257 réponses à ce sujet

[shodiswe]

When KL showed up on Thessia I would have said, "I didn't know you were this eager to die!"

[CDR David Shepard]

Eterna5 wrote...

CDR David Shepard wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

CDR David Shepard wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

Ticonderoga117 wrote...

Kanaris wrote...

www.youtube.com/watch 

Thanks, and huh, interesting. EDI being a bit of a b*tch. Though it's interesting to note how her arguments can be easily used on the opposite side of things.

I don't see how she's being a ****. She upset and hurt because she knows her commander would sacrifice her in a instant if it cae to a choice between her and an organic crewmember.

I mean, how would you feel? You co pilot the ship, you mantain the ship, you even risk yourself to fight for someone only to find out they would kill you no problem. 

See...this is part of the reason why it pisses me off.

She...just like you are now...assumes that Shepard simply picked organics over sythetics...when that wasn't the case at all.

She...and you...assume that Shepard would kill her in an instant if it came to a choice between her and an organic crewmember.

That fact is...if Joker allied himself with the Reapers...and then I rewrote his data so that he would no longer be under their control...and then he again allied himself with the Reapers...I would absolutely sacrifice Joker to save EDI.

These are the points that she...and you...seem to forget for some reason.

EDi isn't a mind reader and the Geth/Quarian conflict isn't very cut and dry. It comes down to whose extinction you can live with, you picked a Synthetic race and EDi is upset about that. 

 

Yes...but the point of this thread is about dialog that is completely out of place.

It is in my opinion...that EDI saying that is completely out of place. EDI has never been and never should be that illogical. What she assumes is completely illogical.

She illogically equates all synthetics as one in the same...assuming that since Shepard choose the Quarians over the Geth that it would be a close minded choice between her and an organic....just because she is synthetic.

Yet...she's been helping us to eliminate a synthetic race (the Reapers) ever since ME2.

Fact is...it's completely out of place for her to be like that.

It's part of her character development, she is irrational due to her growing sense of hummanity and emotion. Frankly, it would be more out of place if she said nothing. 

Well...I guess it's just a "to each their own" moment.

I for one never would have expected her to sh*t all over Shepard after he just went through one of the hardest and most emotional decisions he's had to make.

Modifié par CDR David Shepard, 11 novembre 2012 - 09:32 .

[grey_wind]

My favourite by far:

"Primarch, I can totally see that Palaven is on fire in the background, but f*ck Palaven, I need your ships for Earth! EARTH EARTH EARTH!"

[Cribbian]

When Joker asked if I wanted to call the council and hang up on them, for old time's sake. For most of my Shepards that did not make sense since they never hung up on the council in the first place.

[Eterna]

grey_wind wrote...

My favourite by far:

"Primarch, I can totally see that Palaven is on fire in the background, but f*ck Palaven, I need your ships for Earth! EARTH EARTH EARTH!"

This I can actually agree with. It's one of my peeves. Why does Shepard assume and expect every race in the Galaxy to abandon their home planets and help Earth? It happened on the citadel, on Palaven and Tuchanka and it made Shepard look really selfish and unsympathetic. 

When my Shepard was acting outraged that the Council couldn't afford to send ships to earth because they needed to see to their own borders I was going "wtf?"

The world doesn't revolve around hummanity Shepard, seriously. 

Modifié par Eterna5, 11 novembre 2012 - 09:56 .

[LegioDamnatus]

shodiswe wrote...

When KL showed up on Thessia I would have said, "I didn't know you were this eager to die!"

When he showed up, I just said "Great, more pigs for the slaughter..."


Aside from that, most of the intro was just painful. "This isn't about strategy or tactics!" I think I broke my nose from facepalming so hard.

[Icinix]

The biggest for me was when Liara spoke to Shepard after Mars about the Crucible...that just made me cringe.

[NRieh]

Nothing can beat Beam Run Normandy Evac scene!! Nothing. Ever.

Using top-power stealth fregate during the vital action as a taxi shuttle for a somewhat wounded squaddie, having another barely hurt squaddie at hand.... with THOSE dialogues...No. Thessia was pure custom RP comparing to this one.

[Foolsfolly]

Eterna5 wrote...

grey_wind wrote...

My favourite by far:

"Primarch, I can totally see that Palaven is on fire in the background, but f*ck Palaven, I need your ships for Earth! EARTH EARTH EARTH!"

This I can actually agree with. It's one of my peeves. Why does Shepard assume and expect every race in the Galaxy to abandon their home planets and help Earth? It happened on the citadel, on Palaven and Tuchanka and it made Shepard look really selfish and unsympathetic. 

When my Shepard was acting outraged that the Council couldn't afford to send ships to earth because they needed to see to their own borders I was going "wtf?"

The world doesn't revolve around hummanity Shepard, seriously. 

I don't even know why Shepard thought it would work like that. Just scream "Help Earth! Only Earth!" Not only would that get him nothing but look at the past in this series.

No one helped the quarians. No one helped the vast majority of the drell. They just sat back and watched those two races die. Then they actually killed off the rachni and put in motion a slow genocide on the krogan.

