226 réponses à ce sujet

[Legbiter]

We've all had our share of creepy ex stalkers.


Trust me, Liara was quite discreet.

[Legbiter]

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Legbiter wrote...

Liara for a feminine, loyal no matter what romance.

Did they fix the "friend-zoning" thing Liaramancers were going on about?

Wouldn't know since I never had any issue through all 3 games.

[fiendishchicken]

Legbiter wrote...

We've all had our share of creepy ex stalkers.


Trust me, Liara was quite discreet.

It's not so much how she behaves as it is the writers constantly give her too much plot armor and make her too important to the story. I'd be perfectly fine, even preffering it, having her sent off to Hackett early in the game never to see or hear from her again minus an email or two.

[DeinonSlayer]

fiendishchicken wrote...

Legbiter wrote...

We've all had our share of creepy ex stalkers.


Trust me, Liara was quite discreet.

It's not so much how she behaves as it is the writers constantly give her too much plot armor and make her too important to the story. I'd be perfectly fine, even preffering it, having her sent off to Hackett early in the game never to see or hear from her again minus an email or two.

But then she can't be traumatized by the fall of Thessia, needing Shepard's comfort!

Besides that, the post-nightmare sequences and telling you about the monastery mission, I can't think of anything else she does that's relevant to the plot.

Modifié par DeinonSlayer, 03 janvier 2013 - 04:29 .

[Han Shot First]

It all depends on your personal preferences. 

But I'd say Liara if your Male Shep is a paragon or paragade. If you include LotSB I think she's got the best romance arc in the series, and with that DLC her romance spans all three games. If Shep is a paragon or paragade, they are also fairly similar characters with fairly similar outlooks.

If your Male Shep leans renegade or renegon, Ash or Miranda (or both) are probably a better fit.

[Fidget6]

I would say Tali just because to me it seems the most natural progression throughout the games and it's fleshed out and has a lot of cutesy moments. I think the fact that you can't romance her in ME1 actually helps it build up more naturally throughout the games. I would say Kaidan, but since you get jipped out of so much content from the first two games (well, really just the first....) when you play maleshep, Tali wins.

Modifié par Fidget6, 03 janvier 2013 - 05:32 .

[HiddenInWar]

In a perfect world, Garrus.

But Tali is a close second.

[ref]

Cannonly, it seems Liara is what BioWare is shoehorning. I liked Liara in ME1, but didn't like her in ME2/3. If she was more like her ME1 self, I might be interested.

I like Jack the most if you Paragon romance her. Other than that, Ashley. If Miranda's romance and character was developed more, she'd probably be in front of Ash.

Modifié par Refara, 03 janvier 2013 - 05:48 .

[TheWerdna]

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Cthulhu42 wrote...

A good LI should generally:

- maintain a mostly consistent personality over the course of the series (Liara, Jacob, (Ashley and Kaidan?))
- be designed as a character first and a romance second (Liara, Traynor, Cortez, Chobot, (Thane?))
- not be subject to random boob jobs (Liara, Ashley, (Miranda already had one))
- not end up getting marginalized or pushed to the side in the final act (Thane, Jacob, Jack, Miranda)

Sadly, the majority of ME LIs fail to meet these criteria.

Odd that Kelly Chambers didn't break any of those criteria AFAIK. Any violators I missed?

So really onlu Garrus and Tali didn't break said criteria...mostly on the ground of not being desgned around being a romance (since they only later became LIs because of fan demands)

[Skullheart]

I would say...

1. Miranda.
2. Ashley
3. Jack.

The rest I don't even considerate it a romance option for me. I don't like Liara nor Tali by the same reason, because their interest in him starts as hero worship. When they meet Shepard he is the first human they see and a charming prince.

One of the thing I like from Miranda is that he sees Shepard as a regular man in person, not as the hero like the alien LI's. Ash and Jack also see Shepard a a mortal being, yeah, he's the butcher/survivor/hero and 1st human espectre, but that not what attract them from him.

And what I enjoy from the Miranda romance is both of them pushing each other buttons. The renegade kiss in ME2 is something you won't see in any other romance.

Too bad the lack of content ruined that in me3.

[DeinonSlayer]

TheWerdna wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Cthulhu42 wrote...

A good LI should generally:

- maintain a mostly consistent personality over the course of the series (Liara, Jacob, (Ashley and Kaidan?))
- be designed as a character first and a romance second (Liara, Traynor, Cortez, Chobot, (Thane?))
- not be subject to random boob jobs (Liara, Ashley, (Miranda already had one))
- not end up getting marginalized or pushed to the side in the final act (Thane, Jacob, Jack, Miranda)

Sadly, the majority of ME LIs fail to meet these criteria.

