Aller au contenu

Photo

Why Petrovsky's fate will decide my final verdict of ME3 as an RPG


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
968 réponses à ce sujet

#901
CroGamer002

CroGamer002
  • Members
  • 20 672 messages

dr_random wrote...

I was tempted to Paragon intervene, but then I thought about the experiments and the Adjutants. I let her have it and felt a bit bad after it. But sometimes justice has to be done.


You call strangling a man near death/to death is justice?!

That's no justice, that's( attempted) murder!

#902
Mr.House

Mr.House
  • Members
  • 23 338 messages

Mesina2 wrote...

dr_random wrote...

I was tempted to Paragon intervene, but then I thought about the experiments and the Adjutants. I let her have it and felt a bit bad after it. But sometimes justice has to be done.


You call strangling a man near death/to death is justice?!

That's no justice, that's( attempted) murder!

Let's not forget when Aria's eyes went black he died, way after the crack. Something fishy is going on.

#903
iOnlySignIn

iOnlySignIn
  • Members
  • 4 426 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

iOnlySignIn wrote...

Brynn Cole is one of your favorite characters. The 20 lines or so she has in the entire trilogy is enough to make her a favorite.

No wonder you support Synthesis. 

20 lines are quite enough to establish a personality and make a character represent something. May I mention that Kate Bowman is another favorite of mine?

Also, what does that have to to with Synthesis?

For me 20 lines is not enough for anything. Especially since most of those 20 lines are background exposition. I honestly have no idea what Brynn Cole's personality is like other than her abysmal tastes in men - which is the only substantial thing I actually witnessed from her.

It is just like your support of Synthesis. You are capable of making decisions based on a minimal (practically nonexistent) amount of data.

Modifié par iOnlySignIn, 29 novembre 2012 - 12:12 .


#904
RiouHotaru

RiouHotaru
  • Members
  • 4 059 messages
Petrovsky WAS aware that the science team was experimenting on the Adjutants.  Listen to his dialog.  "Nyreen killed the one we weren't experimenting on".  He was well aware of what the team was up to.  And he blames Nyreen's death on Aria despite the fact it's the Adjutants that get her killed.

I admit, his statement after Aria leaves his fate to you made me want to pop his head, but it wasn't worth it. But they really kept his character intact. But then that wasn't a surprise. Really, the writing here was great. My only regret is that we didn't get more Nyreen.

It's a bit nostalgic to see folks going gaga for Cerberus again after ME2 shenanigans, but not really in a good way.

Also, even if you haven't read invasion, check the Codex.  They basically summarize Invasion enough so players understand what happened.

Modifié par RiouHotaru, 29 novembre 2012 - 12:29 .


#905
Barquiel

Barquiel
  • Members
  • 5 846 messages
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

Modifié par Barquiel, 29 novembre 2012 - 12:37 .


#906
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages

iOnlySignIn wrote...

Ieldra2 wrote...

iOnlySignIn wrote...

Brynn Cole is one of your favorite characters. The 20 lines or so she has in the entire trilogy is enough to make her a favorite.

No wonder you support Synthesis. 

20 lines are quite enough to establish a personality and make a character represent something. May I mention that Kate Bowman is another favorite of mine?

Also, what does that have to to with Synthesis?

For me 20 lines is not enough for anything. Especially since most of those 20 lines are background exposition. I honestly have no idea what Brynn Cole's personality is like other than her abysmal tastes in men - which is the only substantial thing I actually witnessed from her.

It is just like your support of Synthesis. You are capable of making decisions based on a minimal (practically nonexistent) amount of data.

This is - sorry to say so - plain nonsense. Even one sentence can - and usually does - convey a lot of information, not just about its subject, but often also about the person saying it. If I say "Synthesis will change the biochemistry of organics, giving them the ability to seamlessly integrate technology synthetic life is based on, which will convey on them certain advantages so far only enjoyed by synthetic life forms without affecting anyone's sense of self", this establishes a conceptual framework for the Synthesis in one sentence. I will know what it's about, and I can infer much of the rest from the context. 

More on-topic, Petrovsky can't have much more than 20 lines in the comic and the Omega DLC together. From that, we gain, among other things, the following information:

(1) He's a master strategist
(2) He's following Cerberus stated purpose of advancing humanity
(3) He can be ruthless but he's not callous, and he cares about his people and the people under his rule.
(4) He does not see TIM as he really is.
(5) He was not responsible for creating the Adjutants or for moving them to Omega.

To say this information is insignificant and "near to nonexistent" is ridiculous. In the context of the story, it's enough to tell me he's a man I'd rather have on my side than dead. It's also enough to tell me that my main Shepard would be interested in knowing him better.

#907
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.

Modifié par Ieldra2, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:05 .


#908
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad. Nothing new here.

to be honest Petrovsky could have been Mengele in Omega and I still would have saved him just for Invasion.

