Aller au contenu

Photo

ME3 Leviathan: SPOILER Discussion [poll included]


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1659 réponses à ce sujet

#1426
BiO

BiO
  • Members
  • 2 057 messages

Henioo wrote...

I don't see it, maybe it's burried somewhere in these 57 pages, but can someone tell me if they talked to Balak after beating Leviathan?

Does the dialogue with him change when he mentions the Reaper that indocrinated the batarians?

Oh, BTW, seems like the Leviathan are responsible for the fall of the batarians, eh? :P


Not directly. The Leviathan of Dis was already dead.

#1427
B.Shep

B.Shep
  • Members
  • 1 876 messages
If i am not wrong there is a few chances in the dialogue with Jondum Bau but i have no idea about Balak.

By the way, i agree with Bio_Man about the Leviathan od Dis.

Modifié par B.Shep, 04 septembre 2012 - 06:23 .


#1428
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

Regional_Coffee wrote...

TMA LIVE wrote...

You know, those mind controlling green balls probably would've been helpful during the Priority Earth mission. Especially with Hammer getting to that beam.

Indeed, this is another huge plothole now.  You're got these orbs that basically allow you to control a reaper and/or their forces, why wouldn't Shep have one constantly on the Normandy (shielded), and just drop it on the field from time to time?  Normandy is the vanguard of the fleet, there's no better place for them.


So true, but BW is sticking by its crappy ending. And I'm not even talking about the ending in and of itself but that last part once you hit earth... I skipped in when doing future playthroughs once I decided to only bother with destroy.

They have yet again squandered potential. Lack of creativity or just not caring or maybe playing to an audience that likes mindless shooting without the good storyline and without all the plotholes - well, it's clear that they didn't have an actual 'writer' who has knowledge of how to tell a story well on ME3 or for the ending DLC or even Leviathan.

$20 for used ME3 right now. Just a bit over six months and $20 from 60. That's mindblowingly horrific. usually it's around 40 a year later. And there are stacks of them on the shelves. Stacks! I think there was maybe one new one in stock. It's that bad. They destroyed the entire franchise. They made what could have been a series that had unlimited replayability garbage. The endings could have opened whole new possibilities. Instead, lots of people hated them, enough that it was a media blitz.

I gave Leviathan a chance. I play the MP maybe every couple of days for a few hours if that. More like to get some more levels so I can promote more. I tried playing ME3 again beyond leviathan but couldn't even go to surkesh. It's not fun anymore. They sucked all the fun out of it for me. So sad because I loved ME1 and still do and wish it had more to it than it did. Once you hit noveria it's pretty much a race toward the end.

#1429
coinop25

coinop25
  • Members
  • 618 messages
I liked the Reapers better when they were mysterious, Lovecraftian elder gods in sci-fi dressing. Explaining their origin kind of defeated that approach. Oh well.

A bigger issue for me about this DLC is just that it doesn't hold up very well upon replay. Once you've already beaten it, it becomes really apparent that a LOT of this DLC is watching stuff happen rather than actually doing stuff yourself.

Also, I find it kind of funny that nobody mentions how the Reapers are the only things keeping THIS galaxy-subjugating race of monsters at bay ... but acknowledging another inevitable war would've just made the ending that much more bitter for fans.

#1430
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

ElitePinecone wrote...

JPVS wrote...
snip


James, Liara and EDI are the only squadmates guaranteed to be alive and present at every point of ME3. 

It would be very impractical to have the voice actors for every squad member record all the lines for those crucial plot conversations - not to mention that EDI has her own unique skills in terms of research that other characters can't easily do. Javik would be next to usless when dealing with events, locations and people in this cycle, for example.


Not so. Garrus would have also been gauranteed. If I had no option to do the DLC until after palaven where I pick up Garrus and the Primarch, Garrus would have been better than dumb James who wasn't there for ME1. He should have been there. He would have wanted to be there given he fought to get a task force by going to his father whom he was never on good terms with going back to ME1. Garrus should have been in the lab and there should have been commentary going back to ME1 for true trilogy followers rather than just the late pickups who like a good shotting game and don't care about story which is what ME3 seems to have catered to IMO.

