190 réponses à ce sujet

[DRTJR]

ME1- 91
ME2- 93
ME3- 78

[Ar7emis]

ME1 - 90
ME2 - 75
ME3 - 10 (15 with the EC)

[aruguren]

ME - 85
ME 2 - 70
ME 3 - 75

Modifié par aruguren, 30 juillet 2012 - 09:52 .

[Justicar-Ilua]

ME = 98
ME2 = 60
ME3 = 19

diluted and reducted to appeal to wider audience 

Modifié par Justicar-Ilua, 30 juillet 2012 - 09:53 .

[teh DRUMPf!!]

 ME1: 83
ME2: 68
ME3: 84

[clarkusdarkus]

ME1 - 100
ME2 - 95
ME3 - 40 - EC - 55

[Dragon_Effect 15511]

ME1=90
ME2=99
ME3=97

[dreamgazer]

ME 1 = 88 (92 story, 84 gameplay)
ME 2 = 90 (88 story, 92 gameplay)
ME 3 = 79 (70 story, 88 gameplay, w / EC)

[wantedman dan]

ME1: 87
ME2: 93
ME3: 55 (57 with EC)

[marcustheMezz]

 ME1=85
Great storyline and characters, but some serious glitches and problems with the gameplay mechanics
ME2=75
Although there were amazing characters and gameplay mechanics, they threw the storyline right out the bloody window from the start, it should have been prepping for the Reapers and dealing with the galaxy's baggage, not just fighting these dumb collectors and Shep's completely unnecessary death in the first act.
ME3=70
Storyline gone completely insane, only a few good arcs, ending completely mental, many choices from ME1 and 2 disreguarded completely, war assets do f*** all, some characters betray their own morality, still, it has good action and great mechanics.

[Monster20862]

dreamgazer wrote...

ME 1 = 88 (92 story, 84 gameplay)
ME 2 = 90 (88 story, 92 gameplay)
ME 3 = 79 (70 story, 88 gameplay, w / EC)

Same

[wright1978]

ME1: 85%
ME2: 95%
ME3: 60%

[tanisha__unknown]

ME1: 92
ME2: 87
ME3: 78 (post EC, pre-ec would be 44)

[blueumi]

me1 97
me 2 90
me 3 55 post ec 65

Modifié par blueumi, 30 juillet 2012 - 10:41 .

[darthnick427]

ME1: 90
ME2: 95
ME3 Pre EC: 80
ME3 post EC: 90

Modifié par darthnick427, 31 juillet 2012 - 05:29 .

[Kingthlayer]

ME1 - 84
ME2 - 81
ME3 - 45

I don't normally rate games with scores. I think I'd actually lower the 3 scores a bit. 80+ is kind of crazy for video games.

[Barquiel]

with DLC...

ME1: 90
ME2: 75
ME3: 82

[mnomaha]

ME1: 80...was kinda boring at points
ME2: 100...awesome game

me3: 10...only redeeming points were Tuchanka and Rannoch

The dics itself is worth more than the game IMO.

edited: changed back to my initial thoughts.

Modifié par mnomaha, 30 juillet 2012 - 10:49 .

[F4H bandicoot]

94
95
75

[BloodyTalon]

-2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222 for all games

Kidding

ME1 would be a 99
ME 2 would be 95
ME 3 would be about 92

Whole Series 95

[Kelwing]

ME1 - 93
ME2 - 95
ME3 - 90 but may change once all DLC for SP has been released. To give complete look at the entire story.

[TheChris92]

ME1: 94 - Very fun! Nice set of characters, gripping story, fun sidequests, all in all compelling

ME2: 70 - Shepard's Death was silly and just ridiculously done, defeating the Collectors gave no feeling of accomplishment (The story was just really uninteresting and it felt too much like filler. At least to me), too many squadmates and thus too little dialogue (mostly the Chris L'Etoile characters + Jack who were among the most interesting), the Arrival DLC added to my disappointment of the game, although in general it had some solid DLC, The Hammerhead was bad (Vehicle must have been made by papermache, no shields, barely any weapons), I missed the neutral option in the conversation wheel from ME1.

ME3: 73 - Despite its flaws like auto-dialogue, bad treatment of ME2 romances, fetch quests, bad journal, bad endings, no exploration, it still was a lot more interesting compared to ME2 in terms of story, and some of the romances had improved. Those whom BioWare had chosen to focus on, while still a shame about the ME2 characters getting backhand. Although it still disappointed me and put me off from the Mass Effect franchise.

[Nizzzy]

ME 1 - 85
ME 2 - 100
ME 3 - 55

[themikefest]

1-93
2-95
3-90(yes I do like the game)