#909
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Mr.House wrote...

dr_random wrote...

Our_Last_Scene wrote...

My Shepard is far from a paragon but she always see's reason.

An unarmed man who surrendered, and who holds information, couldn't just be strangled by Aria in my books. I pulled her off Pretrovsky pretty quickly.


I was tempted to Paragon intervene, but then I thought about the experiments and the Adjutants. I let her have it and felt a bit bad after it. But sometimes justice has to be done.

That was the sciance team stationed on Omega, Olegs job was to secure the station, take care of threats and make sure the region is stable. He is not a scientist, what Cerberus scientist do is not his issue, that's berween them and TIM.

. ^

#910
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.

It depends; can they feel pain? Human husks do appear to be more or less mindless, but cannibals and marauders, at least, do display some level of intelligence (and the codex states outright that marauders are intelligent). I wouldn't be at all surprised if adjutants were as well. And even things as dumb as husks might still feel pain.

#911
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages
I don't know what I'd have done in that case, Steelcan, but I certainly would have lost all sympathy for the man. And objected to the presentation as character derailing.

Thankfully, that didn't happen. Surprisingly. For reasons I have outlined on the previous page, it is important to me to find halfway decent people in Cerberus.

#912
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Xilizhra wrote...

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.
Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.

It depends; can they feel pain? Human husks do appear to be more or less mindless, but cannibals and marauders, at least, do display some level of intelligence (and the codex states outright that marauders are intelligent). I wouldn't be at all surprised if adjutants were as well. And even things as dumb as husks might still feel pain.

. So?  I wouldn't feel any sympathy for them at all even were they sapient, but I don't think they are, they are more akin to rabid dogs, or the flood from Halo.  Their only purpose is to infect more adjutants.

#913
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

I don't know what I'd have done in that case, Steelcan, but I certainly would have lost all sympathy for the man. And objected to the presentation as character derailing.

Thankfully, that didn't happen. Surprisingly. For reasons I have outlined on the previous page, it is important to me to find halfway decent people in Cerberus.

. Good thing he wasn't Mengele:wizard:.  Everybody wins, well Aria is still pissed, but I couldn't care less

#914
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages
Referring to my OP, it is important that we have the choice about Petrovsky. It allows for different interpretations to be followed-up by player actions in a meaningful way.

In that regard, I'm satisfied with Omega.

BTW, the ability to ****** off Aria is a real plus in my eyes. Her attitude could do with some adjusting.

Modifié par Ieldra2, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:17 .


#915
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

. So? I wouldn't feel any sympathy for them at all even were they sapient, but I don't think they are, they are more akin to rabid dogs, or the flood from Halo. Their only purpose is to infect more adjutants.

You don't feel sympathy for a lot of people. A shame.

BTW, the ability to ****** off Aria is a real plus in my eyes. Her attitude could do with some adjusting.

No need for that.

Modifié par Xilizhra, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:17 .


#916
iOnlySignIn

iOnlySignIn
  • Members
  • 4 426 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

iOnlySignIn wrote...

For me 20 lines is not enough for anything. Especially since most of those 20 lines are background exposition. I honestly have no idea what Brynn Cole's personality is like other than her abysmal tastes in men - which is the only substantial thing I actually witnessed from her.

It is just like your support of Synthesis. You are capable of making decisions based on a minimal (practically nonexistent) amount of data.

This is - sorry to say so - plain nonsense. Even one sentence can - and usually does - convey a lot of information, not just about its subject, but often also about the person saying it. If I say "Synthesis will change the biochemistry of organics, giving them the ability to seamlessly integrate technology synthetic life is based on, which will convey on them certain advantages so far only enjoyed by synthetic life forms without affecting anyone's sense of self", this establishes a conceptual framework for the Synthesis in one sentence. I will know what it's about, and I can infer much of the rest from the context. 

You have such an outstanding gift to quickly understand both technology and people that ordinary people like me can only dream of. Whichever country you're from had better put you in charge of everything - you'll solve all their problems by the end of next month.

Modifié par iOnlySignIn, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:18 .


#917
Barquiel

Barquiel
  • Members
  • 5 846 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.


The scientists said they tested the "adjutant" virus on various species. They implanted Omega's citizens with control devices, then infect them with the Adjutant virus to create an army of obedient Adjutants. That's more than a bit tasteless, imo.

#918
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Xilizhra wrote...

. So? I wouldn't feel any sympathy for them at all even were they sapient, but I don't think they are, they are more akin to rabid dogs, or the flood from Halo. Their only purpose is to infect more adjutants.

You don't feel sympathy for a lot of people. A shame.

BTW, the ability to ****** off Aria is a real plus in my eyes. Her attitude could do with some adjusting.

No need for that.