Odd that Kelly Chambers didn't break any of those criteria AFAIK. Any violators I missed?

So really onlu Garrus and Tali didn't break said criteria...mostly on the ground of not being desgned around being a romance (since they only later became LIs because of fan demands)

Kaidan's a "maybe" - but the whole Cerberus distrust arc is chiefly responsible there. So Kaidan, Garrus, Tali and Kelly (hard to call her marginalized - how important was she to start?) - unless I missed something.

Modifié par DeinonSlayer, 03 janvier 2013 - 07:07 .

[Yuqi]

Enhanced wrote...

MattFini wrote...

Yuqi wrote...

Male shepard only has one true love in ME3.

This is the single greatest thing that has ever been posted to the BSN.

Really? I don't get it.

Google: pedobear.

[Jadebaby]

ATiBotka wrote...

Diana Allers

this, no question.

[shit's fucked cunts]

Jade8aby88 wrote...

ATiBotka wrote...

Diana Allers

this, no question.

Maybe if you're roleplaying as Pauly D.

[MASSEFFECTfanforlife101]

 MIRANDA<3!

[I WANT YOU TO FUCK ME JERY]

FemShep.

[Yuqi]

SergeantSnookie wrote...

FemShep.

+10

[samgurl775]

Skullheart wrote...

I would say...

1. Miranda.
2. Ashley
3. Jack.

The rest I don't even considerate it a romance option for me. I don't like Liara nor Tali by the same reason, because their interest in him starts as hero worship. When they meet Shepard he is the first human they see and a charming prince.

One of the thing I like from Miranda is that he sees Shepard as a regular man in person, not as the hero like the alien LI's. Ash and Jack also see Shepard a a mortal being, yeah, he's the butcher/survivor/hero and 1st human espectre, but that not what attract them from him.

And what I enjoy from the Miranda romance is both of them pushing each other buttons. The renegade kiss in ME2 is something you won't see in any other romance.

Too bad the lack of content ruined that in me3.

Agreed, this is what I liked so much about Miranda's romance. Also, Ashley has a pretty good line during her romance scene in ME1 where she says something like "I won't be squishy and submissive" which I thought was really cool.

[Neizd]

If you play whole trillogy I would say Tali.

Why?

She is the only female character that basicially doesn't jump into Shepard arms just like that and does not go into his bed because "oh no we can die, lets f**k" Because of that the romance is progressing slowly. It's a shame that BW always make apperance in games quite late, but at least it's a sweet long term relationship that doesn't give you the feeling that She just wants to bang Shepard. Other girls basicially jumped into Shepard bed because they found love just like that...they are too easy :/

[Falaxe]

Neizd wrote...

If you play whole trillogy I would say Tali.

Why?

She is the only female character that basicially doesn't jump into Shepard arms just like that and does not go into his bed because "oh no we can die, lets f**k" Because of that the romance is progressing slowly. It's a shame that BW always make apperance in games quite late, but at least it's a sweet long term relationship that doesn't give you the feeling that She just wants to bang Shepard. Other girls basicially jumped into Shepard bed because they found love just like that...they are too easy :/

In ME1 Shepard would have been sent to jail, if he`d touched Tali...

[darthnick427]

It depends what you prefer. I personally like Liara and Tali best. And sometimes I'll have my character romance Jack or Miranda if I feel like something different. Not a fan of Ash myself.....

Tali and Liara are probably best though. Liara in terms of amount of content, Tali in terms of quality (excluding her face reveal)

[Samtheman63]

i think <insert my LI here> is the best

[Ignis Mors]

Miranda, she's the character with the most depth, and of the options, the only one my Shepard wouldn't feel uncomfortable romancing .

[Lars Honeytoast]

I take Miranda just so I can say "I'm just trying to get you into bed." It fits my Shep.

[StayFrosty05]

Lars Honeytoast wrote...

I take Miranda just so I can say "I'm just trying to get you into bed." It fits my Shep.

She didn't believe my Shep was serious when he said that....she obviously hadn't taken much notice of what had been happening right under her nose on the Normandy........he had already tapped Kelly and Jack.......Romance Miranda and save Jack's LM until after the SM and side with Jack........and Play Boy, bad boy Shep taps a trio in ME2 whilst remaining relationship free....