Aller au contenu

Photo

Cole: an Analysis - *SPOILERS!*


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
88 réponses à ce sujet

#1
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages
With all the speculation about who our companions will be in The Next Thing, one of the names that's getting tossed around a lot lately is Cole's. Unfortunately, a lot of us haven't read the Asunder novel and aren't sure who or what Cole is, what his abilities are, or how/why he would/wouldn't make a good companion.

So I'm drawing this up as kind of a guide for anyone who is curious about Cole but not curious enough to finish an entire novel to find out. I'll also include my two-cents on what I think is happening behind the mystery of Cole's powers, but not till the end - because everybody should be able to sepeculate on their own based on the facts, right? But skip past this part if you've read Asunder already.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cole is a young man in his late teens or early 20's with dirty blonde hair and always dressed in filthy leathers. He was picked up by the Templars and brought to the White Spire in Val Royeaux after murdering his father. The Templars handle him pretty roughly and toss him into one of the dungeon cells where they hold mages until placing them within the Circle. Terrified, Cole prayed fervently to the Maker for the Templars to completely forget that he exists.

So they did.

From that point on, Cole is invisible to almost everyone almost all of the time. He's spotted rarely and when he is, those that see him soon forget about him. Normally, he can stand within inches of someone and never be detected. He spends some of his time watching the lives of the Spire's mages and Templars, but mostly prefers to stay in the dark underbelly of the tower with all of the other forgotten things.

Vague rumors circulate about a Ghost of the Spire as his sightings grow more numerous, and people are found murdered for no obvious reason. What occasionally happens is that Cole can feel himself slipping out of reality, and when he does he discovers a feeling of being drawn to someone in the Tower who will be able to see him. Then he kills them (using a dagger) and in the moment that their life slips away and their eyes are looking directly into his he knows that he is the most real thing in the world to them. He does feel somewhat sorrowful and actually quite ashamed of the murders, but feels strongly that they must be done nonetheless.

Rhys, a mage who has a talent for communicating with Fade spirits, is able to see Cole. He literally chases him through the Spire and convinces Cole that he can see him. When Rhys doesn't forget Cole later, Cole is incredibly relieved and can scarcely believe it. The two form a friendship, with Rhys becomes a sort of father figure for the boy. When Rhys is in trouble, Cole actually leaves the Spire to help him.

Lord Seeker Lambert (who is in charge of the White Spire) is convinced that Cole is a demon. Cole admits that he doesn't know what he is. He's heard about demons around the Tower but doesn't think he's ever met one. He could be a ghost, but he doesn't remember dying - and he still eats and sleeps. Toward the end of the book Lambert uses the Litany of Adralla to try to reveal Cole for what he is - and Cole actually loses his invisibility and appears to everyone. Lambert accuses Cole of being a demon who attempted to convince himself he was human, and implies that he used mind domination to fool Rhys into believing the same thing. Cole never denies it, but actually begins to cry as a look of realization passes in his eyes. Then he disappears again completely. Even Rhys can no longer see him.

In the Epilogue, on the night when Lambert prepares for the Seekers and Templars to separate themselves from the Chantry, Cole comes to him while he's sleeping. He presses his knife against Lambert's neck and tells him
"There was a Cole. You forgot him in that cell, and I heard his cries when no one else would. I went to him, and held his hand in the darkness until it was over. When the templars found him, they erased everything to hide their shame and I was helpless to act." Remembering this seems to bring him sorrow. Finally, he commands Lambert to look at him, and we're left to assume that Lambert is murdered.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So what is Cole? I was really confused until I read this from an interview with David Gaider:

TUK: With mages and possession, does a mage actually have to agree to a deal with a demon in order to get possessed, or can it just happen? Can demons just go "Ah-hah, you're asleep, I will slip in while nobody's looking..." Is the truth different from what the Chantry says on the subject?

