78 réponses à ce sujet

[AresKeith]

^ and why should I ****** off?

[Eterna]

AresKeith wrote...

^ and why should I ****** off?

Because you won't have angry sex with me. 

[AshenShug4r]

Spawnfreak73 wrote...

arial wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

You can fight like a Krogan, run like a leopard, but you'll never be better than Commander Shepard!

everyone on these forums is better then Commander Shepard.

Shepard is a fictional character

Real Life > Fictional Story.

  You can keep your reality that'sriddled with famine and disease. I'll take my world of Biotic powers and blue alien lesbians over your reality anyday of the week.

You can have your reapers, illogical AI children, batarians, husks, banshees and threat of galactic extinction.

[Iakus]

magnetite wrote...

iakus wrote...

The part where they said it would be darker than the "dark second act"

And you made the assertion, it's up to you to back it up.

You need me to actually prove to you that the third game was darker than the second one?

Okay, well if billions dead across the galaxy and such doesn't sound dark and depressing and people having lost their loved ones, I don't know what is.

No.  I need you to back up your assertion that " they even mentioned this before the game was released, that the third chapter was going to be much darker than previous games." 

They did call ME2 the "dark second act" I recall no such assertion about ME3

Bonus points if you can tell me how this justifies railroading Shepard's death.

[AlanC9]

So...... after all that fuss, has the board finally come around to thinking that the main problem people have with the endings is that they're not happy enough?

If so, I'm owed some apologies.

[Andres Hendrix]

arial wrote...

let me grab my Magic 8-ball...

Ohh Wonderful Magic 8-ball, will this thread end up being locked

*Shakes magic 8-ball*

...yeah its gonna be locked....

I do not think consulting a "magic 8 ball" makes you a proponent of reality ... Good luck with your atrocious brand of sarcasm. [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/sick.png[/smilie]

Modifié par Andres Hendrix, 15 novembre 2012 - 04:27 .

[AdmiralCheez]

AlanC9 wrote...

So...... after all that fuss, has the board finally come around to thinking that the main problem people have with the endings is that they're not happy enough?.

No, not really.  There are too many problems with ME3's ending to single out one specific thing.

MEHEM is great not because it's "happy," but because it's sweet, simple, and uplifting.  A really sad ending can still be uplifting (explaining how involves invoking Greek drama and the notion of emotional catharsis), and an ending with everyone peaceful and happy and smiling can still be unfulfilling (Synthesis).

[xsdob]

What mods can't do? Allow multiple ending choices and work on the console. Also have original content that isn't from the other games. Also not have a sequence that doesn't rely on jump cuts and fades. Also, have shepard not wearing blood soaked and damaged armor, even though he's suppose to be honoring his dead mentor and friend.

[MrFob]

xsdob wrote...
... Also, have shepard not wearing blood soaked and damaged armor, even though he's suppose to be honoring his dead mentor and friend.

I wasn't going to post in this thread but patience is a virtue my friend.

[xsdob]

MrFob wrote...

xsdob wrote...
... Also, have shepard not wearing blood soaked and damaged armor, even though he's suppose to be honoring his dead mentor and friend.

I wasn't going to post in this thread but patience is a virtue my friend.

Now that's more like it. All we need to now is adress all the other points I made.

I'll wait for the modder to finish, I got a few years to kill anyway.

[DeinonSlayer]

iakus wrote...

No.  I need you to back up your assertion that " they even mentioned this before the game was released, that the third chapter was going to be much darker than previous games."

They did call ME2 the "dark second act" I recall no such assertion about ME3

Did you expect the Reaper War to be bright and cheerful compared to what their pawns were doing in the lead-up to it?

iakus wrote...

Bonus points if you can tell me how this justifies railroading Shepard's death.

They didn't. Some people simply refuse to accept that, and demand that Bioware rescue them from their own miserable headcanons.

I'm not defending the writing here, but good God man... how long is this gonna go on? You've gotta come to terms with it at some point.

[Iakus]

AlanC9 wrote...

So...... after all that fuss, has the board finally come around to thinking that the main problem people have with the endings is that they're not happy enough?

If so, I'm owed some apologies.

