166 réponses à ce sujet

[LTKerr]

Jacob. He's... useless.

[Mr.House]

Ignis Mors wrote...

ForThessia, Liara is the ONLY squadmate that died frequently for me, no one else got downed frequently. In ME2 on insanity I didn't lose teammates very much, only in the hardest battles did anyone die. In ME3 on NORMAL Liara died in every fight when I used the tactics that had gotten me through the previous title fine. Tell teammates where to take cover and what abilities to use.

Again that's the players fault, why? Because my expiernce is way diffrent then yours. I use Garrus/Kaidan with Liara and I never have an issue with my squad. Also I play an Inflitrator and Liara's stasis is perfect for certain targets to get headshot or putting singularity and then doing a ibotic explosion(thanks to Kaidan or her own warp) or fire explosion.

You simply don't know how to use her, there is nothing wrong with being bad with some squadmates but to say she sucks? No, she simply sucks for you because you don't know how to use her properly.

Alsi Liara has no point in this thread, why you and the other Liara haters could not just say Ash,Kaidan or Jacob is beyond me. This type of hate is not healthy.

Modifié par Mr.House, 04 janvier 2013 - 02:32 .

[Ignis Mors]

Perhaps, but it gets annoying for those of us who hate her to have a ton of, "Awww, Liara is awesome!" which there has been in BSN lately. Sometimes we need to vent our rage.

[Jake Boone]

Mr.House wrote...

Ignis Mors wrote...

ForThessia, Liara is the ONLY squadmate that died frequently for me, no one else got downed frequently. In ME2 on insanity I didn't lose teammates very much, only in the hardest battles did anyone die. In ME3 on NORMAL Liara died in every fight when I used the tactics that had gotten me through the previous title fine. Tell teammates where to take cover and what abilities to use.

Again that's the players fault, why? Because my expiernce is way diffrent then yours. I use Garrus/Kaidan with Liara and I never have an issue with my squad. Also I play an Inflitrator and Liara's stasis is perfect for certain targets to get headshot or putting singularity and then doing a ibotic explosion(thanks to Kaidan or her own warp) or fire explosion.

You simply don't know how to use her, there is nothing wrong with being bad with some squadmates but to say she sucks? No, she simply sucks for you because you don't know how to use her properly.

Alsi Liara has no point in this thread, why you and the other Liara haters could not just say Ash,Kaidan or Jacob is beyond me. This type of hate is not healthy.

So hating Ash, Kaidan or Jacob is healthy? or am I misreading that part of your post. I do agree that there was a player issue in handling Liara since all the squadies in ME3 are powerful.

[zaku257]

IMO, depends on two extent I can come up with some worst teammates.
If based on their powers, I'd say Jacob in ME2.
For someone that claims Liara is the worst in ME3, you are not doing it right.
Liara relys on her biotic powers so if your shep is a biotic too she is the most valuable teammate,alongside with Kaidan and Javik to you. Singularity+Warp/Throw = BE for Liara.
If based on their backgrounds,Reaction,etc, I'd say Ashley. I don't know why, she just somehow annoys me. Or Jacob, you guys should know what all the fuss is about him.

Modifié par zaku257, 04 janvier 2013 - 03:28 .

[Ignis Mors]

I found that I couldn't keep Liara alive long enough to frequently use her powers. And I was a soldier or an engineer. Not a biotic.

[gearseffect]

Ignis Mors wrote...

Perhaps, but it gets annoying for those of us who hate her to have a ton of, "Awww, Liara is awesome!" which there has been in BSN lately. Sometimes we need to vent our rage.

Ah Ignis you speak the words that have been on my mind and also the reason I've been MIA from the BSN for a few days. I'd like to vent my rage but I've learned long ago that I'm better off to remove myself due to the horde mindset. Pick and choose my battles, and either remove the source of my problem or limit exposing myself to the source(s). With that I'm ducking out again for a few.

