Aller au contenu

Photo

A Nightmare Solo Guide for Dual-Weapon Assassin/Duelist


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
106 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages
A Nightmare Solo Guide for Dual-Weapon Assassin/Duelist (No Pets Allowed!)

Fights of Interest

The following strategies will work consistently. There is need to reload until you succeed -- you'll be able to win these battles every time.

Screenshots.

(pict.com is a little buggy: the arrow buttons won't advance you to page 2 -- you have to click on "2" or "Next" to see the second page.)

- Gazarath and tower ogre

These are handled by running + Dual-Weapon Sweep.

For the ogre, run around in circles (I follow the circular pattern of tiles on the floor). Every 15s or so the ogre will fall behind, which is enough time needed to recharge Sweep. When there is a nice gap (not too large, not too small) between you and him, turn around, hit Sweep, then run away the instant damage is made (see pictures). The ogre only swipes at you -- he won't do a special move like Grab or Ram.

If the ogre does a Ram or Grab, it means you've gotten too close or stayed too long within melee range. Unlike Grab, the effects of Ram can be mitigated if it happens. Run behind him the moment you see Ram activated. You'll be thrown in the opposite direction he's ramming, which buys you enough time to get up and chug a potion.

For Gazarath it's basically the same thing except you're running all over instead of in a circle. Gazarath can be slowed by trees, rocks, etc., allowing you to create the necessary gap for the Sweep trick.

- Sloth demon

Engage immediately and just hack away at him; don't shapeshift; don't disengage from combat. If you do Circle Tower first then he doesn't appear to have Crushing Prison. For his first form (ogre), if you stay engaged with him then he won't use any special ogre talents like Ram or Grab.

- Uldred and the Fade Beast

Engage immediately. Never leave melee range, otherwise he'll start casting (Crushing Prison = the end). Run to his backside, do one backstab, and run again. He won't push you away with Massive Attack, or if it's activated then it won't hit. Just run circles around him: stab and run, stab and run.

Another strategy is to get him near a wall so that Massive Attack will not launch you out of melee range. Although that works, I couldn't make it 100% reliable like above. If you inch away from him, he'll sometimes follow but sometimes cast. The best you could hope for is to run the same times he does, pushing him towards the wall (he does the Moonwalk), but I couldn't get that reliably either.

- High Dragon, Flemeth, Archdemon

Run to his (or her) backside, at approximately the 4 o'clock or 8 o'clock position. It will look like you're stabbing him in the leg (see pictures). Keep stabbing until you either get swept away or he turns. Unlike Uldred, there's no danger for being out of melee range as long as you have fire resist gear (Wade's Superior). When he begins to turn, just turn with him and start again. Never enter melee range on his frontside.

- Gaxkang

With gear and runes you can reach 100% spell resist. Trivial fight.

- Werewolf Lair

While stealthed, walk to the end of first hallway on the left or right. Plant yourself in a corner then unstealth. You should attract at most two Shadow Werewolves. With Felon's Coat and Lifegiver you should be able to survive two consecutive Overwhelms. If you can't then Rock Salve should put you over the top. Since you're in a corner, you won't get hit by other werewolves while down. Do the same for the other dead-end hallway.

Don't forget to buy the Rock Salve recipe at Ostegar since it's your last chance until Landsmeet.

- Corrupted Spider Queen

Lifegiver and Rock Salve for Overwhelm, Deadhead Charge for Web. You should be fine. If you save Deep Roads as the very last task before Landsmeet, then nothing is much of a danger here.

- Broodmother

Shoot her with a bow to avoid Grab. Wear the Heart of Witherfang for the belches. That's pretty much it.

- Revanants, Orzammar Proving, Jarvia

They can't hit you.

Other Screenshots

Final counts.
Final attributes.
My favorite screenshot.

General Strategy Notes

Take out the mages first, of course. For multiple mages or for an uber mage that can't be killed with one stun, put on spell resist gear (outlined later). Once the mages are gone, change back to normal gear.

Fight with your back against a corner. If you suspect the target could be a rogue then be sure to stun him first, as getting stunned yourself is bad news. Otherwise you can usually get in a couple stabs first, then stun, then back to stabbing.

Before Coup De Grace it is sometimes worthwhile to move to the backstab area after stunning.

