way to go, and a way to control YOU, if needed".

#19590
GethPrimeMKII

GethPrimeMKII
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages

pseudonymic wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.


but we have to keep in mind that shepard = project lazarus, and it was never disclosed what exactly was done to him/her. so that's a connection that could explain it?


We're beated over the head several times with knowledge that TIM never implanted Shepard with any kind of control chip. And Anderson was also being controlled in that scene. If we examine the theory tha everything Shepard sees post Harbinger attack is drawn from memory, it is not such a stretch to assume Shepard remembers TIM undergoing an operation of some kind, and later imagines him as the half human, half husk freakshow he appears as.

Modifié par GethPrimeMKII, 06 septembre 2012 - 06:02 .


#19591
GethPrimeMKII

GethPrimeMKII
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages
Sorry double post.

Modifié par GethPrimeMKII, 06 septembre 2012 - 06:02 .


#19592
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

demersel wrote...

A thought!

If there is some connection between cerberus and salarians. (say Dalatress for example) -
it suddenly makes some sense.
Dalatress new Shepard was going to take the femakes - cerberus aatacks the facility.
Dalatress asks Shepard to sabotage the cure.
Cerberus troops try to blow up the bomb and destroy Tuchanka - that prevents geno****e cured (what dalatress wants)
Salarian councilor tips you of that it is Udina behind the coup...

It is interesting, that when cerberus is not pushing it's own agenda - it is the agenda of Delatress.
It is the Salarians who have control over Ilos, btw. - A thing that would certainly interest illusive man,

The two (Salarians and Cerberus) obviously share a taste for "backstabbing", granted. And that's an interesting connection you are making, I never really went back on the reasons behind Cerberus' attack on the Salarian lab.


My theory - there is some arrangement between cerberus and Dalatress.
First she asks them for a favour - to help prevent the geno****e cured, (take females before shapard gets them, blow the bomb before the geno****e is cured)
Then cerberus asks for a favour back - help to organize the coup - and frame udina (for all we know the whole point of the coup might have been to kill Udina).

This leaves a question how they first came into a partnership and what was it initially about. I bet there is going to be a DLC about that.  

#19593
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

pseudonymic wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.


but we have to keep in mind that shepard = project lazarus, and it was never disclosed what exactly was done to him/her. so that's a connection that could explain it?


We're beated over the head several times with knowledge that TIM never implanted Shepard with any kind of control chip. And Anderson was also being controlled in that scene. If we examine the theory tha everything Shepard sees post Harbinger attack is drawn from memory, it is not such a stretch to assume Shepard remembers TIM undergoing an operation of some kind, and later imagines him as the half human, half husk freakshow he appears as.


yes. For all we know - that operation was a success. (unlikely, reaper tech, to much like saren, but still)

#19594
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

Iconoclaste wrote...

pseudonymic wrote...

GethPrimeMKII wrote...

Ah thanks. Regardless there is zero mention of these implants granting people the ability to control the bodies of others like what TIM does inside the Citadel.


but we have to keep in mind that shepard = project lazarus, and it was never disclosed what exactly was done to him/her. so that's a connection that could explain it?

This would account very well for the first sentence TIM addresses to Shepard on the Citadel, something along the lines of  "I told you, control is the way to go, and a way to control YOU, if needed".


Except that Miranda goes out of the way to specifically tell Shepard in ME3 that she wanted a control chip in him during project Lazarus, but TIM said no.

#19595
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Arashi08 wrote...

So...why is this Glyph thing still going on? Do people still think that Glyph will turn out to be an indoctrination ball? while it isn't as ridiculous as the idea of Hackett being indoctrinated, I still don't think it has any real merit to be considered actual evidence.

Based on what we know about BioWare's DLC, especially with mass effect. even if IT is going to be implemented, it will likely be revealed by something new in upcoming DLC. that'd usually hoe BioWare does these things. I still remember in LOTSB threads pre-DLC how some people seriously speculated the Conrad Verner was the SB. But if BioWare had gone with anything other than a different species the DLC wouldn't have been as good.

Also what would be the point? Glyph has a role to play in the game, sending you messages, reminding you of upgrades, etc. even if Glyph was some reaper trap then it would makes sense that you would have to defeat him at some point yes? considering how many people acknowledge his presence it seems like more of a hassle to code in him suddenly not being there at certain places, they'd have to change dialogue in people like Dr. Chakwas and I think Traynor who acknowledges Glyph around the middle of the game as well as Glyph's interactions with Liara. you might as well ask why isn't Traynor a double agent, or maybe Cortez. Traynor seems to always know where Cerberus is and even when Reapers show up sometimes. And Cortez always manages to get away from his pursuers, (except for that one time where he could DIE.) one would say that because they are LI's but people are also eager to accuse Liara of being indoctrinaed even though she's an LI...

