389 réponses à ce sujet

[wright1978]

Not a huge fan of the character. However i do think he makes sense as a potential companion for DA3.

[Maclimes]

wright1978 wrote...

Not a huge fan of the character. However i do think he makes sense as a potential companion for DA3.

As long as they improve his eyesight.

I don't want to order Cullen to kill the evil blood mage, only for him to look at the robed, staff-wielding, glow-eyed maniac who was just casting spells, and have him reply, "I don't see any mages!"

[TobiTobsen]

I demand Cullen because I need to exact vengeance on him for imprisoning Bethany for two-thirds of DAII!

[Battlebloodmage]

TobiTobsen wrote...

I demand Cullen because I need to exact vengeance on him for imprisoning Bethany for two-thirds of DAII!

How is that his fault?

[Sylvanpyxie]

How is that his fault?

It isn't.

Though, technically speaking, Cullen should have ended up dead as a direct result of his involvement, in my game at least - Athena Hawke would have died to protect Bethany from that, she certainly would've taken Cullen with her.

Tobi, I like how you're embracing the name of the game. I also like that your avatar contains Biggles.

Modifié par Sylvanpyxie, 20 septembre 2012 - 04:51 .

[Gabey5]

"You served Merideth well when serving was safe.".
- Eddard Stark

Yeah he was and is a collaborator and should hang.

[LolaLei]

The guy was just doing his job.

Cullen says himself in Act 3 that he promised himself he would never question the Order again after his torture in DA:O, plus to be fair he does kinda give you a heads up in Act 1 about him hearing worrying things about Hawke's sister. To me it was obvious that we'd need to take her with us to the Deep Roads or risk loosing her to the Circle.

[Morgax_Warrior]

I don't get the obsession of him either, i mean he had like few lines in DA:O and at the end of DA2.
Hell i remembered sir-pounce-a-lot more than him and that was literally an item not even a character.

[R2s Muse]

Gabey5 wrote...


"You served Merideth well when serving was safe.".
- Eddard Stark

Yeah he was and is a collaborator and should hang.

But by the same token, he also was one of the few who stood up to Meredith when it definitely wasn't safe. I think a tribunal would have to really weigh all the evidence. Even evil Xena got a chance to redeem herself...

[R2s Muse]

Sylvanpyxie wrote...

How is that his fault?

It isn't.

Though, technically speaking, Cullen should have ended up dead as a direct result of his involvement, in my game at least - Athena Hawke would have died to protect Bethany from that, she certainly would've taken Cullen with her.

Tobi, I like how you're embracing the name of the game. I also like that your avatar contains Biggles.

Yeah, I love that scene when he takes Bethany. My Hawke was definitely ready to throw down as well... It was very brave of him to come himself.

[R2s Muse]

Maclimes wrote...

wright1978 wrote...

Not a huge fan of the character. However i do think he makes sense as a potential companion for DA3.

As long as they improve his eyesight.

I don't want to order Cullen to kill the evil blood mage, only for him to look at the robed, staff-wielding, glow-eyed maniac who was just casting spells, and have him reply, "I don't see any mages!"

I would hope for this as well. I think the writers have called it "oblivious"?  LOL Poor dear, definitely needs some glasses if they include him in the next game.

[TobiTobsen]

Sylvanpyxie wrote...

How is that his fault?

It isn't.

Though, technically speaking, Cullen should have ended up dead as a direct result of his involvement, in my game at least - Athena Hawke would have died to protect Bethany from that, she certainly would've taken Cullen with her.

Tobi, I like how you're embracing the name of the game. I also like that your avatar contains Biggles.

Bah... I had that Avatar before the name of the game was announced! They stole the name from me! ...or... uhh... you know.... maybe Monty Python. 

And of course it's not his fault! But somebody has to pay for the sacrilege of removing Bethany from two-thirds of the game. Cullen is just the scapegoat!

Modifié par TobiTobsen, 20 septembre 2012 - 06:01 .

[LolaLei]

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

[Jinx]

R2s Muse wrote...

Sylvanpyxie wrote...

How is that his fault?

It isn't.

Though, technically speaking, Cullen should have ended up dead as a direct result of his involvement, in my game at least - Athena Hawke would have died to protect Bethany from that, she certainly would've taken Cullen with her.

Tobi, I like how you're embracing the name of the game. I also like that your avatar contains Biggles.

Yeah, I love that scene when he takes Bethany. My Hawke was definitely ready to throw down as well... It was very brave of him to come himself.

While I was ready to throw down as well I respect that he came himself.....

[Sylvanpyxie]

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

*Whistles innocently*...... *Twitches*.....Alright FINE! I admit it! I DID IT ALRIGHT?!

