200 réponses à ce sujet

[Conniving_Eagle]

Do you agree? If not, discuss.

I remember way back when Muzyka said Bioware were going to take from Skyrim for DA3. They should do the same for this game. Seriously, TW2 is a fantastic RPG. Too much of an RPG, according to some of my friends.

If you haven't played and researched this game, Bioware developers, you definitely should.

Modifié par Conniving_Eagle, 30 octobre 2012 - 02:37 .

[Realmzmaster]

Take what from Witcher 2? Also many on the team have played both Witcher 2 and Skyrim. What specifically are they to take from Witcher 2?

[Maria Caliban]

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

If you haven't played and researched this game, Bioware developers...

Yes. There are BioWare developers who have heard of the Witcher, and many who have played it.

[EpicBoot2daFace]

Realmzmaster wrote...

Take what from Witcher 2? Also many on the team have played both Witcher 2 and Skyrim. What specifically are they to take from Witcher 2?

1. How to make a great RPG.
2. How to respect your fanbase.
3. How to take criticism.

The thread should be titled "What Bioware can learn from CD Projekt".

Modifié par EpicBoot2daFace, 30 octobre 2012 - 02:31 .

[hoorayforicecream]

Things I liked about the witcher 2:

- Choices with mutually exclusive outcomes
- Dynamic lighting
- The use of color in its art style
- The amount of lore

Things I did not like about the witcher 2:

- The combat
- How immutable the characters were
- The treatment of women
- The UI
- The crafting system
- The potion system
- The voice acting
- The armor design
- How they handled the save import from the first game
- The gambling system
- The brawling mini game
- The quick time events

Modifié par hoorayforicecream, 30 octobre 2012 - 02:36 .

[challenger18]

I hope they don't take the bland expressionless characters and crappy combat system from the Witcher 2.

[wsandista]

12 minutes and this hasn't devolved into a discussion on sexism in games? I believe that might be a new record for the BSN.

[Heimdall]

What is this Withcer 2?

[Conniving_Eagle]

EpicBoot2daFace wrote...

Realmzmaster wrote...

Take what from Witcher 2? Also many on the team have played both Witcher 2 and Skyrim. What specifically are they to take from Witcher 2?

1. How to make a great RPG.
2. How to respect your fanbase.
3. How to take criticism.

The thread should be titled "What Bioware can learn from CD Projekt".

Sure.

[Massakkolia]

hoorayforicecream wrote...

Things I liked about the witcher 2:

- Choices with mutually exclusive outcomes
- Dynamic lighting
- The use of color in its art style
- The amount of lore

Things I did not like about the witcher 2:

- The combat
- How immutable the characters were
- The treatment of women
- The UI
- The crafting system
- The potion system
- The voice acting
- The armor design
- How they handled the save import from the first game
- The gambling system
- The brawling mini game
- The quick time events

I was going to post a list myself but you pretty much summed exactly my thoughts (the voice acting was decent in Polish though). I'd also add a fixed male protagonist to the list of minuses, especially if we're talking about what influences Dragon Age should adopt and which to avoid. 

[Genshie]

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.

On a serious note: Combat in Witcher 2 is kind of a real chore. On harder difficulties fighting 3+ plus things is not fun you can get locked and or pretty much spammed to death. Also despite me actually liking the darker mature fantasy theme I do agree that women weren't portrayed very well. Though I really enjoyed Saskia and thought her character was well done.

Modifié par Genshie, 30 octobre 2012 - 02:53 .

[hexaligned]

The first Witcher was great, the second one was a decent...half...of a game, I guess. It did look gorgeous though, yes.

[marshalleck]

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

[Emzamination]

Disagree - Tw and the Tw2 contain horrendous stigmas regarding female promiscuity. Bioware doesn't need to learn anything from trash like that.

[Xilizhra]

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

The quality is... meh. Largely for the reasons hoorayforicecream mentioned. Including the fixedly male protagonist.

[Volus Warlord]

Bioware is not CD Projekt or Bethesda.. Bioware is Bioware..

Can we stop putting emphasis on posing as something else?

[marshalleck]

Xilizhra wrote...

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

The quality is... meh. Largely for the reasons hoorayforicecream mentioned. Including the fixedly male protagonist.

Haha, whatever. Don't be mad that CD Projekt commands (and deserves) more respect than Bioware. 

[Genshie]

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

For reasons that Bioware is already trying to do and if not has already done. I wouldn't call Witcher 2 high quality except it does look pretty and the dark fantasy bit is pretty good but thats about it. (I did a quick reedit of the post you quoted off of me)

[Genshie]

marshalleck wrote...

Xilizhra wrote...

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

The quality is... meh. Largely for the reasons hoorayforicecream mentioned. Including the fixedly male protagonist.

Haha, whatever. Don't be mad that CD Projekt commands (and deserves) more respect than Bioware. 

Yes, cause Witcher 1 was awesome right...?  Don't get on such a high horse when they too had issues just like Bioware and every other developer.

[Xilizhra]

marshalleck wrote...

Xilizhra wrote...

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

The quality is... meh. Largely for the reasons hoorayforicecream mentioned. Including the fixedly male protagonist.

Haha, whatever. Don't be mad that CD Projekt commands (and deserves) more respect than Bioware. 

Perhaps it'll deserve more if it can expand beyond novel-slaved garbage.

[marshalleck]

Genshie wrote...

Yes, cause Witcher 1 was awesome right...?  Don't get on such a high horse when they too had issues just like Bioware and every other developer.

Witcher 1 was excellent for their very first outing, Witcher 2 blew that one away, and I'm pretty sure they've yet to produce their own opus, as Bioware did with Baldur's Gate 2.

Modifié par marshalleck, 30 octobre 2012 - 02:59 .

[Shadow Fox]

marshalleck wrote...

Genshie wrote...

You know what I am getting really tired of seeing any threads on Bioware forums about CD Projekt and Witcher 2. This is like fifth thread I have seen with either Witcher 2 or CD Projekt in the title.  

As long as CD Projekt keept cranking out top notch, high quality RPGs and treating its fanbase with respect, you'll keep seeing them mentioned around here favorably. 

in that case I should make threads about how Bioware should copy Skyrim.

[marshalleck]

Xilizhra wrote... novel-slaved garbage.

Look at how mad you are. 

[Iakus]

Just as long as they don't learn dark=deep.

oh wait...

Modifié par iakus, 30 octobre 2012 - 03:02 .

[Dave of Canada]

Genshie wrote...

Yes, cause Witcher 1 was awesome right...?

Except it was.

iakus wrote...

Just as long as tehy don't learn dark=deep.

oh wait...

Go play disney games.

Modifié par Dave of Canada, 30 octobre 2012 - 03:02 .