Modifié par starlitegirlx, 04 septembre 2012 - 08:43 .


#1431
ninjaNumber1

ninjaNumber1
  • Members
  • 423 messages
All this game needed was an epic battle at the end where the outcome of the battle is dependent on how well you established relations with the other races and gathered forces.

What you have hear is a group of people who decided to try and be smart ass and screwed up big time. Instead of determining the outcome of the final battle, it became a outcome of the final three choices.

In other words, the outcome of the final three choices was determined by your assets rather than the outcome of the Battle.

That is where the game failed. Simple error really but with devastating effects for anyone invested in the game.

#1432
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

coinop25 wrote...

I liked the Reapers better when they were mysterious, Lovecraftian elder gods in sci-fi dressing. Explaining their origin kind of defeated that approach. Oh well.

A bigger issue for me about this DLC is just that it doesn't hold up very well upon replay. Once you've already beaten it, it becomes really apparent that a LOT of this DLC is watching stuff happen rather than actually doing stuff yourself.

Also, I find it kind of funny that nobody mentions how the Reapers are the only things keeping THIS galaxy-subjugating race of monsters at bay ... but acknowledging another inevitable war would've just made the ending that much more bitter for fans.


Yes, on the watching stuff happen, which I've always disliked about the ME series in that you cannot skip those parts. When a long part is coming I go to do other things. Conversation always stops it so it's like an automatic pause.

People have mentioned that the reapers were better than the Leviathans. That was back many pages ago. At least 10 or 15. It made it far more doomish to have found them. After I played it though, and stopped just reading other people's reviews, I kind of got the impression that millions of years in hiding may have changed things for leviathan and their kind. Watching, in essence, their own actions, by the reapers only made even more effecient with mass relays and the citadel while also being forced into hiding for fear of their own lives gave me the impression that though they still believed themselves to be the apex of evolution, that dominating the galaxy as they did just to harvest was what led them to this end. I also felt like during it's control of Shepard, it was not doing it for more than communication and it was coming to understand how things could or should be different. But it should have been made clearer on that point.

I have to admit that I did suspect something strange like this regarding leviathan because builders of AI build in their own image though I didn't fully see the dominate and harvest aspect coming. I thought that was based on flawed AI logic in having witness countless harvestings of species that created AI and then went to war with them.

#1433
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

ninjaNumber1 wrote...

All this game needed was an epic battle at the end where the outcome of the battle is dependent on how well you established relations with the other races and gathered forces.

What you have hear is a group of people who decided to try and be smart ass and screwed up big time. Instead of determining the outcome of the final battle, it became a outcome of the final three choices.

In other words, the outcome of the final three choices was determined by your assets rather than the outcome of the Battle.

That is where the game failed. Simple error really but with devastating effects for anyone invested in the game.


The choices were terrible. Yes. It should have been straight out destruction, but I think they were trying to play the 'give you a choice RPG aspect' where you decide your fate but they should have had far more choices incorporated into the series along the way. There were a lot of things forced upon Shepard that most players wouldn't have chosen, like working with Tim.

Also, 'all the game needed' is not quite the case. What the game needed was a lot more of actions taken by shepard incorporated into ME3 rather than forced things. The only thing I know for certain that shepard really helped or hurt in the war effort from previous decisions was if certain people survived ME2 they become assets in ME3 and not very valuable ones. Wrex, if you didn't kill him, would be a far better leader than the other tool. But even that isn't an issue. All of it ultimately didn't matter except in a miniscule way. If you saved Kirrahe, he shows up for one or two cameos. The first is far less momentus though amusing (surkesh). The second I have yet to see because Thane is always the one that fights Lang. Ultimately, nothing you as a player did previously added into the scenario of ME3 except in minor ways as far as I could tell. So some extra war assets, but not much.

