Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark III!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
80611 réponses à ce sujet

#21276
Norlond

Norlond
  • Members
  • 569 messages
1am already? I should get some sleep

Good night people

267x200http://www.templeofcats.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/sleeping-kitten-teddy-bear.jpg[/img]

*edit* ha, good way to end it for today.. yesterday.. this night ^_^
see you -_-

Modifié par Norlond, 11 septembre 2012 - 10:51 .


#21277
TheConstantOne

TheConstantOne
  • Members
  • 463 messages

byne wrote...

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

If this has already been adressed, please forgive me, but this is the first time I've ever opened an IT thread and I quite frankly don't feel like crawling through all these pages.

Shepard proved unable to break through Leviathan's mind prison thingy by himself, and it only let go when it felt like it. Isn't this a big problem for IT?


Leviathan's indoctrination is clearly stronger than regular Reaper indoctrination, seeing as how it can even indoctrinate Reaper troops, and can do so instantaneously.


It actually depends on how you weigh the benefits of each type of control.  Reaper indoctrination takes longer but is permanent.  It also seems to self perpetuate, as in the case of Rana Thanoptis.  The Leviathan indoctrination is temporary and requires the victim to be within a certain proximity.

Out of curiosity, I wonder how much control over thralls a Leviathan can maintain before it tires and the thralls start to wake up?  There's no way to know but it's an interesting thought

#21278
Olaf_de_IJsbeer

Olaf_de_IJsbeer
  • Members
  • 1 923 messages

Home run MF wrote...

byne wrote...

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

If this has already been adressed, please forgive me, but this is the first time I've ever opened an IT thread and I quite frankly don't feel like crawling through all these pages.

Shepard proved unable to break through Leviathan's mind prison thingy by himself, and it only let go when it felt like it. Isn't this a big problem for IT?


Leviathan's indoctrination is clearly stronger than regular Reaper indoctrination, seeing as how it can even indoctrinate Reaper troops, and can do so instantaneously.


I don't know Shepard seemed pretty strong during that conversation with Leviathan, when he says that she will remain there with them and everyone else will be harvested she immediately screams no. When Garneau was nosebleeding he was completly under their control. Shepard was bleeding and still remained herself. Why would they let her go if they could've fully taken control of her in that moment? What does Leviathan mean when he says she's an anomaly?

Shepard does point out that now the Reapers have followed him/her to the last hiding place of the Leviathans, there's no turning back for anyone. If they want to survive, they will have to join the war effort, and they seem to recognise that Shepard plays a fairly pivotal role in the war.

#21279
TheConstantOne

TheConstantOne
  • Members
  • 463 messages

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

A fair point, and that seems like a fairly basic element that I missed about IT. However, it seems to me that the games prove that once the Reapers gain a foothold in your mind they're there to stay. Inducing such hallucinations in someone seems to imply a fair amount of control over a person's mind.


The Reapers are still very much in Shepard's mind.  The interpretation of IT is not that Shepard is banishing the Reapers' presence from his mind but that their current influence on him, while substantial, is not yet strong enough to indoctrinate him.  

#21280
Rankincountry

Rankincountry
  • Members
  • 181 messages

byne wrote...

One thing about Leviathan that really bugged me is when EDI asks if the chunk of Sovereign was shielded to protect against indoctrination.

She acts like thats some common thing, and that indoctrination shields are things that exist. Why have we never heard of these miraculous shields before?


I'd speculate that it's because the "passive" indoctrination signal given off by something like a smallish fragment of reaper wreckage or some otherwise "dead" piece of reaper material is relatively weak, and therefore can be effectively jammed or blocked given a suitable interference signal or containing material/mass effect field.

I'd further speculate that the signal used "actively" by a live reaper would be high power and could presumably be modulated to some extent in order to defeat jamming or containment, rendering such a system impractical for portable or battlefield usage.

