56 réponses à ce sujet

[Todd23]

Can we have the option to import an Anders that was killed in DA2, and have him be alive in DA3? Pleeeeaase?

[TheJediSaint]

Mary Kirby wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

*snip*

If you killed Anders in DA2, he is dead.
If you didn't, he's alive.

Schrodinger's Anders, anyone?

[MagmaSaiyan]

Todd23 wrote...

Can we have the option to import an Anders that was killed in DA2, and have him be alive in DA3? Pleeeeaase?

what would be the point in that? so you could kill him again? if you wanted him alive you shouldnt have killed him, no?

[Maclimes]

Todd23 wrote...

Can we have the option to import an Anders that was killed in DA2, and have him be alive in DA3? Pleeeeaase?

Why? If you want him to live, just ... you know ... don't kill him. It's pretty straight-forward.

[Battlebloodmage]

If Alistair were to make an important appearance in the third game, but he was killed in DAO, they could make it like Ashley/Kaidan in which either Loghain or Alistair will fill the role of that key figure character in the storyline.

Leliana's fate will be ret-con in the third game, so we only need to know about how Anders is still alive if he were killed in the previous game. I hope they at least mention it if he weren't killed in DA2.

Modifié par Battlebloodmage, 26 septembre 2012 - 11:25 .

[Takara_XD]

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Mary Kirby wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

 While Mr. Gaider is in the mood to confirm not-ambiguous character deaths that could theoretically result in ressurection/reappearance, is it intended for the Anders death choice in DA2 to stick?

Its quite clear that we kill him in DA2, but with the explanation for how he came back before(Justice possessing corpse), its possible for him to come back again, assuming that Justice was not forced back to the Fade when Anders was knifed. So could we get a confirmation of whether or not this possibility is being left open?

If you killed Anders in DA2, he is dead.
If you didn't, he's alive.

What about Justice/Vengeance? What happens to him if Anders is killed? He was one of my favorite characters, and I don't think he got nearly enough screen time in DAII to do the whole Anders-Justice merger concept justice.

Pun not originally intended, but now I'm keeping it.

We don’t know what’s going to happen to Justice. Mr. Gaider keeps hinting that Justice is going to show up again, but not the when and how. Which leave me both excited and anxious. For all I know us Justice fans will have to wait for DA4 to see Justice again.

[Emzamination]

Takara_XD wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Mary Kirby wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

 While Mr. Gaider is in the mood to confirm not-ambiguous character deaths that could theoretically result in ressurection/reappearance, is it intended for the Anders death choice in DA2 to stick?

Its quite clear that we kill him in DA2, but with the explanation for how he came back before(Justice possessing corpse), its possible for him to come back again, assuming that Justice was not forced back to the Fade when Anders was knifed. So could we get a confirmation of whether or not this possibility is being left open?

If you killed Anders in DA2, he is dead.
If you didn't, he's alive.

What about Justice/Vengeance? What happens to him if Anders is killed? He was one of my favorite characters, and I don't think he got nearly enough screen time in DAII to do the whole Anders-Justice merger concept justice.

Pun not originally intended, but now I'm keeping it.

We don’t know what’s going to happen to Justice. Mr. Gaider keeps hinting that Justice is going to show up again, but not the when and how. Which leave me both excited and anxious. For all I know us Justice fans will have to wait for DA4 to see Justice again.

Both are gone if you killed Anders in Da2.I remember david saying exactly what mary did some months back about anders/justice death sticking, in a thread dedicated to justice resurrection, in the Da2 forums.

Modifié par Emzamination, 26 septembre 2012 - 11:47 .

[hoodaticus]

I almost don't want Anders to come back - at least not as a male LI - because I can't help but choose him, and I'd rather have a really compelling female companion instead.

New is sometimes better.

Edit: re: Justice's return:

If he comes back, I hope it's as the demon Anders transformed him into.  Maybe he can return to feast on Anders's soul as he reveals Anders's own true dark side in all its depth.

Soul feasting is cool.