I needed a Hawke that lost everything, so I made one! She was soooo angry. Just in general, like a constant state of seething hatred, hidden just below the surface and ready to explode at anyone that bothered her...

I loved her, and I lost the save files. It was terrible.

I also wholly doubt it was Cullen's intention to walk into Hawke's house and take his sister away - An order, probably, so that Meredith knew it had been handled correctly. He probably looked back on it in later years and thought "Maker, I was so lucky I wore my plot armour that day..."

[R2s Muse]

Sylvanpyxie wrote...

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

*Whistles innocently*...... *Twitches*.....Alright FINE! I admit it! I DID IT ALRIGHT?!

I needed a Hawke that lost everything, so I made one! She was soooo angry. Just in general, like a constant state of seething hatred, hidden just below the surface and ready to explode at anyone that bothered her...

I loved her, and I lost the save files. It was terrible.

I also wholly doubt it was Cullen's intention to walk into Hawke's house and take his sister away - An order, probably, so that Meredith knew it had been handled correctly. He probably looked back on it in later years and thought "Maker, I was so lucky I wore my plot armour that day..."

Bwahahaha!! Outstanding!  Gives me new ideas for banners... :lol:

[DreGregoire]

R2s Muse wrote...

I also wholly doubt it was Cullen's intention to walk into Hawke's house and take his sister away - An order, probably, so that Meredith knew it had been handled correctly. He probably looked back on it in later years and thought "Maker, I was so lucky I wore my plot armour that day..."

LOL! Plot Armour!

---------------------
And to the OP I totally imagined a couple of my Hawke's romancing Cullen in DAII

Modifié par DreGregoire, 20 septembre 2012 - 06:23 .

[Reaverwind]

LolaLei wrote...

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

And how is that evil? Your character doesn't know that the expedition leader is going to go bonkers, resulting in a single member of the party becoming tainted, making it necessary to drag along psycho-mage on the off chance he'll lead you to some wardens who conveniently show up to recruit said tainted party member.

Modifié par Reaverwind, 20 septembre 2012 - 06:29 .

[LolaLei]

Reaverwind wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

And how is that evil? Your character doesn't know that the expedition leader is going to go bonkers, resulting in a single member of the party becoming tainted, making it necessary to drag along psycho-mage on the off chance he'll lead you to some wardens who conveniently show up to recruit said tainted party member.

Urgh, I was just playing around, people play the game however they want to. Pull the stick out of your arse dear.

[Jinx]

Reaverwind wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Still, better than getting her killed off in the Deep Roads! That's just evil.

And how is that evil? Your character doesn't know that the expedition leader is going to go bonkers, resulting in a single member of the party becoming tainted, making it necessary to drag along psycho-mage on the off chance he'll lead you to some wardens who conveniently show up to recruit said tainted party member.

I agree with LolaLie.... unless Anders is with you I think the Circle is better.... 

[Sylvanpyxie]

And how is that evil?

Both options are equally misguided on Hawke's part.

However, I believe LolaLei was joking in her statement.

[DarkKnightHolmes]

If only I could kill him in DA1.

[LolaLei]

Sylvanpyxie wrote...

And how is that evil?

Both options are equally misguided on Hawke's part.

However, I believe LolaLei was joking in her statement.

Yeah, I was lol.

[SamaraDraven]

In my opinion, Bethany seemed happier with winding up in the Circle than she did becoming a Warden. Granted she wasn't "happy" happy but she seemed to embrace the mages' plight and fight for freedom with more zeal than she did going to the Wardens. The play through I lost her and Carver in were ones where I didn't bring Anders along.

The first time was because I didn't know and I was trying to appease Anders by not making him to the DRs and appease Carver because he wanted to go. I was really bummed to lose baby bro. When I lost Bethany to the taint, it was for the same reason as Sylvanpyxie. I made a warrior!Hawke who'd lost too much and began cracking with Bethany's death and lost it when Leandra died. She went all "Magic is EEEVIILLLL!!!!" more than Cullen had. He actually made me feel kind of bad for some of the sh!t that Hawke of mine said. Even Varric disliked that Hawke and yet it was the most dramatic PT I've ever done. I learned about Meredith's sister and what drives her to be so harsh on the mages - before the crazy-making idol, that is...

Modifié par SamaraDraven, 20 septembre 2012 - 07:08 .

[Fallstar]

Not fussed about the guy to be honest. He seems like the sort to end up as a Knight Commander one day. I found him irritating in DAO, but didn't mind him so much in DA2. That's probably symptomatic of my general apathy for most everyone in DA2 however.

Modifié par DuskWarden, 20 septembre 2012 - 07:14 .