206 réponses à ce sujet

[himegoto]

Tier list attempt. Hugely depend on weapons and setups. Consumables taken into consideration.
Feel free to agree/disagree
--------------


SSS (Godly)

Geth Infiltrator

 

SS

Salarian Infiltrator

Male Quarian Infiltrator

N7 Demolisher

 

S (Exceptional)

N7 Destroyer

N7 Paladin

N7 Shadow

N7 Fury

Human Sentinel

Kroguard

Human Soldier (BF3 Soldier)

Male Quarian Engineer

 

 

A (Great classes)

Batarian Soldier

Vorcha Soldier

Vorcha Sentinel

Drell Adept

Human Engineer

Geth Engineer

Salarian Engineer

Asari Justicar

Phoenix Vanguard (Pre nerf, S)

Female Quarian Infiltrator

Human Infiltrator

Turian Soldier (With full consumables)

 

B (Average)

Asari Adept

Phoenix Adept

Krogan Sentinel

Asari Vanguard

Human Vanguard

Turian Sentinel

Krogan Soldier

 

C

Female Quarian Engineer

Batarian Sentinel

Human Adept
 

D

Drell Vanguard

N7 Slayer

 
---------------



Turians and Krogans (and Batarians)??
- Sorry, no roll

Asari Adept at B??
- Only ever good against phantoms. Which is easy to deal with
in current days with better classes and weapons. And BE nerf.

QME > DA?
- Yeah, arc grenades is just that much better.


 

If I put one of your favs in lower ranks, doesn't mean I'm
belittle-ing you. Just throwing it out there. We all know people only take
things too seriously in BSN. I love playing as Female Quarian Engineer, Batarian
Sentinel, Krogan Sentinel, Asari Vanguard.

 

Flame away.

Modifié par himegoto, 21 août 2012 - 11:43 .

[MrFuddyDuddy]

So where my Human Engineer, he must be at least A or S tier

[himegoto]

MrFuddyDuddy wrote...

So where my Human Engineer, he must be at least A or S tier

Oops.
I'd say he is A - B ish. Definitely an A with consumables

[dzero]

Interesting... I mostly agree - in fact I think I wholly agree with your tier-ing.

Human Inf. in the A tier makes me happy. I need to go play this class again, but with a shotgun and bonus power rather than a Valiant.

Modifié par dzero, 21 août 2012 - 10:48 .

[dzero]

Human Adept - D

Edit: possibly C

Modifié par dzero, 21 août 2012 - 10:51 .

[himegoto]

Thanks dzero.

Thing is it's not possible to give any inflitrators (with a shotgun) a lower rank...

Modifié par himegoto, 21 août 2012 - 10:54 .

[MrFuddyDuddy]

Human Adept with a Acolyte X is at least an A, one shot the barriers and shields off all mooks on gold, catch with singularity and hit em with shockwave/warp

[Teratoid]

himegoto wrote...

Flame away.

You look like a chicken.

[Crimson Vanguard]

Asari Adept is B? Seriously she can turn a group of Phantom or Marauder into a joke

[Uchimura]

Destroyer should move up one rank imo.

[dzero]

To be fair though I think it is quite a powerful class; cryo blast spam is just awesome for both support and offense. And then there a grenades for bosses/clusters. Only lacks shield-stripping really.

[SierraGHOSTN7]

Disagree about Slayer.
You can rock with him.
And no, without Piranha. Just the Slayer.

[dzero]

MrFuddyDuddy wrote...

Human Adept with a Acolyte X is at least an A, one shot the barriers and shields off all mooks on gold, catch with singularity and hit em with shockwave/warp

Acolyte is too much of an anomaly (for lack of better term) imo. I know weapons are taken into consideration but I don't think Acolyte should have too much influence, it is a single weapon versus infiltrators being considered for i.e. shotguns in general. If that makes any sense (I'm tired).

[spudspot]

himegoto wrote...
D

Drell Vanguard

N7 Slayer

[himegoto]

Uchimura wrote...

Destroyer should move up one rank imo.

He is still great. PR too but I was thinking he's just not as all rounded as with the old Typhoon..

[DirtySHISN0]

God tier;
Asari
Geth
Quarians
N7 humans

Meh tier;
Krogan
Vorcha
Batarians
Turians
Drell














Human tier;
humans

Modifié par DirtySHISN0, 21 août 2012 - 11:09 .

[himegoto]

Crimson Vanguard wrote...

Asari Adept is B? Seriously she can turn a group of Phantom or Marauder into a joke

B is still great. I dont find her as good as those classes in A in an overall aspect

[himegoto]

Astaiir wrote...

Disagree about Slayer.
You can rock with him.
And no, without Piranha. Just the Slayer.

Ok... Where would you put the slayer?

[Hyunsai]

Asari Adept is at least S.

I played again the class a few ways ago after the complaints I heard against the weakness of stasis, warp, and biotic explosion. I still have no idea of the reason of those complaints.

[dzero]

B is a respectable tier. Stasis cooldown and throw/warp missing lets AA down a little, is all. Still an amazing class, probably just more balanced compared to others.

In fact, AA is a rather balanced class come to think of it.

Modifié par dzero, 21 août 2012 - 11:13 .

[Ziegrif]

I have decided to disagree with everything written in this thread due to Skillz > all.
On a technical standpoint though well some charachters have more tools at their disposal but it's the player who has to utilize those tools.
Marking the tools on tiers... eh everything has a use.Everything's equal to me just my opinion :/

Course yer all entitled to voice your disagreements and own opinions on my opinion o.o

[dzero]

Ziegrif wrote...

I have decided to disagree with everything written in this thread due to Skillz > all.
On a technical standpoint though well some charachters have more tools at their disposal but it's the player who has to utilize those tools.
Marking the tools on tiers... eh everything has a use.Everything's equal to me just my opinion :/

Course yer all entitled to voice your disagreements and own opinions on my opinion o.o

Fair enough, though I would argue that a highly skilled player after playing every class to its maximum potential would still be able to form some sort of tier ranking.

[SlimJim0725]

QMI and Demolisher can rank up there with the GI with the SI and Destroyer being very very close to that. Paladin and Fury should both be at least an SS rank with ease. Asari Justicar, Batarian Soldier, Drell Adept, Human Engineer, Geth Engineer, and Female Quarian should all easily be S rank with some having the potential for SS (Asari Justicar or Drell Adept with either a Fury or anything with Warp around are amazing). Human Adept, Asari Vanguard, Human Vanguard, and Asari Adept should all be up at least to A rank.

Those are just my opinions and I am not listing everything nor will I bother giving reasoning behind it (I have in the past only to have people argue worthless reasons why they can't make the character as good as another). Everyone's opinion on a character can differ and some people will just be better with some characters and average at best with others.

I for one am not the greatest with any Krogan (never took the time to get the hang of the Vanguard, don't like how bulky he is), Turian Soldier (his lack of mobility and no stagger immunity keeps me from using him enough), the Drell Vanguard (just not my character), and the Slayer. That is not to say any of them are bad by any means, I am just personally not at my best with any of them while I am sure plenty of the very good members of this forum are amazing with them.

tl;dr: A tier list is fairly pointless, 3/4's of the characters potential relies on the user.

[CptSketch13]

i strongly disagree with alot of this but thats just my opinion.

but yeah put the geth infiltrator up there maybe bioware will nerf it

haha i'm kidding i dislike nerfs

[mpompeo27]

You left out the Krogan Soldier