140 réponses à ce sujet

[Ghost]

No.

[SlottsMachine]

Nightwriter wrote...

All we have is guesswork. I think they ultimately decided that the ME2 cast wasn't where the money was at.

This is just my opinion but I think we would all be surprised by the amount of data EA collects, they know. Also, I think they suck at analyzing the more finer points of that data but one would think figuring out the most popular characters would not be one of those points.

Modifié par General Slotts, 11 août 2012 - 03:54 .

[Kelgair]

Needs more Biotic God.

[garrusfan1]

I like it but yeah wrex would be grunt instead I love wrex but he is the krogan leader. And would love aria

[garrusfan1]

Oh and add liara too

[spirosz]

I liked when they promoted the idea of not exactly "permanent squadmates" and we got permanent squadmates, but that's just me nitpicking, they were using the same formula since ME1. My Shepard would of had a very different line up in ME3, but that might not of worked with the context of the story itself and you know, Starchild logic.

Modifié par spirosz, 11 août 2012 - 04:42 .

[Sousabird]

yeh switch wrex and grunt, and then I'd say just drop Aria, she is kind of irrelevant in the game

[TsaiMeLemoni]

No, needs Miranda.

[Zaire Taylor]

Every ME2 loyal squadmate should be available. Maybe Thane would be unavailable. That's a tough one. But why not everyone else? Kaidan/Ashley think I'm untrustworthy but want to be on my ship, while loyal squadmates love me but are too busy to join up?

[DeadpoolBub]

HYR 2.0 wrote...

> Legion is fine.
> Okay as such, but the VS had a lousy character-arc in ME3. It would need to be fixed.
> Jack's characer-arc is fine without squadmate status, but I certainly wouldn't complain about getting my LI back.
> Thane needs to die.
> Aria....... I approve!!!
> Not allowing Mordin to die curing the genophage is a crime against his character-arc.
> Team Dextro is fine by me.
> Any krogan on your squad in ME3 is problematic, given the option to sabotage the genophage cure, what to say of it being Wrex.
> Minus points for no Javik.


Not a fan overall.

I didn't make it, I just found it & thought it'd be cool to share.

As for the Krogan thing, it'd be similar to what happens to Tali if you side with the Geth only. The Krogan squadmate would be killed.

& if it was up to me, I WOULD have Javik.

As for Thane, Legion & Mordin...I think they should have lived if you did certain things right. Do something right & Thane gets a lung transplant/doesn't get stabbed by Kai Leng, do something right & Mordin doesn't have to sacrifice himself, same for Legion.

Modifié par DeadpoolBub, 11 août 2012 - 06:56 .

[Barquiel]

My three favorite characters wouldn't be available -> no

[Raizo]

Where the hell is Miranda.

[Feanor_II]

I can't see Aria working as squadmate, she has almost no emotional vinculation with anyone, better Liara.

Besides that the problem with ME2 people is that any of them can die in that game..... ME2 offered some amount of decisions/consequences regarding squadmates.... and now that's the price to pay

[Lionel Ou]

SergeantSnookie wrote...

 This squad is way better:

 

If you have the Doctor on your side, what would be the purpose with the rest of the characters?

[DeadpoolBub]

Feanor_II wrote...

I can't see Aria working as squadmate, she has almost no emotional vinculation with anyone, better Liara.

Besides that the problem with ME2 people is that any of them can die in that game..... ME2 offered some amount of decisions/consequences regarding squadmates.... and now that's the price to pay

If you weren't a good Commander you should get punished, it's that simple. 

[Boneyaards]

Add in Liara and we are set.

[I SOLD MY SOUL TO BIOWARE]

Lionel Ou wrote...

SergeantSnookie wrote...

 This squad is way better:

 

If you have the Doctor on your side, what would be the purpose with the rest of the characters?

Hey man, Blasto.

[o0 Aidan92 0o]

I dont understand why more of these characters weren't squad members, They all provided their voices in the game and surely it would of been easy to copy and paste most of the coding stuff to make them squad members from me2?

Having legion in your squad for atleast part of the journey surely would of made his death more heartbreaking?

[BatmanPWNS]

YES!

No Liara, no EDI and no Miranda.

[LilLino]

I don't get it, just put every squadmate we ever had. Why whole replacing thing? Such a pointless debate, it's obvious some people prefer some characters over the others and current squad isn't changing anyway.

[Cashless-Nick]

IsaacShep wrote...

No. Tali & Garrus are not necessary to be squadmates for the 3rd time while other characters don't even get a chance to be in the squad twice

Seriously? Playing Mass Effect without Garrus and Liara? They are the most useful squadmates in the whole in my opinion.

[Saberchic]

DeadpoolBub wrote...



Alot of people seem to be disappointed with the squad selection in ME3, paritcularly the lack of ME2 characters. So how about this squad? Add in Liara, Vega & Javik & I think it'd be perfect. Though, I say replace Wrex with Grunt. Wrex is awesome, but's the leader of the Krogan, he can't be messing around with Shepard when he has a people to lead into battle.

Wrex, Mordin, Aria (no thanks), Thane (how could you include him?! He's dying!), and Jack are a little busy. Besides, you've got too many squaddies. ME2 had way too many people IMO. I liked that ME3 had a smaller crew.

What I really wanted was the opportunity to tell some of my crew to go be with their people instead of pal around with me. 

I'd have told Tali to be with the quarians because obviously they can't be trusted to keep their damn word. I'd send Liara off to the Crucible. She'd probably at least be able to... I don't know... be the Shadow Broker there or something because she sure wasn't being a Shadow Broker on my ship.

That would have left me with Garrus, Vega, EDI, and Kaidan. I would have been fine with that. Just add some more side missions with some past ME2 crew members where they're actually on my team, and I'd be good to go.

[jahaa]

Where are Javik and Liara? Mass Effect 2.5 no, thanks.

[Han Shot First]

I like the squad size better but not the selection.

I like that Bioware reunited your old ME1 squad (minus Wrex) for ME3.

If we had 9 squadmates in ME3 instead of 7, these would be my picks:

• Garrus
  
  
• Liara
  
  
• Tali
  
  
• Ashley or Kaidan
  
  
• Grunt
  
  
• Javik
  
  
• Vega
  
  
• Thane (less sickly, though he'd still die during the coup)
  
  
• A Batarian squaddie

Modifié par Han Shot First, 11 août 2012 - 10:26 .

[HopHazzard]

The only change I would make to the squad from the game would be to replace EDI with Legion.