Modifié par hoodaticus, 27 septembre 2012 - 01:34 .

[Sylvianus]

Mary Kirby wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

 While Mr. Gaider is in the mood to confirm not-ambiguous character deaths that could theoretically result in ressurection/reappearance, is it intended for the Anders death choice in DA2 to stick?

Its quite clear that we kill him in DA2, but with the explanation for how he came back before(Justice possessing corpse), its possible for him to come back again, assuming that Justice was not forced back to the Fade when Anders was knifed. So could we get a confirmation of whether or not this possibility is being left open?

If you killed Anders in DA2, he is dead.
If you didn't, he's alive.

That makes me happy !

[TJPags]

Will Leliana be killable again? And will she stay dead this time?

[legbamel]

Battlebloodmage wrote...
If Alistair were to make an important appearance in the third game, but he was killed in DAO, they could make it like Ashley/Kaidan in which either Loghain or Alistair will fill the role of that key figure character in the storyline.

Leliana's fate will be ret-con in the third game, so we only need to know about how Anders is still alive if he were killed in the previous game. I hope they at least mention it if he weren't killed in DA2.

But they could both be dead, as in my first playthrough of DA:O when I didn't know that bastard would dump me and then throw himself in front of a dragon like the idiot he was!  <_<  That really kicked me in the feels, it did.

[Takara_XD]

Emzamination wrote...

Takara_XD wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Mary Kirby wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

 While Mr. Gaider is in the mood to confirm not-ambiguous character deaths that could theoretically result in ressurection/reappearance, is it intended for the Anders death choice in DA2 to stick?

Its quite clear that we kill him in DA2, but with the explanation for how he came back before(Justice possessing corpse), its possible for him to come back again, assuming that Justice was not forced back to the Fade when Anders was knifed. So could we get a confirmation of whether or not this possibility is being left open?

If you killed Anders in DA2, he is dead.
If you didn't, he's alive.

What about Justice/Vengeance? What happens to him if Anders is killed? He was one of my favorite characters, and I don't think he got nearly enough screen time in DAII to do the whole Anders-Justice merger concept justice.

Pun not originally intended, but now I'm keeping it.

We don’t know what’s going to happen to Justice. Mr. Gaider keeps hinting that Justice is going to show up again, but not the when and how. Which leave me both excited and anxious. For all I know us Justice fans will have to wait for DA4 to see Justice again.

Both are gone if you killed Anders in Da2.I remember david saying exactly what mary did some months back about anders/justice death sticking, in a thread dedicated to justice resurrection, in the Da2 forums.

Can you send me a link to that thread?

[Fox In The Box]

Takara_XD wrote...

Can you send me a link to that thread?

I provided a relevant quote on page one, but here you go!

[Takara_XD]

Fox In The Box wrote...

Takara_XD wrote...

Can you send me a link to that thread?

I provided a relevant quote on page one, but here you go!

Thank you

[Vandicus]

Fox In The Box wrote...

Takara_XD wrote...

Can you send me a link to that thread?

I provided a relevant quote on page one, but here you go!

Am I missing something or does that not address both Anders and Justice? I'd like to edit the front page to cover it if it does.

[Applepie_Svk]

Hope he will stay dead, because if not than I will need to do my duty again...

Modifié par Applepie_Svk, 27 septembre 2012 - 05:21 .

[Fox In The Box]

Vandicus wrote...

Am I missing something or does that not address both Anders and Justice? I'd like to edit the front page to cover it if it does.

I don't think it does. However, in the templar-siding rivalry ending, Anders says something about hoping that it would be Justice, not Vengeance, who rises from his corpse. I'm guessing that means Justice would live and just go back to the Fade. Whether or not Justice could come back is another matter - I think that he could, but seeing as killing Anders is optional, it probably wouldn't be anything significant.

Modifié par Fox In The Box, 27 septembre 2012 - 05:28 .

[Nashimura]

Battlebloodmage wrote...

