202 réponses à ce sujet

[thibaut72]

Rojahar wrote...

Isn't there already a free mage state? Called the Tevinter Imperium?

Tevinter is not a good exemple of free mage state. Murders, slavery and other atrocities are bad things when happen in a state. However, it's possible to make a mage state that follow Andraste's teaching, and not those deviant teaching of the templars.

[ElvaliaRavenHart]

ImperatorMortis wrote...

Mr.House wrote...
Yjere are many places where the veil is thin or gone because of magic. Tevinter is also not a free mage state as it has the Black Chantry. Leavings mages with no one to watch them or police them would be a disaster.

And there are many places the veil is thin because of nothing that had anything to do with magic. The veil can be thinned/broken by mass bloodshed of any kind. Wars, genocide, blood magic rituals. Its all the same. 

Examples are the Brecilian Forest, and the Abanadoned Orphanage. Not everything is magics fault. 

ElvaliaRavenHart wrote...

No way I'd support this unless all mages are sent to some type of Circle of Magi School to study magic properly. With their families being allowed to visit or the mage allowed to visit his/her family. I do think their needs to be some type of Templar oversight, to hunt mages that go rogue into blood magic. Thedas will need to have Templars to fight cosmic forces when the Veil is torn

Hey guess what? Of course they would bloody teach mages how to study magic properly. Freakin APOSTATES teach other mages how to study magic properly. This doesn't even to be brought up. If this free mage state happened they're teachings would most likely function like regular schools. Go to classes during the day, then come home. 

No Free Mage State is gonna replicate the Circle exactly. The way the Circle works now is part of the problem. 

ElvaliaRavenHart wrote...
Wardens could also be used to help fight/hunt rogue mages who turn to blood magic even though Wardens need mages and the use of bloodmagic to fight darkspawn. I feel Wardens do a better job than templars. This would really come down to each Warden Commander and The First Warden's views.

So should the Templars and Wardens join forces?

No. Thats stupid, and makes no sense. Warden's don't care about apostates, or blood mages. The Grey Warden Order was created by Blood Mages. The only thing the Grey Wardens care about are Darkspawn. Its been stated multiple times that they don't really give a **** about anyone elses problems. 

Also you think the Mages in the Grey Wardens are gonna wanna help? Hell no, and seriously.. What makes you think Grey Wardens are more suited to hunting down Apostates? They have no magic resistance. This makes no sense. 

Its not gonna happen. 

Not all apostate mages are going to teach another mage proper magic, your assuming this is true.  Velanna in DAA didn't want to discuss magic with Anders and share knowledge.   It would depend on the mages involved.  So you're just assuming.  Sorry but Wardens, do care about apostate mages, why because they need them to fight darkspawn.  Mages are important to the Warden Order.  

Send mages who turn to bloodmagic over to the Wardens where they are needed and can be of use and not use their bloodmagic against the general population.  Wardens who hear of mages that have gone over into bloodmagic, should hunt and recruit them into the order.  Templars/seekers should turn blood mages over to Wardens or kill them outright.

Modifié par ElvaliaRavenHart, 06 décembre 2012 - 07:15 .

[Herr Uhl]

thibaut72 wrote...

Rojahar wrote...

Isn't there already a free mage state? Called the Tevinter Imperium?

Tevinter is not a good exemple of free mage state. Murders, slavery and other atrocities are bad things when happen in a state. However, it's possible to make a mage state that follow Andraste's teaching, and not those deviant teaching of the templars.

But Tevinter is Andrastian.