Aller au contenu

Photo

The Geth and the Quarians - You can only save one [Poll]


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
430 réponses à ce sujet

#251
Chaotic-Fusion

Chaotic-Fusion
  • Members
  • 1 032 messages

Zardoc wrote...

Chaotic-Fusion wrote...

Zardoc wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...



Zordac wrote...
It is justified because they believe they are attacking "evil" machines that wronged them deeply and with whom peace is impossible. From everyone's but Shepard's and Tali's point of view, anyway, for those two know better. And they attacked the geth because of the Reaper threat. As Gerrel said in ME2, they need a safe haven for their civilians.

And I'm not saying the geth deserve to die. But neither do the quarians. Both made stupid decisions and both deserve some peace.

Are you kidding me? The geth never want to attack the quarians. The geth even offered peace with the quarians.
Gerrel  would of had his safe haven with ease if he just tried for peace with the geth. The quarian tried to kill the geth agein? This is not a darwin award to do this?



They didn't.

And I'm starting to get the impression that many of the geth apologists are pretty thick headed. Atleast that's the only reason I can see for why they believe the quarians or the rest of the galaxy knows what Shepard knows. You keep saying "hurr they could've tried for peace", yet you ignore the simple fact that the only people who knew the geth were open for peace were Shepard and Tali. And they only knew through Legion. Sure, Tali mentioned Legion to the admirals, but would you just believe if someone told you the people who drove your ancestors from their homes, drove them to near extinction and force you to wander the galaxy in ships are actually lovey dovey peaceful people? Especially considering the fact that any previous contact with them was always accompanied by violence? And the fact that the geth never tried to contact anyone to tell them how peaceful they are in the whole 300 years they've been free? Anyone who could truthfully answer with yes is hopelessly naive and far too trusting.


No, they obvious thing to do is just attack the Geth while bringing along your liveships and hope for the best.



In their position? Yeah it is.



What about just not attacking and waiting for the reaper threat to be over? A little common sense. Did the Quarians even prepare a strategy except attack the dyson sphere and improvise from there?

#252
Banul

Banul
  • Members
  • 323 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

It could've improved something the Geth weren't able to take out her people until Legion uploaded the code. Taking out Legion could've saved her people no matter how slim the chance of her being successful. Standing there crying has no chance at all of saving her people. She who values her people so highly can't muster up enough backbone to attempt to stop their slaughter other than blubbering at Shepard? Pathetic. Spineless. Snivelling. I don't see how it's hard to understand.


And I can just laugh at how hard it is for you to understand that SHEPARD IS STANDING A FEW FEET AWAY FROM HER AND CAN EASILY STOP HER, SINCE HE'S BEEN GOING UP AGAINST CEATURES THAT WERE SEVERAL TIMES BIGGER THAN HIM AND WON.

What's even the point of throwing her life away like that if death is inevitable? Go out with a fight? Are we living in the stone age or something, where muscles before brains is all that counts?

Yes, we get it. You don't like Tali. You have told us that several times over with your needlessly detailed comments.


Awww caps lock. Are you angry everyone doesn't agree with you?

Yes and so has Tali. And yes bette5r to go out with a fight than QQ and throw yourself on a cliff while leaving those you claim to care so much about to die without even giving them a chance for survival.

Yes yes we both get that.


Bro, watch your entire species and everybody you ever cared about die and see how much fight you have left in you.


Tali could've tried to do something about it. Instead she decided to start QQing before they were even dead.


She wasn't QQing. She was trying to convinece Shepard to not to chose the geth over her people. What else was she suppose to do, fight Shepard? We all know how that would end.

#253
Conniving_Eagle

Conniving_Eagle
  • Members
  • 6 013 messages
What is the justification behind instigating a petty war over a planet when there is a present forces that is eradicating all advanced life in the galaxy? Surely this isn't the time to hold a grudge.

#254
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Awww caps lock. Are you angry everyone doesn't agree with you?

Yes and so has Tali. And yes bette5r to go out with a fight than QQ and throw yourself on a cliff while leaving those you claim to care so much about to die without even giving them a chance for survival.