#21281
Home run MF

Home run MF
  • Members
  • 805 messages

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

Home run MF wrote...

byne wrote...

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

If this has already been adressed, please forgive me, but this is the first time I've ever opened an IT thread and I quite frankly don't feel like crawling through all these pages.

Shepard proved unable to break through Leviathan's mind prison thingy by himself, and it only let go when it felt like it. Isn't this a big problem for IT?


Leviathan's indoctrination is clearly stronger than regular Reaper indoctrination, seeing as how it can even indoctrinate Reaper troops, and can do so instantaneously.


I don't know Shepard seemed pretty strong during that conversation with Leviathan, when he says that she will remain there with them and everyone else will be harvested she immediately screams no. When Garneau was nosebleeding he was completly under their control. Shepard was bleeding and still remained herself. Why would they let her go if they could've fully taken control of her in that moment? What does Leviathan mean when he says she's an anomaly?

Shepard does point out that now the Reapers have followed him/her to the last hiding place of the Leviathans, there's no turning back for anyone. If they want to survive, they will have to join the war effort, and they seem to recognise that Shepard plays a fairly pivotal role in the war.


They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

#21282
Olaf_de_IJsbeer

Olaf_de_IJsbeer
  • Members
  • 1 923 messages

Home run MF wrote...

They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

They survived because they hid. When the Reapers unleashed hell upon them, the Leviathans died in droves. They are not following a simple human, and they say as much. It is a simple matter of fighting together or dying alone, and be on their separate ways after it's done.

#21283
401 Kill

401 Kill
  • Members
  • 1 553 messages

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

Home run MF wrote...

They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

They survived because they hid. When the Reapers unleashed hell upon them, the Leviathans died in droves. They are not following a simple human, and they say as much. It is a simple matter of fighting together or dying alone, and be on their separate ways after it's done.

Don't you think that after they are done, the Leviathans would try to reclaim their spot as the "apex" race?

#21284
Home run MF

Home run MF
  • Members
  • 805 messages

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

Home run MF wrote...

They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

They survived because they hid. When the Reapers unleashed hell upon them, the Leviathans died in droves. They are not following a simple human, and they say as much. It is a simple matter of fighting together or dying alone, and be on their separate ways after it's done.


When the Leviathans where harvested the Reapers didn't exist, Harbinger is the first Reaper and he was made from harvesting them. The only thing they say is that they will attack any Reapers that invade that waterworld and give you a few orbs nothing else.

#21285
Olaf_de_IJsbeer

Olaf_de_IJsbeer
  • Members
  • 1 923 messages

401 Kill wrote...

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

Home run MF wrote...

They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

They survived because they hid. When the Reapers unleashed hell upon them, the Leviathans died in droves. They are not following a simple human, and they say as much. It is a simple matter of fighting together or dying alone, and be on their separate ways after it's done.

Don't you think that after they are done, the Leviathans would try to reclaim their spot as the "apex" race?

Yes, exactly.

#21286
Olaf_de_IJsbeer

Olaf_de_IJsbeer
  • Members
  • 1 923 messages

Home run MF wrote...

Olaf_de_IJsbeer wrote...

Home run MF wrote...

They survived for eons, and they seem very capable of defending themselves. You think the self proclaimed apex race would follow a simple human just because of a speech?

They survived because they hid. When the Reapers unleashed hell upon them, the Leviathans died in droves. They are not following a simple human, and they say as much. It is a simple matter of fighting together or dying alone, and be on their separate ways after it's done.


When the Leviathans where harvested the Reapers didn't exist, Harbinger is the first Reaper and he was made from harvesting them. The only thing they say is that they will attack any Reapers that invade that waterworld and give you a few orbs nothing else.

Oh, yes. Quite an important detail I forgot. I'd blame it on me being tired, but there's really no excuse. But it's true that when the downfall of the Leviathans came, it was at the hand of an army nowhere near the strength of the Reaper fleet (or at least, that's what I assume).

