461 réponses à ce sujet

[Sajuro]

I just don't like it because I choose to immerse myself in the game and try to think out explanations for what is happening rather than complain about it. I had enough of his threads when he was still on here so yay for smudboy but I'm hardly a fan

[spirosz]

Someone With Mass wrote...

You know that guy who made the Marauder Shields comics? Here's a journal he wrote about the Leviathan DLC and what he thinks is good writing. With comparisons to ME3's writing.

Takes way less than 37 minutes to read and he's not wasting time on nitpicking.

I enjoyed, at least with this dude, he tries to spin the ending into something positive and enjoyable for a lot of people, instead of drowning it in negativity.  I respect that. 

[davidshooter]

Someone With Mass wrote...

You know that guy who made the Marauder Shields comics? Here's a journal he wrote about the Leviathan DLC and what he thinks is good writing. With comparisons to ME3's writing.

Takes way less than 37 minutes to read and he's not wasting time on nitpicking.

very good read, thanks for posting.

[Morty Smith]

dreamgazer wrote...

Eh, even Citizen Kane and Casablanca have their logic-breaking plot holes, as do many other celebrated games. It all depends on how they're supplemented.

In what regard supplemented?

[Applepie_Svk]

I love this thread, so much butthurt for one video....

You are saying that these are nitpicks, and what ? For past few months we were debunking almost everything from endings and this video shoulnd´t be surprise for anyone which was there...

Modifié par Applepie_Svk, 13 novembre 2012 - 05:03 .

[Gamer790]

Someone With Mass wrote...

You know that guy who made the Marauder Shields comics? Here's a journal he wrote about the Leviathan DLC and what he thinks is good writing. With comparisons to ME3's writing.

Takes way less than 37 minutes to read and he's not wasting time on nitpicking.

It's a good read.  Highly reccomend it.

[Morty Smith]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

J. Reezy wrote...

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

You know that guy who made the Marauder Shields comics? Here's a journal he wrote about the Leviathan DLC and what he thinks is good writing. With comparisons to ME3's writing.

Takes way less than 37 minutes to read and he's not wasting time on nitpicking.

See, now I really enjoyed that article. It makes a really good point, it's concise and it's not insulting to it's viewers.

What is that supposed to mean?

He doesn't insult anyone who may or may not see it. He welcomes all viewpoints and viewers.

As you do just now?

[Brovikk Rasputin]

Just that voice... ugh. How can anyone watch over 30 minutes of this?!

[Seboist]

Brovikk Rasputin wrote...

Just that voice... ugh. How can anyone watch over 30 minutes of this?!

Those that watch his videos don't make up reasons not to hear how this Gears knock off's story is abysmal. That's how.

[Chaotic-Fusion]

His points are valid, as always, but he should really make an effort to not sound like an arrogant ******. Listening to him is really unpleasant.

[Someone With Mass]

Seboist wrote...

Brovikk Rasputin wrote...

Just that voice... ugh. How can anyone watch over 30 minutes of this?!

Those that watch his videos don't make up reasons not to hear how this Gears knock off's story is abysmal. That's how.

No, they just wasted more than half an hour of their lives listening to some guy talking about things they more than likely already know by now, since the game and its story DLCs have been out for quite a while.

I bet that he'll get around to the Omega DLC around March or April too. Just so he can gather all the criticism from various sources and repeat them in order to have at least some relevant material for his unnecessarily long videos.

Modifié par Someone With Mass, 13 novembre 2012 - 06:14 .

[dreamgazer]

Kroitz wrote...

dreamgazer wrote...

Eh, even Citizen Kane and Casablanca have their logic-breaking plot holes, as do many other celebrated games. It all depends on how they're supplemented.

In what regard supplemented?

Does it make you think? Does it provide emotional satisfaction? Does it reach some form of catharsis?

It's all a balance between creativity, attention to detail, and base satisfaction---one that the ME3 ending didn't get quite right, despite noble intentions and an interesting confrontation between the audience and some the story's underlying themes.

[Anacronian Stryx]

spirosz wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

You know that guy who made the Marauder Shields comics? Here's a journal he wrote about the Leviathan DLC and what he thinks is good writing. With comparisons to ME3's writing.

Takes way less than 37 minutes to read and he's not wasting time on nitpicking.

I enjoyed, at least with this dude, he tries to spin the ending into something positive and enjoyable for a lot of people, instead of drowning it in negativity.  I respect that. 

wait..so you respect sugarcoating?

Well okay i guess.

[Morty Smith]

dreamgazer wrote...

Kroitz wrote...

dreamgazer wrote...

Eh, even Citizen Kane and Casablanca have their logic-breaking plot holes, as do many other celebrated games. It all depends on how they're supplemented.

In what regard supplemented?

Does it make you think? Does it provide emotional satisfaction? Does it reach some form of catharsis?

It's all a balance between creativity, attention to detail, and base satisfaction---one that the ME3 ending didn't get quite right, despite noble intentions and an interesting confrontation between the audience and some the story's underlying themes.

Thanks for the explanation. <3

But I diagree that it all depends on the supplementation. Because it sounds to me that the "sugar-coating" would be the most important thing to solving the problems the endings had and have.

And sadly the EC was little more than just that in my eyes.

[JesseLee202]

Didn't even keep it on for a minute. Sounds like he just finished ME3 yesterday...

[Barbantious]

I find all this nitpicking about his nitpicking rather bothersome, ill just ignore whatever points you have.

[fr33stylez]

People have strange arguments against smudboy. He shouldn't make videos because the game is 8 months old? He's too invested into the game? Really?

Why are you all here posting on a ME3 forum? Aren't 3/4 of the threads on the first page been covered sometime in the past 8 months? Why not volunteer in Haiti instead of playing video games, then logging on to your computer to talk about playing video games? Sheesh.

Modifié par fr33stylez, 13 novembre 2012 - 06:33 .

[Barbantious]

JesseLee202 wrote...

Didn't even keep it on for a minute. Sounds like he just finished ME3 yesterday...

you must have missed the part where he said that was the stuff he wasn't going to talk in depth about because bioware didn't address them in the extended cut, and thus had no place in his video. 

[Maxster_]

Seboist wrote...

The sad thing is that smud only scratches the surface of the derp of ME3. He hasn't mentioned how they retconned the Protheans losing due to a surprise decapitation strike and losing control of the relays to...... not having been multicultural(wha...?).

Well, i doubt that putting all stupidity and nonsense of ME3 into one video is possible.
He hasn't even teared apart Catalyst properly

Well, he said he will made at least 1 more video.