Yes yes we both get that.


No, I just used Caps Lock for you to read better.

I thought we were past the ages where people thought that violence solves anything and doesn't breed more violence.

Tell me. If the geth were already starting to destroy the fleet and Tali SOMEHOW manages to stop Legion with Shepard standing idly by (which would be so in character for him), who is there left to save and how can she lead her people to victory without knowing the ships' positions or which ones are left?

I'm sad to say this, but the quarians were always as emotional, even back in Javik's time. If you think that you're better than someone just because they have emotions you can't understand (as the whole "displaying emotions is a sign of weakness herp a derp" crap) or just because they're emotional in away that makes you think you're better than them, then maybe you should stick to something you do know about, such as getting into barfights for no good reason or punching random pedestrians because they're wearing ugly clothes or maybe burn romance novels.

#255
Conniving_Eagle

Conniving_Eagle
  • Members
  • 6 013 messages

Banul wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

It could've improved something the Geth weren't able to take out her people until Legion uploaded the code. Taking out Legion could've saved her people no matter how slim the chance of her being successful. Standing there crying has no chance at all of saving her people. She who values her people so highly can't muster up enough backbone to attempt to stop their slaughter other than blubbering at Shepard? Pathetic. Spineless. Snivelling. I don't see how it's hard to understand.


And I can just laugh at how hard it is for you to understand that SHEPARD IS STANDING A FEW FEET AWAY FROM HER AND CAN EASILY STOP HER, SINCE HE'S BEEN GOING UP AGAINST CEATURES THAT WERE SEVERAL TIMES BIGGER THAN HIM AND WON.

What's even the point of throwing her life away like that if death is inevitable? Go out with a fight? Are we living in the stone age or something, where muscles before brains is all that counts?

Yes, we get it. You don't like Tali. You have told us that several times over with your needlessly detailed comments.


Awww caps lock. Are you angry everyone doesn't agree with you?

Yes and so has Tali. And yes bette5r to go out with a fight than QQ and throw yourself on a cliff while leaving those you claim to care so much about to die without even giving them a chance for survival.

Yes yes we both get that.


Bro, watch your entire species and everybody you ever cared about die and see how much fight you have left in you.


Tali could've tried to do something about it. Instead she decided to start QQing before they were even dead.


She wasn't QQing. She was trying to convinece Shepard to not to chose the geth over her people. What else was she suppose to do, fight Shepard? We all know how that would end.






If the Quarians survived the Geth onslaught she would be regarded as the ultimate traitor.

#256
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Banul wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

It could've improved something the Geth weren't able to take out her people until Legion uploaded the code. Taking out Legion could've saved her people no matter how slim the chance of her being successful. Standing there crying has no chance at all of saving her people. She who values her people so highly can't muster up enough backbone to attempt to stop their slaughter other than blubbering at Shepard? Pathetic. Spineless. Snivelling. I don't see how it's hard to understand.


And I can just laugh at how hard it is for you to understand that SHEPARD IS STANDING A FEW FEET AWAY FROM HER AND CAN EASILY STOP HER, SINCE HE'S BEEN GOING UP AGAINST CEATURES THAT WERE SEVERAL TIMES BIGGER THAN HIM AND WON.

What's even the point of throwing her life away like that if death is inevitable? Go out with a fight? Are we living in the stone age or something, where muscles before brains is all that counts?

Yes, we get it. You don't like Tali. You have told us that several times over with your needlessly detailed comments.


Awww caps lock. Are you angry everyone doesn't agree with you?

Yes and so has Tali. And yes bette5r to go out with a fight than QQ and throw yourself on a cliff while leaving those you claim to care so much about to die without even giving them a chance for survival.

Yes yes we both get that.


Bro, watch your entire species and everybody you ever cared about die and see how much fight you have left in you.


Tali could've tried to do something about it. Instead she decided to start QQing before they were even dead.


She wasn't QQing. She was trying to convinece Shepard to not to chose the geth over her people. What else was she suppose to do, fight Shepard? We all know how that would end.