#21287
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages
 EA almost admitted, that if Casey Hudson would propose to do the whole IT thing - they would back him up. And would do so again for any of his future games.

www.vg247.com/2012/09/11/bioware-owns-its-creative-culture-is-free-to-make-new-ips-says-gibeau/comment-page-1/

#21288
Home run MF

Home run MF
  • Members
  • 805 messages
From Bioware blog

Re: Operation VIGILANCE
Confidentiality classification: XB-PRIME
Distribution: N7 Forces Only
Soldiers of the Milky Way –
As mentioned in previous communications, we’ve seen a number of reports describing unusual enemy activity. Operation VIGILANCE was prompted by the latest in a string of unexpected attacks. I regret to inform you that the operation has failed.
Before our drones could complete their assignments, our troops were overrun by enemy forces. It is clear they knew what we were trying to do. Our troops were forced to salvage what they could before withdrawing from the battlefield. While we will put the salvaged materials to good use, we’ve learned very little about the initial attacks or how we might counter similar attacks in the future.
We will continue our investigation. I know that comes as little consolation to those involved. To you, all I can say is that you must stay alert and rely on your fellow soldiers. The Reapers have a plan. We must be ready for anything.

–Admiral Hackett

Is this Battlestar Galactica? :huh:

#21289
Big_Boss9

Big_Boss9
  • Members
  • 532 messages
And we continue to fail every 4th Operation. MP DLC announcement coming soon? Let's hope.

#21290
DoomsdayDevice

DoomsdayDevice
  • Members
  • 2 357 messages

byne wrote...

Leviathan's indoctrination is clearly stronger than regular Reaper indoctrination, seeing as how it can even indoctrinate Reaper troops, and can do so instantaneously.


Eh?

No, just no.

Taking over Reaper troops is not indoctrination, it's ASSUMING DIRECT CONTROL. Big difference.

When the Leviathan explains how he's controlling Shepard's mind, he explains that all Reapers have the ability to influence organics. I took from that, that they inherited the Leviathans' ability. He then explains how, over time, the Reapers perfected it to indoctrination.

So in other words, if the Leviathans can take Shep's memories to build a visual/auditory illusion, the Reapers can do so even better.

The fact that Shep dips in and out of the illusion suggests that the Leviathans' ability isn't as strong as the Reapers'.

This only strengthens IT, as it clearly supports the possibility of the ending being an illusion.

Modifié par DoomsdayDevice, 12 septembre 2012 - 12:32 .


#21291
FFZero

FFZero
  • Members
  • 1 072 messages

Big_Boss9 wrote...

And we continue to fail every 4th Operation. MP DLC announcement coming soon? Let's hope.


Well there have been some rumors about an MP DLC being released some time this month. No one knows what’s going to be in it though, it seems Bioware found the guy who was leaking info. There was something on Reddit about Collectors being added as a new enemy type but I think that was quickly labelled fake.

#21292
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages

demersel wrote...

 EA almost admitted, that if Casey Hudson would propose to do the whole IT thing - they would back him up. And would do so again for any of his future games.

www.vg247.com/2012/09/11/bioware-owns-its-creative-culture-is-free-to-make-new-ips-says-gibeau/comment-page-1/


So effectively EA placed all the blame (or glory) of the ending of ME3 on BioWare solely. :? Good or bad? If the ending is truely horrible as literalists think...BioWare gets the sharp end of the blade. If it is actually ends up being good with IT then BioWare gets all the glory of making such a great game. Either way it takes EA out of the equation. Am I wrong?

#21293
Big_Boss9

Big_Boss9
  • Members
  • 532 messages

FFZero wrote...

Big_Boss9 wrote...

And we continue to fail every 4th Operation. MP DLC announcement coming soon? Let's hope.


Well there have been some rumors about an MP DLC being released some time this month. No one knows what’s going to be in it though, it seems Bioware found the guy who was leaking info. There was something on Reddit about Collectors being added as a new enemy type but I think that was quickly labelled fake.

