54 réponses à ce sujet

[AlanC9]

Those bodies are supposed to have come up from Earth, though. That room doesn't prove much of anything about what happens to the rest of the Citadel.

[Ithurael]

They were turned into lemons

and then died

[Leonia]

Last I heard was death by Twitter via Walters but some have dismissed that claim.

[VirtualSoldier27]

hmmm,I beleive the citiadel went from a interspecies space startion haven,to a reaper harvesting center

remember EDI's descripton of the harvesting camps on earth

not good

I just feel sorry for Kelly Chambers,she is still suffering from severe PTSD and Flashbacks,I saved her from Cerberus,but she died anyway

[jackkel dragon]

From my understanding, there was a flip-flop on their fates. At one point, someone said they died when the Crucible activated, but then after the EC this person turned around and said that they survived. Might just be a rumor or wishful thinking, but that's what I'm told.

[garrusfan1]

I remember someone saying the shields on the arms saved them when the citadel moved. And someone who made the game said some lived I think at PAX or whatever the one that happened shortly after ME3 came out

[GreyLycanTrope]

If memory serves, first we heard they were dead, then someone else said they weren't. Final word was that some people died but everyone plot relevant or significant enough survived. Now I'm not sure how plot significance is determined so whether Kelly made it or not is ambiguous and left up to you to decide. So speculate, cause that's the most definitive answer you're likely to get.

Modifié par Greylycantrope, 16 octobre 2012 - 04:08 .

[Grubas]

They said explicitly the characters we got to know, have survived, while some (nameless) citicens died.

/edit: lol second.

Modifié par Grubas, 16 octobre 2012 - 04:02 .

[DoomNation]

There's rumors that there will be another SP DLC to explain this

[Ticonderoga117]

The Reapers played "Will they blend?"

The answer was yes.

[GreyLycanTrope]

DoomNation wrote...

There's rumors that there will be another SP DLC to explain this

"We'll need DLC to explain this" is becoming the new "This proves IT"

This proves IT btw

[NM_Che56]

Patrick Weekes indicated that most people on the Citadel survived via ... whatever you call that mechanism that kept Joker from getting spaced while trying to save the Normandy at the begining of ME2. This was based on what he said on a panel at PAX East in April

[Kel Riever]

You a crazy troll, OP!  Yah?

If not, yes, there are some serious wonderings about certain people like Aria and Bailey.  But, you know, it is down the list of things wrong with the ending, certainly not in the top, say, 5.

Modifié par Kel Riever, 16 octobre 2012 - 04:18 .

[MB957]

I think the reapers stopped off at a burger joint on the way to earth...most people got off the citadel then..while the reaps werent looking...

after some burgers, fries and a few milk shakes...the reapers all piled back into the citadel and got back on the road...

it wasnt till they got around mars did someone say...hey..where are the kids? did you leave them behind?...

then a big argument broke out about who left who behind and when and where...

then harbi said...dont make me stop this citadel...and come back there...

then it got real quiet...all the way to earth...

except for the catalyst...who kept asking...are we there yet?...

[hiraeth]

I'm personally still really concerned about Commander Bailey...poor guy.

[LucasShark]

Nope, no they did not, well not in game anyway.

Some desperate tweeting said "nobody died" and that they are still alive... somehow surviving even Shepard hitting the summon firey apocalypse tube.

[NM_Che56]

Check this out



44:31 - 46:00

Emergency Shields and Kenetic Barriers.

[Gervaise]

One of the slides shows something that looks like a ravaged presidium - certainly no sign of any life, with the damaged arms of the Citadel visible above it. But then again, perhaps most people evacuated when the Citadel started being moved. Shepard and Anderson only thought the dead bodies had come from earth. They could just as easily been corpses that the Keepers thoughtfully removed from the streets like they always do. It is one of those things that I wish they had addressed in the EC properly - given the number of people we interacted with on the Citadel and recommended various courses of action, not to mention the ones we actually knew by name, it would have been nice to have been told one way or another.

[hukbum]

MassEffectFShep wrote...

I'm personally still really concerned about Commander Bailey...poor guy.

Oh, he'll be fine ... blended next to his son and daughter ... there will be some trouble with his blended ex-wife, but I think he'll handle this ...

What a beautiful family-reunion ...

Modifié par hukbum, 16 octobre 2012 - 04:49 .

[BHRamsay]

Aria is the Chuck Norris of the Mass Effect Galaxy :-)

[Brhino]

the initial tweet said that some people got out, but for the rest "bad times". Whether Bad Times means "processed into reaper meat" or "the power to the freezers went out so they had to eat all the ice cream before it melted" is up for speculation. In any case in the Original Ending it sure looked like the citadel completely exploded... so that's bad.

In the Extended Cut it becomes clear that the citadel did dot completely explode, at least not all of it. It certainly was heavily damaged. The death toll was likely large, but there would have been survivors. It's possible when the reapers invaded (we assume they invaded, anyhow - we never see any live or dead husks or anything) they focused on the areas they needed to be rather than immediately sweeping the entire citadel. One can imagine running battles between the reapers and C-Sec, aided by the citizen's militia Shepard did or did not authorize, bolstered by the Citadel Defense Force (whose strength was effected by dozens of different decisions Shepard made). Of course, since they didn't actually bother to show us any of our war assets in action, who knows.

[hiraeth]

Brhino wrote...

the initial tweet said that some people got out, but for the rest "bad times". Whether Bad Times means "processed into reaper meat" or "the power to the freezers went out so they had to eat all the ice cream before it melted" is up for speculation. In any case in the Original Ending it sure looked like the citadel completely exploded... so that's bad.

In the Extended Cut it becomes clear that the citadel did dot completely explode, at least not all of it. It certainly was heavily damaged. The death toll was likely large, but there would have been survivors. It's possible when the reapers invaded (we assume they invaded, anyhow - we never see any live or dead husks or anything) they focused on the areas they needed to be rather than immediately sweeping the entire citadel. One can imagine running battles between the reapers and C-Sec, aided by the citizen's militia Shepard did or did not authorize, bolstered by the Citadel Defense Force (whose strength was effected by dozens of different decisions Shepard made). Of course, since they didn't actually bother to show us any of our war assets in action, who knows.

QFT