249 réponses à ce sujet

[M2S SOLID JOSH]

Robhuzz wrote...

Top Gaming Moment (Tuchanka), Hell yes. One of the only truly memorable things about this game and one of the most awesome gaming moments in the past years imo.

GOTY, definitely not. If ME3 somehow wins GOTY then it's the final bit of proof that these things are fixed.

Best RPG: Erm... there isn't much rpg left in Mass Effect so that'd be a huge insult to the entire genre. That's a definite No.

^ this

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

I voted Skyrim. 300 hrs worth. I have TW2 but I'm having trouble getting into the game.

[Neizd]

Mass Effect3 is not RPG anymore so how can it be best RPG?! It's more like a shooter with RPG elements. Voted and gave best moment to ME 3 other two went for the witcher 2

[Sable Rhapsody]

Voted for Tuchanka. One of my favorite gaming moments ever.

The other two went to Skyrim. Not because I think it's the greatest thing since sliced bread, but because I haven't gotten suckered into a world like that since Baldur's Gate.

[SpamBot2000]

Might agree with the 'moment' thing, I did find Tuchanka excellent... but a vision of Mac Walters parading his golden joystiq for it troubles my sight.

[FlamingBoy]

mass effect 3 is so undeserving

[Sable Rhapsody]

SpamBot2000 wrote...

Might agree with the 'moment' thing, I did find Tuchanka excellent... but a vision of Mac Walters parading his golden joystiq for it troubles my sight.

...cannot unsee   That mental image is somehow so much worse than any fanfiction I've read to date.

[tobiasks]

Voted for The Witcher 2.

[clarkusdarkus]

GOTY > Skyrim

RPG > Dragons dogma

Moment > Griffon battle

ME3 was not an enjoyable game way before the ending masked what was a mediocre game at best

[EnvyTB075]

Now why would i want to do that?

[paul165]

tobiasks wrote...

Voted for The Witcher 2.

[Ridwan]

The only modern game released this year that I enjoyed was Legend of Grimrock and Skyrim. ME3 was good until I got peed in the mouth at the end.

[Zerohero17]

Made Nightwing wrote...

Top gaming moment? Absolutely. The other two? Absolutely not. It was a good game, but there were many that were better.

I did not vote for it on any of them,it is a hollow shell of what could have been a GOTY thanks to EA's meddeling but other than that nope, there is so much sour taste in my mouth I will never forget it, havent bought a single DLC, except for javick(fool me once), but I respect everyones opinion.

[N7 Shadow 90]

I voted for ME3 in all three sections.

[BalooTheBear]

Voted for top gaming moment as Tuchanka was amazing. Sadly don't think it's worth GOTY though.

[Someone With Mass]

Wow, the nominees in all categories sucks, because they only have the generic mainstream crap.

I'm not voting at all.

[legion999]

Spec Ops: The Line wins Best Moment for me.
Best RPG is Witcher 2.
GOTY was Arkham City I think.
Also this isn't right, I've done this before, is it on the second round of voting?

[Aaleel]

I had to go with Skyrim as best RPG, and Arkham City as Ultimate Game of the Year.

Couldn't go with ME3, I thought the game was mediocre even before the ending. From the moment they said we've had scientists here for decades but just now happened to find these plans for a superweapon lying around the story was terrible to me.

[Xellith]

You can now vote for Mass Effect 3 to win the "Ultimate Game of the Year"

I CAN.  But I wont.

[CELL55]

N7 Lisbeth wrote...

Reth Shepherd wrote...
The frell they couldn't! Want to fix things? Don't retcon it, add more endings! Add a couple of new ending branches! The Marauder Shields comic is proof that a competent writer can take the very same game universe, information given, and characters, and create a completely different ending concept. Adding a different branch to follow would free them up even more. And you cannot tell me that people wouldn't have eaten up a successful Refuse ending, even if the EMS to get it was insanely high.

No, Bioware CHOSE to stick with what they had.

^ This man (turian?) has the right of it, and that's why I won't let it go.

You're all welcome to do what you want. Nothing anyone says will change that. But I find it cathartic to say what I intend to do, and I have every intention of letting Bioware see that where they can read it. I still feel that strongly about it, and the EC was awful. They said they'd change the endings and they changed nothing. They just bury themselves deeper and deeper with EC and, later, Leviathan.

They think strongarming you into Synthesis is the answer to Destroy being the only half-successful ending. Not half-successful because Shepard lives - that's not a factor in it at all - half-successful because the reapers don't win. And I hate having to commit genocide to accomplish it. I blame them for that. And that's my right.

So, no; no awards for ME3 as far as I'm concerned. It deserves nothing with those endings. Trying to award it for other parts that were in-fact great is like admitting that the ending doesn't matter, and I'm not bending on that.

Lastly, I apologise for what may be perceived as volatility. I guess the wounds are still a little fresh and it's hard not to let a little of that colour my opinions.

I like this human, she understands!

[szkasypcze]

Know this Bioware.

I will vote for Mass Effect 3 in all three cathegories, provided that you apply Indoctrination Theory. There is little time left, so I suggest you hurry up.

[Baa Baa]

Voted mostly for Witcher 2 and Arkham City. I did think ME3 deserves best moment though. Tuchanka was a great part of the game.

[4stringwizard]

Sorry, no way I'm voting this as a better RPG than "Skyrim."