ejustinp wrote...
Ironically the majority of people who complained about Genesis already had ME1 on Xbox or PC and they generally did so about stuff like Feros or no Conrad Verner or whatever - essentially a series of choices that would have had little to no contextual significance to new players (who the comic was made for): stuff like saving Shiala or if you helped Parisini and so on.
All you would have done by swamping them with a hundred or so (most of which trivial) choices all at once, is make what was already a lengthy infodump unbearable as you droned on and on to ask them questions about whether or not they helped the Consort with the Elcor diplomat.
If you feel its not a good solution for you I would counter that it wasn't designed for returning players, since effectively there were none on the PS3, but rather for people who were jumping into the deep end of the pool.
Heck, the PS3 user quoted above confirms as much.
I have to agree. Having Genesis is much better than having nothing, because at least then you had some control over some of the biggest questions, as well as context regarding the most important things that happened in the first game without delivering the mother of all infodumbs and a huge broadsheet of yes/no boxes. It was all but essential to the new PS3 players. Sure now that the first ME is on PS3 it becomes clear how very limited Genesis is and how much it leaves out, but for new players who are newcomers to the series, most of the info it leaves out is obsolete.
Of course a save file transfer is better, but interactive comic is better than nothing.
But... why are we even talking about this? Haven't the developers said multiple times that they're bringing save file transfer back if it is possible? I've heard they're having some problems figuring out a way to do it, but the game is over a year from certification, so I guess they have plenty of time figuring out how to implement that -- and if they can't, I am sure we'd get a heads-up early on since save file transfer has been a big part of the most recent BW franchises (ME and DA), so speculating about it at this stage is somewhat pointless.
Modifié par MissOuJ, 30 juin 2013 - 03:44 .