If Alistair were to make an important appearance in the third game, but he was killed in DAO, they could make it like Ashley/Kaidan in which either Loghain or Alistair will fill the role of that key figure character in the storyline.

That, is a great idea - just the chance of Loghain coming back in a main role would fill me with joy though. 

[Vandicus]

Fox In The Box wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

Am I missing something or does that not address both Anders and Justice? I'd like to edit the front page to cover it if it does.

I don't think it does. However, in the templar-siding rivalry ending, Anders says something about hoping that it would be Justice, not Vengeance, who rises from his corpse. I'm guessing that means Justice would live and just go back to the Fade. Whether or not Justice could come back is another matter - I think that he could, but seeing as killing Anders is optional, it wouldn't be anything significant. Possibly just a cameo.

Can't believe I was phrasing that as Justice "dying" all this time. Always meant a return to the Fade. Unfortunately dialogue implications or epilogue text slides aren't sufficient to make it official on the thread's OP. Trying to keep it limited to what we're absolutely sure about.

[Fox In The Box]

Vandicus wrote...


Can't believe I was phrasing that as Justice "dying" all this time. Always meant a return to the Fade. Unfortunately dialogue implications or epilogue text slides aren't sufficient to make it official on the thread's OP. Trying to keep it limited to what we're absolutely sure about.

Wynne is dead, at least. Kicked the bucket in the books.

[narayani d.d]

So much hypocrisy in some of the comments. In DAA he was "mentally ready" to go on living even if not very long, but happily. Why was it on that will not leave? But no, there he was resurrected, the whole game was tortured and eventually led to his death. (Slaughter)
Poor Anders((

Modifié par narayani d.d, 27 septembre 2012 - 05:42 .

[Vandicus]

Fox In The Box wrote...

Vandicus wrote...


Can't believe I was phrasing that as Justice "dying" all this time. Always meant a return to the Fade. Unfortunately dialogue implications or epilogue text slides aren't sufficient to make it official on the thread's OP. Trying to keep it limited to what we're absolutely sure about.

Wynne is dead, at least. Kicked the bucket in the books.

Are they considered canon? That pretty much unambiguously settles another possible violation of the Cardinal Rules of Magic. Once somebody figures out how to teleport, magic will have no bounds.

[Alessa]

Vandicus wrote...

Fox In The Box wrote...

Vandicus wrote...

Am I missing something or does that not address both Anders and Justice? I'd like to edit the front page to cover it if it does.

I don't think it does. However, in the templar-siding rivalry ending, Anders says something about hoping that it would be Justice, not Vengeance, who rises from his corpse. I'm guessing that means Justice would live and just go back to the Fade. Whether or not Justice could come back is another matter - I think that he could, but seeing as killing Anders is optional, it wouldn't be anything significant. Possibly just a cameo.

Can't believe I was phrasing that as Justice "dying" all this time.
Always meant a return to the Fade. Unfortunately dialogue implications
or epilogue text slides aren't sufficient to make it official on the
thread's OP. Trying to keep it limited to what we're absolutely sure
about.

Here's what David Gaider said about Justice in case of Anders being killed:

http://social.biowar...9241/1#12605490

David Gaider wrote...

brushyourteeth wrote...
Out of curiosity, when Anders dies what happens to Justice/Vengeance? (if it's not too spoilery to say)

If you believe Anders, then Justice would have been freed. If not, then Justice was destroyed along with him.

Either way, Justice won't be possessing Anders' corpse. A dead Anders is gone.

Also,
if we had taken Anders with us into the fade in DAII and put the murder
knife through Justice/Vengeance, what would have happened to the two
(or one?) of them? I've always been curious about that and as his LI
wished I'd had the chance to chew that d**n spirit out for ruining my
boyfriend's life.

I'll leave that to speculation,
though I doubt that would be a good solution. It certainly would not
have simply killed Justice and freed Anders, at any rate.

Modifié par Alessa-00, 27 septembre 2012 - 06:27 .

[Vandicus]

Ty for the info Alessa.