I remember reading that. A new faction in the Collectors would be a welcome addition.

TJBartlemus wrote...

So effectively EA placed all the blame (or glory) of the ending of ME3 on BioWare solely. smilie Good or bad? If the ending is truely horrible as literalists think...BioWare gets the sharp end of the blade. If it is actually ends up being good with IT then BioWare gets all the glory of making such a great game. Either way it takes EA out of the equation. Am I wrong?

To me, that read as PR doublespeak of EA distancing themselves creatively from Mass Effect 3 entirely. "We love Casey, he's our man, but we had absolutely, positively, no involvement in the development of Mass Effect 3, we swear!" Well, except for enforcing a shortened deadline, of course. ;)

Modifié par Big_Boss9, 12 septembre 2012 - 12:41 .


#21294
TJBartlemus

TJBartlemus
  • Members
  • 2 308 messages

Big_Boss9 wrote...

I remember reading that. A new faction in the Collectors would be a welcome addition.


Like how a new Reaper playable faction would be epic? :lol: It would be like Gears of War 3 Beast Mode but more epic. Imagine it...playing as a Banshee or a Brute would be awesome!! 

#21295
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests
So after finishing up the first Mass Effect book "Revelation" just now, I'm kind of mind blown how indoctrination has been hinted at even before Mass Effect 1 was even released. The book was published in May 2007, but they didn't officially release Mass Effect 1 until November 2007, and the following May for PC. It would be pretty insane to plan this indoctrination plot all along right up to the ending of Mass Effect 3.

#21296
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

Big_Boss9 wrote...
 Well, except for enforcing a shortened deadline, of course. ;)


what is that about enforcing shortened deadline??  ME 3 was announced in december, with a realease date set somewhere early ortober of next year. During summer they moved release further to march. That is Six Months More ,than they initially wanted. 

#21297
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

demersel wrote...

Big_Boss9 wrote...
 Well, except for enforcing a shortened deadline, of course. ;)


what is that about enforcing shortened deadline??  ME 3 was announced in december, with a realease date set somewhere early ortober of next year. During summer they moved release further to march. That is Six Months More ,than they initially wanted. 



Last I heard they'd initially asked for an extra year and only got the six months you're talking about.

#21298
Big_Boss9

Big_Boss9
  • Members
  • 532 messages

demersel wrote...

Big_Boss9 wrote...
 Well, except for enforcing a shortened deadline, of course. ;)


what is that about enforcing shortened deadline??  ME 3 was announced in december, with a realease date set somewhere early ortober of next year. During summer they moved release further to march. That is Six Months More ,than they initially wanted. 


What Byne said. I also suspect EA pushed MP hard (microtransactions from all!), but that turned out working surprisingly well. I was definitely among the group who thought it would be a bad idea. Glad I was wrong.

Modifié par Big_Boss9, 12 septembre 2012 - 01:05 .


#21299
demersel

demersel
  • Members
  • 3 868 messages

byne wrote...

Last I heard they'd initially asked for an extra year and only got the six months you're talking about.


Ok. Even so - that is not unreasonable. Extra six months is a LOT of time. 

Unreasonable deadline - is what bioware gave obsidian - they gave them 1.5 years to develop the game, and THEN in the middle of production they rushed the release 4 month early. THAT is a shorthanded deadline. And it was done by bioware. 

#21300
TheConstantOne

TheConstantOne
  • Members
  • 463 messages

TJBartlemus wrote...

Big_Boss9 wrote...

I remember reading that. A new faction in the Collectors would be a welcome addition.


Like how a new Reaper playable faction would be epic? :lol: It would be like Gears of War 3 Beast Mode but more epic. Imagine it...playing as a Banshee or a Brute would be awesome!! 


And very possible given the events of the Leviathan dlc.  Such an MP pack would be a spoiler for those who haven't played Leviathan though