193 réponses à ce sujet

[chevyguy87]

1. The Reapers, they lost their luster and turned into props rather then villains
2. The Crucible, out of nowhere with no foreshadowing or even a hint of its existence we received our "easy button" to deal with the Reapers
3. Having multiplayer affect your Galactic Readiness Rating
4. God-awful character treatment (offing Emily Wong in a twitter post)
5. The lack of any consistency in the story

Modifié par chevyguy87, 04 janvier 2013 - 11:44 .

[Kulbelbolka]

1) Poor quality of game - it's like they didn't have time for alpha-testing to understand what is good and what should be cut.
2) Shooting mechanic sucks - I don't feel shooting in ME3, but in ME2 shooting was pretty cool.
3) Lame storyline - it's like it was written by fat ugly girl whose favourite book series is Twilight.
4) No ME feeling - while playing ME1 and ME2 I actually felt that I'm traveling around Milky Way, in ME3 magic is gone: it's now like an unsuccessful sci-fi TV show, which budget had been cut before filming third season, so creators decided to make it the last season and make as possible good as they can. So the story takes place in several floors of sci-fi-like decorations (Normandy) and several floors of pseudo-futuristic city (Citadel). Because creators don't have money for something more, tired actors playing very bad-written roles and waiting for ending of the contract. Sometimes story shortly goes to different locations, but you spend most of the time on Normandy and Citadel.
5) Ending, of course - I don't know what they we're thinking while making this ending, but it definetely wasn't shown to beta-testers.

[Neizd]

1. Diminished role of RPG...I don't consider ME3 an RPG or Action RPG. Just Shooter with slight RPG elements.
2. Autodialoque
3. Tali face...or rather the "effort" they put for 5 years of mystery and wasted potential
4. Priority:earth...nothing epic...this should be the most epic final mission. And yes endings included.
5. Overall plot - Magical weapon of mass reaper destruction they just took from thin air -.- WTF?!

[Costin_Razvan]

AtreiyaN7 wrote...

1. Annoying fans who can't move on with their lives.

That's pretty much the extent of it for me at this point.

I am sorry, coming to care about the characters, the universe, the story and then having that smashed right into your face is fine? Because that's what ME3 did to me and I used to care a lot, the fact that I don't anymore is a testament to how bad it is. I don't give a damn about the so called horrible 15 minutes of the ending. I give a damn that the ENTIRE game is ****.

If someone wants to enjoy the ME series they should just play ME1 and ME2 and not touch ME3 if they are new to it. Just imagine there was a huge epic battle with all the races coming together with technology being used from the Collector Base to make better weapons and shields and you would have something a lot better then ME3.

My reasons:

1) The portrayal of Cerberus.
2) The lackluster cinematics and soundtrack. ME2 was epic, ME3 is dull.
3) The ****** poor story and lore logic and consistency.
4) The portrayal of the reapers.
5) The portrayal of the war in general.

Modifié par Costin_Razvan, 05 janvier 2013 - 12:29 .

[deatharmonic]

Major:
1. Auto-dialogue
Had to check about 3 times to see if I had accidentally chosen action mode. A needless attack on player agency imo

2. Hollow fetch quests
Nothing but pointless quest-log filler

3. No neutral option
Hated having to always go from one extreme to the other.

Minor:
4. EMS issue
Both the implementation of it and the way Bioware handled it

5. Writing for Shep
Felt like I was watching an really really cheesy action film at times, where the hero would come out with total hero #36 ****. As well as the scenes where he argues with the council about saving Earth, I couldn't believe the writers would come up with that.

[Draining Dragon]

1-Unfitting endings ripped off of Deus Ex
2-Autodialogue
3-No neutral dialogue options
4-Butthurt Shepard after Thessia
5-Casey Hudson

[Shepard108278]

Not_art_just_plotholes wrote...

Shepard108278 wrote...

Mr.Racoon wrote...

GimmeDaGun wrote...

Mr.Racoon wrote...

@SpamBot2000
Your point?

The point it that Israeli girl is hot as hell... 

and my point is that it is an Israeli girl and not Tali

First I like the game ending included second I thought the photo was fine and how I'd imagine Tali.

C'mon, surely you have to admit that at least some small part of you wanted to see a fully animated face under Talis mask when she removed it, one that had obviously had a lot of work put into to please fans.

I never said I didn't but I like what we got. Sure that would have been great nut the photo wasn't bad IMO.

[IC-07]

2012 wasn't the best year for video games as I hear. Oh well, let's see what ME4 has to say in the future.