. Aria is a bloodthirsty warlord who thrives off of slavery, drug dealing, seduction, murder, etc....  She thinks she owns the galaxy and has a much inflated sense of her own self importance.  She needs an adjustment.

As for me not feeling sympathy, if the people are already dead I don't see any need for sympathy.  The adjutants are no more deserving of sympathy than husks or collectors.  They are rabid dgs to be used or put down, nothing more.

#919
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages
@iOnlySignIn
I am still waiting for you to provide evidence for your claim that the information we get about Petrovsky (or Synthesis) is insignificant.

Modifié par Ieldra2, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:23 .


#920
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Barquiel wrote...

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.


The scientists said they tested the "adjutant" virus on various species. They implanted Omega's citizens with control devices, then infect them with the Adjutant virus to create an army of obedient Adjutants. That's more than a bit tasteless, imo.

. Seems a good idea to me.  They'd be great assets.

#921
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages

Barquiel wrote...

Ieldra2 wrote...

Barquiel wrote...
After hearing the logs in the lab I wouldn't have stopped Aria from killing him. But since my Shep "paragonized" Aria, he was lucky.

I see experimenting on Adjutants as akin to experimenting on mindless zombies. Perhaps a bit tasteless, but not nearly on the same level as experimenting on humans.

Of course the story suggests that it's just as bad, and even worse, it leaves the player who doesn't know Invasion to assume he was responsible for their creation in the first place. Nothing new here. I'm taking Miranda's stance from ME2 instead.


The scientists said they tested the "adjutant" virus on various species. They implanted Omega's citizens with control devices, then infect them with the Adjutant virus to create an army of obedient Adjutants. That's more than a bit tasteless, imo.

Did they say they used Omega's citizens? I don't think so. All I heard was them experimenting on adjutants, not creating new ones.

@Steelcan:
You're about to dig your own grave, arguments-wise, in case you haven't noticed.

Modifié par Ieldra2, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:26 .


#922
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

. Aria is a bloodthirsty warlord who thrives off of slavery, drug dealing, seduction, murder, etc.... She thinks she owns the galaxy and has a much inflated sense of her own self importance. She needs an adjustment.

She's also the least bad of the Terminus lords that we've seen and maintains more stability than would be found otherwise (Cerberus would not be stable). She's distasteful but necessary until a better solution can be found (although I suppose in the Control ending, the Reapers could be used to invade and pacify the Terminus, but that wouldn't be my first choice).

As for me not feeling sympathy, if the people are already dead I don't see any need for sympathy. The adjutants are no more deserving of sympathy than husks or collectors. They are rabid dgs to be used or put down, nothing more.

The originals are dead, but the new life forms are alive.

#923
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Ieldra2 w
Did they say they used Omega's citizens? I don't think so. All I heard was them experimenting on adjutants, not creating new ones.

@Steelcan:
You're about to dig your own grave, arguments-wise, in case you haven't noticed.

. I'll be fine;)

#924
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 283 messages

Xilizhra wrote...

. Aria is a bloodthirsty warlord who thrives off of slavery, drug dealing, seduction, murder, etc.... She thinks she owns the galaxy and has a much inflated sense of her own self importance. She needs an adjustment.

She's also the least bad of the Terminus lords that we've seen and maintains more stability than would be found otherwise (Cerberus would not be stable). She's distasteful but necessary until a better solution can be found (although I suppose in the Control ending, the Reapers could be used to invade and pacify the Terminus, but that wouldn't be my first choice).

As for me not feeling sympathy, if the people are already dead I don't see any need for sympathy. The adjutants are no more deserving of sympathy than husks or collectors. They are rabid dgs to be used or put down, nothing more.

The originals are dead, but the new life forms are alive.

. Cerberus would put in order.

 I don't see rampant gang violence happening under Petrovsky.  The originals are dead, and the new forms as husks, literally and figuratively, you need to listen to Mordin's speech about the collectors again

Modifié par Steelcan, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:34 .


#925
Ieldra

Ieldra
  • Members
  • 25 178 messages

Steelcan wrote...
As for me not feeling sympathy, if the people are already dead I don't see any need for sympathy.  The adjutants are no more deserving of sympathy than husks or collectors.  They are rabid dgs to be used or put down, nothing more.

I think the idea is to make experimenting on them seem bad because they were once human. It's the same reasoning that makes people destroy the Collector base because of what was done there. But past is past.

Having said that, I see all life forms as valid and as a rule wouldn't kill anything just for existing. Our typical hierarchy of values makes us see experimenting on animals as not nearly as bad as experimenting on humans, though you'd still have a duty to avoid causing unnecessary pain. I'd put the Adjutants in the same category. If they were sapient I would consider them on the same level as humans, and experimenting on them would be equal to experimenting on POWs.

But they aren't sapient, so I don't have a big problem with how things go. 

Modifié par Ieldra2, 29 novembre 2012 - 01:38 .