215 réponses à ce sujet

[Carne Diablo]

Neofelis Nebulosa wrote...

Biotics, because the Jedi and Sith would kill each other first.

Next question?

Who would win: a Thresher Maw or a Krayt Dragon?

[Blind2Society]

Love Star Wars but sorry, jedi/sith don't stand a chance.

[ParkBom]

Pacificsharp09 wrote...

Jedi

(Biotics can only do like three things.)

Reave, Warp, Throw, Shockwave, Pull, Charge, Nova, Lift, Singularity, Stasis, Dominate, Warp Ammo, Biotic Sphere, must I say more?

[TazMonkey2011]

Pacificsharp09 wrote...

Jedi

(Biotics can only do like three things.)

Right Biotics don't make them faster or able to jump buildings or stick to walls or lift entire Star Destroyers..... need i continue.

[IllusiveManJr]

I want a Spartans vs N7 operatives discussion next.

[TehMerc]

Hackulator wrote...
40k will defeat any other Sci Fi Universe in a straight fight. Its just that brutal.

Personally I'd side with 40k just because how unrealistic most of Star Trek's "peace and friendship!" themes are.

But then people bring up the Q  and Chaos Gods and it becomes a very convoluted discussion. They're funny things to read through though.

[ParkBom]

TazMonkey2011 wrote...

Pacificsharp09 wrote...

Jedi

(Biotics can only do like three things.)

Right Biotics don't make them faster or able to jump buildings or stick to walls or lift entire Star Destroyers..... need i continue.

Charge, charge, never saw any force user do that, look at the gif from before. BIOTIC GOD.

[Blind2Society]

theillusiveman11 wrote...

I want a Spartans vs N7 operatives discussion next.

Pull > bullet to the head > tactical roll to avoid incoming spear?

[CrutchCricket]

JusticarFlareon wrote...
I don't think that I've ever seen a Sith break a neck with a thought. 
We counter your Mind Trick with Dominate.

Happens all the time. Force telekinesis is lethal. Only reason there's no instant neck snapping in duels is that any Force user knows to throw up a Force barrier to block the effects. But otherwise even untrained Force users can crush and pulverize bones with little effort.

And I might allow your Dominate the minute you explain it using mass effect fields.

[lordofdogtown19]

TazMonkey2011 wrote...

I find your lack of faith Disturbing

[SavagelyEpic]

CrutchCricket wrote...

SavagelyEpic wrote...
It's all the damn ending's fault. If they had just let Karpynshyn do ME3 like he did the first two games... The Reapers were supposed to be all-powerful, unfathomable entities comparable to gods and deities, not some dopey kid's playtoys.

Biotic god is disappointed. So disappointed that he'll let the Sith win.

Edit: Spelling

Well I don't know about all powerful. But the Reapers were screwed irreversably. I share your pain.

I know </3

And Hackulator, a Reaper may be smaller but size is not a measure of power. The eezo core of a Reaper could.. I dunno. Power like over 9000 of those ISD's.

But it doesn't matter, because the Reapers are now officially starkid's sandbox toys.  And yes, I absolutely refuse to capitalize starkid. I need to find that .gif of Shepard throwing a grenade in the vent in Vancouver the first time he sees him...

[megawug]

Hackulator wrote...

SavagelyEpic wrote...

CrutchCricket wrote...

SavagelyEpic wrote...
Show me a Sith who can do this.

Known for:



No further questions.

Imperial Destroyer =/= a goddamn REAPER (in Sovereign/Nazara's words... "There is a realm of existence so far beyond your own, you cannot even fathom it")


No further questions.

Sovereign's arrogance is not the same as proof. Also, it doesn't matter, if you can telekinetically trash an Imperial Star Destroyer, you can do it to a Reaper which is smaller.

I would not consider that to be canon.  If it didn't happen in the 6 Star Wars movies, then it's just game fanfic.

In any case, I put $20 on Wrex to beat Jar Jar.

[Hackulator]

CrutchCricket wrote...

N7Kopper wrote...
But I'm assuming that all these battles take place in the Star Wars universe, because The Force doesn't exist in Mass Effect, and the sheer lack of it would probably paralyze the Jedi and Sith.

And thus we come to the logical end of any vs debate. Namely: it can never be settled because each side operates in a different universe with its own rules and removing said rules skews the results. There is no Force in Mass Effect and there is no mass effect in Star Wars.

Thus, maybe it's time to let this thread go.

Obviously we are working under the assumption that both work, and each group has just not discovered how to use the other's powers.

megawug wrote...
I would not consider that to be canon.  If it didn't happen in the 6 Star Wars movies, then it's just game fanfic.
In any case, I put $20 on Wrex to beat Jar Jar.

Star Wars is very specific that everything in all media is supposed to be Canon. 

I would pay $20 to watch Wrex beat Jar-Jar

Modifié par Hackulator, 10 août 2012 - 12:17 .