Origin: Dwarf Noble

10% spell resist is a win, and the 25 gold for taking the bribe (grr, wish it was the promised 100 gold) lands you two early Grandmaster runes (the first things I recommend spending money on).

Sequence of Quests

It seems obvious that Circle Tower should be first for the ability increases. Other than that, I generally did quests in the order of what gear I most wanted and was easiest to obtain.

Circle Tower -- ability bonuses
start Orzammar -- Key to the City
Stone Prisoner -- Helm of Honnleath, Harvest Festival Ring
Denerim stealing errands -- money
Denerim blood mages -- Magister's Shield
Warden's Keep -- storage chest
Haven, Ruined Temple (not yet Caverns) -- Ancient Elven Gloves (spell resist)
Redcliffe -- money for Lifegiver (for Drake's Overwhelm), Shielded Dwarven Armor (spell resist)
Caverns, the Gauntlet -- Master Dweomer Rune, unlock Felon's Coat
Brecilian Forest -- Dusk Ring (used just for opening chests; go back to Haven and get Antivan Leather Boots)
Elven Ruins -- money for Felon's Coat (for Shadow Werewolves)
Werewolf Lair -- money
Orzammar Proving, Carta -- money
High Dragon -- Grandmaster Fire Rune, Deadhead Charge
Flemeth -- since my daggers were already configured for High Dragon (no fire runes)
Deep Roads -- Master Dweomer Rune (from Branka)
finish Crows -- Grandmaster Dweomer Rune, Red Jenny Seekers, another Crow Dagger
Gaxkang -- since I reached 100% spell resist

Abilities

5 points into Cunning gives you 30 Cunning (with gear) which opens any chest and disables any (or most any?) trap. Everything else goes into Dexterity.

First pants, then shoes. You need to hit first, then you can do damage. I need to power through Weakness, Growl, and other attack penalties. I can still miss with debuffs like those, and I don't like missing.

I'll take the defense bonus, attack bonus, physical resistance bonus, and 1/2 damage bonus with Dexterity over a mere damage bonus with Cunning. A party-based rogue (where high Cunning is reasonable) is a totally different concept.

With such high defense you are mostly not hittable (special attacks aside: Rake, Sweep, etc). The exception is, oddly enough, the archers in the arl's estate. Friggin Jedi Masters, those archers are. And they aren't even using talents like Aim. Also there is Ser Cauthrien, who hit me once. Out of curiosity I re-fought the battle but couldn't reproduce her hit. Maybe it was a fluke.

Talents

Roughly in order:

Dual-Weapon Training
Dual-Weapon Sweep, Flurry, Momentum
Deft Hands
Stealth
Dual-Weapon Finesse
Dueling
Stealthy Item Use
Combat Stealth
Improved Tools, Mechanical Expertise
Master Stealth
Device Mastery
Upset Balance, Keen Defense
Combat Movement, Coup De Grace
Dual Striking, Riposte
Mark of Death, Exploit Weakness
Below the Belt, Deadly Strike, Lethality

A more powerful build could be made by ignoring the Deft Hands tree, but I prefer to disable traps and unlock chests. I didn't need more power; utility is nicer. Avoiding traps with foreknowledge of their location is cheesy, as is reloading when you hit one. Also, Antivan Leather Boots are in a strongly locked chest.

You might be surprised that I took Coup De Grace so late. Here my philosophy is, again, "first pants, then shoes." The first order of business is attack and defense. I can live without Coup De Grace, but I can't live with missing or getting hit. +10 attack and +10 defense from dueling mode is a big win.

Riposte comes later because it requires more stamina, because it's not as reliable at stunning as Dirty Fighting (perhaps because Riposte is a physical resistance check), and because Combat Stealth makes it slightly redundant.

I've never seen Dirty Fighting and Riposte work consecutively on the same target. After a Dirty Fighting stun, a successful stun with Riposte is ignored, and vice-versa. For a given target it's as if there is a cool-down interval for stunning as a whole. Though a nice talent, Riposte isn't quite as nice as it looks.

Lethality is last because the bonus is small.

With a 5-minute recharge time, Feign Death can't be incorporated into a combat strategy. It might be useful as a fallback, but if that is the case then your strategy failed. Find a different strategy, one that works every time.

