47 réponses à ce sujet

[AngryFrozenWater]

Even if IGN gave DA:O the second place then they won't win me over. The damage has been done.

Modifié par AngryFrozenWater, 28 août 2012 - 02:44 .

[eroeru]

Sorry for the trolly post, but I've got to say what I feel relevant:

IGN is ****.
There. Plain and simple.

[legion999]

GoW3 is the most complete package aside from the Orange Box?

lolnope.

In fact lolnope at this entire list.

[ObserverStatus]

LOL! Yeah right, these people had Fallout 3 as #7 and New Vegas didn't make this list? I'm sorry, I loved ME1 too, but these people wouldn't know good storytelling if slithered up and bit them.

[horacethegrey]

I'd sooner dive buck naked in ice water than take IGN's word. But on a serious note, I wouldn't place Mass Effect on a Top 25 list of Xbox360 games, as Mass Effect 2 was a better game and an improvement on all fronts IMO. But even I don't think any of Bioware's games are the best RPG's on the system. That title goes to The Witcher 2.

[legion999]

bobobo878 wrote...

LOL! Yeah right, these people had Fallout 3 as #7 and New Vegas didn't make this list? I'm sorry, I loved ME1 too, but these people wouldn't know good storytelling if slithered up and bit them.

This^.

[Milan92]

While I do love ME 1, its definatly not the best xbox game ever made. I'd say, Batman Arkham City or Sleeping Dogs or something like that. Atleast those two in the top 5.

[Splinter Cell 108]

Isn't that the same list they always release anyways? I thought it was the list like from 2 years ago or something. Splinter Cell Conviction has no business being in that list, that game is terrible in every sense. That list is a joke and so is IGN.

[Splinter Cell 108]

J. Reezy wrote...

Splinter Cell 108 wrote...

Isn't that the same list they always release anyways? I thought it was the list like from 2 years ago or something. Splinter Cell Conviction has no business being in that list, that game is terrible in every sense. That list is a joke and so is IGN.

I strongly disagree. The problem with Conviction isn't that it's a bad game, the problem is that it's a bad Splinter Cell game.

Maybe, I still think its a bad game aside from being a Splinter Cell game. First its way too simple, they might as well just let the game play on its own, second the story is just crap, there's nothing there that I'd call original, i'm pretty sure much of it is the same as 24, the only difference is that its Sam Fisher not Jack Bauer. I don't know if those things make it a bad game for other people but they do for me. To each their own I guess. 

[DukeOfNukes]

ME_Fan wrote...

What a terrible list. Those people are seriouslyy useless. Mass Effect 1 is a 'okay' game in my opinion, but best 360 game ever? Shut up IGN.

You should be fired. Out of a cannon...into a brick wall.

J. Reezy wrote...
Indeed.
Wanna know what else is lame? The topic title. The "1" is not needed
here as the word "game" already indicates that IGN is referring to a
single title and not a series of games.

Put it in there to specify that I wasn't saying "A Mass Effect", but THE Mass Effect.

happy_daiz wrote...
No Fallout: New Vegas? Or Resident Evil?

I'm
puzzled by the dance, guitar, and racing games being on the list, but
maybe that's just because I don't like those types of games.

New Vegas was most likely left off because of it being too similar to 3. It really didn't gain the noteriety of the first, and I know ultimately, a lot of people weren't interested in the story. And why on Earth would a Resident Evil game be on the list?

Dance Central 2 was a really good game, if you were the audience. Obviously, you weren't the audience. Guitar Hero 3 was a great game...the last great music game really...not really their fault the whole thing crashed. And why on Earth wouldn't they include Forza 4? Trust me, it is just because YOU don't like those types of games.

[DukeOfNukes]

Splinter Cell 108 wrote...

Maybe, I still think its a bad game aside from being a Splinter Cell game. First its way too simple, they might as well just let the game play on its own,

Just wait for Splinter Cell Blacklist.

[Splinter Cell 108]

DukeOfNukes wrote...

Splinter Cell 108 wrote...

Maybe, I still think its a bad game aside from being a Splinter Cell game. First its way too simple, they might as well just let the game play on its own,

Just wait for Splinter Cell Blacklist.

I'm assuming that's sarcasm. Am I wrong?

[Seboist]

Objectively, ME1 is a mediocre shooter with half-baked RPG elements.

Besides, we all know Bayonetta is the best X360 game.

[Seboist]

Skelter192 wrote...

It's IGN what did you expect? Especially after having Chobot in ME3.

There's also the fact that EAware hired the reviewer who gave DA2 a high score.

[Splinter Cell 108]

J. Reezy wrote...

Lol I was thinking the same thing. Blacklist is more of the same. Even worse so if the gameplay I seen is any indication.

Yeah the only thing that surprised me is that they're adding the old multiplayer back Spies vs Mercenaries but then again I'm sure it will be the super dumbed down version anyways. 

[PaulSX]

pfff, ME1? I would agree on ME2 being the best game though.

[DukeOfNukes]

Splinter Cell 108 wrote...

DukeOfNukes wrote...

Splinter Cell 108 wrote...

Maybe, I still think its a bad game aside from being a Splinter Cell game. First its way too simple, they might as well just let the game play on its own,

Just wait for Splinter Cell Blacklist.

I'm assuming that's sarcasm. Am I wrong?

I wouldn't say sarcasm...but I meant Blacklist will be even worse.

[DukeOfNukes]

greengoron89 wrote...

Ah, I didn't realize you were championing the list - now your thread will undoubtedly descend into an argument between you and people who think the list is bollocks.

I'm not "championing" the list. I agree with a few of their choices, and I can see WHY most of them are on there. Do I agree with all of them? No...but you're hard pressed to find a list I agree with ALL of the choices on.

[Chromie]

stonbw1 wrote...
I'm loving Fallout 3 though.I think BW could do wonders with the Fallout genre as an IPO for the next gen.  Wishful thinking I suppose..

Lol, oh you. I think the only studio that could do more harm to Fallout than Bethesda is Bioware. I really hope the franchise ends up in Obsidian's hands or just dies. Fallout 3 is probably the worsr game I ever bought on launch.

[BatmanPWNS]

IGN and Aller just bootlick Bioware.