Aller au contenu

Photo

Smudboy: Extended Cut Analysis


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
475 réponses à ce sujet

#101
squee365

squee365
  • Members
  • 1 536 messages

MegaSovereign wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

I remember when I saw his videos about ME2 a while back. What a joke.


Yup, he said that ME had too many squadmates and apparently that had a negative effect on the plot.

I told him on the comment section that it's just a videogame and that he's making a big deal out of something so silly. Needless to say my comment got deleted and he blocked me.


This is exactly what I was talking about. 

#102
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Op, you know everyone is going to hate on this thread for doing this? Why bother?


Everyone? I think you mean a few people.
I could count them on 1 hand.

What? This topic is flooded with hate and anyone and I do mean anyone, who has been on this borad for long knows the hate smudboy has on this forum....He was banned from bsn for a reason.

#103
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Maxster_ wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Maxster_ wrote...

Mr. MannlyMan wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

You can make anything seem bad if you nit pick enough. Entertainment and media requires that you to some degree suspend your disbelief. 


And it requires the creator to, by some degree, suspend your disbelief for you.

The EC evacuation scene was freaking retarded. An appropriate analogy
would be a military commander on the beaches of Normandy calling for a
helicoopter to evac his squad (in the middle of a hot zone). It's so
unbelievable that it breaks my suspension of disbelief.

We already have to accept the notion of a sci-fi setting with bipedal aliens, faster-than-light travel, and blue babes that can murder you telepathically. It's the creator's job to make sure that all those elements remain as consistent and believable within that context as possible throughout a story (or trilogy), so that the audience can continue to accept it. Bioware dun goofed way too many times for them to have succeeded at this, so any loss of suspension of disbelief in the final act rests squarely on their shoulders.

Any serious battle from modern wars is perfect example of utter retardness of that evacuation.
Shepard endangers more than a 100 crew, and advanced frigate(which have role and position in fleet), to evacuate TWO expendable soldiers(and ignore other) in most important battle. Then Joker deserts his frigate pack, to compel order from ashore officer, completely ignoring chain of command. That is complete nonsense. Shepard is retarded in this scene, Joker is deserter. Teleporting Normandy is a big plothole.

When did the normady teleport?

When arrived in few seconds(3-5) after that order.

How do you not know it was not over head near by before? 

#104
Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*

Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*
  • Guests

iakus wrote...

On a note that's actuially on topic, Tali's blood was a good point. Open wound+suit rupture likely means dead quarian.


Is it even blood?
I thought it was oil or something as there is no way in hell they would be alive if they were bleeding that bad.

#105
Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*

Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*
  • Guests

dreman9999 wrote...

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Op, you know everyone is going to hate on this thread for doing this? Why bother?


Everyone? I think you mean a few people.
I could count them on 1 hand.

What? This topic is flooded with hate and anyone and I do mean anyone, who has been on this borad for long knows the hate smudboy has on this forum....He was banned from bsn for a reason.


I was on this forum for a long time.
I know people hate him but not everyone, well at least back when the topic of Mass effect 3 was still talked about alot .

#106
Gamer790

Gamer790
  • Members
  • 273 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

Gamer790 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Op, you know everyone is going to hate on this thread for doing this? Why bother?


I don't hate this thread.  In fact I'm fairly stimulated.  Others may proceed to make jokes about how dull and unfullfilling my existance must be at the discrestion now.


Right because you're the majority.<_<

Sorry but in case yyou not been here long...The name "smud boy" comes with a crowd of pitch forks, torches and angry mobs here.


Funny I don't seem to recall ever stating the opnion of anyone other than myself in that comment.  As for your suggestion about the length of my history (based soley on the 3 underneath my avatar I'm guessing) with this franchise, I've been playing Mass Effect since September 2009 when the Mass Effect 2 hype got me interested in this series.  Also, I've known about Smudboy since he first posted his Mass Effect 2 plot analysis here over two years ago.  If I have somehow offended you I am sorry.  I was simply attempting to be facetious.

Modifié par Gamer790, 13 octobre 2012 - 09:49 .


#107
Maxster_

Maxster_
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

iakus wrote...

On a note that's actuially on topic, Tali's blood was a good point. Open wound+suit rupture likely means dead quarian.

Well, i wasn't even looking over squad, i was laughing from that scene. I couldn't take that seriously .

Also, with EDI evacuation, everything is whole another level of idiocy. Shepard endangers EDI, to evacuate unneeded hardware. :pinched:

#108
SNascimento

SNascimento
  • Members
  • 6 002 messages

MegaSovereign wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

I remember when I saw his videos about ME2 a while back. What a joke.