Though it looks promising, Evasion is disastrous for a solo rogue. There is an animation tied to Evasion: daggers are held up in a defensive posture with a distinctive "chinggg" sound effect. Say you've sneaked into the middle of a hoard of archers to assassinate a caster. You begin wailing on him, but every other second you stop, hold up your daggers, and wait for the "chinggg". Meanwhile the stun wears off and you haven't killed the caster. The problem appears to be that Evasion is applied before the normal attack/defense check. But whatever the reason it's better to get hit than to interrupt backstabbing a stunned target.

Skills

The only points I really cared about were:
1 point stealing (for Denerim quests)
2 points Coercion
2 points Herbalism

After that, in order:
max Coercion
max Herbalism
max Poison

I didn't use traps or bombs.

I didn't use poison until after Landsmeet. Having no other use for my money, right before Landsmeet I bought ingredients for loads of health potions, Swift Salves, and Quiet Deaths. The buffs aren't strictly necessary, just convenient.

I didn't make any salves besides Swift Salves, but I hoarded whatever I came across.

Gear

I carried around three sets of gear.

default gear:
- The Rose's Thorn, Crow Dagger
- Helm of Honnleath
- Red Jenny Seekers (Backhands until Crows is finished)
- Felon's Coat (if unavailable: Senior Enchanter's Robes by default, Duster Armor for Overwhelm)
- Bard's Dancing Shoes
- Magister's Shield; Deadhead Charge for Web and knockdown attempts
- Harvest Festival Ring; Lifegiver for Overwhelm; Ring of Ages for Archdemon
- Key to the City (always on)

fire resist gear:
- Wade's Superior Drakeskin Armor, Gloves, Boots.

spell resist gear:
- Crow Daggers: 10% 8% 8% | 8% 6% 6% (or the best Dweomer runes you have)
- Spellward: 30%
- Ancient Elven Gloves: 4%
- Shielded Dwarven Armor: 4%
- Antivan Leather Boots: 4%
- Key to the City: 4%

Adding 10% for Dwarven spell resist makes 102%.

If your Crow Daggers are not Dragonbone with 3 rune slots, give them to a merchant to upgrade (I use Levi).

During Dead Trenches and the final battle sequence, swap in the two Grandmaster Silverites for the default gear set.

Ground Rules

- Don't use party members. If they are forced into your party, set their tactics to Self:Any -> Wait to avoid auto-attack.

- Don't use party members during peacetime for skills or talents.

- Don't split up enemy groups by luring.

- Don't call in armies during the final battle, except for the encounter where your character is not in the party. In this case all my party members were naked so I summoned Dwarves, which is why my screenshots say 44 Dwarves. I could have equipped them, but I didn't bother.

I violated the luring rule in two places: the fields of Lothering, and the three-Drake ambush at the goat cages. Otherwise I was not at all tempted to lure. With pumped Dex I didn't get hit much, and it's more fun to do it right. Much of the time I didn't even use stealth -- I just planted my butt in a corner and hacked away. Sometimes I didn't even bother using corners. I stood in the middle of the room and pounded on Witherfang, with hordes of werewolves jumping this way and that; not one hit me, nor did Witherfang.

I use the term "luring" as distinct from "pulling" because pulling refers to groups. You can't pull groups in Dragon Age. Luring (as I use the term) refers to drawing out individuals from a group, which is in my opinion an exploit. (Please, no arguments about luring here; take it up in the other thread.)

Regrets

- I wanted to do Deep Roads last, however I supported Harrowmont, causing the palace rooms to be locked, causing the Crows quests to blocked, causing Red Jenny Seekers to be unavailable. When I realized this I was too far along to redo it, but Backhands (10% crit damage instead of 15%) was good enough anyway.

- I forgot to buy Ring of Ages for the Archdemon. I don't enjoy chugging more potions than necessary.

- I thought the Sloth Demon might be impossible at 8th level, so I went paranoid and brewed 50 regular (not lesser) health potions. It turns out Slothy was quick and easy. Wasting money early in the game hurts. Plus, those 50 potions went unused throughout the game.

- Helm of Honnleath and Harvest Festival Ring are too uber. I got them at the beginning and rarely took them off. It's as if I payed money to rig the game in my favor. A play-through without any DLC items would feel more legitimate.