Modifié par IC-07, 05 janvier 2013 - 01:25 .

[Xellith]

Shepard108278 wrote...

Not_art_just_plotholes wrote...

C'mon, surely you have to admit that at least some small part of you wanted to see a fully animated face under Talis mask when she removed it, one that had obviously had a lot of work put into to please fans.

I never said I didn't but I like what we got. Sure that would have been great nut the photo wasn't bad IMO.

Stock + Bioware photoshop.


Fan made is better:


I mean how hard is it to even get the HAND right.  That is one of the quarians most distinctive features.  The version in game is just very. very lazy

[Brovikk Rasputin]

I do not agree with the OP.

[MegaSovereign]

I've been playing through the trilogy lately and while ME3 is clearly the worst when it comes to auto-dialogue, I'm surprised by how much of it I also caught in the first two games.

[thepimpto]

1. Super linear plot structure/quest-chain in a game about making choices

2. Very limited squad. VS and Tali absent for half the game. EDI as an unnecessary squadmate addition. Lack of temp squadmates with cameos. And forced squadmate missions.

3. Forced resolution without a climax. Yes, I'm talking about the ending. Thanks for telling me how I "defeated" the Reapers before I actually defeat the Reapers.

4. ME3 makes ME2 pointless, meaningless, and unnecessary.

5. Multiplayer. I know some people love it, but I play single player games because I am a misanthrope, and the resources wasted on MP could have been better spent on the single player campaign. Any game pandering to the COD crowd with a FPS-esque MP cannot be defended with "Artistic Integrity"

[C9316]

1. Really linear, predictable story.
2. Horrid Journal and Quests.
3. Auto dialogue removing the ability to role-play your Shepard.
4. Unnecessary plot-holes, and retcons.
5. Choices not mattering/ The Ending

[Taboo]

Mr. Raccoon? All I see with Raccoon is Raccoon City.

I've been playing WAY too much Resident Evil.

[Brovikk Rasputin]

Well, to be fair, I guess I should try and come up with a list too.

1. Too short. But hey, I guess all good things must come to an end!
2. I simply can't come up with anymore points?! The game is just so good!

In my opinion.

[IC-07]

Brovikk Rasputin wrote...

Well, to be fair, I guess I should try and come up with a list too.

1. Too short. But hey, I guess all good things must come to an end!
2. I simply can't come up with anymore points?! The game is just so good!

In my opinion.

What a sweet person you are. Cookies?

[Dubozz]

I think Brovikk is some kind of EA bot or something. I thinks i'll better put him in ignore list for good.

5 minor downsides
1. Lack of exploration
2. Crazy quest journal
3. Crucible requiress more introduction
4. Kai Leng (space ninja rofl)
5. Diana Alers

[Galbrant]

I totally forgot about Diana Allers.  So I updated my post. >_>

[The Spamming Troll]

1. the journal is really annoying to the point i avoid the citadel because id rather not clutter up the journal with eaves dropping quests. thane dies offscreen in my ME3.
2. lazy tali photoshop face in my version of ME3. the vision of an entire species, created in under 15 minutes. bam, BIOWARE.
3. crucible being out of sight out of mind, hidden like carmen sandiego. every time i talk to adrmiral hackidiot im reminded how ridiculous this stories ending will be. so no, i do not talk to hacket.
4. inconsequential consequences, inconsistencies in stories, ending...
5. not enough alien sex.

Modifié par The Spamming Troll, 05 janvier 2013 - 02:59 .

[Saito404]

1. Plot
2. Character development
3. Forced relationships (forced conflict with the VS, forced romance-like friendship with Liara ect.)
4. Autodialogue
5. BUGS. LOTS OF BUGS.

[SteJo6sic6]

Mr.Racoon wrote...

1 - Poorly photoshopped stock photo of an Israeli girl
2 - Lackluster Horde Mode MP
3 - Autodialogue
4 - Various plotholes 
5 - Ending

Post your own 5 reasons below !

I pretty much agree with all of these but I would swap out the MP with the entire side quest system.  I actually thought the Hoard Mode in ME3 is one of the best hored modes out there.

[3DandBeyond]

AtreiyaN7 wrote...

1. Annoying fans who can't move on with their lives.

That's pretty much the extent of it for me at this point.

Hmm, as you have? 

Modifié par 3DandBeyond, 05 janvier 2013 - 04:56 .

[The RPGenius]

1. Synthesis
2. Control
3. Refuse
4. Destroy
5. Allers