She said you can't choose the Geth over my people. That's all she said.

And no she was supposed to try to kill/stop Legion. And she might've succeeded doing that before Shepard managed to stop her. It's a slim chance but it's better chance than standing there crying.

It's like if Mordin had instead decided not to cure the genophage becuase Shep sided with the Salarians. No convincing and dead Eve and Wrex necessary. It severely weakens the character.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 05 août 2012 - 05:09 .


#257
Banul

Banul
  • Members
  • 323 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...

hoodaticus wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

Only two people are man enough to stand up to Shepard. Mordin and Wrex.


well Legion stands up to Shepard as well. And the VS (even if it was on a complete idiotic topic).

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...

You assume she doesn't do anything because of cowardness, Something she has proven to be everything must.


Oh? So
what reasoning is there for standing and doing nothing but crying as Shepand the Geth decide to protect the Geth the Quarians have to die  and then jumping off a  cliff rather than face the results of her
inaction? 

Love and being emotionally overwhelmed by betrayal.

Basically this. Some people just don't understand emotion, she could be confuse, panicking, worried, mad, sad, a lot of things which would have left her in shock.


I understand emotion just fine. I just don't see letting emotion let you not take any opportunity to save your people. Particularly not someone in a leadership position. Especially not someone who cares about her people as much as Tali. It weakens her character severely in my eyes (not that ME2 did her any favors).

You ovbiously don't. She's in shock and doesn't know what to do, acting on impluse and attacking just doesn't seem right, it's not that she's scared, it's shock and many things going on her head that' all. Not everybody is as impulsive as you apparently


She was an admiral on a military operation. Freezing up is something she can't afford to do. She is not a civilian at that point. She doesn't get a pass on that for me. It was her duty to try to stop Shepard. She failed. Her people weren't lost until Legion completed the code yet she let that window of opportunity fly by. Attacking Legion has a chance no matter how slim of saving her people. Standing there crying has zero chance of saving her people. Her standing there doing nothing to me is pathetic. Even more so because her admiral position.

It also means she took Shepard siding with her people for granted.


Shes only an admiral because of her experience with the geth. Having that rank doesn't make you magically immune to shock and terror. When the fate of your species is in your hands and one of your greatest friends is about to betray you, lets see how well you do.

#258
Khajiit Jzargo

Khajiit Jzargo
  • Members
  • 1 854 messages

Ryzaki wrote...


She was an admiral on a military operation. Freezing up is something she can't afford to do. She is not a civilian at that point. She doesn't get a pass on that for me. It was her duty to try to stop Shepard. She failed. Her people weren't lost until Legion completed the code yet she let that window of opportunity fly by. Attacking Legion has a chance no matter how slim of saving her people. Standing there crying has zero chance of saving her people. Her standing there doing nothing to me is pathetic. Even more so because her admiral position.

It also means she took Shepard siding with her people for granted.

It was mentioned plenty of time that her admiral position was just a formality and the she wasn't choosen for her military expertise, but for her knowledge on the Geth. She's hasn't changed, she's the same as ME2, a horrible leader, but someone who deeply cares for her species.

#259
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Zardoc wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...



Zordac wrote...
It is justified because they believe they are attacking "evil" machines that wronged them deeply and with whom peace is impossible. From everyone's but Shepard's and Tali's point of view, anyway, for those two know better. And they attacked the geth because of the Reaper threat. As Gerrel said in ME2, they need a safe haven for their civilians.

And I'm not saying the geth deserve to die. But neither do the quarians. Both made stupid decisions and both deserve some peace.

Are you kidding me? The geth never want to attack the quarians. The geth even offered peace with the quarians.
Gerrel  would of had his safe haven with ease if he just tried for peace with the geth. The quarian tried to kill the geth agein? This is not a darwin award to do this?



They didn't.