[ParkBom]

CrutchCricket wrote...

JusticarFlareon wrote...
I don't think that I've ever seen a Sith break a neck with a thought. 
We counter your Mind Trick with Dominate.

Happens all the time. Force telekinesis is lethal. Only reason there's no instant neck snapping in duels is that any Force user knows to throw up a Force barrier to block the effects. But otherwise even untrained Force users can crush and pulverize bones with little effort.

And I might allow your Dominate the minute you explain it using mass effect fields.

*shrugs* I don't got to explain anything. But I'll let Morinth do that. Morinth?
Morinth: SHRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!
See? Simple. Also, still waiting for that proof. Talk is cheap.

[xsdob]

SavagelyEpic wrote...

CrutchCricket wrote...

SavagelyEpic wrote...
Show me a Sith who can do this.

Known for:



No further questions.

Imperial Destroyer =/= a goddamn REAPER (in Sovereign/Nazara's words... "There is a realm of existence so far beyond your own, you cannot even fathom it")


No further questions.

And I think you forget that the clip of the volus is a practical joke patrick weekes tweeted about when he claimed the ending cinematic was leaked.

And that the starkiller thing did actually happen in game.

Questions reopened.

Modifié par xsdob, 10 août 2012 - 12:18 .

[TehMerc]

megawug wrote...

then it's just game fanfic.

In any case, I put $20 on Wrex to beat Jar Jar.

Glad I'm not the only one who thought that game was over the top :3

And yes, someone should pay Wrex to eat Jar Jar. And whiney Anakin too.

[Pacificsharp09]

So I have seen the stasis argument thrown around. Hate to break it to you stasis just stops them from moving not using their mind to throw a conveniently placed concrete barrier at your head, or slapping that jiggly bum bum.

[JumboWheat01]

Considering that Biotics require a physical movement to get their biotic attack off, and biotic attacks CAN be dodged, I can see Sith winning, since all they have to do is point at you and you're suddenly being fried, extra crispy.

Plus, those particularly powerful in the Force are granted glimpses of the future. This may allow them to come prepared for a battle against Biotic users. And let's not forget, Sith are manipulative S.O.B.s, so they'd probably just get the Biotic user to kill themselves.


Now, as for a Biotic vs. Jedi battle, the Jedi would also win. Why? They'd launch into such a long-winded speech on morals the pointless nature of the fight that the Biotic would commit suicide.

[TazMonkey2011]

Wrex vs Chewie

[CrutchCricket]

JusticarFlareon wrote...
*shrugs* I don't got to explain anything. But I'll let Morinth do that. Morinth?
Morinth: SHRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!
See? Simple. Also, still waiting for that proof. Talk is cheap.

Using Banshee Morinth? She's just a banshee. Big whoop. Sith can still snap her neck with a thought.

And what proof do you need? You corrected me on Sith and Jedi ranks, I think you know well enough what the Force can do.

[Hackulator]

TazMonkey2011 wrote...

Wrex vs Chewie

I really, REALLY love Chewie....

....but Wrex would tear him the **** apart.

edit: unless you put them on some savage uncivilized world and they had to hunt one another....then Chewie would have a shot

Modifié par Hackulator, 10 août 2012 - 12:24 .

[ParkBom]

CrutchCricket wrote...

JusticarFlareon wrote...
*shrugs* I don't got to explain anything. But I'll let Morinth do that. Morinth?
Morinth: SHRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!
See? Simple. Also, still waiting for that proof. Talk is cheap.

Using Banshee Morinth? She's just a banshee. Big whoop. Sith can still snap her neck with a thought.

And what proof do you need? You corrected me on Sith and Jedi ranks, I think you know well enough what the Force can do.

The only reason I know of those ranks are because of KotOR and SWTOR, so not really. Also, Banshee Morinth could use her magnet hands and her instahug. Regular Morinth could just Dominate just like she does in ME2 combat. You have pushed it in the biotics' favor by adding Banshees to their side. 

[WMcAlister]

Jedi. The Force isn't known for missing when the battlefield gets laggy....

I think. Never played the new MMO.

Modifié par WMcAlister, 10 août 2012 - 12:25 .

[CrutchCricket]

JusticarFlareon wrote...
The only reason I know of those ranks are because of KotOR and SWTOR, so not really. Also, Banshee Morinth could use her magnet hands and her instahug. Regular Morinth could just Dominate just like she does in ME2 combat. You have pushed it in the biotics' favor by adding Banshees to their side. 

Banshee Morinth would still be dead before she got in range to magnet grab. And you still haven't explained dominate using mass effect principles so it doesn't count.

Really I don't see how this is even a discussion. Force telekinesis alone wins, let alone the crazier **** Sith Lords have done over the millenia like suck an entire planet dry of life essence. Say you played SWTOR? That's what that Sith Emperor did.