51 réponses à ce sujet

[holdenagincourt]

The most important thing is that it's coherent within the narrative and doesn't feel imposed exogenously to inject import or urgency into the game.

If it satisfies those criteria then a fork in the road decision that you can't avoid and which has far-ranging repercussions is all well and good. I think a better example than Virmire is the Landsmeet. That choice between characters and outcomes was much more significant, emotional, necessary to the story, organic, you name it than Virmire was.

[Sylvius the Mad]

Only if we had the option to try to save both - even if that was doomed to failure and meant we would lose both. The strict either-or choice on Virmire felt contrived largely because it lacked that third option.