And I'm starting to get the impression that many of the geth apologists are pretty thick headed. Atleast that's the only reason I can see for why they believe the quarians or the rest of the galaxy knows what Shepard knows. You keep saying "hurr they could've tried for peace", yet you ignore the simple fact that the only people who knew the geth were open for peace were Shepard and Tali. And they only knew through Legion. Sure, Tali mentioned Legion to the admirals, but would you just believe if someone told you the people who drove your ancestors from their homes, drove them to near extinction and force you to wander the galaxy in ships are actually lovey dovey peaceful people? Especially considering the fact that any previous contact with them was always accompanied by violence? And the fact that the geth never tried to contact anyone to tell them how peaceful they are in the whole 300 years they've been free? Anyone who could truthfully answer with yes is hopelessly naive and far too trusting.



1. Peace was offered.
2. When legion came on borad it was offered ageint.

Understand this. If the quarians did not go to war the the geth, The geth would not have the chance to kill them off. The quarians easily could of had peace.

Peace was offered from ME2..

#260
agu123

agu123
  • Members
  • 234 messages

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.

#261
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Awww caps lock. Are you angry everyone doesn't agree with you?

Yes and so has Tali. And yes bette5r to go out with a fight than QQ and throw yourself on a cliff while leaving those you claim to care so much about to die without even giving them a chance for survival.

Yes yes we both get that.


No, I just used Caps Lock for you to read better.

I thought we were past the ages where people thought that violence solves anything and doesn't breed more violence.

Tell me. If the geth were already starting to destroy the fleet and Tali SOMEHOW manages to stop Legion with Shepard standing idly by (which would be so in character for him), who is there left to save and how can she lead her people to victory without knowing the ships' positions or which ones are left?

I'm sad to say this, but the quarians were always as emotional, even back in Javik's time. If you think that you're better than someone just because they have emotions you can't understand (as the whole "displaying emotions is a sign of weakness herp a derp" crap) or just because they're emotional in away that makes you think you're better than them, then maybe you should stick to something you do know about, such as getting into barfights for no good reason or punching random pedestrians because they're wearing ugly clothes or maybe burn romance novels.


*yawns* 

Oh yes because it's clearly a good thing to stand there and let your people be exterminated en masse. Clearly that's better than violence! :pinched:

The geth didn't start destroying the fleet until the code was completely uploaded. Have you forgotten? They were completely vulnerable. If she manages to stop Legion her people can wipe out the Geth with impunity. She'll have all her ships left that were available when the Reapers go offline.

I rather someone control their emotions than QQ while their race is wiped out. Nothing wrong with emotions. Something's severely wrong when you allow them to result in you watching your people be exterminated and do nothing but QQ when you have a chance no matter how slim of stopping it.

#262
Conniving_Eagle

Conniving_Eagle
  • Members
  • 6 013 messages

agu123 wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.


Killing Shepard doesn't save her people, killing Legion does.

#263
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Banul wrote...
Shes only an admiral because of her experience with the geth. Having that rank doesn't make you magically immune to shock and terror. When the fate of your species is in your hands and one of your greatest friends is about to betray you, lets see how well you do.


Having that rank means you have to be able to deal with your emotins quickly for the betterment of your people. Not immune not at all but if one has that position they should be able to push said emotions to the side and deal with them when extermination isn't about to occur if you do nothing but cry. Greatest friends? Not even. And yeah the fate of her species was in her hands and she decided to cry.

As for how well I'd do. Don't know. I'd hope I wouldn't stand there will millions of innocents die and cry instead.

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...
It was mentioned plenty of time that
her admiral position was just a formality and the she wasn't choosen for
her military expertise, but for her knowledge on the Geth. She's hasn't
changed, she's the same as ME2, a horrible leader, but someone who
deeply cares for her species.


And that really doesn't make that less pathetic to me. She cares about her species...but instead of trying to save them she'd rather cry? 

#264
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

agu123 wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.


Killing Shepard doesn't save her people, killing Legion does.

She would have to kill Shepard to get to legion.

Modifié par dreman9999, 05 août 2012 - 05:16 .


#265
Guest_Cthulhu42_*

Guest_Cthulhu42_*
  • Guests
The reason Tali didn't try to do anything is because Legion cheated; it jumped from having 40% of the code downloaded straight to 100.

