115 réponses à ce sujet

[Edolix]

Jacob.

=p

[futurepixels]

ZeCollectorDestroya wrote...

If you like Lesbians, then go with Liara or Samantha.
If you have a life, then go with nothing.

These two are not mutually exclusive.

[Abraham_uk]

I made the mistake of dating Jacob.


Let's just say, saying "I'm more interested in talking for a bit" in a sultry voice scared him off into the arms of another woman.

Modifié par Abraham_uk, 14 décembre 2012 - 09:20 .

[TMZuk]

I wish that James Vega was an option for Femshep. He makes me laugh so hard with his insolence and provocative remarks.

Kaiden is boring, Jacob even more so. Garus is fine but well... just to alien. Thane was alright, though rather to alien as well. His romance was pretty uninteresting. I can understand why those who exclusively plays female characters finds the options a bit underwhelming.

Maleshep has Ashley, who has a bite. Liara.. well Femshep has her to, but being a man, and then play a lesbian is just to predictable. Anyway, Liara... she never caught my interest. Miranda. Yummy! Jack. The Psycotic Biotic. Adorable with all her anger issues.

[chasemme]

Romance Kaidan, Leave him on Virmire.

Romance Garrus, send him into the vents.

Romance Liara, finish the game with low EMS.

[Solas]

Garrus.

[carine]

Kaidan with a faithful FemShep in ME3 is my favorite by far. He also has a good romance scene, as opposed to Garrus's pre-Cerberus HQ scene. Garrus still has a good progressive romance -- like a friends with benefits to true relationship arc, but Kaidan's will always be the best in my opinion.

Can't say anything for Liara. I've never romanced her.

[M2S SOLID JOSH]

liara and if not choose garrus

[Lenimph]

Liara or Garrus.

Kaidan is boring.

Thane romance is still interesting too IMO even if he *spoilers*

Modifié par Lenimph, 15 décembre 2012 - 10:20 .

[medusa_hair]

I am also starting a 1-2-3 playthrough and I am also having trouble...Here's why:

ME3 #1 - My Shepard had no romance in ME2 so I picked Kaidan (lesbian not interesting to me so obviously choice was limited ).  I thought it was fine, the pre-cerberus scene was good, the goodbye was very sad.  Overall though I thought he was kind of a weenie half the time.

ME3 #2 - My Shepard romanced Thane in ME2, which reunion I was looking forward to and was sadly disappointed by.  I could not bring myself to go with Kaidan after that.  He just couldn't match "the voice"! 

Since I did not romance Garrus in any of my 4 ME2 playthroughs (I guess I was just drawn to big eyes and THE VOICE), I think I will remain celibate in ME1 and go for Garrus in ME2 and beyond.  He is very cool.

I liked all the conversations with Thane and I felt he was more mature and had a prior life that was beyond our experience.  You could go with Kaidan ME1/Thane ME2/Kaidan ME3.  Or Kaidan ME1/Garrus ME2 & 3.

[ZeCollectorDestroya]

futurepixels wrote...

ZeCollectorDestroya wrote...

If you like Lesbians, then go with Liara or Samantha.
If you have a life, then go with nothing.

These two are not mutually exclusive.

Burn

[d-boy15]

if you don't want lesbo and xeno romance then I suggest you go with kaidan.

well, just don't mind him when he smile...

anyway, my femshep playthrough didn't romance anyone. 

Modifié par d-boy15, 16 décembre 2012 - 05:46 .

[Billea]

I'd go with Liara or Garrus.
Haven't romanced Kaiden, so I can't comment on his romance arc. Samantha's arc is alright, as is Thane's. 
If none of those options work, there's always Jacob 

[NoForgiveness]

Liara shes got the cute science nerd thing and shes a virgin. plus girl on girl can actually be beautiful and not just a hot ****. also the asari melding thing is kool it allows them to have sex with anothers soul and not just body.
 also i see theres alot of garrus going around but personally i like him as a bestie. him being sheps right hand fits his character better i think. hes an incredibly loyal person and i think the daryl dixon position really works

Modifié par MR_PN, 16 décembre 2012 - 06:08 .

[Kaidan Fan]

carine wrote...

Kaidan with a faithful FemShep in ME3 is my favorite by far. He also has a good romance scene, as opposed to Garrus's pre-Cerberus HQ scene. Garrus still has a good progressive romance -- like a friends with benefits to true relationship arc, but Kaidan's will always be the best in my opinion.

Can't say anything for Liara. I've never romanced her.

Agree 100% with this.  Kaidan is by far the best imo.  Garrus is a very close 2nd. 