DG: They have to agree, but agree doesn't necessarily mean a conscious "Yes, please, please come in my body and turn me into a twisted abomination." Agreeing can be a moment of weakness. If you're unwilling or unable to resist being possessed then you'll be possessed. There are mages who make an intelligent bargain with a demon. Sometimes, the tricky part, something we haven't been able to show very well, is sometimes they're not aware that's what they're doing. I don't know how many people have read Asunder, the last Dragon Age novel. That does show a bit of how it's possible for a mage to be in contact with a demon and not even be aware that that's what's happening, and agreeing to things that they don't know that they're agreeing to. To say that a mage must agree is both true and false in the sense that a lot of it relates to the will of the mage and their strength to resist a very determined demon, but I think you can also see from the games and the novels that there are levels of possession as well. Not everybody who becomes possessed by a demon immediately turns into an abomination and starts attacking everything in sight. It depends on the type of demon that's attempting to take possession, how powerful they are, how intelligent they are, and the mage in question. As is typical of Dragon Age, the answer is never [typical].

It seems to me that the only person in Asunder that DG could be talking about is Cole. I can also only account for his complusion to murder by saying that it has to be some kind of blood magic that rejuvinates his power to either stay invisible or remain on this side of the Fade. Whether he's an abomination or a demon/spirit that fused with the real Cole and took on his memories as he died is anyone's guess. By the end of the book, Cole obviously knows he isn't just a scared young man - he's something quite different, but that doesn't mean he's sure what he is either. The Litany of Adralla worked on him, and that was a huge eye-opener. But the Litany only reveals mind-domination, not demonic presence. Cole isn't necessarily a demon, but also technically could be.

In combat: Cole is technically a mage, but doesn't use conventional mage powers. In the book he's always wearing leathers and wielding a dagger. His ability to be invisible may make him a valuable rogue companion.

As a companion/LI: expect Cole to be very emotionally clingly, (his emotional age is much younger than his physical age) and oblivious to how normal human interaction works. It wasn't uncommon for Cole to watch humans undress and even have sex in the Spire without the slightest hint of arousal - just mild curiosity. Cole is jumpy and easily frightened. He finds it much easier to hide or to run than to fight, though assassinations are something he's comfortable with. He comes from a very troubled (and weird) past and does not have much of a sense of humor. However, unless his end-of-book realization changes him much, Cole doesn't seem to have any kind of agenda like Anders/Justice did. Rather, he's actually kind of lost.

Of course that's assuming that Cole would still be Asunder Cole, and not more like "I'm a spirit and I know it." Cole.

Too Long/Didn't Read:
Cole is unusual.

Hope that's helpful to somebody. Did I miss anything? What are your thoughts/theories on Cole?

Modifié par brushyourteeth, 16 août 2012 - 06:14 .


#2
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests
I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.

#3
Reznore57

Reznore57
  • Members
  • 6 144 messages
I kind of have a big doubt about the book , but did Rhys realise that he killed some people because of Cole?

I can't remember if it's just Lambert playing with him.

Anyway I like Cole as a book character , as a companion , I don't know...
I'm not a big fan of "I'm posessed." and he's really f***ed up , i don't mind character with problems , but reading the book , his story is so sad that you end up forgiving him for being a cold blooded murderer.
Discovering what he really is ,would be really cool.
I'd like something else than a spirit (again) , a demon ...if it shows that demon can be affected by human , just like a abomination but the other way around.The human side wins over and the demons become something else , could be interesting.

There's also the idea of a lost soul...the way Cole feels when he's about to disappear is very close to death.

There's a lot of potential there , I hope it just won't go the Janders /Wynne road and that it will be surprising.

#4
thats1evildude

thats1evildude
  • Members
  • 10 995 messages
Rhys believes that Cole manipulated him into killing people. That may be the case, and it may not be.

#5
Chaos Lord Malek

Chaos Lord Malek
  • Members
  • 735 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Cole is 100% demon, because in book .... SPOILER :







Lambert uses some kind of script from Tevinter on him, which works ONLY on demons.






END SPOILER

Besides people were whining for a demon companion, now we getting it.

Modifié par Chaos Lord Malek, 16 août 2012 - 07:00 .


#6
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


I totally agree, but something had to happen between Cole the regular guy who was brought to the Spire and Cole 2.0 because he has some of the original Cole's memories now, right?