Yup, he said that ME2 had too many squadmates and apparently that had a negative effect on the plot.

I told him on the comment section that it's just a videogame and that he's making a big deal out of something so silly. Needless to say my comment got deleted and he blocked me.

.
Really? That is sad. 

#109
Cainne Chapel

Cainne Chapel
  • Members
  • 2 301 messages
Not a big fan of smudboy, but as with anything he has his fans and critics I guess *shrug*

#110
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

iakus wrote...

On a note that's actuially on topic, Tali's blood was a good point. Open wound+suit rupture likely means dead quarian.

1. Quarian blood is not red.
2.Open suit is not instant death for them.
3. A quarin can sevive being expose...How do you think Tali can have sex with Shepard?

#111
squee365

squee365
  • Members
  • 1 536 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

iakus wrote...

On a note that's actuially on topic, Tali's blood was a good point. Open wound+suit rupture likely means dead quarian.


Is it even blood?
I thought it was oil or something as there is no way in hell they would be alive if they were bleeding that bad.


I thought the same thing. 
Thats one of the problems I have with the guy, he doesn't believe there could be anything BUT HIS own interpretation.
You see thousands of threads on here disputing different nuances of the story/game/whatever, yet smudboy thinks his opinion is the only one worth mentioning. 

#112
Maxster_

Maxster_
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

Maxster_ wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Maxster_ wrote...

Mr. MannlyMan wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

You can make anything seem bad if you nit pick enough. Entertainment and media requires that you to some degree suspend your disbelief. 


And it requires the creator to, by some degree, suspend your disbelief for you.

The EC evacuation scene was freaking retarded. An appropriate analogy
would be a military commander on the beaches of Normandy calling for a
helicoopter to evac his squad (in the middle of a hot zone). It's so
unbelievable that it breaks my suspension of disbelief.

We already have to accept the notion of a sci-fi setting with bipedal aliens, faster-than-light travel, and blue babes that can murder you telepathically. It's the creator's job to make sure that all those elements remain as consistent and believable within that context as possible throughout a story (or trilogy), so that the audience can continue to accept it. Bioware dun goofed way too many times for them to have succeeded at this, so any loss of suspension of disbelief in the final act rests squarely on their shoulders.

Any serious battle from modern wars is perfect example of utter retardness of that evacuation.
Shepard endangers more than a 100 crew, and advanced frigate(which have role and position in fleet), to evacuate TWO expendable soldiers(and ignore other) in most important battle. Then Joker deserts his frigate pack, to compel order from ashore officer, completely ignoring chain of command. That is complete nonsense. Shepard is retarded in this scene, Joker is deserter. Teleporting Normandy is a big plothole.

When did the normady teleport?

When arrived in few seconds(3-5) after that order.

How do you not know it was not over head near by before? 

Cutscenes, dialogues. Common sense, also.

#113
clarkusdarkus

clarkusdarkus
  • Members
  • 2 460 messages
i love any reason to reopen the crap that is ME3, i agree with smudboy even though i do remember this from awhile back.The normandy scene was just one of many ridiculous moments in ME3..... i'll take what smudboy says or any fan with logic over what professional sites say anyday of the week.

#114
Applepie_Svk

Applepie_Svk
  • Members
  • 5 469 messages

dreman9999 wrote...
Ya, because everyone one of them can spoil the ending for us and not get falling into consiquence because of it.:whistle:

Please, ME3 is not a bad game...It may not have the ending you want but just because it does not doesnot make it a bad game..In fact it's a great game.....And Yes we had reviews say the ending is not top notch...



Overall it´s ME3 just a average game with many flaws, at best 78 score but far away from 85+...but journalism works differently these days:whistle:

Image IPB

#115
squee365

squee365
  • Members
  • 1 536 messages

SNascimento wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

I remember when I saw his videos about ME2 a while back. What a joke.


Yup, he said that ME2 had too many squadmates and apparently that had a negative effect on the plot.

I told him on the comment section that it's just a videogame and that he's making a big deal out of something so silly. Needless to say my comment got deleted and he blocked me.

.
Really? That is sad. 


On one of his videos, I said I enjoy Mass Effect 2 for what it is and he equated me to being an eater of fecal matter and then blocked me. 

Modifié par squee365, 13 octobre 2012 - 09:50 .


#116
Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*

Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*
  • Guests

MegaSovereign wrote...

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

Why are you calling people who are defending themselves "haters?"