[Thrazesul]

Well, I'd say Thane in ME2, since he was nice before they ruined his character in ME3.

But, Garrus is for me the best. They really seem to connect and act as real partners.

I haven't played Kaidan's or Liara's romance at all.

[ImDedicatedToMyApologies]

I accidentally get my shep into a relationship with liara... well I'm not saying I disrelish her, I was just speaking to her pretty frequent on the presidium when I step by to shop...


I'll go for garrus, if only he didn't die in my suicide mission...

Modifié par U H E, 16 décembre 2012 - 11:48 .

[ImDedicatedToMyApologies]

Thrazesul wrote...

Well, I'd say Thane in ME2, since he was nice before they ruined his character in ME3.

But, Garrus is for me the best. They really seem to connect and act as real partners.

I haven't played Kaidan's or Liara's romance at all.

what do u mean, "they ruined his character"? 

PS: I was gonna say *that* , but then I realized, no spoiler...

[Gilsa]

Both Kaidan and Garrus are really, really well done. There is no "one is better than the other" when it comes to those two.

If you'd like to see a romance that gets tested by the events of the game and provides will-they-or-won't-they drama, then go for Kaidan. If you'd like to see a romance that defies all odds and expectations (a turian and a human ... can it be done?), to see how love grows from a simple friendship to discovering that they've found their soulmate in the damnest of all places, then go for Garrus.

Edit: Don't view the fact that Garrus' romance comes late in ME2 as a disadvantage. Kaidan is on the sidelines for ME2 so both characters still only have active romances for 2 out of 3 games. Garrus is just available as a squadmate for all three, that's all.

Modifié par Gilsa, 16 décembre 2012 - 11:59 .

[Joran Anduril]

someone else wrote...

Kaidan...for greatest continuity through the triology - but femshep has fewer options than broshep, and none of the ME2 options really carry through to ME3 - Garrus is a great charactder, but the "romance" seems a little too much like buddy sex than a deep involvment...Liara's just works too well with my male sheps to make the switch credibly...

Disagree about Garrus - it's an awkward romance in ME2, but I think it grows into something quite lovely and meaningful in ME3.  My only Femshep playthrough is a Garrus romance, and I can't really imagine romancing anyone else.  A faithful to Kaidan playthrough might be worth seeing, but I find his romance the dullest of the ME1 romances (I've played them all), so I haven't been able to resist Garrus.

Modifié par Joran Anduril, 17 décembre 2012 - 02:23 .

[Asch Lavigne]

If you think by not romancing Garrus in 1 that you miss out on anything, you're wrong. With the romance in ME2 you have the opportunity to watch their relationship turn from mentor and student to friend (and still a bit of a mentor) and you see Garrus show a lot of respect for Shep, into a romance. For me it was a better transition then two conversations in and other LIs want you. I mean you hardly know them at that point.

I thought the relationship between Garrus and FemShep grew really well.

[Patchwork]

Faithful Kaidan and Garrus romances are pretty equal in awesome. The first is an against the odds/how much can we take epic while the second is more friends who realise they have the potential to be so much more, a soulmate discovery.

I don't know about Liara she's simply a character type that doesn't appeal to me. I do know that going through a game knowing you're not going to romance anybody is freeing RP-wise.

[someone else]

Joran Anduril wrote...

someone else wrote...

Kaidan...for greatest continuity through the triology - but femshep has fewer options than broshep, and none of the ME2 options really carry through to ME3 - Garrus is a great charactder, but the "romance" seems a little too much like buddy sex than a deep involvment...Liara's just works too well with my male sheps to make the switch credibly...

Disagree about Garrus - it's an awkward romance in ME2, but I think it grows into something quite lovely and meaningful in ME3.  My only Femshep playthrough is a Garrus romance, and I can't really imagine romancing anyone else.  A faithful to Kaidan playthrough might be worth seeing, but I find his romance the dullest of the ME1 romances (I've played them all), so I haven't been able to resist Garrus.

wrong in one particular at least - dullest romance priiiiize goes to...may I have the envelope, please?

[Joran Anduril]

I meant of the three ME1 romances. I have played all three, and I thought Kaidan's was dreadfully dull. But I may give him another chance, because several people have said that the ME3 Kaidan romance is terrific if you stayed faithful.

But yeah, worst overall romance of the trilogy award definitely goes to the priiiiiize. Isn't that why they chose Jacob as the cheater - the gameplay data revealed that virtually no players chose him as their LI?

[AlanC9]

Kaidan/Thane/Kaidan worked pretty well for one of my FemSheps. Liara's pretty good too, but I guess not to the OP's tastes/