[Natabre]

I've only paid attention to Kaidan and Liara mainly because they're the only people that I've used quite often, but if you're speaking of combat - it would be Liara>Kaidan. So I can't say who's the worst until I've really tried them all.

Edit: Sorry, but for combat - Idk. Non-combat reasons - I definitely pick Jacob, even his loyal mission didn't have me take an interest in Jacob - the mission was good, but it was mainly because of the mission itself.

Modifié par Natabre, 04 janvier 2013 - 03:43 .

[aM1ty]

Ashley. Her ignorant racism annoyed me.

[Seifer006]

liara

[Ignis Mors]

Sorry I didn't notice you here earlier, Gears. How's your writing going?

[chevyguy87]

Let's see, (I'm basing this on abilities, not charisma or personality)
ME1 - They were all equally mediocre, no best or worst.
ME2 - Jacob, he had absolutely nothing to contribute, would have been better off washing windows.
ME3 - Tie between Ashley and Kaidan, there is nothing either of these two do that others can't do better.

[ld1449]

Kaidan

[Obsidian Gryphon]

For the presented trio. It's Jacob. I rarely bring him out but on the missions that he did go to, I had to micromanage this guy. My squad tend to comprise of Liara and Garrus.

[garrusfan1]

Jacob Jacob and Jacob. I love ash and liked Kaiden but Jacob is just annoying

[garrusfan1]

How are all of you having such trouble keeping liara alive. Seriously I play on hardcore on everything (except rannoch reaper) or on insanity and she doesn't usually die Edi dies a lot not liara. I don't give liara directions and she generally doesn't die

[Examurai]

Story-wise Jacob. Combat-wise Tali.

[Ignis Mors]

garrusfan1 wrote...

How are all of you having such trouble keeping liara alive. Seriously I play on hardcore on everything (except rannoch reaper) or on insanity and she doesn't usually die Edi dies a lot not liara. I don't give liara directions and she generally doesn't die

Lucky.

[garrusfan1]

Ignis Mors wrote...

garrusfan1 wrote...

How are all of you having such trouble keeping liara alive. Seriously I play on hardcore on everything (except rannoch reaper) or on insanity and she doesn't usually die Edi dies a lot not liara. I don't give liara directions and she generally doesn't die

Lucky.

I think I know what's happening with you guys. She only dies a lot if she doesn't get to cover fast enough cause that is the only time she dies in my games plus come on the medi gel isn't exactly hard to come by I use it to regain health if I have to.

[o Ventus]

Combat-wise, probably Tali.

[garrusfan1]

aM1ty wrote...

Ashley. Her ignorant racism annoyed me.

Your either a troll or you didn't understand what she meant. She was cautious of aliens. In ME3 she calls Tali her little sister so yeah she was a total racist. Oh and in ME1 if you talk to her you can get her to be totally accepting of aliens like everyone else is. As for the I can't tell the aliens from the animals thing tell me why everyone calls the hanar jellyfish and if you look at the elcor they look a lot like an elephant 

[garrusfan1]

o Ventus wrote...

Combat-wise, probably Tali.

Blasphemy

[Galbrant]

Hmmm don't see how Liara dies all the time in my games it was always Javik.

[o Ventus]

garrusfan1 wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

Combat-wise, probably Tali.

Blasphemy

While I never used her in ME1, I can tell you that giving her a shotgun in ME2 and 3 was one of the dumbest things I've ever seen.
 
In ME2 she was borderline useless. As a Sentinel, Shepard himself could do everything she could, minus summon drones. Even her drones weren't useful, since I always had Miranda help to Warp bomb things. Enemies just died too quickly. 

In ME3, it's almost the exact same problem. As a Sentinel (and another Engineer), I can detonate all 3 combo powers on my own and kill almost everything (if not everything) about as soon as I enter combat.

Modifié par o Ventus, 04 janvier 2013 - 05:16 .

[Oni Changas]

What Mr. House said. Though I liked him in ME2. In 3 he was captain lame.