Yes, it is those horrible three choices at the end that make a difference between a good ending and a disasterous, and I still suspect they were headed into indoctrination theory (plenty of evidence for it) but decided to not head in that direction or remain silent about it. I say that because it's the only way those other choices make sense. Otherwise, they are idiotic. Try to manipulate Shep at that point? Why give the choice at all? You never have choices in boss fights that are final but in this one, which wasn't even a boss fight, you have a choice of how to end it depsite the sole purpose was to destroy the reapers from ME1.

#1434
Don_Esteban

Don_Esteban
  • Members
  • 72 messages

starlitegirlx wrote...


Not so. Garrus would have also
been gauranteed. If I had no option to do the DLC until after palaven
where I pick up Garrus and the Primarch, Garrus would have been better
than dumb James who wasn't there for ME1. He should have been there. He
would have wanted to be there given he fought to get a task force by
going to his father whom he was never on good terms with going back to
ME1. Garrus should have been in the lab and there should have been
commentary going back to ME1 for true trilogy followers rather than just
the late pickups who like a good shotting game and don't care about
story which is what ME3 seems to have catered to IMO.


Thats wrong... god damnit.... Garrus can die at the assault on collectors base. Pls do some research before posting ****..

if you did really wrong, both Tali and Garrus getting killed and you can shot Kaidan/Ashley at citadel.
James Liara and Edi are the ONLY Squadmembers that are avialable for sure any time in the game under any circumstances.

So whats the point? Doing more work to cover every possibility, thats so much effort, its not worth it...
They just go the "easy" way, choose the mates that are with you a 100%. By
doing this its logical to choose edi and James cause Liara has already
so much time with you in the game (Mars, Thessia, Lair...).

Modifié par Don_Esteban, 04 septembre 2012 - 10:24 .


#1435
ILuvMe3

ILuvMe3
  • Members
  • 25 messages
So does Leviathan hint towards indoctrination? maybe shepard wasn't being infected by Leviathan cuz he already was! lol

#1436
Doom of Haestorm

Doom of Haestorm
  • Members
  • 2 messages
Who wrote this DLC? When Leviathan ended up saying "They are created in Harbinger's image. Our image." I literally through my controller to the floor. Are we to the point were you can't ruin ME3's ending anymore so you have to mess up ME2 instead? I understand how the story changed after the second game, but has Bioware/EA really come to the point of discrediting ME2 all together? Not only that, but you continue to push the out-of-place God-Child logic through this. This is just salt on the wound. I might have forgiven all of that if I GOT A LITTLE HISTORY ABOUT THE REAPERS THAT MADE AN OUNCE OF SENSE! Leviathan took control of reaper soldiers and took down a reaper itself effortlessly, so I still have no idea how they were harvested in the first place. Besides that, I don't even know if anything else was revealed to us.

This DLC was a total waste of $10. I'm getting sick of losing money to you, Bioware. Step up. this sloppy story writing is getting REALLY out of hand. We can't even make good theories anymore, this has become so bad.

#1437
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages
Anyone think that we might get some kind of Reaper forces in MP as a result of Leviathan?

#1438
bmrvorlon

bmrvorlon
  • Members
  • 1 messages

SRP wrote...

tymtraveller wrote...

I liked the DLC, but the biggest problem is that no matter how you expand the lore, it doesn't change the mediocre-to-lousy ending (even with the extended cut). Now, if the ending could be changed as a result of later DLC...It's just a fantasy, but wouldn't it be great if you could amass enough war assets to actually win conventionally?


I've suspected for a long time that this was Bioware's plan. Considering the things Bioware did and didn't say during the ending debacle, it's not that difficult to piece together the theory that they have something big planned. My thoughts are that we are meant to have the current ending for a while and to let everything sink in. Then maybe in a year or two, as you are suggesting, after additional dlc has been released, we'll get something different.