You're not defending them, you're hating on him.
Posting negative comments about his well-being is a bit beyond defending something.


I never insulted him. So no you are wrong.

It's in response to the haters of this guy, that you attempted to defend.
My post was made in a direct reply to all haters of him, the context of your post and my reply implies this.

You're wrong.

Modifié par A Bethesda Fan, 13 octobre 2012 - 09:51 .


#117
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Gamer790 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Gamer790 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Op, you know everyone is going to hate on this thread for doing this? Why bother?


I don't hate this thread.  In fact I'm fairly stimulated.  Others may proceed to make jokes about how dull and unfullfilling my existance must be at the discrestion now.


Right because you're the majority.<_<

Sorry but in case yyou not been here long...The name "smud boy" comes with a crowd of pitch forks, torches and angry mobs here.


Funny I don't seem to recall ever stating the opnion of anyone other than myself in that comment.  As for your suggestion about the length of my history (based soley on the 3 underneath my avatar I'm guessing) with this franchise, I've been playing Mass Effect since September 2009 when the Mass Effect 2 hype got me interested in this series.  Also, I've known about Smudboy since he first posted his Mass Effect 2 plot analysis here over two years ago.  If I have somehow offended you I am sorry.  I was simply attempting to be facetious.


Sorry, I did not mean to be condisending...I just saying alot of peolpe just don't like smdboy...The op should know posting anything form him is not going to be well reseaved here.

#118
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

Why are you calling people who are defending themselves "haters?"


You're not defending them, you're hating on him.
Posting negative comments about his well-being is a bit beyond defending something.


I never insulted him. So no you are wrong.

It's in response to the haters of this guy, that you attempted to defend.
My post was made in a direct reply to all haters of him, the context of your post and my reply implies this.

You're wrong.

If you putting his stuff on a borad that generally hates him...What do you expect?

#119
Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*

Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*
  • Guests

SNascimento wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

I remember when I saw his videos about ME2 a while back. What a joke.


Yup, he said that ME2 had too many squadmates and apparently that had a negative effect on the plot.

I told him on the comment section that it's just a videogame and that he's making a big deal out of something so silly. Needless to say my comment got deleted and he blocked me.

.
Really? That is sad. 


MegaSovereign is highly untrustworthy.
Believe nothing he says.

#120
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Applepie_Svk wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
Ya, because everyone one of them can spoil the ending for us and not get falling into consiquence because of it.:whistle:

Please, ME3 is not a bad game...It may not have the ending you want but just because it does not doesnot make it a bad game..In fact it's a great game.....And Yes we had reviews say the ending is not top notch...



Overall it´s ME3 just a average game with many flaws, at best 78 score but far away from 85+...but journalism works differently these days:whistle:




Right because what IGN does means everyone does it.<_<

BS. You can grade everyone by what one person or group does.

#121
Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*

Guest_A Bethesda Fan_*
  • Guests

dreman9999 wrote...
If you putting his stuff on a borad that generally hates him...What do you expect?


It's only a vocal minority that hate him.

#122
MegaSovereign

MegaSovereign
  • Members
  • 10 794 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

Why are you calling people who are defending themselves "haters?"


You're not defending them, you're hating on him.
Posting negative comments about his well-being is a bit beyond defending something.


I never insulted him. So no you are wrong.

It's in response to the haters of this guy, that you attempted to defend.
My post was made in a direct reply to all haters of him, the context of your post and my reply implies this.

You're wrong.


Point to where I said I was defending people who threw personal attacks at smudboy.

I was defending those who were criticizing his videos. Criticizing a youtube video is nothing personal.

#123
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

SNascimento wrote...

I remember when I saw his videos about ME2 a while back. What a joke.


Yup, he said that ME2 had too many squadmates and apparently that had a negative effect on the plot.

I told him on the comment section that it's just a videogame and that he's making a big deal out of something so silly. Needless to say my comment got deleted and he blocked me.

.
Really? That is sad. 


MegaSovereign is highly untrustworthy.
Believe nothing he says.

It 's like a popaganda campaign with you, isn't it?

#124
squee365

squee365
  • Members
  • 1 536 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
If you putting his stuff on a borad that generally hates him...What do you expect?


It's only a vocal minority that hate him.


Thats what they all say :happy:

#125
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

A Bethesda Fan wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
If you putting his stuff on a borad that generally hates him...What do you expect?


It's only a vocal minority that hate him.

Everyone that posted in this topic stated that they dissagree with him or find that he is way too nickpick...That says alot.