- I regret the two cases of luring. I probably could have hatched a plan with traps or something. I didn't use traps, and I didn't use salves or poisons until the end battle, so those options were unexplored. (I was obsessed with saving money.) The problem with Lothering is that in the open fields there are no walls (preferably corners) to cover your back, and enemies don't follow you into town. And the problem with Drakes is consecutive Overwhelms. Without Felon's Coat I can survive one Overwhelm, but not two or three. Yet traps + Rock Salve + Swift Salve + Quiet Death may have solved the problem.

Background

I've always done post-BG2 Bioware games solo. It's a way to make them more challenging since (after BG2) they are not really made for RPG strategists. (Please don't flame here; that's not the point.)

On my first play-through of Dragon Age I tried a solo assassin/duelist on Nightmare. I failed in most of the fights mentioned at the beginning of this post.

I also did quests in the exact wrong order. I looked on the DA wiki to see which daggers were nice, and I chose Dead Thaig Shanker from the Shale quest. Thus I did Orzammar first. Little did I know what was in store for me. Doing all of Deep Roads as a low-level solo rogue was absolutely exhausting. Each encounter had to be planned specially. I kept thinking the Shale quest (and my dagger) was just around the corner. Holy crap. I eventually resorted to luring, and I hated it. So that is the story behind the (now cringeworthy) post I made on luring.

And I did Circle Tower last, not knowing about the ability bonuses. Phooey.

On my second run I did Deep Roads last, which didn't require any luring. Pumping Dexterity yields disproportionately favorable results at higher levels. And doing Circle Tower first means you get Combat Stealth for free, and right when you need it.

I was glad to find reliable strategies which solve the problems I encountered, and I write this post to share them. I hope you found something useful.

Modifié par Naked Fury, 03 janvier 2010 - 03:44 .


#2
bas273

bas273
  • Members
  • 556 messages
Excellent guide! Well done, it was very useful.

I've completed two solo playthroughs: ArcaneWarrior/BloodMage and a DW Rogue. I'm now pretty far with my DW Warrior.

I used Master Stealth a lot (DW Rogue) and I regret that now. I activate stealth, kill an enemy mage, run around in circles and then activate stealth again. It feels like cheating to be able to use stealth during combat.

#3
knownastherat

knownastherat
  • Members
  • 625 messages
Excellent post! Good observations and advices. Thank you for putting it up.



Not much to add just a little (personal) comment. I would like it a bit more if you'd left out "judgments" as: cheap, or to do it right. I do realize, and you mentioned it several times, that it is how you "feel", but I believe the negative connotations are not needed to describe the adventure and challenge you went through.

#4
tmp7704

tmp7704
  • Members
  • 11 156 messages

Naked Fury wrote...

Lethality is last because the bonus is small.

If i remember right the bonus to crit chance from Lethality is 10% which effectively doubles the base value... wouldn't really call it small.

#5
ChaoticBroth

ChaoticBroth
  • Members
  • 431 messages
I remember making a solo DW Rogue (Assassin/Duelist), and I was bored one day, so I was just messing around with equipment. I found Cadash Stompers to actually be a decent set of boots, despite the fact that they provide 1% more fatigue.



Other than that, your guide is pretty good. It all varies with playstyles and whatnot, but I took Riposte somewhat early. The main use of Riposte was to switch to a different target while under pressure, stun him, then switch back to my original target. Somewhat tedious, but it saved my hide in several situations. That, and Mark of Death made several fights easier early on.



Too bad I scrapped that character.

#6
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages

tmp7704 wrote...

Naked Fury wrote...

Lethality is last because the bonus is small.

If i remember right the bonus to crit chance from Lethality is 10% which effectively doubles the base value... wouldn't really call it small.


At level 21 my base damage is 32.8. Lethality brings it to 33.9, an increase of 1.1 damage. And this is the tail end of damage output. For a low-Cunning rogue, this is the talent you take when there's nothing left to take.

When base damage is smaller, the Lethality bonus is going to be proportionately smaller. For low- to medium-level Dex-based rogues, damage output is pretty small, so Lethality bonus will be real small (remember, low Cunning). Definitely not worth 3 talents early on.

Modifié par Naked Fury, 03 janvier 2010 - 09:20 .


#7
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages

ChaoticBroth wrote...
It all varies with playstyles and whatnot, but I took Riposte somewhat early. The main use of Riposte was to switch to a different target while under pressure, stun him, then switch back to my original target. Somewhat tedious, but it saved my hide in several situations.