And why should they suddenly release a different ending year(s) after the game shipped? Not going to happen mate, not even a chance. It would be a giant waste of money and a loss of integrity for Bioware & EA, if they would actually do something like that. So yeah, not going to happen ever.

People should just start to accept the endings we have, there's no point in complaining forever. I'm mean it's not like the "godchild" stepped in out of nowhere, there were a few hints throughout the game suggesting an unknown party involved. I think with the extended cut the endings gained a lot and are acceptable.

Modifié par bmrvorlon, 05 septembre 2012 - 09:40 .


#1439
ElitePinecone

ElitePinecone
  • Members
  • 12 936 messages

BiO_MaN wrote...

Henioo wrote...

I don't see it, maybe it's burried somewhere in these 57 pages, but can someone tell me if they talked to Balak after beating Leviathan?

Does the dialogue with him change when he mentions the Reaper that indocrinated the batarians?

Oh, BTW, seems like the Leviathan are responsible for the fall of the batarians, eh? :P


Not directly. The Leviathan of Dis was already dead.


The downfall of the batarian Hegemony was still caused by a Reaper, not by a Leviathan - yeah.

Some time in the distant past a Leviathan killed a Reaper, and that disabled Reaper was then found by salarian scientists, captured by the batarians, and managed to indoctrinate (even though it was 'dead', like the one Cerberus found in ME2) most of the Hegemony's government. The Leviathan of Dis was actually a Reaper, which is a bit confusing.

(Come to think of it, how did a Leviathan kill that Reaper anyway, when most of them were killed to create the *first* Reaper, Harbinger? I thought they were all in hiding after the initial cycle?)

#1440
BiO

BiO
  • Members
  • 2 057 messages

ElitePinecone wrote...

BiO_MaN wrote...

Henioo wrote...

I don't see it, maybe it's burried somewhere in these 57 pages, but can someone tell me if they talked to Balak after beating Leviathan?

Does the dialogue with him change when he mentions the Reaper that indocrinated the batarians?

Oh, BTW, seems like the Leviathan are responsible for the fall of the batarians, eh? :P


Not directly. The Leviathan of Dis was already dead.


The downfall of the batarian Hegemony was still caused by a Reaper, not by a Leviathan - yeah.

Some time in the distant past a Leviathan killed a Reaper, and that disabled Reaper was then found by salarian scientists, captured by the batarians, and managed to indoctrinate (even though it was 'dead', like the one Cerberus found in ME2) most of the Hegemony's government. The Leviathan of Dis was actually a Reaper, which is a bit confusing.

(Come to think of it, how did a Leviathan kill that Reaper anyway, when most of them were killed to create the *first* Reaper, Harbinger? I thought they were all in hiding after the initial cycle?)


Most planets in the Dis system are icy, so it's possible leviathan(s) are hiding somewhere under the surface. A Reaper got too close and they acted.

Also, am I the only one who thinks moving these Leviathan orbs to key locations is a very risky and foolish move? I don't consider the Leviathans to be any better than Reapers. In fact, they could be more dangerous, given their more advanced indoctrination capability.

#1441
Calamity

Calamity
  • Members
  • 415 messages
I didn't notice this until playing with Levi installed but after I completed the DLC there were announcements on the citadel saying something like, if you hear voices or are experience headaches please see a csec officer for assistance (not word for word but cant remember the quote). I didn't notice this in my non-levi play-through, did anyone else?

#1442
V-rcingetorix

V-rcingetorix
  • Members
  • 575 messages
Might have helped if there had been a reinforcement wheel, like in DA:O; being swarmed by cannibals? Call the Krogan. Getting rushed by Banshees? Call the Asari. Getting stung by husks/Cannibals? Call the Geth/Salarians/humans...you get the idea.

#1443
ElitePinecone

ElitePinecone
  • Members
  • 12 936 messages

BiO_MaN wrote...

