292 réponses à ce sujet

[LiarasShield]

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Modifié par LiarasShield, 07 septembre 2012 - 07:06 .

[I am disappoint]

IT Speculation

[Village_Idiot]

This will not end well.

[LiarasShield]

I am disappoint wrote...

IT Speculation

that is why we couldnt get closure?

[Pitznik]

Hmm. My idea: human fully customizable Shepard is difficult to put in any form of pre-rendered video or even slides - different face, different LI. He would have to wear a helm all the time, or it would have to be some real time rendered cutscene, which usually doesn't give that really cinematic feel to it...

...but that is awfully weak explanation, tbh.

[Iakus]

LiarasShield wrote...

I am disappoint wrote...

IT Speculation

that is why we couldnt get closure?

If that's the case my rage will blot out the sun

[I am disappoint]

LiarasShield wrote...

I am disappoint wrote...

IT Speculation

that is why we couldnt get closure?

They thought they could milk it more for cash or something.

[wright1978]

LiarasShield wrote...

I am disappoint wrote...

IT Speculation

that is why we couldnt get closure?

Yep they were terrified of annoying IT fans so they refused to give any proper exposition for high EMS shep lives in epilogue.

[Ninja Stan]

LiarasShield wrote...

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Your last thread was closed for being confrontational and elitist, both in the thread title and in your responses to others, not because of the opinions you hold. If you can carry on this conversation without name-calling or insults against those who disagree with you, this thread can stay open.

[LiarasShield]

Ninja Stan wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Your last thread was closed for being confrontational and elitist, both in the thread title and in your responses to others, not because of the opinions you hold. If you can carry on this conversation without name-calling or insults against those who disagree with you, this thread can stay open.

I don't believe you

[Iakus]

 Seriously it would have taken one scene and a few seconds to fix this.  A scene of a convalescing Shepard.  Or just slightly altering a scene that already exists

Breath scene:  Show a rescue team finding Shepard (echoes of ME1) and calling for a medic

Memorial scene:  LI hesitates, Normandy receives word of Shepard's rescue, Normandy takes off.

A full-on reunion isn't necessary.  It would be great.  But not necessary.  Just the certainty that Shepard lives to match the certainy in every other ending that Shepard dies.

Modifié par iakus, 07 septembre 2012 - 07:17 .

[LiarasShield]

iakus wrote...

 Seriously it would have taken one scene and a few seconds to fix this.  A scne of a convalescing Shepard.  Or just slightly altering a scene that already exists

Breath secne:  Show a rescue team finding Shepard (echoes of ME1) and calling for a medic

Memorial scene:  LI hesitates, Normandy receives word of Shepard's rescue, Normandy takes off.

A full-on reunion isn't necessary.  It would be great.  But not necessary.  Just the certainty that Shepard lives to match the certainy in every other ending that Shepard dies.

That is all that was needed that wasn't worth asking too much U_U

Modifié par LiarasShield, 07 septembre 2012 - 07:15 .

[fil009]

Its up to your imagination.

[Iakus]

LiarasShield wrote...

Ninja Stan wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Your last thread was closed for being confrontational and elitist, both in the thread title and in your responses to others, not because of the opinions you hold. If you can carry on this conversation without name-calling or insults against those who disagree with you, this thread can stay open.

I don't believe you

Please don't, LiarasShield.  I'm as passionate about this topic as you are.  It's something I think the devs really need to hear about and address.  And don't want to see this thread closed and buried too.  

[Zooter]

I'm commander shepard and this is my favorite place for speculations on the BSN.

[LiarasShield]

fil009 wrote...

Its up to your imagination.

It shouldn't have to be I shoudn't have to imagine shepard being alive when all they would've had to do was normandy get a message of him or her being alive or showing his or her face or a team digging shepard out not a full on reunion but something a bit more


Why couldn't they have done that in extended?

[AxStapleton]

LiarasShield wrote...