Well, people certainly insist on trying to oversimplify it that way. 

But while yes, MEHEM does finally give a real alternative to "Shepard's the hero, and therefore, must die" mentality, it also neatly amputates the Catalyst form the story, thus unloading a sizable chunk of the insane troll  logic and galactic war crimes the original and EC endings saddled us with.

[AresKeith]

^ nobody has a problem headcanoning the rest of Shepards life, the problem is how they ended othe only ending where Shepard is supposed to live

[Iakus]

DeinonSlayer wrote...
Did you expect the Reaper War to be bright and cheerful compared to what their pawns were doing in the lead-up to it?

That's deflecting, not answering the question

I'm not defending the writing here, but good God man... how long is this gonna go on? You've gotta come to terms with it at some point.

It will go on as long as people keep asserting that "Happy endings are so cliche and predictable, they have no place in a war story" like this is some sort of universal truth.

[DeinonSlayer]

iakus wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...
Did you expect the Reaper War to be bright and cheerful compared to what their pawns were doing in the lead-up to it?

That's deflecting, not answering the question

I'm not addressing the question - I'm asking, what did you honestly expect?

iakus wrote...

I'm not defending the writing here, but good God man... how long is this gonna go on? You've gotta come to terms with it at some point.

It will go on as long as people keep asserting that "Happy endings are so cliche and predictable, they have no place in a war story" like this is some sort of universal truth.

Then I suspect you'll be here for a very, very long time. There will always be someone saying that. You can't change everybody's minds.

[JPR1964]

iakus wrote...

Well, people certainly insist on trying to oversimplify it that way. 

But while yes, MEHEM does finally give a real alternative to "Shepard's the hero, and therefore, must die" mentality, it also neatly amputates the Catalyst form the story, thus unloading a sizable chunk of the insane troll  logic and galactic war crimes the original and EC endings saddled us with.

Because MEE and MEHE I probably start playing again this craphorse game : removing starbrat is a real smart move for me!

JPR out!

[sUiCiDeKiNgS13]

Other than Sheploo's very feminine walk and hip tworking, I like that mod

[Humanoid_Typhoon]

arial wrote...

MegaSovereign wrote...

Real life has no replay value. The AI sucks too. People go down in like one shot.

well of course it doesn't have replay value, it is constantly being updated and added to, as a result there is always more to do, and it makes 100% it a real challenge.

Do I get to pick three different colors? I think not.

[Ironhandjustice]

rollblows wrote...

what was that Monstrosity
what did i just watch

Still a better ending. By far.

[Iakus]

[quote]DeinonSlayer wrote...
]I'm not addressing the question - I'm asking, what did you honestly expect?[/quote]

Fair enough.  Honestly I was expecting Earn Your Happy Ending, something this mod finally provides.

[quote]iakus wrote...

It will go on as long as people keep asserting that "Happy endings are so cliche and predictable, they have no place in a war story" like this is some sort of universal truth.[/quote]Then I suspect you'll be here for a very, very long time. There will always be someone saying that. You can't change everybody's minds.
[/quote]

"I prefer war stories that have sad endings"= valid statement
"Happy endings have no place in a war story"=not a valid statement.

But you're right.  If I addressed every troll who spewed a deliberately provocative phrase in the hopes of squeezing out more tears to drink, I'd be doing nothing but posting responses here.  I have my ending, and it can't be taken away from me.  It can only get better with more updates.  Sadly, some bridge dwellers are adept at pushing my buttons.  I'll try to restrain myself in the future.

[Sable Rhapsody]

iakus wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...
]I'm not addressing the question - I'm asking, what did you honestly expect?

Fair enough.  Honestly I was expecting Earn Your Happy Ending, something this mod finally provides.

Same.  If I wanted to experience a horrible universe where war is inevitable and everyone dies forever, I'd play some Dark Heresy.  Or hell, pick up A Song of Ice and Fire again.

Modifié par Sable Rhapsody, 15 novembre 2012 - 08:08 .

[Jadebaby]

MegaSovereign wrote...

Real life has no replay value. The AI sucks too. People go down in like one shot.

LOL

[Catroi]

I thought you got banned by Origin if you modded your game?