I have Dueling and Momentum running 24/7. When you factor in fatigue, I need to be pretty high-level for Riposte to be useful. If I can just barely fit in a Dirty Fighting followed by a Riposte then, well, that's nice, but then my stamina is gone and I can't stun again for a long time. Since Riposte is 1.6 times more expensive, I end up wishing I didn't use it.

But when you have stamina to spare, Riposte is great.

#8
huxley00

huxley00
  • Members
  • 22 messages
Good guide, Rogue is definitely made manageable by stealth, makes an insane difference. Now show me how to do this with a sword and board and I will be impressed!

#9
fantasypisces

fantasypisces
  • Members
  • 1 293 messages
Thanks I will give this a read over, maybe post some questions when I get it done. (mostly a shameless save for me to come back hehe)

#10
stillnotking

stillnotking
  • Members
  • 923 messages
Neat guide, thanks.  It's also interesting to read what tactics various people consider "cheesy".  I'm not surprised you had to split up some of the groups in Lothering.  Those encounters can be tough even in a four-person party, due to absence of ranged CC or some way to mitigate archer damage.

How come you keep Momentum running 24/7?  On my rogue I usually turned it off between fights, because it's an instant activation and by leaving it off you can make use of the stamina first.

Modifié par stillnotking, 04 janvier 2010 - 07:31 .


#11
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages

stillnotking wrote...
How come you keep Momentum running 24/7?  On my rogue I usually turned it off between fights, because it's an instant activation and by leaving it off you can make use of the stamina first.

Perhaps I've missed something. I don't see the advantage of turning off Momentum.

If you activate some talent then turn on Momentum, how is that different than having Momentum on beforehand then activating that other talent?

It even seems worse if you start with Momentum off. If you're activating talents while Momentum is off then you might not have any stamina left for Momentum when you need it. If Momentum is always on then you never face that possibility.

#12
stillnotking

stillnotking
  • Members
  • 923 messages

Naked Fury wrote...

stillnotking wrote...
How come you keep Momentum running 24/7?  On my rogue I usually turned it off between fights, because it's an instant activation and by leaving it off you can make use of the stamina first.

Perhaps I've missed something. I don't see the advantage of turning off Momentum.

If you activate some talent then turn on Momentum, how is that different than having Momentum on beforehand then activating that other talent?

It even seems worse if you start with Momentum off. If you're activating talents while Momentum is off then you might not have any stamina left for Momentum when you need it. If Momentum is always on then you never face that possibility.


Momentum is a sustained ability, and lowers your maximum stamina, not your current stamina -- unless your current stamina is higher than your maximum stamina minus the Momentum cost, in which case you waste some stamina.

Momentum, like all sustained abilities, can be activated at zero stamina.  It just lowers the maximum amount you can have.

#13
Rahelron

Rahelron
  • Members
  • 230 messages
Why did you kill the fade beast? She gives you 25 sovrans if you let her go and is not a though fight, one that you absolutely have to do to feel you have done your job.

#14
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages

stillnotking wrote...

Naked Fury wrote...

stillnotking wrote...
How come you keep Momentum running 24/7?  On my rogue I usually turned it off between fights, because it's an instant activation and by leaving it off you can make use of the stamina first.

Perhaps I've missed something. I don't see the advantage of turning off Momentum.

If you activate some talent then turn on Momentum, how is that different than having Momentum on beforehand then activating that other talent?

It even seems worse if you start with Momentum off. If you're activating talents while Momentum is off then you might not have any stamina left for Momentum when you need it. If Momentum is always on then you never face that possibility.


Momentum is a sustained ability, and lowers your maximum stamina, not your current stamina -- unless your current stamina is higher than your maximum stamina minus the Momentum cost, in which case you waste some stamina.

Momentum, like all sustained abilities, can be activated at zero stamina.  It just lowers the maximum amount you can have.

Oohhhh...sustained abilities can be activated at zero stamina. It's funny that I've played an embarrassing number of hours yet never noticed this (because I had Momentum on 24/7).

So I could do a Dirty Fighting and a Riposte, and even if that saps all my stamina I can still turn on Momentum. That doesn't change my argument about regretting using the more expensive Riposte at lower levels with a small amount of stamina reserve, but it certainly changes the equation.

