Earthborn_Shepard wrote...
Oh you mean because it's so different from that one time when the protagonist was a warden of the grey wardens?
Considering I wasn't forced to be all happy about the prospect in the game, then it
is entirely different. At least, not initially was I forced to be happy about the prospect, though the game ended up failing later on by making you unable to keep such a mindset -- even if the game would still inevitably dictate that you should save Ferelden, you should've been allowed to constantly take issue with the plan.
Anyway, I was still allowed to shape my character. Did he voluntarily join the Wardens, or was he forced into it? Was he pro-Mage or pro-Templar? Did he side with the Architect or against him? And so on and so forth. The Warden's beliefs were his own. Even the Eluvian choice with Morrigan for a romanced Warden can be seen as "Have I had enough of this life?".
With DAII, Hawke was reduced to little more then a bystander to events that would indeed threaten him, his home, his friends, and his way of life
until he was forced to act in them. We could barely shape his beliefs, and even then the game overtook our character in favor of some other design -- the guy who does nothing for years on end.
Additionally, plot stupidity/railroading would render him incapable of attempting to perform acts that could be seen as intelligent -- the Petrice moment in particular.
If DA3 forces you to play as a part of the New Inquisition, you're forced to be anti-Mage. You're either a pro-****themages character, or a Chantry Loyalist Mage.
Neither is very promising.
As opposed to DAO where a Mage Warden could be Libertarian, Loyalist, or IIRC -- I've only played the Mage Origin twice, so I don't know if you could be the other 3 -- any of the other three branches of the fraternities.
RenjiRenee wrote...
/BSN
Don't be disingenuous. I'm not saying anything of the sort until I receive more information on DA3. What I
am saying is that going down that road does not bode well for the series considering the backlash DAII had simply for forcing Hawke to do things that players wouldn't have otherwise had their Hawke do.
Besides, I had never even said I would pre-order DAIII anywhere in the past. In fact, I've repeatedly stated that I wouldn't be preordering DA3 -- or would at least be really apprehensive about doing so -- based on how disappointed I was with DAII.
I'd have to be a fool to preorder a game that's a sequel to a sequel -- can't phrase that eloquently, I admit -- that disappointed me personally, with very little information to really go on as to what that future game would contain. I can however say that based on what information I do have -- whether it's real or fake -- that I'm leaning more towards not buying it then buying it.
If it seems to be better then its predecessor, then I lean towards the "buy" area. If it seems to be worse or the same as its predecessor, then I remain in the "don't buy" area.
As of now, any information on DA3 that's been confirmed by devs hasn't been substantial for me to warrant an "Instant buy" mindset. Most of it's theoretical, and even then there seems to be some problems with how those theoretical concepts would play out.
To be honest, I've actually been bouncing between my feelings on the matter. In the DA Twitter thread, there was a tweet that raised my hopes for DA's gameplay potential. That didn't mean I was an instant pre-order, but it did cause me to be hopeful for the series' design future
based on what I knew, which wasn't much.
And now, reading that the PC may be forced into a particular viewpoint and set of beliefs seems to have tarnished what hope there was for me. Because while gameplay might be fun -- assuming DA3's gameplay is improved
significantly -- if the story isn't as captivating then it's a wasted venture for me. And that's assuming this is legit.
When the idea for the DA3 PC was being a Seeker that forumites were tossing around, that was different. I could get behind that, because there was a myriad of reasons for why one could be a Seeker. But being a part of the New Inquisition? Not much room for roleplaying there.
Which is really the nature of being blind to what's going on. You're happy, then sad. Happy, then sad. Then you eat ice cream.
Modifié par The Ethereal Writer Redux, 15 août 2012 - 07:26 .