Seriously though, yeah, it might be OOC, but that's all the more reason not to choose it. Just like Wrex's incredibly stupid attempt to kill Shepard on the Citadel.

#266
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...
Shes only an admiral because of her experience with the geth. Having that rank doesn't make you magically immune to shock and terror. When the fate of your species is in your hands and one of your greatest friends is about to betray you, lets see how well you do.


Having that rank means you have to be able to deal with your emotins quickly for the betterment of your people. Not immune not at all but if one has that position they should be able to push said emotions to the side and deal with them when extermination isn't about to occur if you do nothing but cry. Greatest friends? Not even. And yeah the fate of her species was in her hands and she decided to cry.

As for how well I'd do. Don't know. I'd hope I wouldn't stand there will millions of innocents die and cry instead.

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...
It was mentioned plenty of time that
her admiral position was just a formality and the she wasn't choosen for
her military expertise, but for her knowledge on the Geth. She's hasn't
changed, she's the same as ME2, a horrible leader, but someone who
deeply cares for her species.


And that really doesn't make that less pathetic to me. She cares about her species...but instead of trying to save them she'd rather cry? 

So you saying she should attack Shepard to get to Legion knowning full well what Shepard can do?

#267
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

agu123 wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.


Killing Shepard doesn't save her people, killing Legion does.


Yup. If she'd tried to kill Legion I'd respected that. Same as I respect Legion trying to kill Shepard. It would've showed me that they care about their people more than Shepard and aren't willing to let Shepard stomp all over them. It shows backbone, that something is more important to them, there's something they're willing to die to protect. I respect that like I respect Legion, Mordin and Wrex. (Can't respect the VS because...Udina. Just...dumb is dumb).

#268
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...
Shes only an admiral because of her experience with the geth. Having that rank doesn't make you magically immune to shock and terror. When the fate of your species is in your hands and one of your greatest friends is about to betray you, lets see how well you do.


Having that rank means you have to be able to deal with your emotins quickly for the betterment of your people. Not immune not at all but if one has that position they should be able to push said emotions to the side and deal with them when extermination isn't about to occur if you do nothing but cry. Greatest friends? Not even. And yeah the fate of her species was in her hands and she decided to cry.

As for how well I'd do. Don't know. I'd hope I wouldn't stand there will millions of innocents die and cry instead.

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...
It was mentioned plenty of time that
her admiral position was just a formality and the she wasn't choosen for
her military expertise, but for her knowledge on the Geth. She's hasn't
changed, she's the same as ME2, a horrible leader, but someone who
deeply cares for her species.


And that really doesn't make that less pathetic to me. She cares about her species...but instead of trying to save them she'd rather cry? 

So you saying she should attack Shepard to get to Legion knowning full well what Shepard can do?


Huh? When did I say aim at Shepard? Legion's the main problem. Yeah Shep will more than likely interfer but it's a better chance than her standing their simpering.

#269
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

agu123 wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.


Killing Shepard doesn't save her people, killing Legion does.


Yup. If she'd tried to kill Legion I'd respected that. Same as I respect Legion trying to kill Shepard. It would've showed me that they care about their people more than Shepard and aren't willing to let Shepard stomp all over them. It shows backbone, that something is more important to them, there's something they're willing to die to protect. I respect that like I respect Legion, Mordin and Wrex. (Can't respect the VS because...Udina. Just...dumb is dumb).

Hipicrite. You make it sound the VS knew full well Udina was the trator.

#270
zeypher

zeypher
  • Members
  • 2 910 messages
Ill add this line said by bishop from nwn2. If you are not willing to kill and die for it, how important can it be. If tali really cared for her people she should have done something to try and prevent it.

Modifié par zeypher, 05 août 2012 - 05:19 .


#271
RogueBot

RogueBot
  • Members
  • 830 messages
I would save the Geth because I found them an interesting take on the "AI uprising" tale. The quarians were cool too, but story-wise they were fairly generic "travelers without a home".

So I just based it on how original I found them, although I like both and in the game I didn't have to choose just one.

#272
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

agu123 wrote...