Therefore I have to rethink everything I've said about Riposte. I'd even have to do another play-through in order to have a valid opinion about it.

Thanks for the clarification.

#15
Naked Fury

Naked Fury
  • Members
  • 40 messages

Rahelron wrote...

Why did you kill the fade beast? She gives you 25 sovrans if you let her go and is not a though fight, one that you absolutely have to do to feel you have done your job.

Well it would seem incomplete if I avoided a boss fight. I wanted to show that everything can be done. Who knows, someone might want to kill him for the XP. In my own playthrough I let him live.

#16
tetracycloide

tetracycloide
  • Members
  • 543 messages

Naked Fury wrote...

...
Ground Rules

- Don't split up enemy groups by luring.

...-- I just planted my butt in a corner and hacked away.


I'm not sure I follow a line of logic that begins with 'don't split up groups it's an exploit' and ends with 'use terrain to split up groups via spacing.'  I mean either way you're limiting the number of targets that can engage you at once, it's the same strategy achieved with only slight differences in tactics.

Also, RE: Lethality.  While the damage component is small on a low cunning rogue there is also the increase in critical chance to consider.  Espeically with the amount of time a solo rogue will spend not backstabbing.  Probably not enough to warrent moving it up in the priority list but it's still there.

Modifié par tetracycloide, 04 janvier 2010 - 06:07 .


#17
knownastherat

knownastherat
  • Members
  • 625 messages
Indeed, that is why I commented on the negative connotations. Anyone who knows the game well enough knows what possible is and what not.

This is not a game of skill, in the traditional sense, this is a game of knowledge in the first place. Two players managing characters with same attributes, skills, talents differ only/mainly in their approach to tasks at hand, not in faster/slower hand-eye coordination, not in ability to execute combos or special moves through pressing of several buttons in specific order in specific interval, not in robot-like aim, not in any human based skill except ability to solve problems.

If someone claims s/he does not use cheap pulling or luring or whatever for example and plays it like a man (sry women ..) rushing into a pack of enemies fighting them all at once head to head, I know s/he is a liar because if I cannot do it, nobody can and it is not because I am godly, but simply because the game mechanics do not allow for it.

Of course soloing, and other challenges which push players to limits, require what I call unconventional approaches which can be labeled as cheap, wrong, exploits, whatever and from where I sit there is no shame to admit it.

It is possible to describe an event without giving it/suggesting any positive/negative undertones.

edit: how come having so high Dex that almost nobody can touch me is not cheap?  .. is not that a God mode? .. pointless debate.

Modifié par knownastherat, 04 janvier 2010 - 06:40 .


#18
Zecele

Zecele
  • Members
  • 114 messages

I'm not sure I follow a line of logic that begins with 'don't split up groups it's an exploit' and ends with 'use terrain to split up groups via spacing.' I mean either way you're limiting the number of targets that can engage you at once, it's the same strategy achieved with only slight differences in tactics.




I don't think they're the same at all. Luring seems cheesy to me because I find it hard to believe that when I shoot that Hurlock and move around a corner the other one standing right next to him doesn't react at all. That's taking advantage of spotty AI.



Parking yourself in a corner (or doorway) so you can't be flanked and only fight one mob at a time is classic military strategy.

#19
knownastherat

knownastherat
  • Members
  • 625 messages
Yes, that is your opinion or as I would call it fallacy ;) You try to apply some/yours/know from the so-called real world "logic" to a virtual game without realizing or accepting other people can have their own "logic". So how is yours .. better? Because it is classic military strategy? Gimme a break ..

edit: Playing to win - www.sirlin.net/articles/playing-to-win-part-1.html

"The scrub would take great issue with this statement for he usually believes that he is playing to win, but he is bound up by an intricate construct of fictitious rules that prevent him from ever truly competing. These made-up rules vary from game to game, of course, but their character remains constant. In Street Fighter, for example, the
scrub labels a wide variety of tactics and situations "cheap."

So-called "cheapness" is truly the mantra of the scrub. Performing a throw on someone often called cheap. A throw is a special kind of move that grabs an opponent and damages him, even when the opponent is defending against all other kinds of attacks. The entire purpose of the throw is to be able to damage an opponent who sits and blocks and doesn't attack. As far as the game is concerned, throwing is an integral part of the design--it's meant to be there--yet the scrub has constructed his own set of principles in his mind that state he should be totally impervious to all attacks while blocking. The scrub thinks of blocking as a kind of magic shield which will protect him indefinitely. Why? Exploring the reasoning is futile since the notion is ridiculous from the start."

