106 réponses à ce sujet

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

I agree with Elton John is dead in the most parts.
Skyrim is only better in having bigger world, better character creator and graphic. In other aspects DA:O is superior.

[Bfler]

Most of the problems people mention here in case of Skyrim are already solved with mods, f.e. intelligent follower with a developing friendship and dynamic dialoque. It is your problem if you buy the game on console or don't use the mods. They are since many years the core of the Elder Scrolls series.

DA:O and Skyrim are both amazing and fine games, and as long as the final product entertains me, I don't care about the design of DA3.

Modifié par Bfler, 20 septembre 2012 - 04:05 .

[Persephone]

LobselVith8 wrote...

ianvillan wrote...

But skyrim doesn't have voice or a dialogue wheel so it will need innovating before it can come up to Biowares standards

Don't forget the Awesome Button.

Which never existed, so this "joke" is bloody pathetic. And I'll take the bloody Button Of Awesome over thousands of glitches, bland VO acting, pathetic choices and ludicrous "companions" and "romance". DAII is not a button masher, it wasn't even when Auto-Attack was not patched.

Modifié par Persephone, 20 septembre 2012 - 04:05 .

[BubbleDncr]

If I wanted Dragon Age 3 to be like Skyrim, I wouldn't be at these forums. I would just be playing Skyrim instead.

[AnniLau]

I liked DA2, even with the issues. I made it to the first town in Skyrim and stopped.

So, no.

[jkflipflopDAO]

Skyrim is a game that requires you to have a little creativity and imagination to get the most out of it. It appears ****s lack that gene.

[Flatrid]

No, Keelah No!

[Gabey5]

I dislike skyrim. Running around a vast empty landscape gets boring for me pretty quickly. The dragons that could be defeated so easily lost all menace when you encounter them every 5 seconds. The main plot line was also pretty tired. I prefer a smaller map with a much tighter main story and side quests that are interesting. Skyrim side quests where " i forgot my frog in the cave on the other side of the map, fight 20 skeletons and i will reward you with a wheel of cheese". That to me is not even remotely interesting, i prefer caring about the quest giver at least a bit. Give him or her a bit of a story and some good acting.

So yeah i want this to be nothing like skyrim

[Realmzmaster]

Bfler wrote...

Most of the problems people mention here in case of Skyrim are already solved with mods, f.e. intelligent follower with a developing friendship and dynamic dialoque. It is your problem if you buy the game on console or don't use the mods. They are since many years the core of the Elder Scrolls series.

DA:O and Skyrim are both amazing and fine games, and as long as the final product entertains me, I don't care about the design of DA3.

The point is I should not have to use mods to solve the problems or errors of the game. That is the designer's responsibility.  I see using mods to enhance or add to what the designer did but not to fix the problems the designer left.

Modifié par Realmzmaster, 20 septembre 2012 - 04:51 .

[The Hierophant]

Gabey5 wrote...

 Skyrim side quests where " i forgot my frog in the cave on the other side of the map, fight 20 skeletons and i will reward you with a wheel of cheese". That to me is not even remotely interesting, i prefer caring about the quest giver at least a bit. Give him or her a bit of a story and some good acting.

So yeah i want this to be nothing like skyrim

Over exaggerating much? It's funny how people don't mention quests like Blood on Ice, The forsworn Conspiracy, Thief Guild quests, or that quests can be completed without  killing anyone.

[Fast Jimmy]

One area I would advise taking caution in copying from Skyrim is crafting/smithing/enchanting system.

On one hand, I enjoyed the system and would like to see a deeper system like this in the DA games, I would caution against making it so overpowered. Being able to smith the most powerful weapons and armor by level 15 and then being able to enchant that gear as being more powerful than any but the most unique plot items is kind of weak.

I'd like to see a crafting mechanism that let's you craft equipment based on materials, but the materials have both bonuses and detriments. For instance, chain mail gives a bonus to piercing weapons, but slows attack speed, or leather armor increases sneak and critical hit stats, but has a penalty to heavy weapons.

And I liked the way DA does enchanting, with runes being placed on equipment, but I think it would be better if instead of runs stones, you would bring your enchanter runs drawings hey would learn, and then could be applied to equipment as many times (with a cost of both money and ingredients). But each piece of equipment could only be enchanted a certain number of times, and runes could never be erased.

Just some ideas.

[Volus Warlord]

Huh?

No.

Bethesda RPGs: Huge, open world environments. Memorable environments, factions, scenery.

BioWare RPGs: Deep, memorable, and relatable characters, vivid and complex storytelling. Well, spare *cough*


Point is, stop going against the grain here. Do what you do best, what your fans expect you to do.


Not what other studios are doing.  Trying to make DA3 Skyrim 0.5 would be 

1.) Sacrificing your game's identity

2.) Making more subpar.

Well, I guess it wouldn't hurt to have more memorable factions. The only faction in BioWare games that ever had real significance or identity was Cerberus. 

Modifié par Volus Warlord, 20 septembre 2012 - 06:12 .

[Rawgrim]

The Hierophant wrote...

Gabey5 wrote...

 Skyrim side quests where " i forgot my frog in the cave on the other side of the map, fight 20 skeletons and i will reward you with a wheel of cheese". That to me is not even remotely interesting, i prefer caring about the quest giver at least a bit. Give him or her a bit of a story and some good acting.

So yeah i want this to be nothing like skyrim

Over exaggerating much? It's funny how people don't mention quests like Blood on Ice, The forsworn Conspiracy, Thief Guild quests, or that quests can be completed without  killing anyone.

Exactly.  People also forget that alot of the side quests in DA2 were pretty much the same stuff too. "Ohh look. I found a scarf. This has to belong to Matilda`s, a person I have never seen before, husband. I am pretty sure she hangs out near the chantry. I should bring it to her  for a reward. Not much story involved in those quests, and very little acting.

[DreGregoire]

You know Skyrim was nice but for some reason it did not hold my attention like Dragon Age: O & II did so although some aspects of Skyrim might be nice, I don't want it to be exactly like Skyrim.

[Rawgrim]

I like both Dragon Age and Skyrim, but for different reasons. I wouldn`t want one of them to turn into the other. Variety is good.

[naughty99]

Giltspur wrote...

Here's something to learn from Skyrim: making a world more immersive by adding small details to the environment.  That doesn't mean making the game open-world or taking party members out of the game.   Dragon Age should still primarilly be Dragon Age, but there are cool things about Skyrim's environments, exploration and region-specific architecture that could positively impact DA3's design.

Great point!

I'd love to see more storytelling through the environments. I think DA:O was a bit stronger than DA2 in this area.

[SCJ90]

No no no a thounds times no. As many have said, Skyrim has a beatifull world but other then that it has no charm or character deapth, there is only one person that i have liked in skrim, so no and take some notes from ME3 while you are at it

[Costin_Razvan]

Two words:

**** NO.

Make DA3 like TW3, thank you very much.

[AdmiralDavidAnderson]

Skyrim is good and all... But even Dragon Age 2 has a better story than it.

[Chromie]

AdmiralDavidAnderson wrote...

Skyrim is good and all... But even Dragon Age 2 has a better story than it.

No...not it doesn't.