So maybe they fused before Cole's death. Or maybe they're joined together still. Maybe they made a connection and the new Cole is still inhabiting the old Cole's body and keeping it rejuvenated through the magic he uses?

#7
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

Chaos Lord Malek wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Cole is 100% demon, because in book .... SPOILER :







Lambert uses some kind of script from Tevinter on him, which works ONLY on demons.






END SPOILER

Besides people were whining for a demon companion, now we getting it.


You're referring to the Litany of Adralla. It's function is to dispel mind control spells. It's not specifically for demons.

#8
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages

Chaos Lord Malek wrote...

Cole is 100% demon, because in book .... SPOILER :







Lambert uses some kind of script from Tevinter on him, which works ONLY on demons.






END SPOILER

Besides people were whining for a demon companion, now we getting it.

Actually, he uses the Litany of Adralla (like I said above) which breaks the power of mind domination (from blood magic). It doesn't necessarily prove that anyone's a demon - just a blood mage. Even if Cole didn't realize that's what he was doing.

I think Cole was basically a spirit that wanted to believe he was human. Now that he knows better, though - who knows? Still, I don't think he has his own agenda or is pro-or-anti-anything, really. He'll be fiercely loyal to anyone who wins his friendship and probably pick up their cause as his own.

... as long as we're cool with him maybe killing people to stay corporeal.  Posted Image

#9
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

brushyourteeth wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


I totally agree, but something had to happen between Cole the regular guy who was brought to the Spire and Cole 2.0 because he has some of the original Cole's memories now, right?

So maybe they fused before Cole's death. Or maybe they're joined together still. Maybe they made a connection and the new Cole is still inhabiting the old Cole's body and keeping it rejuvenated through the magic he uses?


Cole has no body. He disappeared when Lambert used the Litany and materialized in Lambert's quarters later.

#10
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

brushyourteeth wrote...
... as long as we're cool with him maybe killing people to stay corporeal.  Posted Image


There should be no reason for Cole to kill for that purpose any more. He knows what he is now and knows that he won't "disappear."

#11
Guest_PurebredCorn_*

Guest_PurebredCorn_*
  • Guests

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Very powerful demons can manifest without having a host body. There are examples of this in both Origins and DA2.

#12
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Very powerful demons can manifest without having a host body. There are examples of this in both Origins and DA2.


Such as? I don't recall any demons without solid corporeal form.

#13
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

Cole has no body. He disappeared when Lambert used the Litany and materialized in Lambert's quarters later.

Magic?

BrotherWarth wrote...

There should be no reason for Cole to kill for that purpose any more. He knows what he is now and knows that he won't "disappear."


Unless the purpose of the killing was a compulsion toward the kind of blood magic ritual that would keep him in the physical world OR hidden from it. In which case we might expect it to continue.

I don't necessarily think that Cole is or is related to a demon. Definitely some kind of Fade spirit, and maybe a demon - maybe. But here's the thing: if Cole isn't a demon or joined to a demon, how did he end up *accidentally* using blood magic? As far as I know (from Justice in Awakening especially) *good* Fade spirits don't do that.

Modifié par brushyourteeth, 16 août 2012 - 07:28 .


#14
Guest_PurebredCorn_*

Guest_PurebredCorn_*
  • Guests

BrotherWarth wrote...

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Very powerful demons can manifest without having a host body. There are examples of this in both Origins and DA2.


Such as? I don't recall any demons without solid corporeal form.

Hybris (pride), and Allure (desire) in DA2. There were others too I just don't feel like looking up all their names. In Origins there was the demon you encounter in Orzammar when you gather up all the body parts and place them on the altar.

Modifié par PurebredCorn, 16 août 2012 - 07:41 .


#15
TamiBx

TamiBx
  • Members
  • 3 150 messages
Well, thank you for writing this :)
And the more I read about him, the less I want him to be my companion.
I think Anders left me traumatized. XD

#16
Guest_PurebredCorn_*

Guest_PurebredCorn_*
  • Guests
Personally, I think Cole is interesting because he doesn't fit neatly into either the demon or spirit category. He's very unique.

Modifié par PurebredCorn, 16 août 2012 - 07:45 .