This is a universe that by in large does not care. The only force shown to care about other people's problems throughout the series was Shepard.

[Raizo]

It's all bad. I started a new game on the 360 last night ( I have yet to get past Sur'kesh on the 360 since the game is so awful ) and I stated to cringe the second Shepard and Anderson started speaking.

[Patchwork]

So many-

The entire meeting with the defence committee, I don't know who that person talking was but it sure wasn't my Shepard.

Expecting the council to head towards Earth (Shepard's Earth centric attitude in general was irritating). How about we just ask for scientists to help figure out the Crucible while acting like reasonable people who understand they aren't the centre of the universe?

Cerberus helping the Collectors while helping Shepard defeat them is a big bit of information we didn't get to investigate. ME2 forced Shepard to work with Cerberus if she was that big of a chump then questions need to be asked.

Even if Shepard's mission on Thessia had been successful the planet would still have fallen to the Reapers. If the matriarchs hadn't been playing king of the hill while the galaxy burned then the beacon could have been retrieved before the invasion. Knowing this my Shepard isn't going to be stomping around the ship like a stroppy two year old after the Thessia mission.


It wasn't cheating and we're still together.

Shepard calling a timeout during the beam run and ordering Joker to pick up the injured squaddie. So much fail in one little scene.

[deatharmonic]

HOOYAH!!

[ioannisdenton]

Worst out of place line you say.
I.... don't know which one .
i am the catalyst is propably the one that makes me angry

[Rune-Chan]

Talking to Traynor when she offers to play chess.

Shepard openly states not only a lack of interest in it, but a complete lack of understanding of how the game even works.

The first one irritates me because it takes away player agency, the second irritates me because it also takes away player agency while suggesting that Shepard is a moron.

That said, the dialogue overall was the worst part of the game, easily. Too much cheesiness, too much auto-dialogue and too many action movie one-liners.

Modifié par Machines Are Us, 11 novembre 2012 - 03:15 .

[SpamBot2000]

I suppose someone must have mentioned it, but how about "So, the Illusive Man was right!"

[Steelcan]

Every thing Liara ever said in ME3, everything Kai Leng said, and a lot of what Shepard said as well.

[Supabah]

"Good luck"

To Anderson in the beginning, Shepard says it so quietly in the middle of a war zone, did Anderson even hear it?
Makes sense to say good luck, but it has always bothered me.

[DeinonSlayer]

ioannisdenton wrote...

Worst out of place line you say.
I.... don't know which one .
i am the catalyst is propably the one that makes me angry

Shepard just says "let's get this over with" if you only react positively to a single offered choice.

[spirosz]

Raddx Fusion wrote...

somewhat disassociates me as the player from Shepard.

We have a winner!  

[CroGamer002]

ME2 Shep to Council about Spectre reinstatement: You can take that offer and cram it up your ass.

ME3 Shep to Council about Spectre reinstatement: ...


HELLO?!

[Mr. MannlyMan]

Machines Are Us wrote...

Talking to Traynor when she offers to play chess.

Shepard openly states not only a lack of interest in it, but a complete lack of understanding of how the game even works.

The first one irritates me because it takes away player agency, the second irritates me because it also takes away player agency while suggesting that Shepard is a moron.

That said, the dialogue overall was the worst part of the game, easily. Too much cheesiness, too much auto-dialogue and too many action movie one-liners.

This. Granted, there are plenty of people who like hard cheese and soap dialogue, but I couldn't stand it. IMO there was way, way too much of it in ME3.

[_aLucidMind_]

Machines Are Us wrote...

Talking to Traynor when she offers to play chess.

Shepard openly states not only a lack of interest in it, but a complete lack of understanding of how the game even works.

The first one irritates me because it takes away player agency, the second irritates me because it also takes away player agency while suggesting that Shepard is a moron.

That said, the dialogue overall was the worst part of the game, easily. Too much cheesiness, too much auto-dialogue and too many action movie one-liners.

Hardly anything moronic about not knowing how to play chess or having no interest in chess, and it is highly likely that maybe Traynor is a bad teacher and didn't explain the rules very well.

[Alex101Crusader]

Kanaris wrote...

I don't have a specific place that felt out of character per say but I got a distinct feeling that Shep was kind of cold towards his LI at parts which to me would have been out of place for my shep as My LI was the reason for doing all this not just to save the galaxy.

+1

[Display Name Owner]

Shepard's total exasperation with the Council was kind of unwarranted, given that their arguments for not leaping to Earth's defence actually made total sense. Same goes for the attitude he/she gave the Turian Councillor over the deal to save the Primarch. It was a decent olive branch and completely fair 'favour for a favour' deal. I like my Shepards to be cosmopolitan - they see the value of working together with the others species, none of that wildly pro-human stuff, so it was kind of jarring.

Also, I for one found Jokers Thessia gag pretty funny, so an option to not blow up on him would have been cool. Although I did like the whole thing with Shepard just being tired and stressed and frustrated after Thessia, so I can roll with that one.

[Tempest_]

It really bothers me how Shepard just agrees to be part of the plan to set up and kill the vorcha.

Kreete I think his name was.