428 réponses à ce sujet

[Ithurael]

3/10 for the ending

10/10 for the thread

[CDR David Shepard]

9/10 in my opinion.

[Odplata pride]

Why there is not 0/10? It would be right answer!

[Reth Shepherd]

There should be a 0/10, possibly including negative numbers as the ending to that single game managed to retroactively destroy the previous two games.

I rate it roughly a -10/10 for the original ending, -9/10 for the EC (shiny pictures!), and as high as 5/10 if IT/Refuse is used. However, since the game is then missing the ending (well, what happened THEN?), it is still well below average.

[N7 Shadow 90]

Seival wrote...

Subjective poll... How good is ME Trilogy ending for you personally?

...And please, stay calm and be civil. Just opinion. No fighting.
http://social.biowar...72/polls/41590/

Here is my personal rating for ME3 ending:

I've never eally thought of the ending in that way. I agree with it now. Compltely. I loved the ending anyway, but I never thought of it in this way.

[Tronar]

Arcian wrote...

The ME trilogy was the equivalent of taking a luxury cruise to Hawaii with impeccable service, great entertainment and almost nothing but pure joy broken up by mishaps such as a waiter giving me a watered down Caesar's Salad (ME2's dumbing down of RPG mechanics), the mariachi-band not being mexican (Retcons) and the captain forcing us to do the limbo (Railroading) even though we'd rather dance hula.

After a great cruise, we arrive at the exact second Super MAC obliterates the island chain from orbit, leaving nothing but a gaping hole (Missing Logic) in the ocean floor (The Catalyst's reasoning). Also, my kids, my wife and my best friends died (Original Ending Shepard and Co. dying or getting stranded on Gilligan's Planet) in the blast and the cruise ship we came in on was irreparably damaged (Original Ending Relays). Except my friends actually lived (EC Normandy isn't stranded), it only looked like they were dead and the boat ends up being salvageable (EC Relays) after a couple of months (Years/Decades). But the island is still a gaping hole in the ocean floor (Catalyst's Logic still Effed up) and my wife and kids are still dead (Shepard, Destroy notwithstanding).

To give this vacation anything more than a 1/10 is completely absurd. Yes, the journey is overall more important than the destination, but it is the destination that validates the journey. If not, why the hell were you even travelling in the first place? If you undertake a trip, you want to get somewhere worthwhile. Having Hawaii blown up in your face by the same guy who sold you the cruise is incredibly, unfathomably insulting.

+1

[Doofe2012]

With the EC, it's an acceptable 6/10 or 7/10.

[Dr_Extrem]

Jade8aby88 wrote...

I love you Seival.

edit: I put 5 out of 10, first this was because I thought it was about the whole game in general. When I realised it wasn't and I couldn't change it. I thought of keeping it the same anyway. And this is why.

it's neutral because The "real" ending is yet to be determined. You can only judge Mass Effect 3 as a whole (ending inclusive) once the dlc schedule is finished.

Therefore, if nothing is done, it drops to 0 or 1 if I'm feeling generous (yes, I feel it's actually that bad, no hyperbole here). But if there is something "bigger" in the works. eg; IT, PT etc...

Then It would be bumped up to 9, or even 10.. Depending on how enraged it makes Synthesis supporters if it's Indoctrination.

So 5 it is.

my thoughts exactly ...  but i voted 1/10 because i am a bitter, german realist.

[The_Other_M]

Arbiter156 wrote...

2/10 (with EC)

1/10 (original)

the ending is broken, wrong and absolutely repulsive.

it does not honour the key themes of the series

it does not give weight to any of the previous decisions made by the player thorught the series

it does not provide closure for shepard or the other characters we grew to love.

it severley limits the future of the series.

do we need me to make a megathread on why the ending is bad?

[Mathias]

Am i the only one who thinks of assimilation when i see Sevial's avatar?

[Fifmut]

Odplata pride wrote...

Why there is not 0/10? It would be right answer!

[Bill Casey]

Jade8aby88 wrote...

It's better than IT.

Nothing is better than IT...

[GreyLycanTrope]

Arcian wrote...

The ME trilogy was the equivalent of taking a luxury cruise to Hawaii with impeccable service, great entertainment and almost nothing but pure joy broken up by mishaps such as a waiter giving me a watered down Caesar's Salad (ME2's dumbing down of RPG mechanics), the mariachi-band not being mexican (Retcons) and the captain forcing us to do the limbo (Railroading) even though we'd rather dance hula.

After a great cruise, we arrive at the exact second Super MAC obliterates the island chain from orbit, leaving nothing but a gaping hole (Missing Logic) in the ocean floor (The Catalyst's reasoning). Also, my kids, my wife and my best friends died (Original Ending Shepard and Co. dying or getting stranded on Gilligan's Planet) in the blast and the cruise ship we came in on was irreparably damaged (Original Ending Relays). Except my friends actually lived (EC Normandy isn't stranded), it only looked like they were dead and the boat ends up being salvageable (EC Relays) after a couple of months (Years/Decades). But the island is still a gaping hole in the ocean floor (Catalyst's Logic still Effed up) and my wife and kids are still dead (Shepard, Destroy notwithstanding).

To give this vacation anything more than a 1/10 is completely absurd. Yes, the journey is overall more important than the destination, but it is the destination that validates the journey. If not, why the hell were you even travelling in the first place? If you undertake a trip, you want to get somewhere worthwhile. Having Hawaii blown up in your face by the same guy who sold you the cruise is incredibly, unfathomably insulting.

Umm The poll asks for your opinion on the ending speciffically not ME3 or the trillogy as a whole.

Modifié par Greylycantrope, 13 novembre 2012 - 07:42 .

[GreyLycanTrope]

Bill Casey wrote...

Jade8aby88 wrote...

It's better than IT.

Nothing is better than IT...

I'd say waffles are better than IT. Especially with a side of bacon and some OJ.

Modifié par Greylycantrope, 13 novembre 2012 - 07:43 .

[Yesmar]

Greylycantrope wrote...

Bill Casey wrote...

Jade8aby88 wrote...

It's better than IT.

Nothing is better than IT...

I'd say waffles are better than IT. Especially with a side of bacon and some OJ.

Are waffles better than IT.... or do waffles prove IT.

[GreyLycanTrope]

Depends on the side of bacon. It's that wonderful taste sensation I know is 100% real, accept no substitute.

Modifié par Greylycantrope, 13 novembre 2012 - 07:48 .

[Robhuzz]

Any ending that renders an entire trilogy unplayable and invalidates every choice you ever made in said trilogy doesn't even deserve a number. But I'll give it a 1/10. For the minuscule effort they put in I guess.

[dreamgazer]

And thus, the BLT theory was born.

[Yesmar]

I prefer bacon with a fried  tomato myself.

[hiraeth]

Robhuzz wrote...

Any ending that renders an entire trilogy unplayable and invalidates every choice you ever made in said trilogy doesn't even deserve a number.

i won't even give ME a 0/10...i'll give it an F!

[AresKeith]

I'm hungry now