#17
Eliamor

Eliamor
  • Members
  • 87 messages
Thanks for the read, brushyourteeth. I haven't read the books but when I hear of Cole I'm dying to know more about him ^^

As for a companion, I think he would be interesting to play, but he seems a bit too unstable personality-wise. Instead, I think I would prefer if there was a quest or questline about him, or that he just appears as a major character somewhere in DA3 but not necessary as a companion.

#18
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Very powerful demons can manifest without having a host body. There are examples of this in both Origins and DA2.


Such as? I don't recall any demons without solid corporeal form.

Hybris (pride), and Allure (desire) in DA2. There were others too I just don't feel like looking up all their names. In Origins there was the demon you encounter in Orzammar when you gather up all the body parts and place them on the altar.


We don't see how Hybris and Allure entered our world. Is there a reason why they wouldn't be possessing mages?
And the demon in the deep roads obviously has corporeal form. His severed body parts are scattered about...

#19
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages

TamiBx wrote...

Well, thank you for writing this :)


Eliamor wrote...
Thanks for the read, brushyourteeth. I haven't read the books but when I hear of Cole I'm dying to know more about him ^^

You guys are so welcome! Posted Image Glad all that typing was useful to somebody!

#20
Guest_PurebredCorn_*

Guest_PurebredCorn_*
  • Guests

BrotherWarth wrote...

We don't see how Hybris and Allure entered our world. Is there a reason why they wouldn't be possessing mages?
And the demon in the deep roads obviously has corporeal form. His severed body parts are scattered about...


David Gaider has also mentioned that very powerful demons can manifest on their own without possessing a body. This was years ago, maybe even before BSN, I honestly can't remember when he said it or how I could go about trying to locate the quote. So I guess I will agree to disagree.

Modifié par PurebredCorn, 16 août 2012 - 08:18 .


#21
Kidd

Kidd
  • Members
  • 3 667 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

I don't think we can really classify Cole as a demon. He's not really possessing anyone. He's not in a host body, living or dead so he's some new kind of spirit.


Very powerful demons can manifest without having a host body. There are examples of this in both Origins and DA2.


Such as? I don't recall any demons without solid corporeal form.

Aren't Shades basically demons that pop over to Thedas without any host bodies or anything?

#22
thats1evildude

thats1evildude
  • Members
  • 10 995 messages
Shades are demons that have learned to manifest in the mortal world without taking a host. But it's not a great choice; shades tend to be weaker than demons that keep their old form and they constantly hunger for life energy, never being sated no matter how many people they kill.

The Baroness was an example of a demon so powerful that it could appear in the mortal world without a host. You can even ask her how she can appear in the world without a body, and she responds that she's fed so long on the people of Blackmarsh that "my true form has substance here."

Modifié par thats1evildude, 16 août 2012 - 08:49 .


#23
brushyourteeth

brushyourteeth
  • Members
  • 4 418 messages

thats1evildude wrote...

Shades are demons that have learned to manifest in the mortal world without taking a host. But it's not a great choice; shades tend to be weaker than demons that keep their old form and they constantly hunger for life energy, never being sated no matter how many people they kill.

The Baroness was an example of a demon so powerful that it could appear in the mortal world without a host. You can even ask her how she can appear in the world without a body, and she responds that she's fed so long on the people of Blackmarsh that "my true form has substance here."


And the Veil was thin there the way is would be at the White Spire, right? Though maybe on a lesser scale. Interesting.

I can't claim to know exactly what Cole is. Not necessarily human and blood-magicy is all I know.

#24
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

PurebredCorn wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

We don't see how Hybris and Allure entered our world. Is there a reason why they wouldn't be possessing mages?
And the demon in the deep roads obviously has corporeal form. His severed body parts are scattered about...


David Gaider has also mentioned that very powerful demons can manifest on their own without possessing a body. This was years ago, maybe even before BSN, I honestly can't remember when he said it or how I could go about trying to locate the quote. So I guess I will agree to disagree.


Interesting. I hadn't heard that.

#25
deuce985

deuce985
  • Members
  • 3 567 messages
Cole sounds like he has a classic case of schizophrenia.