Killdren88 wrote...
Agreed. Synthesis is just a prettier word for Forced Eugenics via space magic. I'm slow trust and accept something some of the worse people in history wanted as well.
111987 wrote...
I'm not arguing you should choose Synthesis. I'm refuting inaccurate claims about it.
And like you said, it doesn't remove differences. And in fact, it doesn't change the understanding of organics. It changes Synthetics understanding of organics. It is an addition to their knowledge, not a change in it. No mass indoctrination going on here.
iakus wrote...
Xilizhra wrote...
Shepard's implants, other cyborging, biotic implants, etc.Rifneno wrote...
::image snipped::
Natural progression, which are both optional to individuals and are technology the galaxy understands and is ready for.
Nobody knew what teh Crucible did or how to activate it until teh Catalyst stepped in. Heck no one knew what it did while they were building it using the equivalent of Dick and Jane instructions left by the Protheans.
The Night Mammoth wrote...
111987 wrote...
I'm not arguing you should choose Synthesis. I'm refuting inaccurate claims about it.
And like you said, it doesn't remove differences. And in fact, it doesn't change the understanding of organics. It changes Synthetics understanding of organics. It is an addition to their knowledge, not a change in it. No mass indoctrination going on here.
An addition that changes their entire understanding of organic life to prevent an apparent inevitability.
That's indoctrination. They've been changed to think in a different way about organics.
I'm pretty sure, certain, almost, that the same thing happens vice versa, organics change to understand organics. That's made pretty clear in the epilogue.
Wayning_Star wrote...
somone/thing knew, but it's important, that Shep didn't get to find out...ever?!?
"We are not ready" is the eternal defense of the traditionalist. We learn to handle things after we have acquired them, not before. It has always been so.ziloe wrote...
The races are not ready for it. They do not understand its responsibilities. Understanding or not, another war would eventually be inevitable, because someone with their newfound power, would want to find themselves the superior race.
Modifié par Ieldra2, 23 décembre 2012 - 06:43 .
iakus wrote...
Wayning_Star wrote...
somone/thing knew, but it's important, that Shep didn't get to find out...ever?!?
I't s important that Shepard (and the galaxy at large) learn for themselves. Not take shortcuts.
SpamBot2000 wrote...
There are no organics to gain an understanding post-green beam. That's what many find an abomination. The permanent end to organic life. Replaced by something else.
Killdren88 wrote...
SpamBot2000 wrote...
There are no organics to gain an understanding post-green beam. That's what many find an abomination. The permanent end to organic life. Replaced by something else.
And thus the Reapers Permantly win.
SpamBot2000 wrote...
There are no organics to gain an understanding post-green beam. That's what many find an abomination. The permanent end to organic life. Replaced by something else.
SpamBot2000 wrote...
Killdren88 wrote...
SpamBot2000 wrote...
There are no organics to gain an understanding post-green beam. That's what many find an abomination. The permanent end to organic life. Replaced by something else.
And thus the Reapers Permantly win.
Pretty much.
Ieldra2 wrote...
"We are not ready" is the eternal defense of the traditionalist. We learn to handle things after we have acquired them, not before. It has always been so.ziloe wrote...
The races are not ready for it. They do not understand its responsibilities. Understanding or not, another war would eventually be inevitable, because someone with their newfound power, would want to find themselves the superior race.
Ah, and no progression is more natural than another. Technology exchange, by trade or by force, has been the norm for all of human history.
Ieldra2 wrote...
"We are not ready" is the eternal defense of the traditionalist. We learn to handle things after we have acquired them, not before. It has always been so.ziloe wrote...
The races are not ready for it. They do not understand its responsibilities. Understanding or not, another war would eventually be inevitable, because someone with their newfound power, would want to find themselves the superior race.
Ah, and no progression is more natural than another. Technology exchange, by trade or by force, has been the norm for all of human history.
Ieldra2 wrote...
"We are not ready" is the eternal defense of the traditionalist. We learn to handle things after we have acquired them, not before. It has always been so.ziloe wrote...
The races are not ready for it. They do not understand its responsibilities. Understanding or not, another war would eventually be inevitable, because someone with their newfound power, would want to find themselves the superior race.
Ah, and no progression is more natural than another. Technology exchange, by trade or by force, has been the norm for all of human history.
kal_reegar wrote...
Synthesis is neither good or evil
The only two negative things can be:
- reapers are alive and FREE. It they want, they can be the dominat specie and rule the galaxy. For sometimes, at least. In any case, they could be a really serious problem even now. Or maybe not, who knows.
- like Legion once said, accepting "from above" one other's technology blinds that race/civilization to only one path and does not allow them to find their own unique way of solving a problem. I agree with that. Going from A to Z is not always the best choice.
and, but this is my personal taste, it's very unaesthetic. Glowing eyes, half synthetic leaves and sexbot becoming real person... maker help us all...
but these are just speculations.
Galbrant wrote...
Before you know when the Bo- *ahem* Synthesize Galaxy visit organic galaxies ones the first they will say "Resistance is futile."
Galbrant wrote...
Before you know when the Bo- *ahem* Synthesize Galaxy visit organic galaxies ones the first they will say "Resistance is futile."
Guest_Finn the Jakey_*
OperatingWookie wrote...
FemaleMageFan wrote...
OP didn't ask for this
I take it he's against the entire theme of transhumanism that existed in Mass Effect 2.
They will create massive factories to nearby galaxies, where they brainwash new civilizationgs under reaper-control. "Synthesis is soooo beautiful"Wayning_Star wrote...
Galbrant wrote...
Before you know when the Bo- *ahem* Synthesize Galaxy visit organic galaxies ones the first they will say "Resistance is futile."
How could we know, how could we ever really be sure?
Finn the Jakey wrote...
OperatingWookie wrote...
FemaleMageFan wrote...
OP didn't ask for this
I take it he's against the entire theme of transhumanism that existed in Mass Effect 2.
You mean like this?
1!NO TROLLS NO TROLLS NO TROLLS!1!Wayning_Star wrote...
everyone chant!!
!!NO TOOLS NO TOOLS NO TOOLS!!!
(ie, hippy movement?)
Retour en haut