Aller au contenu

Photo

Should there be nudity, or no? (The thread that just won't die)


1841 réponses à ce sujet

#426
Redbelle

Redbelle
  • Members
  • 5 399 messages
Nudity comes in many shapes and forms....... ok, maybe full frontal get's the most hit's. But partial nudity, tastful nudity, gratuitous nudity etc, etc.

Simply put, let the nature of the character's dictate if they are or are not nude to varying degree's of skin exposure. Don't allow fan based bais to dictate how a relationship is resolved in a game that tradtionally allows the player to dictate the relationship, with who, how far and what manner the relationship takes.

It would not make sense for an Isabella character to pounce on her LI wearing an eskimo coat and matching gloves. Likewise,a Wynne character would not be seen gyrating around in a string bikini before putting on an exhibition match in front of the whole camp.

Both character's have their temperment's and those should be what inform the direction of the relationship. Not clothe's on or clothes off or somewhere inbetween........... as a rule. Let the character's set their own rule on the issue.

#427
edeheusch

edeheusch
  • Members
  • 356 messages

Doctor Moustache wrote...

This is basically the point I would make. Nudity is not nessisary overall, but if they make a scene where logically the character would be nude, don't slap underwear on them and make it awkward. Nobody showers in their underwear. They could of made her nude and still not actually shown "the goods" with proper use of camera angles and cuts. The Liara scene did exactly that and it was flawless. *shrug*

If they don't want to make nude models even just to not show anything, like the Liara scene, then just don't make the scene to begin with. Otherwise it just comes off as odd and perhaps lazy. You don't make a scene sexy by taking half their clothes off and putting them in a situation that suggest all of their clothes should be put of but hey pg-13 yall. Its actually very distracting. (actually pg-13 allows partial nudity so idk what to call that) If you want a "safe" scene, make a safe scene. In this example, maybe just have Traynor talking from behind a closed shower door, where you can hear the water running. You get the information that she's taking a shower without actually seeing it. Easy, safe. Don't make a sexy scene that plays it too safe and costs believability.


I agree completely with that.

The DAs are not erotic games and I don’t want to have my characters nude if I remove their armour. To my point of view, without armour they could either wear underwear (being completely nude under an armour should be rather uncomfortable), or wear they default clothes, it is not because your companions follow you that they should agree to walk in a city in underwear (or nude) if you ask them to do it, if you don’t ask them to wear an armour they wear what they prefer.

By opposition having a sex scene in underwear is just weird!
If there are sex scenes, the protagonist should be nude but it doesn’t mean that their sexes should be shown (personally I would not consider that the game show too much if we see a breast or a butt but I would not specially expect it either). If the scenes are well done you can even suggest that the characters are nude without showing anything you don’t want by simply showing that the characters throw their underwear away for example.

#428
Lobos1988

Lobos1988
  • Members
  • 308 messages

Redbelle wrote...

Nudity comes in many shapes and forms....... ok, maybe full frontal get's the most hit's. But partial nudity, tastful nudity, gratuitous nudity etc, etc.

Simply put, let the nature of the character's dictate if they are or are not nude to varying degree's of skin exposure. Don't allow fan based bais to dictate how a relationship is resolved in a game that tradtionally allows the player to dictate the relationship, with who, how far and what manner the relationship takes.

It would not make sense for an Isabella character to pounce on her LI wearing an eskimo coat and matching gloves. Likewise,a Wynne character would not be seen gyrating around in a string bikini before putting on an exhibition match in front of the whole camp.

Both character's have their temperment's and those should be what inform the direction of the relationship. Not clothe's on or clothes off or somewhere inbetween........... as a rule. Let the character's set their own rule on the issue.


so you are trying to tell us that wynne showers in underwear?...

#429
SeismicGravy

SeismicGravy
  • Members
  • 646 messages
Side boob causes far less mental damage than redecorating a hallway with somebody's brains.

#430
Lobos1988

Lobos1988
  • Members
  • 308 messages
depends on whose sideboob it is ^^

#431
SeismicGravy

SeismicGravy
  • Members
  • 646 messages
Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?

Modifié par SeismicGravy, 07 mai 2013 - 03:27 .


#432
Redbelle

Redbelle
  • Members
  • 5 399 messages

Lobos1988 wrote...

Redbelle wrote...

Nudity comes in many shapes and forms....... ok, maybe full frontal get's the most hit's. But partial nudity, tastful nudity, gratuitous nudity etc, etc.

Simply put, let the nature of the character's dictate if they are or are not nude to varying degree's of skin exposure. Don't allow fan based bais to dictate how a relationship is resolved in a game that tradtionally allows the player to dictate the relationship, with who, how far and what manner the relationship takes.

It would not make sense for an Isabella character to pounce on her LI wearing an eskimo coat and matching gloves. Likewise,a Wynne character would not be seen gyrating around in a string bikini before putting on an exhibition match in front of the whole camp.

Both character's have their temperment's and those should be what inform the direction of the relationship. Not clothe's on or clothes off or somewhere inbetween........... as a rule. Let the character's set their own rule on the issue.


so you are trying to tell us that wynne showers in underwear?...


Your assuming she showers, at all.