Also, am I the only one who thinks moving these Leviathan orbs to key locations is a very risky and foolish move? I don't consider the Leviathans to be any better than Reapers. In fact, they could be more dangerous, given their more advanced indoctrination capability.


Lots of speculation for everyone™, I guess. 

I'm slightly bemused that ME3 was meant to definitively end the Reaper story arc, and the Extended Cut was meant to provide "clarity and closure" to the universe and its civilisations, when the very first bit of proper DLC not only introduces tons of lore that we've never previously heard of but also leaves the future of the galaxy perhaps more ambiguous and uncertain than ever before. I think it's exceedingly unlikely that we'll ever revisit the universe post-ME3, or have anything to do with the Leviathans again, and so the constant reminders that the aliens are expansionist megalomaniacs will just make me even more jaded about the direction they took the Reaper/Leviathan/cycles storyline.  

None of this is very satisfying, plot-wise. As much as I'm still disappointed with practically everything in the narrative from Priority: Earth onwards, there's something even worse and diminishing about tying the Mass Effect trilogy's plot to a billion-year old mistake on the part of a race of self-important cuttlefish we've previously never heard of with delusions of grandeur. The strength of the series was always the character stories, but Leviathan seems to want to re-explain the Reapers for the third time, with possibly even more ridiculous logic.  

(I'm quietly optimistic about Omega if it really is a thing, but will we be constantly beaten over the head about how important it is for the war effort, a war we've already won? Is there any point, now that we know the entirely-too-convoluted origins of the Reapers and their harvests?)

#1444
B.Shep

B.Shep
  • Members
  • 1 876 messages

BiO_MaN wrote...
Most planets in the Dis system are icy, so it's possible leviathan(s) are hiding somewhere under the surface. A Reaper got too close and they acted.

Also, am I the only one who thinks moving these Leviathan orbs to key locations is a very risky and foolish move? I don't consider the Leviathans to be any better than Reapers. In fact, they could be more dangerous, given their more advanced indoctrination capability.


They just need to use shield protection, similar to the one in Bryson's lab, to avoid the orbs from controlling organic forces instead of reapers' troops. Then disable the shields remotely after they are very far from the orb.
It's risky indeed,  carrying something that dangerous behing enemy lines.

#1445
BiO

BiO
  • Members
  • 2 057 messages
Survey results are out https://twitter.com/...367756756553729

#1446
B.Shep

B.Shep
  • Members
  • 1 876 messages
So pretty much the marjority of the people who played Leviathan enjoy it.
Haters deal with it. B)

Modifié par B.Shep, 05 septembre 2012 - 07:08 .


#1447
Don_Esteban

Don_Esteban
  • Members
  • 72 messages

B.Shep wrote...

So pretty much the marjority of the people who played Leviathan enjoy it.
Haters deal with it. B)


If you read through the most of the threads and news about Leviathan, yeah majority  of the people liked the DLC overall, though some are not satisfied about the end or the way it affects the ME 3 end. Well, but we all know, that those people will never stop complaining, until BW changes the whole end. And that will probably never happen.

#1448
Fixer5000

Fixer5000
  • Members
  • 25 messages
If anything the Leviathan's description of the Catalyst seemed like a subtle apology for its stupid motivation.

We created an intelligence to preserve life. It failed massively, continues to fail, and frankly it's turned the galaxy into one big experiment. Almost as if there were some actual problem it were trying to solve that wasn't 'machines killing their creators'.

If there were some sort of horrible dark energy catastrophe the reapers were trying to avert... that might make sense.


but no, we suck at making AI.

Our bad - The Leviathans.

#1449
seitani

seitani
  • Members
  • 122 messages
Leviathan DLC was great but i wish it had been part of the original game with EC.

#1450
nomoredruggs

nomoredruggs
  • Members
  • 841 messages

Fixer5000 wrote...

(...)
Our bad - The Leviathans.



:lol::lol::lol:

hehe that cracked me up!