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

"Upload the code Legion"

"But you're going to kill my people!"

"Deal with it."

"Bu-bu-bu-bu-"

"Upload 100% complete. Personality dissemination required."

Comitting suicide was out of emotion, standing there and doing nothing was out of stupidity.


If Tali had attempted to kill you, you'd probably add it to your list of reasons to kill the Quarians.


Killing Shepard doesn't save her people, killing Legion does.


Yup. If she'd tried to kill Legion I'd respected that. Same as I respect Legion trying to kill Shepard. It would've showed me that they care about their people more than Shepard and aren't willing to let Shepard stomp all over them. It shows backbone, that something is more important to them, there's something they're willing to die to protect. I respect that like I respect Legion, Mordin and Wrex. (Can't respect the VS because...Udina. Just...dumb is dumb).

Hipicrite. You make it sound the VS knew full well Udina was the trator.


VS knew full well Udina was a snake since ME1. He's not trustworthy. So yeah trusting his word implicitly is idiotic. Especially since you can gain their "trust" just by visiting them in the hospital. NVM that Shep has more important things to do.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 05 août 2012 - 05:21 .


#273
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Banul wrote...
Shes only an admiral because of her experience with the geth. Having that rank doesn't make you magically immune to shock and terror. When the fate of your species is in your hands and one of your greatest friends is about to betray you, lets see how well you do.


Having that rank means you have to be able to deal with your emotins quickly for the betterment of your people. Not immune not at all but if one has that position they should be able to push said emotions to the side and deal with them when extermination isn't about to occur if you do nothing but cry. Greatest friends? Not even. And yeah the fate of her species was in her hands and she decided to cry.

As for how well I'd do. Don't know. I'd hope I wouldn't stand there will millions of innocents die and cry instead.

Khajiit Jzargo wrote...
It was mentioned plenty of time that
her admiral position was just a formality and the she wasn't choosen for
her military expertise, but for her knowledge on the Geth. She's hasn't
changed, she's the same as ME2, a horrible leader, but someone who
deeply cares for her species.


And that really doesn't make that less pathetic to me. She cares about her species...but instead of trying to save them she'd rather cry? 

So you saying she should attack Shepard to get to Legion knowning full well what Shepard can do?


Huh? When did I say aim at Shepard? Legion's the main problem. Yeah Shep will more than likely interfer but it's a better chance than her standing their simpering.

How do you not understand that Shepard would stop Tali if she even attemts to stop Legion. Legion can be hacked or one shotted by Tali far ranged. No matter what she would have to go through Shepard to get to LEgion. She would fail.

#274
Chaotic-Fusion

Chaotic-Fusion
  • Members
  • 1 032 messages
Tali is more than willing to kill and stop Legion when Shepard has her back. Really, if she had at least tried to stop the process I would respect her more. Right now it seems like she depends on Shepard's approval.

#275
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

*yawns* 

Oh yes because it's clearly a good thing to stand there and let your people be exterminated en masse. Clearly that's better than violence! :pinched:

The geth didn't start destroying the fleet until the code was completely uploaded. Have you forgotten? They were completely vulnerable. If she manages to stop Legion her people can wipe out the Geth with impunity. She'll have all her ships left that were available when the Reapers go offline.

I rather someone control their emotions than QQ while their race is wiped out. Nothing wrong with emotions. Something's severely wrong when you allow them to result in you watching your people be exterminated and do nothing but QQ when you have a chance no matter how slim of stopping it.


And you completely ignored the part where Shepard more than likely will stop her, because you're so obessed with her crying about losing her people that you're just repeating the same crap over and over again, which makes me repeat my comments, since you refuse to acknowledge the biggest hole in your statement.

Her chance of stopping Legion is nonexistent, since not only does she need to make his body completely inoperable (this is the geth that survived getting the center of his chest blown out), she needs to do it before Shepard stops her, which would be rather easy, since he's within arm's reach.

Tell me this: What's the point in throwing away your life for nothing? To prove that you went out swinging? Yeah, that will really count for something if you die a moment after that.

Something is severely wrong with you more than anything.