Modifié par knownastherat, 04 janvier 2010 - 07:07 .


#20
Zecele

Zecele
  • Members
  • 114 messages

Yes, that is your opinion or as I would call it fallacy ;) You try to apply some/yours/know from the so-called real world "logic" to a virtual game without realizing or accepting other people can have their own "logic". So how is yours .. better? Because it is classic military strategy? Gimme a break ..


Well for starters when I use words like "I think" and "it seems to me" that's meant to be an expression of my own opinion without devaluing your own position. If I wanted to say your logic sucked and mine was better I would have simply said your logic sucks and mine is better :P.

Second, I'll wager that I've correctly pegged why the OP considers luring cheesy as opposed to doorway/corner fighting and was just trying to explain what I (and he probably) consider the subtle difference...I.E. I consider one a viable tactic for reducing the advantage a numerically superior enemy has on you while I consider the other borderlline exploitation of bad AI.

Modifié par Zecele, 04 janvier 2010 - 07:02 .


#21
Zecele

Zecele
  • Members
  • 114 messages

edit: Playing to win - www.sirlin.net/articles/playing-to-win-part-1.html


That article isn't really applicable for this kind of discussion. The author has a very specific audience he's talking to which is people playing competitive multiplayer games. He's basically saying that all's fair in Player vs Player and only scrubs complain otherwise.

He's not waxing about the difference between how you fight a computer AI opponent.

That kind of article has more of a place in a player vs player discussion. Just for the record I agree with what that author says 100% in a PvP context. If the game allows it I consider it fair.  I use line of sight "luring" in PvP all the time in WoW.  I'm quite a champ at it really and it earns me numerous whispers from anonymous level 1's.  Players have a brain behind them though.

Modifié par Zecele, 04 janvier 2010 - 07:14 .


#22
knownastherat

knownastherat
  • Members
  • 625 messages
If there is no "cheap" in competitive gaming, if there is only situation to be solved, my "logic" tells me there is no "cheap" in single player game either.

#23
Zecele

Zecele
  • Members
  • 114 messages

If there is no "cheap" in competitive gaming, if there is only situation to be solved, my "logic" tells me there is no "cheap" in single player game either.


I'll say this last bit and then drop it. Learned quite a while ago what arguing on internet forums accomplishes.

I think we've got differing definitions of cheap. I consider combat stealth "cheap" to some extent. Do I use it? Hells yeah. I consider trapping a room while stealthed "cheap" yet I do that with abandon too. I'm all for employing cheap tactics.

However, when you shoot a mob in a group of three and only the one you shot reacts I don't consider that cheap. I consider that broken AI and I consider that exploiting said AI.  That specific situation is what started this little side tangent and it seems we've taken the scope way beyond what my opionion on that isolated incident was/is.

Modifié par Zecele, 04 janvier 2010 - 08:01 .


#24
tetracycloide

tetracycloide
  • Members
  • 543 messages

Zecele wrote...

I don't think they're the same at all. Luring seems cheesy to me because I find it hard to believe that when I shoot that Hurlock and move around a corner the other one standing right next to him doesn't react at all. That's taking advantage of spotty AI.

Parking yourself in a corner (or doorway) so you can't be flanked and only fight one mob at a time is classic military strategy.



Divide and conquer is a classic military strategy.  Cutting off flanking angles or using feints and terrain to lure small groups away from a larger force are both classic military tactics that achieve this strategy.

However, what would or would not happen in 'reality' is irrelevant since these situations are not played out in reality but within the arbitrary construct of a game.  Functionally both tactics achieve the same overall strategy in that they prevent the player from being attacked by an entire group at once.

#25
Zecele

Zecele
  • Members
  • 114 messages

Divide and conquer is a classic military strategy. Cutting off flanking angles or using feints and terrain to lure small groups away from a larger force are both classic military tactics that achieve this strategy.




Sure it is but again we're not talking about feinting and manuevering. We're not even talking about luring one whole room of mobs into another room (a completely viable tactic).



We're talking about shooting a person and the person right next to him doesn't react at all.