#433
9TailsFox

9TailsFox
  • Members
  • 3 715 messages

Redbelle wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

Redbelle wrote...

Nudity comes in many shapes and forms....... ok, maybe full frontal get's the most hit's. But partial nudity, tastful nudity, gratuitous nudity etc, etc.

Simply put, let the nature of the character's dictate if they are or are not nude to varying degree's of skin exposure. Don't allow fan based bais to dictate how a relationship is resolved in a game that tradtionally allows the player to dictate the relationship, with who, how far and what manner the relationship takes.

It would not make sense for an Isabella character to pounce on her LI wearing an eskimo coat and matching gloves. Likewise,a Wynne character would not be seen gyrating around in a string bikini before putting on an exhibition match in front of the whole camp.

Both character's have their temperment's and those should be what inform the direction of the relationship. Not clothe's on or clothes off or somewhere inbetween........... as a rule. Let the character's set their own rule on the issue.


so you are trying to tell us that wynne showers in underwear?...


Your assuming she showers, at all.


Wynne is old lady mage and yes I am pretty sure she does you speak abouth Oghren

#434
Lobos1988

Lobos1988
  • Members
  • 308 messages

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:

#435
Lenimph

Lenimph
  • Members
  • 4 561 messages

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P

#436
Fast Jimmy

Fast Jimmy
  • Members
  • 17 939 messages

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P



Yet all forms of sideboob are inferior to the ever-illusive underboob. 

Modifié par Fast Jimmy, 07 mai 2013 - 04:47 .


#437
Redbelle

Redbelle
  • Members
  • 5 399 messages

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P


Depend's if your as ripped as schwarzenegger.

Or this guy.

Posted Image

#438
BouncyFrag

BouncyFrag
  • Members
  • 5 048 messages

Redbelle wrote...

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P


Depend's if your as ripped as schwarzenegger.

Or this guy.

Posted Image

It seems we've garnered some unwanted attention.
Posted Image

#439
Lobos1988

Lobos1988
  • Members
  • 308 messages
*thinking about posting some nice topless women pics*... better not ^^

#440
Trolldrool

Trolldrool
  • Members
  • 223 messages
Neverwinter Nights 2: Kiss and fade to black.
Mass Effect Liara romance: Dark shadows and clever camera angles conceal any explicit naughty bits.
Dragon Age - Origins: A game of Twister gone horribly wrong.
Dragon Age 2: Make out and fade to black.

Honestly, as long as it's not like in Origins, I think I'll be fine with whatever they choose.

#441
SeismicGravy

SeismicGravy
  • Members
  • 646 messages

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P


Ah, but men don't have sideboobs.

They have sidemoobs :P

#442
Fallstar

Fallstar
  • Members
  • 1 519 messages
Tasteful nudity to one person is explicit and vulgar to another. It's hard to get right. Personally I would prefer nudity to the underwear on stuff that tends to just look awkward.

#443
Sir George Parr

Sir George Parr
  • Members
  • 1 052 messages

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P

A woman's side boob is infinitely more aesthetic and hints at a world of wonderous possibilities.Where as a side moob hints that eye bleach may figure in your immediate future.

#444
Redbelle

Redbelle
  • Members
  • 5 399 messages
Catherine Zeta Jone's once came down on a scene in the Mask of Zorro as being a scene that technically, contained a topless scene. But was well developed in narrative and context that she didn't mind. Plus it was not gratuitous.

Linking the whole thing so people can make up their own minds. Note. You don't actually see anything.

Zorro Stable fight

#445
Lluthren

Lluthren
  • Members
  • 258 messages

XM-417 wrote...

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P

A woman's side boob is infinitely more aesthetic and hints at a world of wonderous possibilities.Where as a side moob hints that eye bleach may figure in your immediate future.


That's only old/fat man and and nasty hairy moobs. Also, the brood mother...

#446
MissOuJ

MissOuJ
  • Members
  • 1 247 messages

XM-417 wrote...

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P

A woman's side boob is infinitely more aesthetic and hints at a world of wonderous possibilities.


Like "buffet"? I've heard kids love it!

#447
EpicBoot2daFace

EpicBoot2daFace
  • Members
  • 3 600 messages

Redbelle wrote...

Lenimph wrote...

Lobos1988 wrote...

SeismicGravy wrote...

Are you suggesting that some sideboobs are better than others?


well... yes... :blush:


A woman's side boob is better then a man's typically for example.  :P


Depend's if your as ripped as schwarzenegger.

Or this guy.

Posted Image

There will never be a better Liu Kang. Ever.

#448
garrusfan1

garrusfan1
  • Members
  • 8 049 messages

TsaiMeLemoni wrote...

No, simply because it's not necessary and wouldn't add anything but controversy with all the conservative groups.

the controversy is not an issue cause look at the witcher 2 that was extremely dark brutal and adult and there was less controversy then ME1. basically times change

#449
Tenshi

Tenshi
  • Members
  • 361 messages
if it you were able to turn it off than i cant see why not..? it would be win-win situlation for both kids and us :)

#450
MKfighter89

MKfighter89
  • Members
  • 201 messages
do it like the witcher 2, it all depends on the players choice of going the route needed to romance.

Modifié par JillBSuiT, 08 mai 2013 - 06:33 .