Svest wrote...
Leifa wrote...
Well Alistair says that, of all the Grey Wardens that he knew, all of them who had children had fathered them before their joining.
But that aside, Alistair does not want to be king; and thus should not be.
Much of his story is about Duncan being the first person who ever cared about what he wanted, thus making us want to be the second, no?
At least, I do.
There is just too much emphisism that was put on his having been thrown around as a lad, for me to ignore what he wants now.
See this is where I think you are wrong. Deep down Alistair does want to be king. He's just had that idea beaten out of him all his life, to the point where he has a hard time accepting it himself at first. He was practically programmed to reject the idea from the day he was born so there wouldn't be a war of succession. However, if in the game you "harden" him he happily accepts becoming king. He not only accepts it, but he dedicates himself to learning how to be a good king, giving it everything he's got. Think about what you do when you harden him. You convince him that, at least occasionally, he should go after what he wants and not what he thinks others want.
So, I would agrue that if your PC really did care about and get to truly know Alistair and what he really wanted (what people say they want and what they really want are often not the same thing) then you should make him king. If your PC really thinks Alistair doesn't want to be king then she simply doesn't know the man she loves as well as she thinks she does.
I undersand.
But you can only get these lines out of him if you convince him of the fact. Siting in a room, discussing laws is not something which would make Alistair happy. He says very clealy that Duncan rescued him and that he'll always be thankful to him for doing so.
And you'll agree with me that you can convince Alistair of doing prety much anything in this game, except letting Loghain live. Why? Because he's a nice guy and has such a strong sense of duty that he would sacifice his freedom for you/the people. In fact that is why he has to see Loghain dead; he's honor bound to bring justice for Duncan.
But he's not that dumb, he knows what he wants. Listen to him before you decide to convince him of what you and Eamon think is best for him, he makes an excellent case of telling you why he would hate to be king.
And him being king would compare a lot to what he lived when he was young. The little people would think he's putting on airs and the nobles would always look down on him because he's a commoner. They may not say it to his face, but really, does that make a difference? You want to put him through all that, again?
Loving someone is listening to what they want and giving it to them, not using that trust they have in you to convince them of what you or others think would be best for them.
And IMO, Alistair has been hardened by life already (years of loneliness and rejection) -- he just has a big heart.
You'll agree that when the going gets tough, he rises to the occasion every time. He doesn't crumble like other NPCs. Just look at how he leads the army in the end.
Do not confuse being sensitive to being weak, it's not the same thing at all
It's life's job to harden you, not the people you love. They are suppose to be there for you, to comfort you when life deals you a blow.
Well that's what I think anyways, take it for what it is





Retour en haut






