31 réponses à ce sujet

[Eveangaline]

thats1evildude wrote...

Wynne was Pro-Whatever Side Results in the Most Good Being Done. Seriously. Wynne's position is to support whatever saves the most innocent lives. If she was "pro-Chantry," it was because she didn't want to see people die in a conflict between templars and mages. She attacks you for defiling the Ashes because a) you're helping a murderous dragon cult that will only wreak havoc in Ferelden and because the Ashes could help a lot of people.

She was pro-chantry. I remember in the conversations you could have
she talked about advice given to her by a revered mother, and how as she
grew up she realized how true that priests words were, and how she kept
finding herself in the chapel, and how she realized how alike she was
to the priest.

That combined with the ashes thing I think really shows she likes the chantry

[Dirgegun]

Eveangaline wrote...

thats1evildude wrote...

Wynne was Pro-Whatever Side Results in the Most Good Being Done. Seriously. Wynne's position is to support whatever saves the most innocent lives. If she was "pro-Chantry," it was because she didn't want to see people die in a conflict between templars and mages. She attacks you for defiling the Ashes because a) you're helping a murderous dragon cult that will only wreak havoc in Ferelden and because the Ashes could help a lot of people.

She was pro-chantry. I remember in the conversations you could have
she talked about advice given to her by a revered mother, and how as she
grew up she realized how true that priests words were, and how she kept
finding herself in the chapel, and how she realized how alike she was
to the priest.

That combined with the ashes thing I think really shows she likes the chantry

I just want to point out that seeking advice from someone and finding a kindred spirit in them doesn't mean you have to believe in their organisation. Wynne also said that the priest was handed over to the Chantry much like she was 'handed' over to the Templars/Magi Circle/what have you.

Saying that, I think it's clear that Wynne believes in the Maker, however that doesn't mean she's pro-chantry. People can believe without being pro-church or whatever. I think her opinion on the ashes had more to do with her FAITH than the actual chantry. 

Anders totally wasn't pro-chantry, but he still believed in the Maker. 

Modifié par Dirgegun, 07 octobre 2012 - 07:02 .

[InfinitePaths]

TCBC_Freak wrote...

HeriocGreyWarden wrote...

ScarMK wrote...

I'd rather have origins type companions: Down to earth (mostly) with their quirks rather than Da2's extremist on every angle. (Varric seems to be an exception here.)

Then i guess you would like TCBC Freak's suggestion,which i persoanally also like.I guess his companion would be something like Wynne but with less understanding of mages and more supporting the templars.But yeah,my companion would be an extremist,and that's why I like my idea,he would just be so unique and unexpected,he would definitly stand out .

If both of our ideas got taken and used, that could lead to some party conflict I think, espically because it'd be different. They are both against a mage rebellion but for different reasons and with different goals, even though they'd be on the same side they would butt heads a lot I bet. I'd pay to see that.

Agreed

[InfinitePaths]

Quicksilver26 wrote...


looks good but should be the other way around

-Rivaly path:He learns that not all mages are bad and starts to be a normal person,he is HARDEND,he gets more healing power

-Friendship  path-You increased his hate for the world,he has so much fury that he is a living nightmare for every mage.

because it's a rivalry if you're changing core things about him and friendship if your agreeing with him about mages:D

Nope,you can't force someone to change his opinion,see Fenris will only side with the mages at the end of the game if you are in Friendship with him,becouse with love and support he realises that mages here are also slaves just like he was one,If you rival him you only make him more mad and angry and you have to kill him,same thing for Anders,Merril and Aveline(she doesn't die)

[Bad King]

Dirgegun wrote...

Eveangaline wrote...

thats1evildude wrote...

Wynne was Pro-Whatever Side Results in the Most Good Being Done. Seriously. Wynne's position is to support whatever saves the most innocent lives. If she was "pro-Chantry," it was because she didn't want to see people die in a conflict between templars and mages. She attacks you for defiling the Ashes because a) you're helping a murderous dragon cult that will only wreak havoc in Ferelden and because the Ashes could help a lot of people.

She was pro-chantry. I remember in the conversations you could have
she talked about advice given to her by a revered mother, and how as she
grew up she realized how true that priests words were, and how she kept
finding herself in the chapel, and how she realized how alike she was
to the priest.

That combined with the ashes thing I think really shows she likes the chantry

I just want to point out that seeking advice from someone and finding a kindred spirit in them doesn't mean you have to believe in their organisation. Wynne also said that the priest was handed over to the Chantry much like she was 'handed' over to the Templars/Magi Circle/what have you.

Saying that, I think it's clear that Wynne believes in the Maker, however that doesn't mean she's pro-chantry. People can believe without being pro-church or whatever. I think her opinion on the ashes had more to do with her FAITH than the actual chantry. 

Anders totally wasn't pro-chantry, but he still believed in the Maker. 

Wynne is not particularly faithful- there's a dialogue between her and Leliana where Leliana expresses doubt that Wynne believes in the Maker. Wynne replies that she does to an extent but isn't obsessed. Her opinion on the ashes then was less to do with her faith than to do with her empathy for those who would suffer due to its destruction.

Other than that, I agree with what you state. Wynne was never a loyalist but she supported continued good relations between the Circle and the Chantry/Templars.

Edit: Hmm... it appears that I just resurrected an ancient thread. So be it.

Modifié par Bad King, 13 janvier 2014 - 01:36 .

[OctagonalSquare]

Vivienne is pro-Circle.