Jade8aby88 wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
Interesting. Where is your proof that this peace will last forever?
thats not how it works. The game specifically stated that they are at race. You are the one suggesting it being last. Burden f roof falls on you to prove it won't, which you have failed to do so.
Guest_frudi_*
Good, we're making progress, we've actually established that holo-****** is just making sh*t upEterna5 wrote...
Your being a tad dumb. There is no event of a Synthetic race completely wiping out all organics because if that was the case the Catalyst would have failed in its purpose.
Versus Omnibus wrote...
I'm not saying it's the best solution; I'm just saying I understand what he was trying to do.
frudi wrote...
In la-la land, playing checkers with your proof of how synthetics will inevitably wipe out all organics...Eterna5 wrote...
Interesting. Where is your proof that this peace will last forever?
frudi wrote...
Good, we're making progress, we've actually established that holo-****** is just making sh*t upEterna5 wrote...
Your being a tad dumb. There is no event of a Synthetic race completely wiping out all organics because if that was the case the Catalyst would have failed in its purpose.
Jade8aby88 wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
Interesting. Where is your proof that this peace will last forever?
thats not how it works. The game specifically stated that they are at peace. You are the one suggesting it wont last. Burden of proof falls on you to prove it won't, which you have failed to do so.
@zecollectordestroya. If you honestly expect me to read your posts when you include veiled insults you can go jump.
Eterna5 wrote...
BleedingUranium wrote...
Bottom line, the Reapers use organics by turning them into goo to make more Reapers, the villain of any story will tell the hero whatever helps his cause, usually by lying. It'd be hard to find a villain that doesn't do that.
The cycles are Reaper reproduction, nothing more.
With the intent of preserving organic life.
Jade8aby88 wrote...
When you make the peace on rannoch..........
Modifié par Festae9, 01 janvier 2013 - 11:44 .
Eterna5 wrote...
frudi wrote...
In la-la land, playing checkers with your proof of how synthetics will inevitably wipe out all organics...Eterna5 wrote...
Interesting. Where is your proof that this peace will last forever?
I don't need to prove it. The Catalyst even says he was programmed by those who believed extinction from Synthetics was inevitable. The occurences of Synthetice rebelling against their creators is enough to justify his creators ideals and logic.
BleedingUranium wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
BleedingUranium wrote...
Bottom line, the Reapers use organics by turning them into goo to make more Reapers, the villain of any story will tell the hero whatever helps his cause, usually by lying. It'd be hard to find a villain that doesn't do that.
The cycles are Reaper reproduction, nothing more.
With the intent of preserving organic life.
Ah yes, "preserving organic life"; we have dismissed that claim.
Guest_frudi_*
Well I understand what Hitler was trying to do... so where does that leave us?Versus Omnibus wrote...
I'm not saying it's the best solution; I'm just saying I understand what he was trying to do.
Modifié par frudi, 01 janvier 2013 - 11:45 .
Jade8aby88 wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
frudi wrote...
In la-la land, playing checkers with your proof of how synthetics will inevitably wipe out all organics...Eterna5 wrote...
Interesting. Where is your proof that this peace will last forever?
I don't need to prove it. The Catalyst even says he was programmed by those who believed extinction from Synthetics was inevitable. The occurences of Synthetice rebelling against their creators is enough to justify his creators ideals and logic.
you don't think that had anything to do with the creators being indoctrinated thrills that the created viewed as evil beings in the first place?
Eterna5 wrote...
BleedingUranium wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
BleedingUranium wrote...
Bottom line, the Reapers use organics by turning them into goo to make more Reapers, the villain of any story will tell the hero whatever helps his cause, usually by lying. It'd be hard to find a villain that doesn't do that.
The cycles are Reaper reproduction, nothing more.
With the intent of preserving organic life.
Ah yes, "preserving organic life"; we have dismissed that claim.
Not really. The Synthesis epilogue even proves that past civilizations were in fact preserved.
Guest_frudi_*
Saying "he's programmed that way" does not exempt his logic from being flawed. In fact, logic errors are one of the three type of programming erros... here we have a perfect example of itEterna5 wrote...
No, he is following his programming. He fully believes it to be the case.frudi wrote...
Good, we're making progress, we've actually established that holo-****** is just making sh*t up
Eterna5 wrote...
Not really. The Synthesis epilogue even proves that past civilizations were in fact preserved.
Modifié par Fixers0, 01 janvier 2013 - 11:49 .
Festae9 wrote...
The catalyst never gives it a chance, it's 50,000 or so and done - peace out homies!
He should let it go several cycles if he wants to see if it really is inev... stupid dummy
Modifié par Eterna5, 01 janvier 2013 - 11:49 .
Eterna5 wrote...
Jade8aby88 wrote...
When you make the peace on rannoch..........
I don't recall anyone saying "This peace will last forever and always!"
Modifié par Someone With Mass, 01 janvier 2013 - 11:49 .
Someone With Mass wrote...
Eterna5 wrote...
Jade8aby88 wrote...
When you make the peace on rannoch..........
I don't recall anyone saying "This peace will last forever and always!"
I don't recall anything hinting that the geth will revert back to their state where they're killing any organic in sight either.
That is, anything worth paying attention to.
Eterna5 wrote...
Festae9 wrote...
The catalyst never gives it a chance, it's 50,000 or so and done - peace out homies!
He should let it go several cycles if he wants to see if it really is inev... stupid dummy
Several cycles is more than enough time for a synthetic creation to advance far beyond organic capabilities, perhaps even reaper.
Someone With Mass wrote...
Versus Omnibus wrote...
I'm not saying it's the best solution; I'm just saying I understand what he was trying to do.
Oh, I do as well. It's actually pretty simple.
It's just that it's not worth any praise whatsoever, since the intent and the execution were so far apart from each other.
Retour en haut