And people STILL think Shepard was implanted with Reaper tech? Seriously? Grayson was the first one implanted with Reaper tech AFTER the events of ME2. and yes they did have cybernetic prosthetics before they found Reaper tech, it was one of the reasons why the Parlamentary Subcommittee for Transhuman Studies existed. I can't see TIM risking Shepard's identity with tech that could possibly indoctrinate her when he wanted to keep who she was intact.

im not angry or anything, so don't accuse me of yelling or whatever, I just think we should be looking forward rather than back. I mean we already know that there are clues that lead us ot believe that indoctrination maybe occuring, but to me, it seems like if IT is real, future DLC will contribute to it far more than looking at every character who acts unusual.


Glyph is not an indoctrination ball. 
It is a thing that keeps things on the path, the reapers desire. Just like Mass Relays and the citadel. 

#19596
SubAstris

SubAstris
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

Arashi08 wrote...

So...why is this Glyph thing still going on? Do people still think that Glyph will turn out to be an indoctrination ball? while it isn't as ridiculous as the idea of Hackett being indoctrinated, I still don't think it has any real merit to be considered actual evidence.


Haven't heard this before bout Glyph, what's the "evidence"?

Based on what we know about BioWare's DLC, especially with mass effect. even if IT is going to be implemented, it will likely be revealed by something new in upcoming DLC. that'd usually hoe BioWare does these things. I still remember in LOTSB threads pre-DLC how some people seriously speculated the Conrad Verner was the SB.


For real? HAHA

#19597
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

Home run MF wrote...

"Females kept secret. Possibly a mole in STG. Could be indoctrinated."-Mordin

Has anyone tought that TIM could be already under Reaper control and he doesn't know it? Saren had doubts after Virmire and Sovereign implanted him.

Very plausible, since TIM's actions, all over the game, goes well against human interests in general, in a counter-productive and apparently irrational manner. In fact, Cerberus appears as much as enemy the whole game as the Reapers, to the point we never know which ones are going to fall on our heads.

#19598
pseudonymic

pseudonymic
  • Members
  • 370 messages

demersel wrote...

yes. For all we know - that operation was a success. (unlikely, reaper tech, to much like saren, but still)


agreed. plus that might've been what was expected of tim, from shepard's mind. though in a really off-tangent bite of speculation, who's to say they had the model and just wanted to use it. ><

#19599
Raistlin Majare 1992

Raistlin Majare 1992
  • Members
  • 2 101 messages

demersel wrote...

Iconoclaste wrote...

demersel wrote...

A thought!

If there is some connection between cerberus and salarians. (say Dalatress for example) -
it suddenly makes some sense.
Dalatress new Shepard was going to take the femakes - cerberus aatacks the facility.
Dalatress asks Shepard to sabotage the cure.
Cerberus troops try to blow up the bomb and destroy Tuchanka - that prevents geno****e cured (what dalatress wants)
Salarian councilor tips you of that it is Udina behind the coup...

It is interesting, that when cerberus is not pushing it's own agenda - it is the agenda of Delatress.
It is the Salarians who have control over Ilos, btw. - A thing that would certainly interest illusive man,

The two (Salarians and Cerberus) obviously share a taste for "backstabbing", granted. And that's an interesting connection you are making, I never really went back on the reasons behind Cerberus' attack on the Salarian lab.


My theory - there is some arrangement between cerberus and Dalatress.
First she asks them for a favour - to help prevent the geno****e cured, (take females before shapard gets them, blow the bomb before the geno****e is cured)
Then cerberus asks for a favour back - help to organize the coup - and frame udina (for all we know the whole point of the coup might have been to kill Udina).

This leaves a question how they first came into a partnership and what was it initially about. I bet there is going to be a DLC about that.  


Isent there a scene of kai Leng speaking with TIM regarding Udina´s death and the failure to take the Citadel. Cant recall details, but I seem to remember it presenting Udina as having been working with Cerberus.

Ill look it up.

Edit: Ah here we are. Jump to 3.40.

Brief rundown:

"The Council is still in Control and Udina is dead" Kai Leng.

"Udina was expendable" - TIM

Seems to imply Udina was working with Cerberus.

Also we have to remember that without interference Kai Leng actually kills the Salarian Councilor. TIM is certainly not above backstabbing, but should such things not wait until your plans have come to frution and not before?

Modifié par Raistlin Majare 1992, 06 septembre 2012 - 06:14 .


#19600
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Raistlin Majare 1992 wrote...

Isent there a scene of kai Leng speaking with TIM regarding Udina´s death and the failure to take the Citadel. Cant recall details, but I seem to remember it presenting Udina as having been working with Cerberus.

Ill look it up.


Yes, there was such a scene, but what did it really say? Please look it up. 
As far as I remember it only implies the connection. 
something like "Udina was a failure".  Which could mean that their plans about udina did not play out as they have hoped.  

Modifié par demersel, 06 septembre 2012 - 06:11 .