10 réponses à ce sujet

[Major Crackhead]

I've played Human Noble, Magi and City Elf.

Didn't really "like" City Elf because it makes out your Warden to be a pan** when Bann Vaughan bit** slaps you and knocks you out stone cold. But I felt it was a good origin for the character I played.

Human Noble is the best imo, simply for the WHAM factor when your family gets killed.

Modifié par EvilCecil4th, 25 septembre 2012 - 08:54 .

[lambent templar]

i like human noble as tend to play as a rogue and there are plenty of chests and locked doors for exp. city elf isn't too bad as you get retribution but im also fond of the dwarf noble/commoner origin as am fond of the grumpy little ****s.,

[mousestalker]

1. Female city elf, male is a bit lower.
2. Dwarf commoner
3. Dalish elf, if you have the Witch Hunt DLC, otherwise it's last
4. Dwarf noble
5. Elf mage
6. Human noble
7. Human mage

[chrcol]

for me dalish elf is very dissapointing just played it and I do have witch hunt DLC. (but I am judging just on start of game dont know if something good later).
drawf commoner seems the best out of them so far, the only one I havent played now is drawf noble and dalish elf I just played up to lothering.

[Major Crackhead]

Yeah I played a female City Elf and she was badass. I still cringed at that b**** slap though

[lambent templar]

*spoiler*
I was disappointed with dalish elf, felt like it was over a bit too quickly. Would have been nice if there was a follow up quest to retrieve the mirror shards and rescue tamlen

Modifié par lambent templar, 24 septembre 2012 - 09:06 .

[Portia Cousland]

My favorite is a tie between noble and city elf (female), female mage, noble dwarf, casteless dwarf (female), with Dalish elf being my least favorite. The only part about the Dalish story that I like is when

***spoiler***


you run into Tamlen again. That took me by surprise. 

Modifié par Portia Cousland, 25 septembre 2012 - 05:49 .

[sylvanaerie]

Favorites from top to bottom:

Human Noble (male or female, this is the only origin I was able to play either gender). Wins points for the Cousland family, and I love Bryce's scene in the Guantlet.  Can be king/queen of Ferelden at the end.

City elf *female* for the sheer badassery of the character. I get a real sense of community playing through, though the squalor of the Alienage loses points for the origin, the family (mostly Shianni and Soris, the PC's Dad is kinda boring) makes up for it. Wins points for getting up in Duncan's grill prior to the wedding scene and after, when Duncan takes you away, thumbing your nose at the city guards who want to take you away for lopping off Vaughan's head.

Mage *female* (I prefer elf over human but either is fine). I like the mage class best in game and my most 'canon' warden is the Surana in my Avatar. I also like the personalization i feel in the Circle during the treaty quest.

Dalish *female* wins points for the scene with Tamlen later in the game, and if you trigger the additional 'romance' in the origin, he has some heartbreaking dialogue later when encountered. Loses points when the rest of the group you're with just say the usual dialogues after the battle, but gains some when Alistair tries to comfort the Dalish Warden after.  This was my most reluctant warden, despite she needed the Joining to save her life mostly because the idea of going among the shemlen terrified her.

Dwarf Noble *female*, points for being able to take sticking it to Bhelen personal. Loses points for the extremely dysfunctional behavior of Endrin (what, he just sends off his 'favored' child to the deep roads without even a trial?) Bah, he can go to hell. My Aeducan wanted to be a GW and told Duncan this at her party. The events just cemented that desire. Gorim is my favorite "origin story romance".

Dwarf Commoner bored me to tears. I was able to get one to Ostagar for the achievement of completing the origin then deleted her.

Modifié par sylvanaerie, 26 septembre 2012 - 02:42 .

[Shinobu]

Female city elf. Hometown girl makes good. I have played all of the other (female) Origins up to Ostagar but don't love them as much as I love my Tabris and couldn't continue the game with them.