Ninja Stan wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Your last thread was closed for being confrontational and elitist, both in the thread title and in your responses to others, not because of the opinions you hold. If you can carry on this conversation without name-calling or insults against those who disagree with you, this thread can stay open.

I don't believe you

Just stop. You really are getting confrontational about this. Your opinion is fair. Your demeanour really isn't.

[LiarasShield]

iakus wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

Ninja Stan wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

This is what bothers me the most and I'm not gonna stop talking about it ninja stan you can lock or ban me if you want but it is not something I'm going to just let go of

Your last thread was closed for being confrontational and elitist, both in the thread title and in your responses to others, not because of the opinions you hold. If you can carry on this conversation without name-calling or insults against those who disagree with you, this thread can stay open.

I don't believe you

Please don't, LiarasShield.  I'm as passionate about this topic as you are.  It's something I think the devs really need to hear about and address.  And don't want to see this thread closed and buried too.  

Yeah but the false interviews and the false prerelease  comments before mass effect 3 even came out it makes it extremely hard to trust any of the moderators espically if they are from bioware

[fil009]

I agree it would have been easy for them to add a sign Shepard is alive but they simply don't want to... spekulationz and all. I'm happy we at least got the Memorial Wall scene.

[LiarasShield]

But yeah closure for our 5 year protagonist shouldn't have been really too much to ask for but I guess making some of us suffer is appealing I guess well if they make a new one I hope it doesn't repeat the same thing again

[Iakus]

LiarasShield wrote...

Yeah but the false interviews and the false prerelease  comments before mass effect 3 even came out it makes it extremely hard to trust any of the moderators espically if they are from bioware

Then don't give any excuse.  Just keep asking the questions:

 Why was a live Shepard not given closure?

 Why are there only speculations when every other ending confirms a death?

 Why can't a few seconds and minor changes be added to provide closure?

Be intelligent.  Be respectful.  Be the better arguer.  If Bioware really cares about the fans, they need to hear this.  And if we're ignored, at least we did all we could.  And at least we know how much we're really valued.

[Iakus]

fil009 wrote...

I agree it would have been easy for them to add a sign Shepard is alive but they simply don't want to... spekulationz and all. I'm happy we at least got the Memorial Wall scene.

It's not enough.  A suddenly Force-sensitive LI doesn't provide closure to Shepard's situation. 

[wright1978]

iakus wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

Yeah but the false interviews and the false prerelease  comments before mass effect 3 even came out it makes it extremely hard to trust any of the moderators espically if they are from bioware

Then don't give any excuse.  Just keep asking the questions:

 Why was a live Shepard not given closure?

 Why are there only speculations when every other ending confirms a death?

 Why can't a few seconds and minor changes be added to provide closure?

Be intelligent.  Be respectful.  Be the better arguer.  If Bioware really cares about the fans, they need to hear this.  And if we're ignored, at least we did all we could.  And at least we know how much we're really valued.

100% agree Iakus.

[LiarasShield]

iakus wrote...

LiarasShield wrote...

Yeah but the false interviews and the false prerelease  comments before mass effect 3 even came out it makes it extremely hard to trust any of the moderators espically if they are from bioware

Then don't give any excuse.  Just keep asking the questions:

 Why was a live Shepard not given closure?

 Why are there only speculations when every other ending confirms a death?

 Why can't a few seconds and minor changes be added to provide closure?

Be intelligent.  Be respectful.  Be the better arguer.  If Bioware really cares about the fans, they need to hear this.  And if we're ignored, at least we did all we could.  And at least we know how much we're really valued.

Yeah I'm letting my anger drive me you're definitly more reasonable then me I'm sorry

Modifié par LiarasShield, 07 septembre 2012 - 07:27 .

[Legendary Chop Chop]

Stargazer was more than enough for me to imply a solid closure to the legacy of Shepard. I don't want everything spelled out for me.